Season 3 Premiere:
Matt Roush says...
This intensely creepy but strangely enjoyable series, which caused nary a ripple on Lifetime before becoming a bingeworthy hit on Netflix, moves from the city to the “white picket purgatory” of the suburbs for its addictive third season. Romantic obsessive/stalker extraordinaire Joe (Penn Badgley) is now married to his psychotically impulsive not-quite-soulmate Love (Haunting of Bly Manor’s Victoria Pedretti), and they take to new parenthood about as easily as they adjust to their privileged neighborhood of smug mommy bloggers and tech whizzes. The bloody fun begins when Joe finds his latest target of sensual obsession: sexy realtor neighbor Natalie (Michaela McManus), whose marriage to tech mogul Matthew (new Grey’s Anatomy love interest Scott Speedman) may or may not be a complication. You already know if You is your thing, so dig in.