Ask Matt: Superheroes on the Decline at The CW?

Batwoman Javicia Leslie
The CW
Batwoman

Welcome to the Q&A with TV critic — also known to some TV fans as their “TV therapist” — Matt Roush, who’ll try to address whatever you love, loathe, are confused or frustrated or thrilled by in today’s vast TV landscape. (We know background music is too loud, but there’s always closed-captioning.)

One caution: This is a spoiler-free zone, so we won’t be addressing upcoming storylines here unless it’s already common knowledge. Please send your questions and comments to [email protected] (or use the form at the end of the column) and follow me on Twitter (@TVGMMattRoush). Look for Ask Matt columns on many Tuesdays and some Fridays.

Has a Power Producer Lost His Superpower?

Question: With the cancellation of DC’s Legends of Tomorrow and Batwoman, does that mean that Greg Berlanti‘s reign as Supreme Overlord of the CW is on the decline? – Brian

Matt Roush: I guess that’s one way to look at it, although it still sometimes seems like every other show out there comes from Greg Berlanti’s amazingly prolific production company (You and The Flight Attendant among those that reveal a diversity of products beyond comic-book adaptations and The CW). I have long wondered when the tipping point would come when a network airs so many of the same sorts of shows, and all it took was a rumored impending sale of the network and a mega-merger swallowing its production company (Warner Bros. Discovery) to halt the proliferation of DC shows on The CW. What really surprised me was that Legends wasn’t given the chance for a proper sendoff after such a long run, but as others have speculated, so long as the Arrowverse still has a foothold (though not as big a footprint) on The CW, we could still see some of these characters from time to time, and that could be an avenue for closure. The fallout from this merger will take some time to process, but it’s also affecting what you’ll see on the Turner networks (fewer scripted shows on TNT for sure), and hoping that HBO Max will come to the rescue is probably a pipe dream.

From Broadcast to Streaming and Back to Broadcast?

Question: Some of my favorite shows from broadcast TV moved to streaming — shows like Evil, SEAL Team, and Lucifer — but I’m in the category of refusing to pay for something I wouldn’t use much of. Is there any chance reruns of those seasons will be offered as reruns on broadcast TV? — Jim C

Matt Roush: I doubt you’d see these shows repeated on their former networks, but it’s not out of the question for shows like these to eventually make their way to syndication, perhaps on cable. (Lucifer is already airing on TNT, and SEAL Team would also seem a natural for this, although Evil is so specifically bizarre I imagine it will remain a streaming-only show for the foreseeable future.) Each of the shows you mention moved to streaming for different reasons — Lucifer rescued from Fox’s cancellation, Evil and SEAL Team moved from CBS to the streaming platform to keep them viable — but in the bigger picture, it’s no secret that these companies see streaming as their future, which is why for the time being these new seasons will likely stay exclusive to the streaming sites.

All Aboard the Memory Train

Comment: In the April 29 episode of Blue Bloods, actor Steve Schirripa’s character Anthony Abetemarco made a comment about a possible threat to his boss Erin Reagan. He commented that the threat was harmless due to him having trains as a hobby. Then I remembered his hobby and where he was killed when he played Bobby “Bacala” Baccalieri on The Sopranos. I thought that was quite funny and had to explain it to my family. — Tom Y

Matt Roush: Once a fan of toy trains always a fan. I love this observation and the fact that Blue Bloods would embed such a knowing “easter egg” for sharp-witted listeners. Let’s hope things end up better for Anthony than they did for Bobby.

An Acting (and Writing) Tour de Force

Question: (Spoiler Alert for those not keeping up with Better Call Saul): In response to the kudos for Michael Mando in the “Rock and Hard Place” episode of Better Call Saul, I’m just wondering if Michael Mando was allowed to go off-script and implement any type of improv. I’m asking because it wasn’t his performance, it was the delivery of his performance that seemed both organic and spontaneous. I am specifically speaking about everything that he said prior to his demise. I hope that he wins an award for his outstanding performance! He really brought the Nacho character to life, added layers of depth and quality that seemed true to himself, although not knowing him, his heartfelt, authentic expressions tell me that he was not so unlike the genuine, caring character that he portrayed. — Pamela P

Matt Roush: Nothing I’ve seen in the post-mortems for this great episode and swan song suggest Michael Mando was doing anything but giving vivid life to the script of WGA Award-winning and multiple Emmy-nominated executive producer and writer Gordon Smith (who also directed the episode). I’d imagine when you’re delivering the words your own director has written, you’d stay close to the script while bringing your gifts, technique, and personality to what is obviously a very heightened situation. These drama categories are always so competitive, but I’d love to see Mando acknowledged for his role as Nacho. This would be high on the list of the best TV episodes of 2022 to date.

Striking Out at the Bowling Alley

Comment: Regarding CBS’s How We Roll, it’s very disappointing that the powers that be took an interesting premise and threw a gutter ball by inserting the usual contrived sitcom plots instead of focusing on what actually happens on the Pro Tour. The only saving grace for the show is Julie White and Chi McBride. Hopefully, it will improve to a strike from the 7-10 split it is now. — David M, Saint Charles, MO

Matt Roush: Hard to see how. How We Roll is wasting a decent premise and some fine performers — I’m hoping to catch Tony winner Julie White soon among an inspired female ensemble in the Broadway comedy POTUS — with such tired writing and execution I couldn’t make it past the first few episodes sent for review. I might give a good sports comedy about bowling a try, but this isn’t that show.

Same Old Same Old

Question: I recently cut my cable and purchased a digital antenna. As a result, I have been watching more of the standard networks and shows, such as the different versions of the FBI and NCIS shows. Though I know they are all highly rated, I’m noticing that the plots for all of these shows are all the same: This person did it, no this person did it, no this person did it. Oh, actually this person did it. They’re getting boring. How about writing a few shows where the plot is totally different and unpredictable for a change? — Dennis K

Matt Roush: My sympathies. You are caught in a procedural vortex, and while it’s true the traditional broadcast networks aren’t giving you much variety to choose from to find an escape route, you might try an ongoing thriller like ABC’s Big Sky, an occasional hospital drama (also formulaic) or maybe even a comedy to break up the monotony. Rule of thumb: If the show has spawned a spinoff (or multiples), originality isn’t the point.

Or, since you’ve “cut the cord” from cable, you might consider investing in a streaming portal and see what awaits you in the digital world. As a final note, and expanding on a recent exchange in this column about a world beyond cable, here’s a tip from D.P.:

“When my Internet provider Google Fiber decided to get out of the cable business, I wound up following Google’s suggestion of subscribing to YouTube TV, which in most markets around the U.S. carries about 60 to 80 of the channels you would usually get on cable. There are other similar services, but I chose YouTube TV because they are one of the few to carry local PBS stations. So, though I no longer have cable TV, I still have most of the channels I used to enjoy on cable. The price for YouTube TV plus my Internet access is about 1/3 lower than the amount I paid for cable and Internet before. (This does not include the amounts I pay for various streaming services such as Netflix, Hulu, etc., which I was already paying anyway.)”

Matt again: It’s a brave new TV world out there, and I’ve heard from others who have embraced this as a way to keep plugged into the legacy networks while keeping your options open for the plethora of new streamers that seem to never stop producing intriguing new content.

That’s all for now. We can’t do this without your participation, so please keep sending questions and comments about TV to [email protected] or shoot me a line on Twitter (@TVGMMattRoush), and you can also submit questions via the handy form below. (Please include a first name with your question.)




Conversation9 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Comments are closed on this story.

  1. J

    Jena

    A) Superheroes on the decline at the CW? How can they NOT be? I think the network has milked the superhero genre for so long, it was bound to run out of either energy, good writing, or decent superheroes. I enjoyed some good TV back in the superhero heyday, but I strictly limited myself as to which ones I watched.

    B) To Dennis K, who laments the "sameness" of some of the broadcast TV he's watching: dude, they're called PROCEDURALS. They're formulaic on purpose. It's never the obvious suspect, it's never the first one investigators look at. Accept it and move on. 🙃

    3

    1. A

      Antonio Montealegre

      Yeah, if it's Quinn Martin or Aaron Spelling, or currently Dick Wolf, who's producing the program, the last thing you'd expect is innovation!

  2. L

    Laurel Nevans

    When I was in HS, I hung out at a Bowling Alley, and my good friend actually was the youngest person in the history of the game to bowl a 300. I was looking forward to How We Roll to remind me of my alley days. But so far, it is just dreadful! And i think choosing to air it in the slot they did, mid season after Ghosts finished its run, just shows that they know it too. If they really were invested, they'd have moved it to 830 by now, to keep the Sheldon viewers.

    1

  3. T

    txcharley

    I keep hanging in and watching How We Roll, but the laugh track is a BIG turnoff, as are most of the silly jokes. I, too, wish they would spend more time on the bowling tournaments and not on all those "jokes".

    1

  4. C

    CyanPin

    I, too, am impressed with the cast on "How We Roll." But the best member of that cast -- the talented Katie Lowes -- was not mentioned in your article. She is by far the star of that show.V Fan

    2 1

    1. B

      BlueBoomerang

      How We Roll did steadily improve after the mediocre pilot. And like you mentioned the cast is terrific!

    2. B

      BlueBoomerang

      Yes Katie Lowes is fantastic in How We Roll!

      1

    3. T

      txcharley

      She keeps popping up everywhere suddenly, and does a GREAT job everywhere!

  5. B

    BlueBoomerang

    I do watch a lot of procedurals ( All FBIs, Chicago PD, Rookie….) but they are all quite different.

    Rookie is much lighter in tone. Chicago PD and FBI Most Wanted are much darker and more violent than the others. FBI International has foreign locales and a very unique vibe . The original FBI is the most straightforward .

    Like Matt said if a viewer wants something different ABC’s Big Sky is just that. A serialized mystery thriller loaded with twists and turns . . And comedies like Abbott Elementary offer something not seen very often on the networks - originality .

    All the big networks still have lots to offer in scripted. These are the broadcast shows I have enjoyed this season :

    ABC:

    Promised Land

    Queens

    The Rookie

    Good Doctor

    Station 19

    Grey’s Anatomy

    Big Sky

    Conners

    Abbott Elementary

    Black-ish

    FOX:

    9-1-1

    9-1-1 Lone Star

    Cleaning Lady

    Call Me Kat

    Pivoting

    Welcome To Flatch

    NBC:

    Chicago PD

    La Brea

    American Auto

    Mr Mayor

    CBS:

    All FBIs

    NCIS Hawaii

    B Positive

    How We Roll