Who Will Win ‘American Idol’ Season 24? Our Predictions & Ranking

Jordan McCullough, Hannah Harper, Keyla Richardson
Disney/Eric McCandless
Disney/Eric McCandless

The American Idol Semifinals featured two more eliminations when Chris Tungseth and Braden Rumfelt were sent home. Now, just three artists remain in the competition, and they’ll all get a chance to sing for votes to win the show during the May 11 finale.

Once again, the decisions will be in the hands of the fans, as viewers vote for their favorite singer throughout the final episode. The Top 3 will perform during the show, and a winner will be revealed at the end of the night.

While it’s impossible to know exactly how viewers will vote, there are some indicators that can help us predict who will likely make it past the next round (and maybe even win) the competition.

For years, all of the contestants’ performances have been uploaded to the official American Idol YouTube account after each episode airs, and those that rack up more views tend to line up with the singers who receive a lot of votes and continue to move forward. Artists with more of a presence on social media (i.e. more Instagram followers) are also likely to pull in more votes. Of course, this isn’t always the case, as was seen with Kyndal Inskeep’s recent elimination.

However, based on information from performance views and social media, which can obviously change throughout the week, we’ve rounded up our predictions for the Top 3, including who seems most likely to win. Scroll down to check out our ranking of the remaining artists and hop into the comments section to let us know who you’re rooting for to win!

American Idol, Season 24 Finale, Monday, May 11, 8/7c, ABC and Disney+

Jordan McCullough

3. Jordan McCullough

Jordan McCullough has proven to be a favorite amid his peers, winning the platinum ticket in the Ohana Round. However, he has the lowest amount of Instagram followers of the finalists (43,600) and with 36,000 and 45,000 YouTube views on his Top 5 performances so far, he falls at the bottom of the pack.

Keyla Richardson
Disney/Eric McCandless

2. Keyla Richardson

Keyla Richardson has racked up 109,000 followers on Instagram, and her Top 5 performance views are at 37,000 and 56,000 on YouTube so far.

HANNAH HARPER
Disney/Eric McCandless

1. Hannah Harper

Ever since Hannah Harper’s audition went viral, it was no secret that she was going to be a threat in this competition, and she seems to be the favorite to win heading into the finale.

She is way ahead of her fellow finalists when it comes to Instagram followers (397,000), and also leads the pack on performance views, with 60,000 and 57,000 so far.

 

American Idol key art

Hit All the High Notes

Get absolutely everything about American Idol in your inbox!




Conversation4 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Register or sign in to join the conversation.

  1. A

    Anonymous

    rooting for Jordan AND Hannah over here for 2 reasons: Jordan has the most powerful and one of the most moving voices on the show, And Hannah's smooth bluegrass sound is amazing every time. When Jordan sang colors of the wind on Disney night it especially gave me the chills and brought me to tears. and I loved Hannah's first song on the top 3 episode it really showed her fun side personality. overall I would hope for either to win

    4

  2. C

    Chippendale

    Rooting for Hannah Harper to win American Idols. Her audition has a massive impact and resonate with mothers everywhere (post-natal depression). I cried a lot after having my third child at home alone feeling right at the edge of the world. She reminds me so much of Lauretta Lynn (the Coal Miner Daughter's story). Lauretta Lynn navigated her way in pursuing her singing talent while being a mother and a wife. It's Hannah's prime time to NOT abandon her talent and passion in singing while being a mother of three and a loving wife to her husband. Can someone in the country music world step up and nurture and support this young lady's talent and her big family. I also love and admire her signature Hannah style, both hair and outfit, with a homemade and simple designed dress. How adorable and unique with no bother of the fashion world. I hope Hannah will keep up with her signature style in her fashion taste and help the unsustainable fashions these days to become more aware of the damage it causes to the environment (homemade, reuse, repair, and restrain).

    3

  3. A

    Anonymous

    Jordon should win he is an amazing singer and has a beautiful voice .

    2

  4. A

    Angel

    Would like to see Hannah win!

    2