‘Home Town’ Fans Have Mixed Feelings About Painting Erin Napier Included in This Week’s Design

Ben and Erin Napier
Ben Napier Instagram
Ben Napier Instagram

Erin Napier made a controversial choice with the artwork she chose to include in the home renovation on this week’s episode of Home Town. Following Sunday’s (February 23) episode, fans took to social media to share their mixed reviews about the design choice, which was placed in the living room and featured a floor-to-ceiling painting of a woman dancing.

“I wonder if the owners will keep that huge dancing woman painting Erin made. Dominates the room,” one person pointed out on Reddit. Several others agreed, writing, “Yeah it was a cool painting but it was HUGE and didn’t fit the vibe of the room at all,” “I wondered the same. It’s very specific and so huge. I admire Erin’s work and creative thinking, but not sure I’d want that ‘art piece’ in my house,” and, “I thought the same thing, cool painting but it’s just so big!”

In the comments of Erin’s Instagram post about the episode, the reactions were more positive. “That piece of art you did from the old flooring was simply the best ever,” someone gushed. Another person wrote, “Erin don’t stop painting your amazingly talented,” and someone else said, “Your painting is gorgeous!!! Loved the episode. Fabulous!”

Erin Napier's painting of a dancing woman on Home Town

Erin Napier/Instagram

Erin was proud of the work she and husband Ben Napier did. “Alright this one is one of my very favorite houses and episodes ever,” she shared. “We had fun making it, then I got the giggles last night watching Mary Claire get the giggles and now I guess y’all are probably gonna call it The Giggle One. What’s your favorite part?”

Season 8 of Home Town is currently airing, but the Napiers confirmed earlier this month that filming for Season 9 has already begun. The HGTV series has been picked up for 32 more episodes and will film through 2027

Home Town, Sundays, 8/7c, HGTV




Conversation33 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Comments are closed on this story.

  1. G

    GreenHat

    I own an art gallery. The painting might not meet the aesthetic needs or interests of some people, but I thought it was perfect. It suited the homeowner's mid 20th century collection, fit the dimensions between the windows, was the perfect use of repurposed materials, and Erin incorporating the ghinko design was brilliant. Erin gets an A+.

    30 4

    1. O

      OrangeAirBalloon

      I agree!!

      I think it’s wonderful!!

      1

  2. P

    PurpleHammer

    It was a cool way to repurpose the old flooring. It's not like she painted it on the wall. If the owners don't like it, they're not obligated to keep it and if they do even better. Idk why people complain when it's not their home she put it in.

    11 1

    1. G

      GoldTeepee

      Some people just like to complain.

  3. P

    PurpleAnchor

    It is stunning, tasteful, artistic, fits well with decor, timeless!!!

    13 3

  4. G

    GreenCupcake

    I think the large woman painting was great for the couple and they seemed to really like it. Erin is very talented and creative.

    12 3

  5. O

    OrangeWeights

    I thought it was fantastic.

    11 3

  6. R

    RedTurtle

    If the client loves it that is all that matters. Art is subjective, it is a besutiful painting.

    8 2

  7. B

    BlueTooth

    Love iii

    5 2

  8. R

    RedPalmtree

    I didn't like it, her water colors in her other art are great. And I don't think it goes w the decor. But I love their show and believe they are really sweet people. I watch all their shows and over again

    7 5

  9. P

    PurpleScooter

    I loved the painting! This work elevated Erin (in my opinion) from okay to OKAY! The attention to line and detail are there in all her work, but this showed the depth of her talent!

    2 1

  10. G

    GoldPopsicle

    I personally would not want the painting in my home.

    If the owners do not want the painting they could, trash it, or sell it on eBay or if they like it keep it. It is up to the home owners.

    3 2

  11. R

    RedLobster

    It was awful I know Erin meant well, but I would not want that big picture in my home!

    8 7

  12. C

    CyanPumpkin

    Not for a private home! Only in a museum or gallery!

  13. L

    Lanan

    Why does Erin say the “g” sound for a word that ends in “ing”. It is not a hard g sound. Makes me nuts.

  14. P

    PurpleLeaf

    I loved it, the show is amazing. You can’t go wrong with art. It’s a good conversation piece.

  15. P

    PurpleSubmarine

    It will become the space where they hang a TV.

  16. B

    BlueClover

    I would've waited about 35 minutes for them to get out the door and then I would've taken it down and paint something else on it

  17. C

    CyanTag

    I love you talent not only in your paintings, but this episode was amazing. My cheeks hurt from smiling as does happen quite a bit when I watch your show. Everything you do is top notch, and Ben is very creative with everything he makes. Thank you both!🥰

    1 1

  18. G

    GreenBowtie

    Really like the painting. It looks like a painting that would fit in a business or home in New Orleans.

  19. B

    BlueFlower

    Everyone has a different taste in art. Even my husband and I like very different things, and usually we agree on everything! The home turned out beautiful!

    1 1

  20. R

    RedSushi

    I liked the painting 🙂

  21. O

    OliveBandAid

    I love it. Very creative.

    1 1

  22. R

    RedRocket

    Painting is the ugliest but if owner likes it end of story

  23. B

    BlueSailboat

    The painting did not appear to be attached to the wall so could be removed

  24. G

    GoldCocktail

    As soon as I saw those panels, they felt like a great abstraction so I was happy when Erin claimed them. I wished Erin would not be so representational in her embellishment, but what she did was in her style zone and quite festive. I saw it as a horizontal piece; she went vertical in interpretation. Such is artistic vision. I certainly would be happy to have it and would happily work with the scale. I noticed that they didn't hang the piece so it's the owners to use as they wish.

    1

  25. P

    PurpleCar

    That is ugly. The little houses aren't bad but that one is atrocious.

    1

  26. G

    GoldScooter

    My personal feeling is way to big and ugly. Art is very personal taste thing. Hope the owners don't feel obliged to keep it. Erin is full of talent but it's her talent her vision. The room looks so welcoming it doesn't need that taking over which is what it does

    .

    1 2

  27. R

    RedQuill

    She’s annoying now. It takes some ego to assume someone wants your work that large and prominent. She should just stick with the little house sketches she usually does

    1 2

  28. O

    Olive8Ball

    Not loving it. Looking at the uncomfortable position of the woman’s head within the parameters of the canvas gives me a kink in my neck.

    1 3

  29. O

    OliveCone

    Just to big,it was a show stopper but Not in a good way,not one of Erin's finest works of art for sure.jmo

    2 5

  30. B

    BluePlanet

    If this is about Erin's painting, I think it's too big AND hideous!! She's a better artist than that!

    2 8

  31. B

    BlueCone

    I think it’s awful. I never really liked her anyway. Very snooty and bossy.

    9