‘Wheel of Fortune’ Fans Slam Show for ‘Robbing’ Contestant of $40K With ‘Shaky’ Puzzle

Wheel of Fortune puzzle
Wheel of Fortune/YouTube

Another Wheel of Fortune contestant picked the dreaded “Phrase” category on Wednesday’s (April 3) episode and, as has happened to so many others, lost out on a big money prize because of it.

Sherold Haynes from Richmond, Texas, came into the episode with a steely determination. As she told host Pat Sajak, she finished college last year, at the same time her two oldest daughters were in school. Haynes revealed how she and her daughters pushed and inspired each other.

Haynes showed that same go-getter attitude on Wheel, where she faced off against Aaron Kapanowski, a trampoline park worker from Shelby Township, Michigan, and Ebony Lawrence, a married mother of five from Lakeland, Florida.

By the end of the Express Round, Haynes led the way with $21,400 in cash and a trip to The Buccaneer in St. Croix. While Kapanowski and Lawrence made a valiant comeback in the later rounds, it wasn’t enough to overtake Haynes, who advanced to the Bonus Round.

Haynes selected “Phrase” as the category, and the additional letters “D, P, G, and I,” which left her with a three-word puzzle that read, “_ N / S _ _ _ _ / G R _ _ N D.”

Despite the “Phrase” category often tripping players up, this one looked solvable, and Haynes jumped in right away with “On Solid Ground.”

Unfortunately, it wasn’t quite right.

“No, no, still time,” Sajak told a panicked Haynes.

Haynes struggled to come up with the correct answer (“On Shaky Ground”), guessing “On Sandy Ground” as the timer ran out.

“You know, when you’re sure you know what it is, it’s hard to switch gears after that,” Sajak said reassuringly. “That was a fine attempt.”

The reaction on social media was mixed, with some thinking Haynes was robbed.

“These made up sayings on Wheel of Fortune are getting old!! Who says On Shaky Ground? It’s exactly what she said On Solid Ground!!!” wrote one viewer on X (formerly Twitter).

“@WheelofFortunecheated tonight’s winner on the final board. The winning puzzle was “On Shaky Ground”. The appropriate spelling is “shakey”, which gives different letter spacing. They owe that lady money!” said another.

“I guessed A SOLID GROUND too and then I remembered there was no L in the puzzle,” said a YouTube commenter.

Another added, “I’m of the opinion that if you make it to the final round of WheelofFortune you never choose ‘Phrase’….that would be my strategy…”

What do you think? Was this a lousy puzzle? Or was Haynes just unlucky? Let us know in the comments below.

Wheel of Fortune, Weekdays, check your local listings 




Conversation17 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Comments are closed on this story.

  1. B

    BlueBandAid

    Tired of all this made up “outrage”. It’s a legitimate phrase. Her answer was obviously not correct given the letter choices.

    15

  2. C

    CyanCoathanger

    First off, "on shaky ground" isn't a phrase made up by the show. Secondly, it is spelled "shaky". And there was already a D on the board, so she should have known it was a bad guess.

    12

    1. O

      OliveBeer

      Yep.

  3. R

    RedToast

    She got it wrong. And it is spelled “shaky”. No controversy whatsoever!

    11

  4. G

    GreenQuill

    The phrase is 100% legit. She just didn't have the right answer. No one was cheated out of anything.

    8

  5. O

    OrangeMagnet

    The last letter in "solid" is "d", which was already on the board, so no. Duh. Also begins with letter d, in case you didn't notice.

    6

  6. G

    GreenWrench

    She was wrong. No question. I'm 72 and I've used the phrase "on shaky ground" my whole life.

    2

  7. P

    PurpleRing

    Nothing wrong with that puzzle. Nowhere near as bad as one from a Hawai'i show a few years ago: FOLKSY CHARM!!!

    2

  8. B

    BlueFlower

    Hate that happened to her. Yes, I thought the correct spelling was shaky.

    I saw a bonus round puzzle. Category was Place . The answer was. Swimming Pool. Many of us disagree, that it is a Thing, not a Place. What do you think?

    1

  9. G

    GoldButterfly

    Seems you people have way too much time on your hands to be complaining about a game show The answer is the answer no ifs ands or butts about it.. nobody gets jipped out of anything if they're wrong they're wrong

    1

  10. O

    OliveBeer

    It's all fair , she got it wrong that's it .

  11. G

    GoldButterfly

    If all you're going to do is whine about the answers and who gets jipped out of prize money maybe you should watch another show.... These shows are taped like 3 months in advance

  12. G

    GoldButterfly

    The puzzle IS the puzzle ..if nobody gets it correct, nobody is so called jipped out of anything either they get it right or they don't end of discussion

  13. O

    OliveBandAid

    I think the employees of TV Insider are required every single day to come up with a story about either "Jeopardy" or "Wheel of Fortune," or both, and I feel sorry for you guys.

  14. R

    RedSeahorse

    I guessed shaky of the top and in time - obviously no L or D. She blew it.

  15. G

    GoldRing

    Typical wheel. I do think they should not include the price of the trip people win. Thats not fair at all. It should be the cash they win only. Thats fair to all contestants. I dont know who made that rule, but they should be replaced. It's not fair at all.

  16. B

    Blue8Ball

    Give it to her. In fact any nonyt player that comes on just can guess tomato and they should win because owed it for racism. Slavery, discrimination, white privilege and not having same chances.

    1