Katy Perry Weighs In on Her ‘American Idol’ Replacement

Katy Perry for American Idol
Disney/Art Streiber

After spending seven seasons as a host on American Idol, Katy Perry is getting ready to say goodbye. Although fans are sad to see her go, the question on everyone’s mind is: Who will take her place?

Well, according to Perry, the answer is simple. “Just someone that can put up with Luke and Lionel,” she said.

The “Firework” singer added, “Keep my seat warm.” Is Perry hinting at a possible return to the show in the future?

Although ABC has yet to reveal who will be taking Perry’s spot alongside Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie on Season 23 of the show, there are a few pop singers’ names, including Jennifer Lopez, that have been floating around.

“A return from the past is on the cards,” a source close to American Idol told DailyMail.com. “J.Lo will be asked to come back. When people come back, things work… people like nostalgia, and people like Jen. It would be a big get to get her back.”

The “Jenny From the Block” singer first appeared on the show during Season 10, then returned as a judge in Seasons 11, 13, 14, and 15.

Another familiar female singer who is rumored to be in the running for the open position is former Idol winner Jordin Sparks. She recently took to X (formerly known as Twitter) to express her interest in being a judge next season, writing, “Oh hiiii @AmericanIdol —I hear a seat opened up at the judges table! I’m putting my name in the hat!” 

Perry announced that she was leaving the popular singing competition after Season 22 on Jimmy Kimmel Live! back in February, revealing, “So I think this will probably be my last season for Idol.” 

Perry claims that being on the show makes her feel “connected with the heart of America,” but that she now needs to “feel that pulse to my own beat.”

The reason for her departure is to focus on her pop career and to release new music.

“I love the show so much, but I want to go and see the world and maybe bring new music,” Perry told Kimmel. “It’s going to be a very, very exciting year for all pop star girlies. Let’s just say I’m creating space for my new wingspan.”

Who do you think should replace Katy Perry next season on American Idol? Leave your guesses below!

American Idol, Sundays and Mondays, 8/7c, ABC




Conversation35 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Comments are closed on this story.

  1. P

    PurpleBlowdryer

    Tori Kelly?

    8 1

  2. R

    RedElephant

    Please not JLo. She’s a has been. Not Carrie Underwood either. They need a fresh face.

    11 5

    1. P

      PurpleBlowdryer

      They need a fresh face with some success in the music business. There aren't a 'tot of females who live in California and would commit to Idol's schedule who fit that bill. Kelly C. and JHud have gone beyond that. Someone who wants to take time off from touring for a while and appeals to Idol's fandom would be hard to find.

      6

    2. J

      Janessa Zhang

      What’s wrong with JLo and Carrie Underwood? Both Carrie and Jennifer had an amazing year Jennifer had release a new album with an album movie to go with it?

  3. B

    BlueFlower

    Pink, no one else.

    6 3

    1. C

      CyanFish

      Pink is as annoying in her own way as Katy P..

  4. P

    PurpleFlame

    Please not J.Lo anyone but J. Lo or Shakira ugh.

    5 2

  5. G

    GoldAnchor

    Just glad the drama queen is leaving.

    3 1

  6. G

    GreenPlane

    Definitely Jordin Sparks!!!

  7. J

    Janessa Zhang

    I would like to see (or bring back) either P!nk, Jennifer Lopez, Christina Aguilera (she was a judge on The Voice), Jennifer Nettles (from the band Sugarland and also a judge on a singing competition Duets), Carrie Underwood, Shania Twain (you get a little bit of pop and country with Shania), Kelly Clarkson, Miley Cyrus, and Shakira! All these fabulous ladies will make excellent judges to America Idol but like Katy said whomever can put up with Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan! And can’t wait to see who Katy Perry will pick to keep her seat warm!

  8. G

    GoldBug

    Not Jordan Sparks. JLo is okay. Boy would I love to see Kelly Clarkson but we know that won’t happen.

  9. S

    Stephanie

    What about someone like Lady Gaga

    1 1

    1. C

      CyanFish

      Another attention starved show off? NO!

  10. O

    OrangeBucket

    I'd like to see Amy Grant as a judge

    1 1

  11. P

    PurpleFlame

    I would hope they keep the judge in the same lane/genre as queen Katie… pop. Keep the panel the 3 main genres… I’d love to see legends like Christina Aguilera, alanis morisette, or current pop gals like dua lipa, troye Sivan, Olivia Rodrigo, Sza, Sabrina carpenter, Tori Kelly, some good fresh insights! Katie’s humor will be missed and her wild themed fashions lol. But can’t wait for her to give us some new music!

    1 1

  12. O

    OliveBullhorn

    Please please please not JLo! She is terrible and definitely a has been!

    1 3

  13. B

    BlueSailboat

    JellyRoll

    3 6

    1. P

      PurpleFlame

      best one yet

      5

    2. P

      PurpleBlowdryer

      They need a female judge and Luke is country, so no.

      2

  14. G

    GoldGlasses

    Alanis Morrisette would be AMAZING!!

    3 6

    1. G

      GoldAnchor

      Jagged big pill?

    2. N

      Nat

      I would say her or Pink. Those would be great choices. Tori Kelly may be a good option too, but I would much prefer Pink.

  15. B

    BlueProcessor

    I would love to see JLo back on the show.

    9 13

  16. P

    PurpleBottleOpener

    I think either Allanis Morrisette, Carrie Underwood, Stevie Nicks, Shania Twain, Reba McEntire, Vince Gill, or Miranda Lambert.

    1 6

    1. P

      PurpleFlame

      cant be reba she is on the voice

      4

    2. P

      PurpleBlowdryer

      Alanna's, Stevie and Shania are too old for Idol viewership. This isn'r Wheel of Fortune that plays to the geriatric set.

      3 1

  17. O

    OrangeRaindrop

    Alanis Morissette, Stevie Nicks, Sheryl Crow

    2 7

    1. B

      BlueSailboat

      What advertisers would pay to support them? Pharmaceuticals and stair lifts? They're done.

      2

      1. C

        CyanFish

        Adult diapers, canes and vitamin supplements.

        1

  18. G

    GoldTeepee

    Miley cyrus

    1 8

    1. G

      GreenPlane

      YES 😊

      5

    2. B

      BlueSailboat

      Not in a million!

      5

    3. N

      Nat

      She was on The Voice for a season or 2 and she was just horrible as a judge.

  19. R

    RedSeahorse

    Good riddance. She's such an attention hog. Bring back JLo, get Carrie Underwood or Jordin Sparks.

    6 15

    1. J

      Janessa Zhang

      If you don’t like Katy Perry’s personality then go find another singing competition to watch cause that is who Katy Perry is and no she’s not an attention hog she just has an bubbly personality that’s all!