‘Chesapeake Shores’: Should Abby Choose Evan or Jay? (POLL)
We’re only a week away from finding out if Abby (Meghan Ory) called Evan (Robert Buckley) or Jay (Greyston Holt) in the Chesapeake Shores Season 5 finale, but as we continue to wait, we want to know who you think she should choose.
There’s Jay, the teacher, whom Abby invited as her plus one for Jess (Laci J. Mailey) and David’s (Carlo Marks) wedding. It seemed like something could happen between them and he won her over with his photo of her as an example of capturing a perfect moment. Still, in the finale, he admitted that while he had feelings for her, he also liked a guidance counselor at the school and wanted to start something with her unless Abby could tell him there was hope for the two of them.
Meanwhile, Abby spent Season 5 bantering with billionaire Evan (and danced with him at the aforementioned wedding). In the finale, upon realizing he wanted to ask her out, he made the grandest of gestures: picking her up from the airport. She agreed to think about going on “a full-on date” with him. While he drove her crazy, she was possibly interested (and it didn’t hurt that he brought her daughter dairy-free brownies).
That left Abby with a lot to think about, but she told her sister Bree (Emilie Ullerup), “I don’t know if I want to be with either of them. I don’t know if I want to be with anyone right now.” Still, by the end of the finale, she’d left someone a voicemail: “I have been thinking about you and I think maybe we should give this a try.”
The Season 6 trailer makes it look like Abby and Evan will be going on a date, but promos can be deceiving. Plus, even if they do go on a date, that doesn’t necessarily mean she called or will end up with him. Both guys have proven they’d be excellent choices and consider her daughters. Sure, for some, it might be hard to imagine Abby getting serious with anyone but Trace (Jesse Metcalfe). But he left, we don’t know if he’ll be back, and she seems ready to move on. Everyone has an opinion about romances on TV shows, so we’re asking you to vote in the poll below to tell us who you think Abby should (not necessarily will) choose.
Chesapeake Shores, Sixth and Final Season Premiere, Sunday, August 14, 8/7c, Hallmark Channel
Conversation12 Comments
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Comments are closed on this story.
-
G
Trace should come back. That is who she married in the books and who she should end up with.
7
-
C
Stick with your books and don’t watch the show.
-
-
G
Neither. Trace was her love and was going to give up his passion for music touring. Please don't pick Evan because he has money. In the long run it will not make you happy.
5
-
C
They had forced chemistry while Evan might be good for Abby as he can provide her with luxuries that Trace never could with based on his income.
Trace was never her true love as she wouldn’t have left him after high school. Abby is a Type A white collar woman and it is time that we show some reality on TV. Women just don’t date men below their own financial status. White collar and blue collar don’t hook up.
-
O
I liked Trace but he couldnt decide on music or Abbey.
If you can’t choose, you lose.
-
-
G
Abby should be with her first love and that Trace. But she should have some fun with Evan.
5
-
G
You should bring Trace back for the last season so they can end up together. Hr is the best for her. They both loved each other and was good together. That would give a good ending to the show.
4
-
R
I love Abby & Evan, she seems lighter and happier with him.
3
-
C
Definitely want Trace to come back for the finale, so they can end up together❤️
2
-
O
Evan for sure, just because he keeps trying for her. Even if he’s a little awkward sometimes.
2
-
P
In which of the book did they get married?
-
G
I love Evan, he is witty, handsome, smart, intelligent and very, very thoughtful of her family members especially her children, They have this sort of rom com chemistry, but also you can see passion developing between them taking their friendship to another level. The way he looks at her is so romantic.
Watchlist Easy access to only the shows you care about — all in one simple place
Alerts Only important notifications — when a show is returning, when it becomes available to stream, and more.
Special Offers Exclusive products we release related to your favorite shows and streaming services