‘American Idol’ Crowns Its 2020 Winner — Did America Make the Right Choice?
Spoiler Alert
[Warning: The below contains MAJOR spoilers for the Season 3 finale of American Idol.]
American Idol made history on Sunday, May 17 when the ABC singing competition crowned its first winner remotely in the show’s 18-year history.
The evening kicked off with a group performance from the Top 7 of The Beatles’ “Come Together,” before the Top 5 was unveiled. Dillon James, Jonny West, Arthur Gunn, Francisco Martin, and Just Sam were the lucky contestants chosen to move forward, vying for America’s live vote for the night. Louis Knight and Julia Gargano were eliminated before the performances began.
First up was Dillon James who performed Eric Clapton’s “Change the World” to much praise from judges Katy Perry, Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan. After that, Francisco Martin took on Harry Styles’ tune “Adore You” and was commended for his improved stage presence.
Just Sam turned to former Idol champ Kelly Clarkson for her performance of “Stronger (What Doesn’t Kill You),” giving the tune her own special twist that earned high praise from the show’s judges. Arthur Gunn was up next, singing Gavin DeGraw’s “I Don’t Want to Be,” impressing the judges with his powerful rendition. And Jonny West finished out Round 1 strong with his version of “You Can’t Keep a Good Man Down.”
(Credit: ABC)
In a brief intermission, mentor Bobby Bones and host Ryan Seacrest discussed the success of this year’s finalists before things moved into Round 2 with the contestants reviving their best songs of the season. Dillon James was up first once again, singing Bob Dylan’s “The Times They Are A-Changin’.” After that it was Francisco Martin performing Maggie Rogers’ “Alaska,” Just Sam singing Andra Day’s “Rise Up,” Arthur Gunn’s unique take on Creedence Clearwater Revival’s “Have You Ever Seen the Rain,” and Jonny West’s original tune, “Makin’ Love.” The songs performed in this round represented their first single should they take the Idol title.
To give America a chance to vote before the big reveal, viewers got about an hour of pure entertainment from a range of performances like judge Luke Bryan’s new tune “One Margarita.” After that, Bryan surprised one of this year’s eliminated hopefuls, Doug Kiker, via video chat, revealing that he’d be performing “Bless the Broken Road” alongside Rascal Flatts.
For another moving musical moment, Just Sam teamed up with Lauren Daigle to sing a showstopping rendition of Daigle’s hit “You Say.” Katy Perry then did a trippy virtual reality-inspired performance of her new single “Daisies,” before Oscar-nominated actress and singer Cynthia Erivo stopped by (in a sense) for a medley of Aretha Franklin hits, joined by the Top 11 —Gunn, James, Martin, West, Sam, Gargano, Knight, Makayla Phillips, Sophia James, Jovin Webb, and Grace Leer.
After their performance, Seacrest announced that Arthur Gunn and Just Sam were America’s choices for the Top 2, bidding the rest of the contestants farewell. In the end, an ecstatic and emotional Just Sam was crowned this year’s American Idol before she joined judges Perry, Richie, and Bryan and the Top 7, as well as alums Alejandro Aranda (aka Scarypoolparty), Fantasia, Gabby Barrett, Jordin Sparks, Katharine McPhee, Kellie Pickler, Laine Hardy, Lauren Alaina, Phillip Phillips, Ruben Studdard, and Scotty McCreery in a performance of “We Are the World.”
Catch Just Sam’s performance of “Rise Up” which will serve as her first single and see the moment she learned that she was the newest American Idol. Let us know what you think about the results below.
Hit All the High Notes
Get absolutely everything about American Idol in your inbox!
Conversation381 Comments
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Comments are closed on this story.
-
C
No, no, no.... not the right choice. She was definitely not the best singer she just happened to be Lionel Richie's favorite! I could tell that he wanted her to win after every performance the way he praised her. Nothing about this post is racist so don't start your hating. Arthur Gunn or Dillon James should have won.
My overall votes were for Arthur Gunn, what a talent!!!
86 6
-
O
Agree.
10
-
C
YEP!!
1 1
-
G
I like Arthur Gunn as well. He sounds a lot like John Fogerty (Creedence Clearwater) and if Bob Dylan had been a cowboy, Dillon James nailed it with his folk ballad style. Don't worry about Arthur and Dillon. Just because they didn't win A.I., doesn't mean that they won't go on to have recording careers. With their talent, I know they're going to be approached by talent agents and record producers. Let's face it, A.I. is kind of a popularity contest as well as a talent show. I'm happy for Sam, but I also have faith in the contestants that didn't win.
4
-
-
G
totally agree
1
-
B
Agree totally .. Arthur Gunn should have won!
10 1
-
R
Arthur hands down
1
-
C
Agreed
-
-
G
Yes, Arthur overall had the best run from Top 40 to the finale. That said, I think Dillon James' performances were heads and shoulders above everyone else's last night. So... The best from last night did not win, and the best from the last month did not win. That's okay, that's just how it goes with a live audience vote based on popularity. Love Just Sam. Doesn't really matter where everyone finished.
6 1
-
G
I agree Dillion had just as good of story to tell/hear. He cane through his drug addiction to be sober & writing, praying, & singing w/meaning. Everyone on AI we’re pushing her /& her story more than anyone else which to me , wasn’t done fairly..that’s why I stopped watching it before.
2
-
C
Totally agree. Im done watching she won cause the judges pushed her the whole way.
-
-
-
C
totally agree. Those other two were more talented and how obvious her story was pushed. Like there isnt anyone else who grew up without a mom or poor. I knew she would win from the very beginning simply because of her boo hoo story. It's probably not even true like how she picked her "just" name. She knew that would work on everyone.
6 2
-
G
Well if it is not racist why are you the first to say it is not?? The winner is determined by the votes that they get It makes no difference how many times you voted for Arthur he just did not get enough votes to win!! Most of the ones on here running their mouths did not vote!!
1 6
-
C
Its fixed
-
-
C
Agree
2
-
-
O
Arthur Gunn did win....he will not be locked in to the American Idol contract. His future is definitely better because of that.
65 3
-
P
Agree 💯%
6
-
O
I have heard that before. Best of luck to Arthur!
2
-
O
YES YES
-
C
hey pot head he will be locked in a contract or he be singing for free, quit smoking pot.
2 2
-
C
You don’t know that! What a stupid thing to say!
-
-
C
Agreed. He was amazing
3
-
-
O
I hate to say it but it seems as if the show pushed her story and her on people the whole season and def feels like the votes did not add up to the winner. If you look on you tube Arthur Gunn has like 105k views on one performance and 89 on other she had like 13k on one and 17k on other? He has clearly been a favorite to watch
61 2
-
G
This in my opinion was decided before voting . Auntie Katie and gang made it happen. She did okay . She’s a cutie . Love her story .
3
-
C
But it’s not Queen for a Day ...it’s American Idol
5
-
C
agreed. She won the first day
-
-
G
Because all the votes were split between seven people. She had way more supporters. It’s America’s choice.
2 1
-
G
I agree, she was pushed all season by the judges, focusing on her sad life.
16 2
-
O
SHE SURE WAS
2 1
-
C
totally and completely agree. Those other 4 guys were more talented and her story was definitely pushed. Come on
6
-
C
Agreed all the way by the judges. Not fair should have been arthur
-
-
O
YES HE WAS THE WINNER TO US
14 1
-
R
Exactly! He would have won if they could have voted on the west coast during the show. And Sam sang with Lauren Daigle during the finale. Really?
7
-
R
Was very Yes appointed me and my girlfriend knew that Arthur gun should have won He was the best I feel very bad for him
1
-
-
R
Arthur Gunn got ripped off he was definitely the best
7
-
G
No he wasn’t! That is why he did not win!!
3 2
-
-
O
I agree luv some Arthur
1
-
C
For the short time that I watched the show this season they really pushed her and her story. Lionel was her biggest push. I do not think she is the new American Idol but you never know. I am sure Arthur will get contracts but will not be known as the winner of the t.v. show.He will succeed better then Sam.
2 1
-
C
Totally agree. Lionel pushed her thru the whole season. Arthurs incredible.
2
-
R
Agreed!!
1
-
G
your so right, she was good but not the best!!
2
-
-
G
No I think Arthur should have won. They were all good
57 3
-
O
ARTHUR SHOULD HAVE WON
20 1
-
R
Look at all these comments for Arthur gun He was surely ripped off
11 1
-
-
G
arthur gunn had the most votes. nothing against Sam but Arthur was the clear winner
51 5
-
P
Yesyesyes
7 2
-
C
Did you count the votes?
4 1
-
C
They didnt its fixed didnt add west coast.
-
-
P
Agree!
1
-
O
Agreed !
5
-
P
yeah i agree
8
-
C
Show is fixed
2 1
-
-
O
how can voting be over when we haven't even watched it yet on the West Coast?
44
-
O
Yah this was so weird?
7
-
G
It’s a joke, west coast votes did not count unless u voted before the show aired
18
-
P
I’ve been saying this since instant save/live voting debuted; bunch of BS! Idol is rigged!
4
-
-
C
I live in Seattle & couldn’t vote!
7 1
-
B
Was thinking the same thing. All three CA dudes in the top scored lowest...odd.
6
-
G
thats not right!! I guess they didnt count the CA votes
-
-
-
P
I like Arthur his singing has that bob marley style. I will buy his album. If he couldn’t win at least he was runner up👍
31
-
G
singing ........He can't sing All he could do is shout ...................Unbelievable
3 18
-
G
His range is 3 notes all pitchy
4
-
G
He has a unique style and a nice range in my opinion as a musician. I like most that he is not like every other singer and actually interesting, what talent. I am really happy for Sam however.
1
-
C
R u hard of hearing
-
-
P
and Sam can sing? Bwah hahaha! You are deranged
2
-
-
C
He got robbed
4
-
-
B
Arthur should have won hands down
28 1
-
B
You wrong
6
-
-
O
No. I think Aurthur Gunn should have been AI.2020
25 2
-
P
No. Arthur should have won.
23 1
-
O
No, Gunn should have won. Even the garbage man sang better than just sam.
23 2
-
G
Arthur Gunn should have been American Idol 2020 winner.
23 2
-
P
so do i
7
-
-
B
Arthur Gunn was amazing and Humble
22 2
-
G
yes amazingly bad
3 11
-
G
stop hating on arthur, he doesn't deserve all that negatvity that ur putting on him
1
-
-
-
P
This year was a hard choice, all the top 5 were great, my favorites where Dillon, Arthur and Just Sam. This group was some of the best contestants I've ever seen on Idol. I really hope they all get recording contracts. I have to say I thought it was great that Just Sam won. I would have been happy with Arthur or Dillion, too. It was an impossible choice.
20
-
B
Yes they were all great. I liked all the guys more than Sam but I'm happy for her. Definitely impossible to choose lol
8
-
C
Arthur was the most unique. Should of won.
-
-
C
I was for Dillon all the way! But I couldn’t vote on West Coast. He will do very well though.
9 1
-
B
Thank you...for not taking her accomplishment away....the others will go far...
1
-
-
R
Wow.. Gunn way better
19 2
-
O
Dillion James was my favorite!
The voting was not fair as Mountain Time and West Coast Zones didn’t get to vote! What’s up with that?
17 1
-
C
Me too! Wanted to vote for Dillon but couldn’t.
2 1
-
-
G
Why didn’t the West Coast get to vote? Such a bunch of crap. Did the show start early tonight?
Arthur Gunn should of won.
17 1
-
C
It was fixed. If they let u vote arthur would of won.
1
-
-
G
Arthur should have WON!!!
20 4
-
B
Kinda of knew it after they saved her🤬
Julia Gargano pure, solid all around performer should of finished first
Secondly, if not Julia then Aurther would of be the next soulful free spirit.
As always disappointing
17 1
-
G
No, Arthur Gunn won. Why didn’t the west Coast vote count
16 1
-
P
Because Idol chooses to ignore everyone not in eastern time zone
5
-
C
When I tried it said voting is closed. Not fair!
2
-
-
P
its ridiculous that she won but not surprised seemed like ai picked the winner instead of the people. was Setup and pre-planned? She doesn’t even sing very well, she’s like a backup singer
20 5
-
O
Should have let west coast vote. The three guys from California did not have a chance with the voting on the east coast feed
14
-
P
The true winner was Arthur Gunn anyway
16 2
-
O
I honestly thought she was going to get least amount of votes. Nothing against her she seems super sweet but the rest were just so talented and were on a different level.
15 3
-
P
Thank you for the voice of sanity! Could not agree more!
3 1
-
-
P
Arthur Gunn is the best singer in American Idol that y’all have had in a while. Arthur is the clear winner.
12 1
-
O
Idol screwed up
12 1
-
G
I feel ripped off, the whole west coast doesn’t get to vote???? After watching all season...
12 1
-
P
THANK YOU!!! Been saying this since live save/votes debuted!
1
-
-
O
100% NO. Arthur and John West were by far the 2 standouts. Arthur should have won for sure. Sam is a decent singer but that’s it nothing more. I was surprised when she made it to top 5.
15 4
-
P
No it was a matter of pity that she won the contest. All politics
16 5
-
R
We were not even given enough time to get all of our votes in and i am pissed. Everyone should have been givin more time. That crap is so wrong. I feel they need to do the voting over and give everyone enough time to get their votes in so we can see who the real true winner is.
11 1
-
G
Arthur Gunn should have definitely won! He was by far the best singer!!!
11 2
-
B
He may have been, but he didn't win....it has happened every....but now you see a problem....Adam Lambert and others....
1
-
-
C
Absolutely i loved Just same, I also loved Arthur Gunn
10 1
-
R
NO... you knew when she stayed in California it was already a done deal... when everybody else went to their homes.
11 3
-
R
I remember why I stopped watching Idol years ago now. Arthur Gunn is TWICE as good.
10 2
-
O
If they would have let West Coast vote... would have been accurate and the true winner Arthur would have won!!!!!
8 1
-
B
He did win....he'll be another Jennifer Hudson and Adam Lambert...
1
-
-
G
No, Arthur Gunn was more deserving of the title and should of been the winner of American Idol.
9 2
-
O
Just Sam has an incredible heart but her voice was no where near the other contestants. Arthur should have won. I’m shocked that he didn’t win.
8 1
-
R
No.....and not surprised at results
7
-
R
Right?!
1
-
-
O
I dont think I will be watching next season. It seems like it was rigged. She was definitely not the best singer in the top five. The judges felt sorry for her and new she could not win on her own. The other four will be more of a success then she will.
8 2
-
B
American Idol is a joke. Clearly Arthur Gunn, won this and Lionel Richie and Auntie Katie set it up for her to win. I don't care what anyone says American Idol is not picked by America it is picked by the judges. Clearly from the beginning Lionel Richie wanted Just Sam to win. I stopped watching American Idol before because of the judges rigging up the votes. It appears to still be rigged so I'm threw watching this mess.
7 1
-
O
Luke was rooting for Francisco the whole time too....they each have their favorite....
1
-
B
I've been saying that for years, but now you see a problem with it....she won....he'll still go far...example, Adam Lambert and Jennifer Hudson...
Congratulations Sam!
-
-
B
My top three were Just Sam, Arthur Gunn and Jonny West. Just Sam is deserving of the crown. Her voice is amazing. All finale five are winners. Congratulations to the girl from the hood with the Cinderella story and fairytale ending.❤
9 3
-
P
The two finalists were a young African American woman and a young man from India. How can choosing the former be racist. You may not like the results but doubt that racism had anything to do with the outcome. Fine to express your opinion as to your favorite but do we really need to trash the winner when it was not our first choice?
7 1
-
G
Oh by the way Auther is from NEPAL and not India for your correction .
2
-
P
Arthur Gunn is from Nepal, NOT India, just thought I’d point this out. As far as Sam, she is NOT a good singer so of course she will get trashed. I agree she seems like a great person and has undoubtedly had a tough go of it, but any of the 4 guys were 1000% more deserving.
12 2
-
O
100% true. This is exactly what I said all 4 of those guys were so talented and she was just ok. Not trying to be mean she seems nice and I wish her the best and I’m sure she’s as good as some other singers out there that are famous but she was nowhere near the best Idol had this season not even in same level as those 4
-
-
O
Arthur Gunn is from Nepal not India
1
-
-
C
Guys you do not have to degrade anyone because your favorite did not win. Just Sam is absolutely AMAZING!!! You have to remember that your comments could be hurtful!!
11 6
-
B
HELL NO
6 1
-
O
Yes! Chose her from day one. However, the top 10 all had something to offer. Happy with the final two and they both will be successful in their own right. Congratulations Just Sam!!!
6 1
-
G
i voted forth Arthur Gunn... He will have a much bigger career than Sam... Look at Jennifer Hudson, Adam Lambert and all the other idol runner-ups who have had monstrous careers 🎬😎❤️
6 1
-
G
Gunn should have won. Like her, happy for that young lady, but she should not been in top 5.
4
-
C
I liked Just Sam but I don’t think she should of won. Arthur Gunns voice is better! I am happy for her though. Congratulations Just Sam!!
4
-
G
*should have
-
-
B
Because it was rigged from beginning
nothing fair about this show.
5 1
-
G
The final two was not the best out of the group. Wow , really. Really got it wrong this year!! Im done watching this show!!!!2🤨
5 1
-
B
I saw that every year....but they've won me over this year...I'm happy for her.
1
-
B
I say that every year....but I accept their accomplishment. Great job Sam!
1
-
-
B
Sam was NOT amazing. Was she sweet... yes
NOT a winning voice.
6 2
-
O
Just Sam ! I’m so happy for you. Well deserved!!💯💯💯💯💯💯❤️
5 1
-
G
No,not at all. Wow
5 1
-
B
She sang from her heart and is wasn't pity
5 1
-
P
PurpleTooth. How can you say Arthur had the most votes? Apparently not.
Honestly I was not that impressed with this years group but I did love Just Sam and am thrilled she won. Bottom line everyone: each of us has our favorites so with so many contrasting opinions the vote is the final judge.
Over the years there are Top 12 whose voices I cannot even listen to and others who I think are phenomenal. Some years I have been spot on, others disappointed, and I’m certain our choices conflict. Time will tell who the real stars will be but meanwhile give it up for Just Sam. With coaching and time she will get even better. At at the very least, she no doubt embodies the American dream.
7 3
-
R
Just Sam Def Had The Soul Type of Voice and R&B Style! She also had good stage Presents. Her Story is just Beginning Congrats Sam! NYC Mike Leto
7 3
-
R
Soooo glad Sam won - I loved her the moment I saw that pure soul. I had hoped the final would be Jovin and Sam; both of them sing from somewhere deep, down inside. I wish them and Dillon , another pure heart ,great success in their careers and lives. Go forth children!
6 2
-
G
Just Sam the winner the talent the voice the American idol.
7 3
-
G
I voted for Arthur but America voted Just Sam. They are all in a good place but yes America voted for the right person. Congratulations Just Sam. I hope you don’t have to celebrate alone. We Love all of you 😇👍🏻💖
5 1
-
C
Your comment is classy and it’s what America need
3
-
-
G
YES!!!!! Love her.
5 1
-
P
YES!! Just Sam as my pic from the first night!!
She & Arthur Gunn - Phenomenal!....
Dillon SO Special .... Jonny so gifted....
... as were so many of the final 20 ...
The Lord Bless them all!!
6 2
-
P
Definitely the wrong choice. Her story was told over and over again and again. People voted alot based on that. AI has lost several die-hard fans here.
4 1
-
B
America, at a time of sadness voted for Just Sam’s “story” (grandmother, New York, singing in a subway) I think voting was unfair as well.
3
-
B
What a joke! Arthur should have won
3
-
R
The West Coast did not have a chance to vote!!! It was over already!!! California was left out!!! We did not get a chance to vote!!!!
Very talented group!!! too bad only some people made the decision not America!!
3
-
C
I think Just Sam earned her place and she deserved to win American Idol!! Her voice is flawless!!! Stop hating!!
4 1
-
B
That part she deserves it!
-
-
R
Sam was absolutely the best and right choice!!
6 3
-
O
#blackgirlmagic continues yaaasssss @NoLongerJustSam
3
-
O
This was rigged. For one thing, anyone in MST or PST time zones didn’t get to vote at all. For another, it’s all over the internet that people are not happy with the ending. Arthur was BETTER! He should have won!
4 1
-
B
The voting started when the east coast program aired and it was only for one hour. I think that’s why Sam won because West Coast voters were not all aware of this and therefore did not vote during the East Coast broadcast. This is so weird and unfair.
3
-
R
Yes!!! It was either Arthur Gunn and Just Sam for me. A lot of the contestants were really good singers. I loved the way Arthur sang familiar hits and made them his own. I loved Just Sam's delivery, presence, charm and that powerful voice. Both of their stories are just so inspiring. In the end it was Just Sam's sparkling personality that won Americas's heart. I gave them both a 10!
3
-
G
I wonder if anyone got to vote tonight? I know the West Coast didn’t get to vote. So very unfair.
3
-
B
Half of America did not vote
4 1
-
R
No...she has no artistic quality compared to Arthur,James and Johnny,ok voice but she'll be forgotten pretty soon.
4 1
-
B
Just Sam won on sympathy votes. Her entire journey was nothing but “poor me”.
7 4
-
R
Hell yes from day one I said it and believed that was the winner, she truly deserves it🙏
4 1
-
C
Yes she was fantastic ❤️
4 1
-
O
Bigots! Arthur Gunn was the winner all the way! She’s nothing more than a cover singer. A lounge act at a cheap club!!!!
12 9
-
R
Absolutely!!!
5 2
-
C
Arthur Gunn is a great singer but not an American idol. Just Sam won because of all her struggles she over came,on her own to be a great singer. Subway singing for money to eat, no assistance from anyone, now that’s an American idol. Not Arthur Gunn took singing lessons, had real parents, no obstacles, no pain, no struggles.
american wants someone to Rise up and she did. It’s over now so wipe u tears and move on....
Riseup!!
2
-
G
Just Sam was a family favorite, I think she deserved to win. Even though Arthur didn't win, he has a future set out for him.
3 1
-
O
Maybe Arthur has a signed contract? And maybe so does Johnny? That would suddenly make them ineligible ...
2
-
R
Arthur's family was celebrating because he is not locked into a crap deal from American Idol management companies. A talented star of that level will go on and sign way more lucrative contracts !
2
-
B
The right person did not win American idol
3 1
-
O
Sam is definitely talented and I am happy for her, but I thought Johnny West and Dillon James were the most talented out of the top 5,
-
-
P
Absolutely NOT the best choice!!
2
-
C
Arthur Gunn should have won! Hi could listen to his voice all day, and I really wait each episode just for him! What is it with American Idol, you place the best for second place?
2
-
C
Too short time to bite! Even then, I thought Arthur Gunn should have won!
2
-
G
Absolutely yes and Just Sam was not only the best singer, but also, the best person to be able to be called the best all around from top to bottom American Idol❣ Sam is just such an inspiration and brought tears of joy to my eyes more than once🥰
4 2
-
B
Just be respectful that we were blessed to see these amazing performances. Sam, got the most votes and won. They are all number 1. Let’s appreciate them.
3 1
-
G
dillon should have been in the top two west coast didnt get to vote aired prerecorded pacific time what a joke
3 1
-
O
all contestants were great! The question is in West Coast, why voting is already closed when we were still watching the performances?
2
-
B
Wrong that West Coast didn’t get to vote. FILLION #1- He will be signed I hope
2
-
C
No, Arthur should have won. He excelled in every category. Must be an error in votes.
2
-
B
Frustrated in CA didn’t even get to vote
seemed unfait
2
-
O
still airing in California and voting is already closed. Voting process was disappointing .
2
-
C
Arthur Gunn did win....he will not be locked in to the American Idol contract. His future is definitely better because of that.
2
-
R
that was horrible two years in a row the obvious winner didn't win horrible
4 2
-
P
The AI producers said that they gave contestants the same gadgets to create a level playing field BUT they rigged the voting rules in the finale. What a joke!
2
-
B
I’m totally behind the result! HOWEVER, I was not able to vote throughout the entire voting period tonight. Did anyone else have this problem??
2
-
O
Sorry Sam.... ARTHUR SHOULD HAVE WON!!!!!
4 2
-
O
I am asking for a recount.......... Arthur Gunn is the winner NOT Just Sam!
2
-
G
Yes, absolutely! Just Sam was, by far, the very best singer of the bunch!
4 2
-
B
Yes yes yes
3 1
-
B
Yes america made the right choice just sam is a star
4 2
-
O
unfair. The most populist state did’nt get to vote
3 1
-
O
How do u know he got more votes?
2
-
C
No, Dillon James should have won.
only a ne who performed with out all the backup stuff
3 1
-
R
You are so right!!
1
-
-
G
Yes they did she has the voice to prove it.
4 2
-
B
Arthur is the star.
1
-
G
Sometimes the runner up, ends up being the longest lasting star.
1
-
C
Yes I loved just Sam!
1
-
B
Definitely, America got it right! Life has been hard for her. All the other singers had family the whole time, her family was a cell phone and a tablet! Good for You Sam, You well earned it!!!
1
-
G
They say America voted. But that did not include MT, PT, and Hawaii.
1
-
C
I didn't realize that voting was over by the time we watched the show on the West Coast. Our family didn't get to vote either. I believe Arthur Gunn would have won, if the West Coast was informed to vote BEFORE our show started. My family and I felt very cheated by not being informed about the voting deadline!!! Arthur should have won, but he now has more freedom with his future because he didn't win. I will be buying tickets to his first concert for sure.
1
-
B
Are we voting on a back story or talent? Definitely wrong winner!
1
-
B
No, Jonny West or Arthur Gunn should have one.
1
-
O
this article should say “did the east coast make the right choice” not “America”
1
-
G
i wish simon was still a judge
1
-
G
yea
1
-
G
I wanted Francisco, Arthur or Jonny to win. I don't think that Just Sam should've won.
1
-
O
The American Dream is still alive. Drop all the negative comments, and celebrate her victory with her. She went from a “street singer“ to an American Idol. Sure, all of the contestants were excellent, and they all are winners. They can determine their own destiny. However America (not American Idol) made her the choice. I also expect more from the author of this headline, “Did the right person win ‘American Idol’?”. Very unprofessional! You should be fired. Another confirmation of “fake news” in America.
1
-
B
To get as far in the “contest” as the finalists did by votes from the people - - they were all great! The best SINGER won. No one pushed anyone. All backgrounds of all were given.
Be happy- they both actually “won” and each is happy for the other. Don’t be Debbie Downers and pick everything apart. It was an unusual season for Idol, but I think they did an exceptional job. To say the least I’m sure it wasn’t an easy thing to co-ordinate!!
1
-
O
In my opinion,Arthur Gunn was the more consistent and unique singer .I wish all of the participants well in their musical future and otherwise.
1
-
O
No
1
-
O
I dont think I will be watching anymore. I feel that the results were rigged. She was definitely not the best singer in the top five. The other four will go on to have more success than she will.
1
-
G
The average American has no concept about who is a better singer. There were better female singers that got voted off earlier in the competition. The judges should somehow be used to steer Americans to the better singers other then cheerleading, "everyone is Great". Not everyone is Great. What a disappointment this years American Idol!!!
1
-
R
no
1
-
G
In the time where we are having to adapt to a new way of life and these contestants had to sacrifice a lot in terms of stage presence and delivery, they ALL won.
1
-
B
Dylan was better than just sam
1
-
P
I think the top 5 were all great but it was unfortunate that the west coast could not vote......Kind of disappointing
1
-
G
Very happy for Sam and for Arthur Gunn / can’t wait to see their successes!
1
-
O
NO...I think the show is set up, they know right from the beginning of the live shows who they(the judges) are going to pick as the winner, the voting is all fake! They made a big deal about Just Sam right from her audition it was obvious that’s who was going to win this year. Last year it was the same, they made a big deal about Laine Hardy right from his audition and he won.
2 1
-
P
Sam should never have even made it to the finale, let alone win! This is BS result and proves the disenfranchisement of every contestant not from the east coast, which I have been saying ever since the “live vote” feature debuted. Vote was over before show was even broadcast in the state from which 3 of the 5 finalists were from, and Arthur is from CO in mountain time zone. I’m absolutely p!ssed off right now! Ridiculous...
4 3
-
P
I also thought Johnny West was awesome! His voice, his piano playing was great. I loved how laid back and chill he was!
1
-
O
NO!
Dillon James should have won!
1
-
P
I agree
-
-
G
Sam deserved it! But all were good this year.
2 1
-
G
ABSOLUTELY NOT! How disgusting. Johnny West was the true winner.
2 1
-
R
Arthur should have won. I am bummed!! I hope he gets a record deal. I want to hear more of his talent!!
1
-
G
Absolutely yes!😊
2 1
-
G
YES! 😊
1
-
C
WHAT we did not get to VOTE What a JOKE, so disappointed with American Idol. Sure Sam alright, but who VOTED. NOT ME. So they CHEATED the other guys BAD,BAD,BAD.
3 2
-
B
Yes. People won’t agree on the winner of shows like this, but I say, yes!
2 1
-
G
Jonny West should have won he's great! He has a natural voice
-
G
Absolutely not
-
R
I won't watch it anymore!
-
G
no! i think Jonny West was by far the most talented and great voice, and wrote his own songs
-
O
So fixed. It was already decided six weeks back. The judges fawned over her claiming them as their child. So stupid. Won’t watch anymore. The girl had a nice voice but it was more about her story.
-
R
Just Sam is a good singer with an interesting life story. She should not have won the title of American Idol. I believe that there was to much favoritism shown by the Judges toward her.
Arthur Gunn is a Great singer with a voice that can Blow the House Down. He should have won American Idol 2020 Hands Down!! I just hope he has a great career in music, Arthur and his family all deserve it. Go get em Arthur!!!
-
O
I really liked Dillon James and Arthur Gunn. They were my favorites.
-
B
Just got to see the finale in South Africa. Just Sam i am thrilled you are the winner. You are so versatile. I love love your voice. CONGRATULATIONS TO YOU
-
C
I guess all you got to do to win American Idol is just make them feel sorry for you and cry your whole way through it and then you will win because that pretty much what Just Sam did and look she won
-
C
The garbage man sings better than Just Sam and Just Sam can not sing but won because she sings in subways and because of favoritism which is wrong Lionel Richie
-
C
Show was differently rig because Just Sam should not of won she should not of even been in the top five there no way she even came close to being as good as Arthur Gunn or Dillion James or Jonny West
-
C
If Just Sam is going to win by favoritisms I don’t think Lionel should be aloud to be a judge no more because it’s not right at all on excusable
-
C
I think the show was rig for her to win come on Seattle could not even vote and the west coast didn’t even get a chance to vote so all of America did not even get a chance the vote so how could just Sam even win this was the worst American Idol ever
-
C
No the right person did not win and how can she win when the west coast has not even voted yet
-
O
i am very disappointed in the winner
Arthur Gunn was everyone’s favorite including mine. What a shame real stars with TRUE talent go unrecognized. Arthur had such an outstanding voice.
-
B
I don't think Arthur got robbed he will do great he is #2 and with the right single or album he will make his name. Just Sam is also a good singer so let's not get caught up in all this they made it to the top and wish them both success. I love them both
-
B
YES America got it right THIS YEAR. Last year I was disappointed when Alejandro Arana did not win when he seemed the obvious choice. As as far as "Pushing" Sam's story, well.... she is an inspiration and it was a story worth sharing. Last year Alejandro's story was also inspiration but it did not earn him the win. It was truly up to America. I can't wait to see more of Sam.
-
C
my favorite was Johny West. He had it over all of them. What a good guy.
-
G
No. The numbers were switched. Two weeks ago, Dillon was No. 18 to vote. This week he was No. 15. Normally they keep the same number. What’s up with that. It doesn’t make sense to change his number to 15 after he is in the top 7!
-
G
Nope... wrong choice! American Idol rarely gets it right. Gunn was way better! More raw talent, 100% better...
-
R
We all have our favorites that we wanted to win. Naturally when they don't win it makes us more than a little upset at times because we are disappointed. Did Just Sam deserve to win? Of course, all of them deserved to win. They came out and sang each week with their all in every song. She may or may not have been my favorite but that doesn't take away from how hard she worked and how far she came. She was singing on subways, and landed on the stage to try her heart out. Honestly, I was more in favor of Dillon or Arthur. But, in saying that Francisco was absolutely adorable and very talented as well. They all did a great job and will have so many chances to soar on their chosen paths. I hope they all do well and find happiness every step of the way.
-
C
No. Arthur Gunn was incredible
-
O
The show should not be about their stories but about their abilities. If I was a contestant I would make up the sappiest, saddest story I could think of. That way the judges would be behind you. That's why this is my least favorite competition singing show.
-
B
live in Washington State. We could vote
-
R
I liked Just Sam and feel like she deserved this opportunity, BUT if AZ could have voted.... I would have voted for Johnny West. He is a really gifted vocalist and song writer. This year really demonstrated idols control over the voting process more than other years.
-
O
Winner chosen without all of America getting to vote? It’s always about who has the saddest story. That’s is why I don’t watch anymore.
-
B
So much negativism, it's like someone graduates and you're complaining "how could they graduate with a "D". Accept that they graduated and be happy for them.
-
B
Please..it's over Sam won...don't take this accomplishment from her...as it says "accept the things you cannot change". Moving forward, Gunn has a career in music. Congratulations Sam...continued success.
-
G
Yes
-
C
No way. We have been watching American Idol for many years but thus year. It seemed manipulated. Just Sam got to stay in LA when all the other contestants had to perform from home. Her performances seem to have better backgrounds and her look better than others. I will not say that the network changed the results but everyone should be on an equal plain when performing. Unfortunately the other singers were much better vocally, Just Sam is only average.
-
O
Did not expect just Sam to win😡 really was hoping for Arthur Gunn 😠
-
C
No no no, Dillon James should have won. Probably rigged
-
C
Come on you all it’s the votes that count and everyone new what time to go on to vote. All was very good but Just Sam Won !! Arthur didn’t win because he didn’t have the majority of the votes have you all thought about that !!!
-
G
Arthur Gunn got totally ripped off he had this hands down. i hate to say it but idol pushed sam's story onto america. and is it really america that voted the winner i think the votes should be shown just to see if its real. post them as they come in so we can see. this not the first time the true winner was not crowned. idol use to be my favorite but now its the voice, they pick who they want by there voice not apperance. idol needs to stop doing stories on contestants let america judge for themselfs.
-
O
All of America wasn’t given a chance to vote. Voting was closed to the West Coast when the show aired. Wonder what the outcome would have been if we could have voted. PLEASE FIX THIS!
-
P
i believe this out come was preordained. They pushed her story forever. Her performances last night were good, but just OK. That's 2 years in a row they( either america or whomever has their thumb on the button) GOT IT SO WRONG
-
O
Johnny West should’ve won,he was the most talented.And My opinion was Arthur Gunn in second.She wouldn’t even have been in the top 5.
-
O
i voted every week, same time 9PM PST. So angry voting had closed. Good Season, Bad ending. Arthur Gunn was cheated. He should have won. The west coast did not get to vote. AI should have given the Top TWO both the WIN!!! Pretty cheep shot not to.
-
O
Gunn could sing but he wasn't the clear winner he mimicked the ppl songs he sang karaoke style and sounded like the artist. Just Sam was raw she deserve to win. Bout time someone of color final won
-
R
I think they definitely got it wrong, 2 years in a row! I thought they were looking for artists, not a story and a karaoke singer. I like Just Sam and wish her the best, but Arthur and Jonny are way more talented. Sorry, but I know I would buy their album and not hers. I think her being a New Yorker and the rest all West of the Mississippi calls the vote into question. They could have done a 30 minute announcement show the day after and it probably would have made a big difference...
-
G
could not vote in Arizona
-
O
Clearly results were fixed. Most of the contestants were from West Coast but people on West Coast not given opportunity to vote. The one contestant from East Coast was declared winner despite all of America not given opportunity to participate
-
G
They should have let the west vote and you would have gotten the true winner.
-
B
I these Four
had my 10 votes from day one....Johnny West...Arthur Gunn....Dillon James...Just Sam....I hope they all get contracts ! xxxx
-
R
Arthur Gunn was clearly the frontrunner the entire season and would have won if votes had been allowed on the west coast. They definitely pushed Sam on viewers. Did any other contestant get to sing with Lauren Daigle during the finale? It could not have been more obvious!
-
G
No the right person didn’t win at all. Not saying she’s not good but there was better talent than her. I think people voted with their hearts because of her tough home situation because so many others sang better and played instruments and some wrote their own songs. That’s talent. She probably won’t go as far but we shall see.
-
O
They said that about Fantasia when she won but now look at her.
-
-
P
Yes. I wanted Just Sam the whole season
-
C
Jonny west could have won, had we (west coast) had a chance to vote. Something wasn’t right. Just Sam is also very good! Congrats to Just Sam.
-
O
Arthur Gunn is the american idol, love just Sam but these stories have to stay out of the voices the story doesnt make who you are the voice does sorry but they were way wrong on this one for sure
-
C
No, ,did not think she was the best singer or preformer.
-
C
Arthur Gunn should have won. America made a mistake!!
-
B
Arthur Gunn is the winner.
-
P
No! Arthur Gunn was the clear winner. He was different and original and a musician. Everyone, including the judges, loved him and referred to him as "Pure". I wanted to watch him and will definitely buy his music and see his shows. He was the most watched on You Tube. Sam was good, but brought nothing new to the table. The show and Sam, really played up her life and subway singing, her grandmother, etc, etc. I will not buy her music or go to her shows. Nothing or fresh from her.
-
P
I have always voted, but was told it was already closed. So disappointed that I could not vote. It was not fair and so if it happens again I will no longer watch it and I love this program.
-
O
I feel that question is a disgrace. You have a young woman whose mother is incarcerated, raised by her grandmother, help me understand the disgrace. I am proud of Sam. We need to encourage our young people.
-
O
Totally fixed! Lionel pushed all season for Just Sam! My whole family saw it happening from the beginning. I deleted my Idol App. So disappointed in the voting process. I just hope Ryan Seacrest is okay.
-
R
Just Sam is so special and deserves to win.
-
C
Obviously not the best singer, that’s who abc wanted to win weeks ago
-
P
Liars..nationwide vote? Actually east coast vote.
-
C
No, the right person did not win! Arthur Gunn was clearly the favorite! Never thought there would be cheating on American Idol, no sense of watching and hoping for the best singer to win, that’s gone!
-
O
Sorry no one on the West Coast got to vote how sad is that, six states that is a lot of Voting
-
C
They absolutely made the wrong choice, I think they looked at the back story and thought it would be good for America right now! Everybody has a back story, Arthur Gunn should have won! He was the better singer!
-
P
I wanted Arthur Gunn. I personally have played his songs over and over. I loved the last contestants they were all so good. But I never purposely listened to the others. Gunn drew all of my attention!
-
G
We will never know who should have won American Idol since ABC excluded half of the country from voting. They should have a re-vote that includes the mountain time zone and west coast. I'm over this show. I like Sam and wish her well but I think Jonny was the most original. I like Dillon and Arthur too. Hopefully they will all have successful careers leaving Idol in the dust.
-
B
Show was fixed!
-
G
Aruther Gunn should have won
-
G
In my opinion the judges/producers had already chose the winner; if you go back & watch the show- Just Sam was previewed MORE than any of the other finalist. I think Dillion should’ve one.
-
G
No the best singer did not win. Arthur Gunn was so far ahead of everyone else. So obvious. What the heck happened? Tried to vote for Arthur Gunn but couldn’t get through. What’s going on Idol? You screwed up big time.
-
B
Arthur Gunn should have won!!!
-
G
She did not deserve to win. Alot of people have been through hard times just my opinion.
-
C
Just Sam is humble, beautiful,and can sing!
-
R
I was so thrilled Just Sam won! She deserved it,!
-
C
I am very disappointed in the vote...Sam was a sad story and the judges used that on every show! The people felt sorry for her and that's how she got the votes!! Really every show they shined on her and not so much for the others. Don't get me wrong she did have a sad story but not the talent that should have won. Arther all the way for me!! And she was set up every time after her performance it was Auntie Katy and daddy Lionel ...
-
G
Dillon should have won. He has an amazing voice and I hope someone picks him up and records a album. Also Jonny West is a very talented person. He has his own way of singing a song and get your attention.
-
O
Interesting how she was coached, got to sing with a celebrity, a non songwriter - guess she can sing Kelly Clarkson covers. Worst decision ever.
-
O
She can get assistance from Auntie Katie and Uncle Lionel!!
-
-
B
No what a disappointment
-
O
Just Sam is your 2020 American (East Coast) Idol.
Votes were not counted for MST or PST viewers. So disappointed.
-
G
I’m wondering if the right person won with the voting. Two weeks ago, Dillon was No. 18. Last night he was No. 15. Were the voting numbers incorrect? Should Dillon have won?
-
O
It’s weird too that Sam will be putting out a version of rise up that sounds just like the original but not as good that is still being played all the time?? How stupid is that?
-
C
no
-
G
Why after every season ppl want to cry “Set up or Fake”. I am just glad the both of them were in the top two, there lives will never be the same and those judges are going to help them with their careers. Arthur is better off now because he’s free to do his own thing where Just Sam is under A. I contract for a year. Congrats to them both. Yes I liked Arthur’s bravado and tones but I also loved Just Sam’s voice as well.
-
C
YES
-
G
The black girl won only because they feel sorry for her.whats new in all shows always feel sorry for the blacks . Arthur was better than all . Oh well just give all to blacks so they don’t complain that they didn’t win cause they black .
-
R
NO, But the Top 7 are all great artists! I believe that Just Sam won because of her story BUT she is a GREAT SINGER
Just not the best for this season! Now Arthur is the winner throughout the season on votes till finale, plus he is a better performer because: how many people have you ever seen, take 1 song & make 3 songs from it all the while sticking to his style & ALL 3 were GREAT!
-
B
No. Nothing against the girl but she should not have won.
-
G
Definitely Arthur should have won. Just Sam got sympathy votes. Got sick of her son story. This is a singing contest not about your sad life story! She was constantly off key . There were much better singers better than her. She won't make it far!!!!
-
C
Nope, she only won because she was on skid row, much better singers than her !!!!!! Terrible !!!!!
-
P
My wife and I have not watch AI for years, after last night we remember why. The show is fixed, pour girl from New York wins, covid-19 stricken NY., any of the guys were better. We won't be watching anymore, thanks ABC for giving me a good reason to tell my wife we are not watching. This is one argument I will win YES!
-
O
Everybody is entitled to their own opinions, that doesn’t make it RIGHT. People can make up their own minds, it depends on your musical taste, and oh yeah the d... votes... PERIOD!!!!!!!!!
-
C
I think they made a huge mistake, i feel she was picked because of her background!
-
O
What about Jonny West's talent? Wow...I thought the final 5 were all valid in being there and any could hold the title. Didn't know about the west coast not being able to vote...I watched late. Sucks for the 3 from CA....I liked Jonny, Dylan and Just Sam...
-
O
Worst year ever. And no the best did not win. That’s a shame.
-
C
I know it couldn’t be helped but this year’s Idol was greatly diminished by being remote. I really missed the band being present, clothes, makeovers, makeup, hair styling and the coaching they usually get behind the scenes from vocal coaches. It seemed like half a show this year. The performances were like audition tapes.
-
O
Not even close. Arthur, Jonny, Dylan and Francisco gave better performances and have more distinctive voices and vocal styles. iI would buy their music. Sam has a nice voice, but nothing distinctive or really unique.
-
C
I live in Seattle & could not vote — at all, ever! Very unfair!
-
P
Yes. They are both winners.
-
P
I think Dillon James or Arthur Gunn should have won. They are great artists and not only do they sing great but they also play the guitar and that should be taken into consideration as an artist.
-
B
That’s why it was cancelled before
-
L
Yes!
-
B
No way!
-
R
I will never watch this show again . This girl, Sam, was transformed by the show into something other than herself. Frankly, I think the results are rigged.
-
B
Those of us who were in Mountain Time Zone, Pacific Time Zone and Hawaii, did not get to vote. How can we say America voted? We could not all other nights except for the final when it counted. American Idol used the votes from the mentioned times to increase their ratings and voting. They also used it for the final, but we couldn't vote. How is this fair?
-
R
Definitely the wrong person won. No Question. This was FIXED. The judges but more Lionel Ritchie pushed and pushed for Just Sam to Win. Terrible. The winner of American Idol is supposed to be about the TALENT not because of someone's backhground. Too bad for Dillon, and West.
Losing it for watching the Fixed American Idol.
Shame! Shame!
Canada Ontario
-
G
Both Arthur Gunn and Just Sam are very talented and they were the top performers. Its all based on the America votes. Last year everyone thought Alejandro would win but he didnt. Regardless they (Gunn and Sam)will have a future in music. Agents will seek them. It's all by votes.. Authur Gunn will have more freedom of choice for contract and Just Sam will have to follow American Idol schedule. Like I said they are both very Talented.
-
G
Absolutely the right person won! She is amazing...
-
O
There was a lot of good singe, I feel she should of win, Arthur Gunn could sing, but to me he did a lot of screaming and he had no range and as far as I'm concerned, if you didn't vote, it really doesn't matter what you think.
-
R
The music market will decide who really won, and no doubt the 2 winners will be Jonny West and Dillon James, songwriters and great musicians! Arthur Gunn was also wonderful!
Nothing against the winners, they are great singers, but West and James and Gunn are just the real deal!
If you listened to the judges, they told all of them, it does not matter what AI decides, you are already on your way in a great music career and really do not need AI. Agree!!
-
R
Oh for sure the wrong person won. She was not the best performer. The three best choices were: Dillon, Jony West and Arthur. Come on voters, what were you all thinking. Really! It just showed how it was ALL ABOUT SYMPATHY, which is so unfair. Thumbs down to the winning choice. Sorry! but lets be fair. If any of the judges pushed for Sam to win Shame On You. You are really losing touch. Isn't all about the talent not the sobbing story
Canada
1 1
-
P
Rock Star Gunn was my pick from his audition. It's a shame how they somehow pick the winner for us.
-
O
They were all great. This year was tough. The top 5 were all winners. Personally any one of them could have been number one.
-
O
NO WRONG PERSON
-
G
YES!!!!!! Just Sam Is definitely the right choice. She was certainly MY CHOICE. And YES, Arthur Gunn was my 2nd Choice. America Got it Absolutely RIGHT!!!!!
-
O
Yes I like both and Dillon also. However some of the pass picks have gone nowhere. Maybe it's time for a change good look Sam you deserve it. Good luck Arthur you will go far and so will Dillon. Talent is what this competition is suppose to be about it's not a popularity contest
-
B
Yes. Just Sam presented her self as a natural talent. In all of her performances,she displayed confidence and variety. Very impressive!
-
O
I think the judges pushed her life so much America felt sorry for her. I voted for Arthur. He will be better off he won’t have to deal with Idol people. Let’s see where his career will go, I hope he becomes very popular with his music
1 1
-
G
Yes. I have felt that she has a compelling story, and an amazing talent. All the finalists will go on to have careers. Very talented. Winning does lock her into restrictions, but she may benefit from those. I’m happy for her, and celebrate all the finalists.
-
O
Perhaps we can imagine the most positive spin. Arthur has a distinct style and creativeness; he is ready to launch! He has a large family to support him and the backing of the Idol judges. He just needs to sign the magic contract (perhaps he already has) or open for Luke Bryan (as offered at the opening). America, we tucked him in! Johnny is a talented, unflappable song writer, performer, and even producer (as stated by Lionel). He will sign and release the original song he produced for us last night. America, we tucked him in! Just Sam is a soulful, inspiring voice. A spark just now breathing fire . She stands to gain from the Idol flagship structure as she takes on the tough business of music. America, we tucked her in, too! I say we did one hell of a job last night.
-
P
She was the judges favorite. This show is rigged.
-
G
NA NA NA NA
-
G
awdsw
-
G
We were pleased with Just Sam's victory and believe she has tremendous potential. All of the top five we're outstanding. Arthur's style of music isn't our favorite, but what a talent - he should go far.
-
C
The best performance was Johnny West's last song but the voting was cut off right after his performance. The whole voting process was flawed. I thought the top three were Johnny, Sam, and Arthur and was happy if any of them won.
-
R
Who one.
-
G
American Idol never disappoints. Such incredible talent. They are all winners. And that rendition of We Are the World... Wow!
-
O
I am so glad Just Sam won, she deserves it.
congratulations
1 1
-
G
I'm so happy for Sam! When she got up and told her story, it broke my heart--to be honest a number of the contestants broke my heart but Sam has something special. All of the final 5 were awesome artists and I hope record producers seek each one of them out for recording contract. I was raised by my grandma so I can relate to Sam. She proves you are not defined by gender, race or your economic circumstances. To paraphrase the end of my favorite movie, "Way to go Sam, way to go!!!
1 1
-
O
Last year and this year were poor choices stopped watching after top 20. They may be stars but out of tough with what consumers want for music
-
R
Definitely the right choice
1 1
-
B
Yes most deserving. Just Sam earned it
1 1
-
P
I didn't even get to vote! Lots of people didn't get to vote, after watching all from the very start of the auditions to the end how is that right? I don't believe in America Idol anymore ....seems rigged to me ...why waste are time if we are not allowed to vote for who we want? Wow unbelievable!
-
C
When do we hear the votes from the west coast?
-
O
Those of us on the west coast didn't even get to vote! What a travesty! So unfair to all the contestants! It was hard enough with the virus for them this year and then to take away the final tally by not allowing everyone to vote? They stated the Nationwide vote....total B.S. The vote was east of the Mississippi!
-
P
Definitely no, what a disappointment.
-
B
I think Dillion should of Won-Best voice & Future. At least been runner up
just Sam Good as well
-
B
Loved Arthur Gunn but the final two should have been Jonny West and Just Sam. Jonny is the all around talent and Just Sam has an easy, crystal clear, story telling voice. Congratulations, Just Sam!!💄👠❤💎💕
-
B
Just unbelievable that Just Sam even made it to top 20 much less won. She was terrible.
2 2
-
P
No far I'm cocerned they voted on her story . Where s he came from not on the best singer. Cause Aurther and Dillion where far better singer's and it's a singing competition not a sob story competition. Yes Sam is a good singer but not near ad good as Dillion or Arthur.
-
O
I tried to vote in AZ-- voting was closed--more people live in the state of NY than AZ, NM & NV combined!
-
R
Yes yes yes sam.yes she sings in Spanish as well.Sam.has came from.humble beginnings and i.love her voice And her talent.to me the guys sounded to much alike nothing stood out as a musician.And a wife of a blues Leg and and Rock a Billy singer I.love her she will go far so will all the 10that were on the idol.i.have seen.it.happen.
-
G
No, but wish her success.
-
B
Knew it was fixed when they saved her👎🏻
julia Gargano fresh, soulful awesome vocals, of not her Arthur was the choice going against SAM! Soulful, humble and true to himself...
another fixed, disappointing year
2 2
-
B
Yes definitely another joke and disappointment!!!
1 2
-
-
B
Sam is NOT a star. She is a pathetic sympathy getter.
3 3
-
C
I agree!! What was that?
1
-
C
You are ignorant
1
-
B
American Idol has once again let us and the “real” winners down.
But Sam will get what’s coming to her. She is a horrible singer and ONLY won from sympathy
shameful.
4 5
-
C
Ignorant
1
-
Watchlist Easy access to only the shows you care about — all in one simple place
Alerts Only important notifications — when a show is returning, when it becomes available to stream, and more.
Special Offers Exclusive products we release related to your favorite shows and streaming services