‘Instinct’ Unwittingly Copied a ‘Bones’ Episode Story Line

Francisco Roman/CBS
Alan Cumming as Dr. Dylan Reinhart

So many crimes, so little plot lines.

Apparently, the story lines from a recent episode of the new CBS procedural drama Instinct (called “Secrets and Lies”) and an episode from Bones in 2009 (called “The Plain in the Prodigy”) were too close for comfort, and some eagle-eyed fans pointed out the striking similarities on Twitter after the episode of the Alan Cumming-led show aired on Sunday.

First Look: Alan Cumming & Whoopi Goldberg on CBS' 'Instinct' (PHOTOS)See Also

First Look: Alan Cumming & Whoopi Goldberg on CBS' 'Instinct' (PHOTOS)

Pics include a first look at Whoopi Goldberg in her guest-starring role.

Both plots centered around an Amish murder victim who secretly played piano. When the investigators discover a not-so-obvious clue in their bedroom, it leads them to question said victim’s piano teacher.

Instinct creator Michael Rauch called the parallels “very distressing and 100% unintentional” on Twitter. He wrote:

With all the various crime shows on television, it’s hard to believe something like this hasn’t happened or been noticed before!