Roush Review: In Weepy ‘Madison,’ Michelle Pfeiffer Gives Emmy-Worthy Performance
Review
The Madison
A river runs through The Madison, Taylor Sheridan‘s (Yellowstone) latest ode to the open spaces and unspoiled beauty of Montana. (Indeed, 1992’s A River Runs Through It has its own cameo in the series, which gives a shout-out to the late actor/director Robert Redford after the first episode.) The river is the Madison, never to be confused with Manhattan’s Madison Avenue — or anything else associated with the Big City, anathema to the pure souls who inhabit the Western heartland.
Ever flowing, a symbol of life and nourishment of the soul, the Madison (gorgeously shot by director of photography and series director Christina Alexandra Voros) becomes a place of healing for the sinfully wealthy Clyburn family. Most especially for matriarch Stacy (a luminous Michelle Pfeiffer), who resisted the call of the wild for years until a terrible tragedy beckons her entire family of “city mice” to abandon the world of luxury townhouses for an outpost with an outhouse.
Paramount+
This is where Stacy’s husband of nearly 40 years, Preston (a likably rugged Kurt Russell), feels most at home, fly fishing in blissful solitude with his brother Paul (Matthew Fox). He made a fortune in finance, but Preston only feels alive when immersed in Montana’s Zen landscape. Too bad it took Stacy and her spoiled brood so long to experience it. Unthinkable loss shares space with regret as the Clyburns become acclimated to roughing it.
Some will dismiss The Madison as grief porn, and they won’t be wrong. The six-episode season (airing in two three-hour batches on consecutive Saturdays) is a wallow in woe, though Pfeiffer commands the camera in much the way Oscar front-runner Jessie Buckley does in the similarly themed Hamnet. Don’t be surprised if her textured performance of rage, sorrow, and motherly resilience earns her an Emmy nomination.
The Madison is a change of pace for Sheridan, whose series from Yellowstone onward tend to favor melodrama over mood. And while there is one wreck-the-cabin catfight between squabbling siblings, the violence here leans mostly into the emotional, and the tone is poignant, the pace soothingly slow. There’s not much plot, and what little there is we’re forbidden to discuss, so let’s just say if you’re looking for a solid tearjerking catharsis, you might find it here.
In other respects, this has many hallmarks of a Sheridan show, scoring too many easy points against the ridiculous city slickers. When Stacy’s whiny younger daughter Paige (Elle Chapman) ventures into the aforementioned outdoor privy, she has a slapstick encounter with a hornet’s nest. Her henpecked husband, Russell (Suits‘ Patrick J. Adams), isn’t much luckier when he attempts to man up and defuse the situation, venturing out in slippers and striped PJs.
Elder daughter Abby (Beau Garrett) is a prickly divorcee with a barbed tongue and two daughters whose angelic looks mask a privileged attitude that causes them to chide a friendly neighbor for using the word “Indian” instead of expressing proper gratitude for the food he brings them. (Grandma Stacy gives the girls and their mother a real talking to from her high horse.) “Woke” is not welcome in a series about being awakened to Nature’s therapeutic qualities.
Even before the tragic event that triggers the main storyline, lady-who-lunches Stacy is heard saying of her Upper East Side existence, “You have to wonder why we choose to live in a place we need to escape.” Granted, such words ring hollow to this Hoosier-turned-New Yorker, but there’s no doubt the breathtaking serenity of the Madison River Valley makes it a great place to visit, to be restored, perhaps even to live. (A second season has already been filmed.) The murderously combative Duttons of Yellowstone infamy might scoff at these heart-on-their-designer-sleeve interlopers, but there’s room for everyone in Sheridan’s expansive and wildly successful TV universe.
The Madison, Series Premiere (three episodes), Saturday, March 14, Paramount+
Conversation
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Register or sign in to join the conversation.
-
P
We love it. Can hardly wait till next weekend. Beautiful movie.
12
-
J
Just barely made it through the first episode. Doubt, if the 2nd isn't better, I won't go further. Vapid and vacuous. With no sub-text that the viewer isn't beaten across the forehead with. I've tried so many Taylor Sheridan shows and just can't get into them. Too "on the nose" as they call it. Lacking in layers. Shame, as I was so looking forward to seeing both Kurt Russell and (to a slightly lesser degree) Michelle Pfiefer in a TV series. As another poster mentioned, Lioness is the only series, so far, I've thoroughly enjoyed. RIP Kurt and Matthew!
10
-
K
Huge fan of Taylor Sheridan, The Madison didn’t disappoint, so good to see Michelle Pfeiffer one of my favourite actors, l hope to see more of her in series/movies in the future and Kurt Douglas.
I look forward to the following episodes with magnificent scenery
7
-
K
I haven't been a huge fan of Taylor's series; Lioness was likely the series that appealed the most. But I adore Michelle Pfeiffer and A River Runs Through It is one of my favorites, so I will give this one a try.
7
-
N
I'm a nobody, USA! I loved it!
6
-
P
6 episodes seasons. Why even bother anymore? What a joke, just like the inane Oscars that honor niche nonsense rather that what really resonates with audiences.
6
-
R
I liked the first three episodes, enjoyed watching Michelle Pfeiffer grow into her role as a protector of her husband's legacy. Regret, grief, love were all beautifully portrayed. I've not watched other Taylor Sheridan shows, finding them mostly too melodramatic or filled with what felt like gratuitous fights/firepower. This show feels more realistic, less about powerful displays of violence and more about tough love.
5
-
A
Loved the first episode! Can't wait to watch the rest. Michelle P is mesmerising, Kurt R attractive and likeable. Interesting supporting cast, like the familial attitudes and the nice relationship between Stacy and her elder daughter and grandchildren. The star of the show though is the wonderful photography of Montana's beautiful scenery. Very soothing and atmospheric.
5
-
S
One of his best so far, Kurt Russell and Michelle Pfeiffer are the perfect match for what continues to be the perfect watch on TV today. Looking forward to catching up with the rest of the series here in the UK
5
-
G
love it
3
-
A
"This Is Us" meets "Green Acres". I liked it
3
-
G
ha ha ha ! great post
-
-
D
Taylor Sheridan needs to learn to stop killing off main characters. Didn't like it at all. Not entertaining and the same old silver spoon shit that Sheridan produces. Don't waste your time. Kurt Russell dead in first episode.....
2
-
C
Yellowstone was unwatchable. It was a soap opera.
1
-
G
a very violent macho macho soap. also unbelievable, you don't become governor or land commissioner just cuz you want to as depicted in ystone.
-
-
D
Sounds like a literal wallow.
1
-
C
Loved it - the the „bitches“ line - I used on my girls once - knowing I raised ungrateful kids and it’s my fault for the way they treated me - and they were mad at me after that but I didn’t care ! That really hit a zinger with me ! Great Sheridan work for getting into a women’s perspective on this one
-
S
Very disappointed in the first episode. I love Michelle Pfeiffer and I was so looking forward to seeing her AND Kurt Russell - all I can hope for is a dream sequence bringing Kurt back to life.
Watchlist Easy access to only the shows you care about — all in one simple place
Alerts Only important notifications — when a show is returning, when it becomes available to stream, and more.
Special Offers Exclusive products we release related to your favorite shows and streaming services