‘The Flip Off’: Ant Anstead Makes Controversial Ruling While Judging Ex Christina & Tarek

Christina Anstead and Ant Anstead attend the Los Angeles Special Screening Of Discovery's 'Serengeti”, Heather Rae El Moussa and Tarek El Moussa attend the Alzheimer's Association California Southland Annual Magic Of Music Gala
Tommaso Boddi/Getty Images/Phillip Faraone/Getty Images

Ant Anstead made a decision that may spark some backlash while judging Episode 4 of The Flip Off. In a surprising move, Christina Haack chose her ex-husband as the judge for the guest bedroom/bathroom renovation. He had to choose whether she or her first ex-husband, Tarek El Moussa, and his wife, Heather Rae El Moussa, did a better job at flipping the guest bedroom/bathroom.

Christina explained that she and Ant, whom she shares one child with, agreed to put their differences behind them after her split from Josh Hall. Meanwhile, Tarek revealed that he had also “built a relationship” with the television presenter after Ant’s divorce from Christina.

“I feel like my relationship with him has been way better than his and Christina’s over the years,” Tarek admitted.

When it came down to judging, Ant announced that it was a tie. He gave Tarek and Heather the points for quality of work and transformation, while Christina got points for use of space and wow factor. However, when it came to overall design, there was a draw since they used a lot of the same ideas. Ant also opted not to score for the added value category since he didn’t feel like this wouldn’t be fair to judge on until the whole house was sold.

Despite the tie score, Ant still chose Christina as the winner, strictly because of their history. “Ultimately, when I came into this endeavor [I was] thinking this was about assessing and judging based on the performance, the design, the execution of the house, but actually it dawned on me that it was so much more than that,” he admitted to his ex-wife. “Hudson’s 5 now and in those five years it’s been really difficult and that changed three months ago. The relationship that we have now is really, really important. And it’s been a transformation.”

He continued, “It took, as parents, 4 and a half years to get to that point, which is really shameful. You and I will always be connected forever because we have a kid. So, ultimately, I have to stand by the mother of my kids. It’s not going to be something that you want to hear because unfortunately it puts Christina and me on the same team forever. So, unfortunately, this judge is swayed.”

Ant explained that he was raised to “stick with your family,” and he admitted that “Christina had already won,” even before he saw the finished products. Needless to say, Tarek was pretty annoyed, especially since this put them at a 2-2 tie for the entire competition. However, the ultimate winner will be decided by who receives the higher return on investment (ROI) when the houses are sold.

After announcing his decision, Ant pulled Christina aside to give her some intel. “Their house is better than yours,” he warned her. “It’s in a better location, it has better marks, but what this has done is it’s given you a fighting chance.”

Do you think the way that Ant made his decision was fair? Sound off in the comments below!

The Flip Off, Wednesdays, 8/7c, HGTV




Conversation39 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Comments are closed on this story.

  1. R

    RedCupcake

    I like Tarek. I think he and Heather’s house is the best. Heather has grown in her designs. I understand Ant wanting to keep it steady with Christina, they have a child together. Frankly, I was a Christina fan until I learned her politics, episode 2. People on tv just aren’t who you think they are.

    33 3

    1. B

      BlueHelmet

      politics being what??

      3

  2. C

    CyanController

    It wasn't fair. So what if they have a kid together. Wrong

    20 5

    1. B

      Blue8Ball

      I agree, it wasn't fair. Just because they have a child together shouldn't be the deciding factor. It was not fair at all.

      16 2

    2. P

      PurpleChilli

      On the previous episode, Christina did a much better job than Tarek and Heather. Judging was absolutely wrong.

      2 2

  3. O

    OrangeStrawberry

    Heather drives me nuts both in design and personality. She pouts. Christina is a talented designer and knows her stuff and is tough. I like her. Ant did a good job on the show and should pop up more often.

    20 9

  4. O

    OlivePaw

    He never should have been permitted to judge being he already was swaying in the judging decision for his ex wife. Ex him out of judging. As for Tarek current wife, she appears to be an afterthought to the show all together because viewers see more of Tarek with his first wife versus her especially lately. So what all this show is to me is a sham, a rock solid sham.

    9

  5. G

    GoldLeaf

    I loved it. The show is a competition show for ratings and fun. What Ant did is a lesson for Hudson, forever. Good on you, Ant!

    14 6

  6. B

    BlueRadio

    I’m always rooting for Christina. She is an amazing designer. Heather is very good now also. In a way the judging was bias, but I can fully understand why Ant would choose Christina’s. After going through a divorce myself and experiencing the drama and hostility for years, it’s so nice to have harmony now, especially for the children’s sake.

    9 3

  7. G

    GoldRing

    It wasn’t fair. He didn’t judge fairly but I expected that when she chose him. He admitted her house wasn’t the best at the end but gave it to her because of favoritism. She gets a cheat win.

    9 3

  8. G

    GreenButton

    Cop Out. Just say who the winner is. Just made the whole point of each episode a moot point. But….it is just a show ☺️

    7 1

  9. G

    GreenPlane

    Very disappointing. Not fair at all.

    6 1

  10. B

    BlueUmbrella

    Totally bogus decision ! Might as well give the whole thing to Christina cause all she seems to pick out judges that she hopes will side with her or at least that's how it seems.I was very very disappointed with the decision Ant made because of why he made it. Hopefully in the future this type of decision doesn't happen again.

    7 3

  11. O

    OrangePumpkin

    Maybe the ex-wife shouldn't have cheated.

    4

  12. B

    BlueBullhorn

    There is nothing wrong with having a favorite and rooting for them. However, don’t take it so seriously. I take what is going on in the world, my health and my friends and family seriously. I take this show for fun and entertainment. I love the show and have a good time watching it.

    3

  13. O

    OrangeAirBalloon

    Overall, I like Christina's designs better. I believe she won this contest fair and square, but I don't think Ant should have made his comments,even if he felt that way. I do respect him for respecting the mother of his child, despite their difficult past. To be fair, Heather is a great designer too, but I prefer Christina's designs, irregardless of size/location of house.

    1

  14. B

    BlueCone

    This competition is for viewership. Tarek and Christina have both grown so much and they are both good at what they do. Heather has shown, she can keep up with Christina in design and it was amusing to see their taste is so similar with inanimate objects as well as in a husband. I’m glad to see these people can all show up for their kids and get along. What examples they are all setting for their children. I’d love to see Tarek and someone (maybe Ant) go against the girls next time around!

    1

  15. P

    PurpleBlowdryer

    WEAK......ANT SHOULD'VE RECUSED HIMSELF, BEFORE WASTING A WHOLE EPISODE ON THAT!!!!!

  16. R

    RedWrench

    My mouth was literally on the floor, and it takes a lot to make that happen!! It was wildly unfair, and Ant shouldn't have accepted to be a judge if he couldn't be 100% unbiased. I did however liked Christina's room the best.

  17. O

    OliveTooth

    He was there as a judge and a judge only.

  18. O

    OliveCactus

    Team Christina all the way. Tarek is cocky beyond belief and Heather is just cringe. Christina has better design and Tarek was better when she was in his team 🤷🏻‍♀️

  19. O

    OliveSailboat

    I like them All.. Heather can be a little annoying ..... it's all in good fun. But I'm team Christina!

  20. O

    OliveSailboat

    It's a tv show, they all had a blast doing it, they're much closer now they have all gotten to know each other better. It's just a friendly competition and the judges are judging on their opinions none of the judges have been people who are professional home appraisers. I love them all and I love that we got a glimpse of Taylor

    1 1

  21. G

    GreenBulb

    Christine was a fool to divorce Ant. I wonder if she has regrets.

    3 3

  22. P

    PurpleTrumpet

    I don’t think it was fair. He promised to be impartial and he wasn’t. You can’t judge someone based on your past experience and you have a child with them. Also I think he gave her too much information on the other teams decor.

    1

  23. P

    PurpleAnchor

    I think Christina is still in love with Tarek. That’s why her last two marriages didn’t work.

    1 2

  24. O

    OliveBox

    I love the show and wish they did more. I laugh because Tarek is such a whiner. Sorry though I cannot stand Heather's laugh.

    2

  25. G

    GoldLeaf

    Totally fair. I hate Tarek . He's so damn annoying

    6 8

    1. G

      GoldCocktail

      I don't hate him, but do find him annoying. Frankly I find Christina and Heather almost equally annoying. I did appreciate the snippet that showed he and Christina addressing that they BOTH created issues in their marriage. Hope they all continue to put their kids first and thank God Izzy and family have their own show

      1 1

  26. O

    OrangeFish

    I loved what He said. Such a true gentleman he didn't want to hurt her. Love it! Great job Ant

    2 5

  27. O

    OrangeBucket

    I like christina..Heather is annoying ...Tarek and Christina could still be doing flip or flop if Heather wasn't so jealous ..it's funny how Tarek goes out and find the exact replica of Chritina ...that should tell you everything...Heather acts like a big old baby ..I didn't like her on her other show sunset something .bring flip or flop back a much better show ..

    2 5

    1. G

      GreenPretzel

      “Exact replica of Christina?” Get your eyes checked!!!

      2

  28. C

    CyanBucket

    I liked Ant as a judge. It was an interesting episode. I feel like Christina has grown a lot during this show while Tarek is still the same.

    8 11

  29. C

    Connie Woods Fagg

    I'm glad he chose Christina simply because Tarek is such a HORRIBLE loser. I hate the way he treats her on this show! On the other hand Christina has been a pretty good sport.

    1 5

  30. O

    OrangeBucket

    Next week Izzy will judge he and another judge ..I hope Christina wins Heather is a whiner ..like a big kid pouting not a good look....flip and flop should still be going ..but Heather was jealous and didn't want them working together....I say go raise a healthy son and go back to your sunset show ....

    1 6

    1. G

      GreenPretzel

      You’re the jealous one! You’ll never look like Heather and you’ll never be married to Tarek. Get a life.

      2

      1. B

        BlueSword

        I think Tarek and Heather are perfect for each other, they are both cry babies and arrogant. He definitely has a type so why are people surprised they look similar. She doesn't hold a candle to Christina though really. They also both gloat to much. Christina was a much more mature loser than those two are.

        1

  31. R

    RedHat

    seeing Ant was Awesome. Having him as a judge was a great idea!! He did a great job!!

    4 9

  32. G

    GreenBulb

    Ant should not have admitted that he chose Christine that morning, before he even saw the rooms, however, I'm glad he did it. It was the best episode yet. Tarek is such an immature cry baby !

    8