Gabby Petito’s Mother Says Family Didn’t Approve Controversial Lifetime Movie
Lifetime has a long history of mining real-life crime stories for ripped-from-the-headlines TV movies. But social media users are slamming the cable network for dramatizing the recent murder of Gabby Petito in the movie The Gabby Petito Story, which premieres tonight, Saturday, October 1, at 8/7c. And now Nicole Schmidt, Petito’s mother, is addressing the small-screen take on her daughter’s death.
“We thought our followers should know that the Lifetime movie on Gabby Petito has no connection to the Petito family nor did they give their approval,” Schmidt said in a statement released by The AWARE Foundation, according to Newsweek. “Lifetime took it upon themselves to make the movie.”
The film “explores Gabby and her fiancé Brian Laundrie’s complicated relationship and what may have gone wrong during their cross-country trip that resulted in Gabby’s tragic murder,” Lifetime says. “As the one-year anniversary of her tragic death approaches, the movie will bring to life Gabby and Brian’s doomed love story, including the warning signs that Gabby’s life was in danger, the ensuing search for her, the eventual discovery of her murder and ultimately, Brian’s suicide.”
As Newsweek reports, Twitter users have recently criticized Lifetime for giving The Gabby Petito Storythe green light — especially so soon after Petito’s death. (Petito, 22, went missing in August 2021 during a road trip with fiancé Brian Laundrie, 23. Her remains were eventually found in Grand Teton National Park in Wyoming, while Laundrie’s were found more than a month later in Myakkahatchee Creek Environmental Park in Florida, along with a notebook in which he admitted that he “ended [Petito’s] life.”)
“This is absolutely disgusting,” one Twitter user wrote. “Foul. It’s barely been a year since she went missing. There’s just so much wrong with this.”
Another person tweeted, “@lifetimetv, y’all are ruthless and should be ashamed of yourselves for profiting off a girl’s death and a family who’s still traumatized and grieving.”
In an essay for MovieMaker, The Gabby Petito Story director Thora Birch — who also plays Schmidt in the movie — wrote that she was initially “inclined to agree that it was too soon” for a TV movie on Petito’s murder.
“But ultimately, I came to be confused by that assertion, because it avoids the true question when it comes to telling Gabby’s story, or that of so many others who have fallen victim to domestic violence: How should one approach such a delicate endeavor?” she explained. “Simply choosing not to engage doesn’t honor her memory, and doesn’t shine a light on situations that are all too common.”
The Gabby Petito Story, Movie Premiere, Saturday, October 1, 8/7c, Lifetime
Conversation7 Comments
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Comments are closed on this story.
-
C
How can they make a movie without knowing the truth? They do not know what was said or how it was between Gabby and Brian! I don’t understand how they can make a tragic true story without facts!
6 1
-
O
I think the acting in this movie was great. It really isn’t anything we didn’t know or read Lifetime but this tragic story together. It was nothing we didn’t know already. I think it was well done
4
-
C
We were all invested in Gabby when she disappeared. I prayed for this family hard! I cried many times for them and just now watching her story. I prayed even harder that Brian and his Parents got what was coming to them full circle. I can't imagine being a Mom, seeing this played out. However, being an abused victim myself..If it helps 1 YOUNG GIRL see what a minute of forgiveness does or what an abuser can do in a fit of rage that turns on in a seconds notice....I'm all for it! It's a bigger conversation to be had with our kids, reflections of our own life that need to be seen and heard. God bless. I loved just seeing how full of life she was and she loved this world. ❤️ She was such a beautiful soul..truly. God bless 🙌
4 1
-
J
Lifetime TV airing a movie that's in bad taste? I'm shocked-- SHOCKED, I say!! 🙄
Lifetime never met a tragedy experienced by a woman that they didn't monetize. Good taste be dogged!
3
-
O
Interesting that Ms Birch knew it was the right time and story to tell without reaching out to the family first 🙄
2 1
-
O
This was nothing but lies
-
O
Then tell a fictitious story; don’t decide what’s best without the consent of the grieving family who are victims in a different way
1



