Carrie Underwood Reflects on Relationship With ‘Bestie’ Bo Bice During ‘American Idol’

Finalists Bo Bice and Carrie Underwood (R) appear onstage at the 'American Idol' final
Kevin Winter/Getty Images

Carrie Underwood and Bo Bice were competing against each other in Season 4 of American Idol, but they were also IRL friends. In the final episode of her Idol to Icon YouTube series, Underwood rewatched the moment she was announced as the winner over Bice in the 2005 finale and reflected on their relationship.

“I also can’t explain how amazing Bo is and was during the entire show,” the country superstar said. “We were besties from early on in the show, so for the two of us to be in the finale together, it was a dream come true to have my friend next to me on that stage, as well.”

Underwood returned to the show as a judge for Season 23 earlier this year and reunited with Bice. She also paid tribute to the 20-year anniversary of her win by re-wearing the dress she wore when she was crowned the champion.

On Idol to Icon, Underwood choked back tears as she looked back at her post-win performance. “I think about my journey on American Idol all the time because it’s so grand. It’s unbelievable.”

Singer Carrie Underwood (R) is named the new American Idol by host Ryan Seacrest

Kevin Winter/Getty Images

She added, “To go from somebody who was going to school, trying to figure out what she wanted to do with the rest of her life, and just kind of on a whim go try out for American Idol, and then to make it past the first round, make it past the second round, to keep going, and then end up the last person standing, and then everything that’s happened since then, it just sounds insane. It sounds insane to me when I think about it. If I hadn’t made that one decision in my life, my life would be completely different.”

The “Before He Cheats” singer also recalled how long it felt to hear Ryan Seacrest announce her name as the winner. “Those few seconds felt like a lifetime,” she admitted. “I was trying not to pass out or get sick or something on stage as we waited for those long seconds. I feel like he drew it out the perfect amount of time.”




Conversation42 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Comments are closed on this story.

  1. C

    CyanBasketball

    I wonder if all these jealous Christian haters realize they should not judge! She is the best dress Christian Country Star I have seen in a long while. You have a beautiful voice young lady, and wearing the same dress you wore twenty years ago after two healthy children. You go girl your the best ❤️

    34 1

    1. P

      PurpleScooter

      Amen

      1

  2. R

    RedCoffee

    Carrie Underwood, Best Legs in country music!!❤️❤️

    35 3

    1. P

      PurpleSubmarine

      One of the best voices, too!

      3

  3. C

    CyanFish

    My gosh what a bunch of haters on here. You guys suck. A little jealous maybe??

    19 3

    1. G

      GreenBee

      ototallyagree.Some people are so jealous when others are so succeeded. Way to go Carrie...You earned your popularity. Keep bein Ig the successful Christian you are. We will be cheering you on.

      20 1

      1. G

        GreenTurtle

        I agree.

        1

  4. R

    RedCupcake

    Haters!, some peeps on this thread are acting like they know her, calling her a liar, and not a christian. And you know all this information about her how????...........

    14 1

    1. P

      PurpleScooter

      Jerks are everywhere. Push for kindness!

      1

  5. G

    GreenHat

    Carrie has an awesome voice. Definitely a great talent.

    13 1

  6. R

    RedToast

    Carrie has a beautiful and rare aura about her.

    8 2

  7. O

    OrangeFries

    Honestly speaking...Bo Bice should have won that year. He was phenomenal in the finale. Singing that one song acapella was incredible.

    8 3

  8. C

    CyanDog

    Carrie is one of the best female vocalists in the world.

    She's the best talent that ever came out of America Idol.

    There's no disputing or denying here vocal abilities!

    While she seems more reserved, distant and might be perceived as a snob, I believe that's simply because she's shy and more of an introvert, whereas Kelly's a bubbly extrovert.

    American Idol has had some amazing talent, but Carrie's another Celine Dion...she's in a league of her own.

    4

  9. B

    BlueProcessor

    My mom and l on Carrie's season of idle, said from the beginning she was gonna win. Her season brings beautiful memories of time enjoyed with my mom. She died right before the finally. But l believe believe she knows. I would give anything to see this beautiful country singer, but that will probably never happen. But we are not here to judge anyone like we are perfect and you know none of us are. People make mountains out of mo hills. I see this so much since l lost my 25 year old son to cancer. All people need to treat eachother with respect, and not judge by hear say. Carrie is beautiful in my eyes, and always will be. I don't listen to hear say. I hope she continues to have a beautiful life, and avoid negativity. Everyone have a beautiful life.

    4

    1. B

      BlueBox

      Im so sorry for your loss. I agree with you about Carrie Underwood. She is beautiful inside & out. She's not perfect, no one is. All you haters stop judging her. She's a good Christian woman with a beautiful family. She deserves every good thing in her life. God Bless

  10. O

    OrangeBasketball

    Why do these videos have to be so damn long! Just get to the point bc most of us never get through the entire video it's honestly frustrating & you can't help but lose interest after just a few minutes

    Just get to the point!!!

    2

  11. O

    OrangeBasketball

    Begins to sound like BS

    1

  12. O

    OliveSword

    That wasn’t about Bo. Narcissistic

    8 14

  13. M

    musksucks

    i lost all my respect for her when she kissed trump,s diaper surrounded taco ass in january.

    4 18

    1. B

      BluePaw

      Thats when I GAINED respect for her.

      8 5

      1. M

        musksucks

        being a real idiot asshole has to suck for you,right boy?

        1

    2. B

      BlueBandAid

      Chump

  14. B

    BlueDice

    That's her face prior to multiple procedures. Now she looks like she would melt in the sun. A little nip/tuck is great, but damn, you've taken it to a new level.

    24 38

    1. G

      GoldLeaf

      She was in a car accident. They had to do a lot of work to fix her face ..

      12 3

      1. O

        OrangeBottle

        Actually she fell off her porch but did mess up her mouth pretty good ...many stitches

        8

        1. C

          CyanLamp

          Split lip almost to the nose!! You can see her scar up close

          1

    2. O

      OrangeFish

      You'd do it if you could afford it... so shutty

      5 1

    3. G

      GoldButterfly

      I don't think she looks that different. It has been 20 years and an accident at that.

      17

    4. R

      RedSushi

      A large amount of those procedures was to fix the damage done by her accident that took many original stitches. I love her.

      61 1

    5. P

      PurpleWheel

      She was in an accident and the surgeon had to basically reconstruct her face. So there's that...

      12

    6. C

      CyanFish

      Not true...be kind. She had surgery to repair her face from the bad tumble she had taken. You do know that ppl do go through facial changes as they age, right? Carrie still shows scars on her upper lip from the large amount of stitches she

      11

    7. P

      PurpleScooter

      You do know she had a serious accident! She is still beautiful inside and out.

      2

  15. O

    OliveUmbrella

    Carrie Underwood is fake she acts like this perfect Christian girl but she's rude... narcissistic liar... Jesus didn't act like that he was humble loving and caring if you say you fallow Jesus then be more like Jesus and less like the world..I will pray for her..

    God bless.

    17 52

    1. O

      OrangeLamp

      But again who are any of us to judge.

      17

    2. O

      OrangeRaindrop

      Priceless. You claim to be a Christian right after you cruelly label a person you don't even know personally as a narcissistic liar. Consider praying for yourself instead.

      7

    3. O

      OliveChefHat

      He also said don't try to take the splinter out of your brothers eye, before you take the plank out of your own! He also said not to judge others... thats His job. Name calling and hating was not His way either. Why don't you put your phone down and get your bible out.

      8 1

    4. G

      GoldCocktail

      Sounds like you are the one that needs prayers. Do you know her personally or where are you getting your info ? I have only heard good about her.Her husband is also a Christian.

      1

    5. P

      PurpleDucky

      You appear to embody the qualities of a true Christian. However, let’s take a moment for a self-reflection: Are you grappling with jealousy? Engaging in gossip? Spreading lies? Passing judgment? Perhaps it would be wise to pray for your own soul and allow others to live their lives. And let’s not forget, misusing the name of Jesus is another important issue to consider.

      1

  16. G

    GoldHammer

    She's so full of it. I know someone personally who was on When she was on and the they said she actually didn't like Bo Bice and that she would go around saying she would win the competition even before the show ended. She's such a liar.

    7 46

    1. R

      RedCloud

      That’s not true, I googled it and they were best friends throughout American Idol. They both were happy for whoever would win. She did not go around saying she’d win because she knew he had a good voice. And actually he outsang her on his last song, but viewers still voted for her, so she knew she was up against tough competition.

      30 1

      1. P

        PurpleScooter

        There are always negative people. She accomplished a lot, has kids she shares and loves her husband. Haters…go pound sand!

        1

    2. G

      GreenFlask

      Don't believe that

      1