How Do Fans and Critics Rank the ‘American Horror Story’ Seasons? (PHOTOS)

Dan Clarendon
4 Comments



Conversation4 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Register or sign in to join the conversation.

  1. O

    OrangeBottle

    9.Roanoke

    8.Apocalypse

    7.1984

    6.Coven

    5.Freak Show

    4.Hotel

    3.Murder house

    2.Cult

    1.Asylum

    A lot of people might bash me on hotel and cult but while I do agree the lady gaga addition to the loss of Lange was bad and the whole idea of vampires I didn't like. I absolutely loved the other dynamic of James Patrick March, Sally, and John Lowe. That one episode where John finally explains everything to his partner is a easy top 3 episode in my book.

    And cult, it was the only season that didn't focus or have any thing to do with something supernatural it felt real and authentic which made it much more thrilling. As a bonus I think Even peters best ever performance followed closely by James Patrick March.

  2. P

    PurpleScooter

    9: Roanoke

    I saw where they were going with it and I liked that but it got really confusing with the actors playing actors

    8: Apocalypse

    I really wanted to rank it higher for the crossover episode, but everything else wasn’t quite great

    7: Cult

    The only thing that saved Cult from last place was Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters preformances, they saved the day

    6: Freak Show

    When Freak Show was bad, it was horrrible but when it was good it was amazing

    5: Hotel

    I loved the setting and the characters, but like Roanoke, it’s a little too confusing

    4: Coven

    I loved the witches and the theme but I feel like it’s not a horror show because nobody dies, they just come back to life

    3: 1984

    1984 was the first season I watched so I didn’t have the same expectations the fans did

    2: Murder House

    YESS, Murder House was amazing in general, but JESSICA LANGE

    1: Asylum

    ..Perfect. All of it

  3. C

    CyanGuitar

    Besides Covenant this was the worst

  4. C

    CyanPin

    I didn't even bother watching 1984. Coven is the absolute best. Cult is the worst. Despite Evan Peters being great (and being robbed the Emmy), Cult was so god-awful.