Did ‘American Idol’s John Foster See the Winner in Ryan Seacrest’s Envelope? He Responds
Exclusive
Jamal Roberts and John Foster were the final two on Season 23 of American Idol, with the winner announced during the live Sunday, May 18, finale. Ryan Seacrest was standing next to the final two contestant on stage as he announced the results of the nationwide vote.
John was directly next to Seacrest, while Jamal was on the other side of John. As always, the longtime host took a dramatic pause before saying the name of the winner, but he opened the envelope shortly before making the announcement. John seemingly had a disappointed look on his face before the winner was revealed, leading fans to speculate that he saw what was written in the envelope first (Jamal was named the winner of the season, with John finishing as runner-up).
TV Insider caught up with John after the finale and he said he “barely” noticed what was written in the envelope. “I was in a total blur,” he shared. “I knew I was at peace with being runner-up. Jamal is such an incredible performer. I was at peace. I really was. It’s a true honor to be runner-up.”
View this post on Instagram
Still, social media blew up with fan comments about the reveal. “John foster fully just saw the American idol results 4 seconds before seacrest announced it. He very clearly looked at the card,” one viewer wrote on X. Someone else said, “It looked like John Foster seen the envelope!” and another agreed, adding, “#AmericanIdol John Foster saw the results in Ryan’s hands. @RyanSeacrest. Yikes.”
Another commenter offered some advice to Seacrest for the future, writing, “Ryan needs to be facing the contestants rather than next to them when announcing results. john foster saw jamal’s name before it was announced.”
The three-hour finale featured Jamal and John’s final performances of the season. Breanna Nix was also one of the Top 3 finalists, but she was eliminated after the first round of the competition due to having the least amount of votes at that point in the night. It was a monumental night, with the amount of votes doubled from last year’s finale.
Plus, there were iconic performances from various artists, including all three Idol judges.
John received a ton of support online, with fans raving that he’ll still have a big career, despite coming in second place on the show. “Congratulations to John Foster! We think you’re a great American and we love your music. I’m sure his career is about to take off,” someone said, while another added, “So proud of John Foster even though he didnt win Definitely made Addis, Louisiana and all of West Baton Rouge proud!”
–Reporting by Michael Maloney
Hit All the High Notes
Get absolutely everything about American Idol in your inbox!
Conversation264 Comments
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Comments are closed on this story.
-
G
They were both good. I think that John Foster will make it BIG. Maybe he is better off not taking first as Idol might have too much control for the winner. Foster will be signed straight away.
240 6
-
P
Hopefully for John. He deserves it altho he’d make a great Dr.
83 4
-
B
John Foster will continue his pre-med education, go on to medical school and become an oncologist. Music will become a hobby and he'll do some touring during his school vacations. He is supremely talented and extremely bright. I expect that while he practices medicine, he'll continue to write songs for other country artists.
7
-
R
Agree....while the other's do nothing, this everyone gets signed and does great mantra is fantasy, they'll all be forgotten in 6 months, happens every year.
-
-
G
Yeah John Foster is free to get a contract elsewhere.
1
-
-
C
If he saw it he handled it very well. There was so much great talent this season and I think it was the best season yet!
I also think Jelly Roll added a tremendous amount of value to the show but mostly to these young artist that need honest help and feedback.
JR is a class act.
Great season!
163 4
-
G
Totally agree. Jelly Roll brought out the best of these contestant in sound and performance. He brought the emotion and soul, which greatly helped these talented artists.
49 4
-
G
Who cares if he saw what was written on the card? I'm sure worse things have happened at AGT.
-
-
P
I think it seemed like John Foster saw Jamal’s name on Ryan’s card…being the class act John is he just hugged Jamal harder.
Jamal doesn’t seem to show much emotion.
I wish All three top runners up successful careers. It was a Wonderful Season!👏 Carrie was Great for her 1st Season.
Thanku Ryan, Lionel, and Carrie👏🎈
137 7
-
P
But not Luke?
2
-
O
Thank you to Luke too, nothing fake about him, he's totally himself no matter what & we love him I'm Georgia. John Foster is the most grounded, poised, professional young man for 18 years old that I've ever seen & I'm past 65 years old.
217 5
-
O
John Foster is the winner in my book!! He is the most talented and grounded young kid that I have seen!! I know he will do better now that he didn’t win!! Just like his predecessors.
40 3
-
B
Totally agree! Love Luke and the up and coming John Foster!!! 🥰
14
-
-
O
He was shocked. And because he wasn’t hugging him don’t mean anything. He had his arm around him before. They all have been through a lot. Stop reading too much in their lives. John will and Breaunna will do well. I’m happy for all the performers who performed last night. They all will do well. Jamal single is already out and breaking numbers with Heal. Maybe you can heal from your disappointment. Now Team Jamal let us celebrate and soak in this victory. 22 years since a Black person has won. Now let him celebrate and take in all of this. Not counting that these young men generated 26 million votes between two. That is major. Never have that been done. Ever in America Idol history. Maybe not on any voting voice contest. Jamal John and Breanns I love them all. Plus the other top 10 who was eliminated will all go on and do great. lol I will be another Patti Slater I actually liked him. And Che and Gabby and Thunderstorm. I wish themblessings
27 4
-
R
ALWAYS HAVE TO USE/ANNOUNCE THE RACE CARD-time to MOVE OOONNNN! Everyone else has
7 4
-
G
Actually, it’s since a black man has won. There have been at least 2 black women since then.
-
-
G
I’ll say! Everyone hugged him no hugs back… I honestly believe that Jamal is not a fan of John’s, also Breanna tried to hold his hand he wasn’t having anything to do with hand holding lol 😂 don’t blame him.. grr autocorrect is nuts today!
4 3
-
O
When Ryan asked them if they had any words to say to each other, Jamal shook his head NO the whole time! Then John said some nice words to Jamal, he replied with NOTHING! He was as rude as possible, I have no use for him. In my books, John Foster won!!
17 4
-
B
I totally agree. He was rude.
-
-
-
G
He did see the name and smile. He look down at it when he open the envelope.
2
-
O
In Season 2 Clay Aiken saw the card before it was announced too. You would have thought Ryan would have learned by now. John Foster for sure saw it.
-
-
O
John Foster Team here!! He was the best all around in my book!! Character, talent, charisma and a a caring human being. I know he will do better by not winning. Wishing you all the best John in your next journey !!!
125 2
-
C
I agree
20
-
P
Give Randy Travis a call John you got this you will be the best one yet you will be the next rising Star in country music
7
-
-
R
I love John he will get a recording ❤️❤️
4
-
-
O
I saw that John Foster saw the results as well. Both did an amazing job. In fact they were all good. Good luck to all of the contestants. This was your beginning and I'm sure you all will make an impact to other singers.
112 6
-
G
Absolutely no doubt in my mind he saw, just like Clay Aiken saw it wasn’t his name, in his season, Clay admitted he saw it, and in both cases runner ups won, this time it wasn’t bad because Jamal can sing Rueben Stodard not so much..
1 2
-
-
O
He did see it. You saw him with a disappointed look but then turned to Jamal to see him win. Both were deserving! Congratulations Jamal!
105 1
-
G
NO JAMAL DID NOT DESERVE TO WIN
13 17
-
G
JOHN WILL GO ON TO SALE LOTS OF RECORDS
MAYBE THEY THOUGHT JAMAL NEEDED THE MONEY MORE THAN JOHN
I HOPE THAT WAS THE ONLY REASON HE WON
IF HE NEEDED THE MONEY THEN I WON;T FEEL SO BAD
4 11
-
R
What a hateful comment. You must be a teenaged kid with many accounts feeling you all do that and try to cast more voted to your favorite and not the one actually better all around.
Congratulations to both John,Jamal,and all of the singers who made it to the TV show recordings(the top 12 or so)
10
-
-
-
-
O
Did anyone also notice that when Ryan asked if they had anything to say to each other, Jamal shook his head. After John said what he wanted to, Jamal turned away from him and said “whatever”.
People might like him, but I thought he was a jerk from the first episode.
114 23
-
R
I agree with you. Jamal seemed very arrogant. I was afraid he was going to win and it wasn't because he was the better singer.
20 14
-
G
He is a better singer
7 4
-
R
Jamal was never arrogant, some people show emotions different than what others think we should. We forget, God made all of us different. From your statement you are just angry your first pick didn't win, which is an arrogant from you.
9 5
-
O
Jamal needs help with getting a record deal which is why he won. The others will get a deal on their own talent.
2 1
-
-
O
You don't even know what was said! You're judging him on speculation! Stop! Both contestants where great!
14 9
-
O
More than one person heard what Jamal said including me. Grow up & face facts. We're not being negative, just honest.
8 7
-
R
Also, I don't think the alligator tears of personal family situations should be part of the show. A person is a Star or not. John Foster is a Star.
4 1
-
-
R
Stop what?
John was the real winner, hands down.
8 3
-
R
John defines being a Star in every aspect.
2 1
-
-
-
O
John Foster handles himself so much better than Jamal, and it's hard to believe John is only 18 years old. He's a winner & I hope will go on to great success. I did notice that Jamal didn't even want to say anything to John & I also noticed that when Breanna was elimated, Jamal nodded his head like he had just won. He's arrogant to me. Hopefully this business or someone will teach him the lesson that people don't like arrogance but we do admire confidence & there is a difference. Wishing John all the success & happiness he deserves.
72 17
-
O
Yes He Is. Felt Bad For John he was trying to reach out to him. He's got the Big head Already. Poor Attitude..
5 4
-
-
P
I think Jamal was still in shock, I think he was still in competition mode and not really grasping the fact yet that he won, because I’m sure he knows everyone wanted John to win. He was up against some amazing singers, I don’t think none should of went home, but it was a competition, so yes he was definitely shocked in away that shocked us.
10 4
-
O
I wasn't shocked that Jamal won & I really don't think he was shocked either. Before tonight's finale, I had been looking at comments on the internet & u tube. The majority of people said that Jamal was going to win & as I previously said, jamal's expression after Breanne was elimated looked as though he thought he had won. He had probably been looking on line too. But this is just my little ole opinion. 😉
7 6
-
-
B
Yes I didn't like Jamals attitude or stage presence either
14 7
-
B
I definitely felt the same way last night. John was much more gracious than Jamal.
7 5
-
O
I am not quick to Judge people in this moment of high stress.
3 2
-
R
See yall judged Jamal having no idea this man's journey to reach this point. He has been trying for years, so you have no idea what he was feeling to finally make it. This was John's first try.
4 4
-
-
O
Yes I thought he was very eragent. He never even shook John's hand of nothing🤷🤷
He's stuck on his self already🤔🤷
5 5
-
R
So dumb to think this, when Jamal was in a state of shock, wow, miss Judy, so your an expert on emotions now hum
5 3
-
-
L
Yes he came off as arrogant and entitled. Not what I look at for an American Idol. John wins in my book.
5 3
-
R
John is a Star. Jamal is a good singer. Maybe even a little less.....
2 1
-
P
And girl your opinion really count……not😁
3
-
-
R
John Foster is a star in every sense of the definition. The others were "good singers". Foster has a personality that cuts through to the audience. The others were singing in a competition. It's like, other people can sing like Elvis but Elvis had a smile and personality that grabbed you. That's how John is. Singing ability isn't everything.
69 4
-
R
John saw the results He looked a bit disappointed but then smiled looking at Jamal I agree that Ryan needs to be facing the contestants not standing beside them I told my daughter Jamal won before Ryan announced it
66 1
-
B
I know he saw the results. I saw the look on his face. I agree Ryan needs to stand somewhere else cuz this isn't the first time he's done that.
61
-
B
I also thought that John saw the winner’s name before Ryan read it.
54 5
-
O
Why does it matter if he saw the results or not. He still handled himself as he has from the audition, like A true grounded, professional young man. He'll go far with his talent & his natural ability to be himself. He's a fine decent young man.
272 5
-
B
They didn't say it mattered. They are simply making an observation. But for the future, they need to prevent that from happening again.
9 1
-
O
Exactly! I'm still shocked he didn't win! He handled himself as he always does, humbleness, graciously, a true winner!
18
-
R
John is a Star. The others were just good singers.
15 2
-
C
John is exremely talented, professional & humble. Characteristics you don't always find in 18 year olds. He is destined to go far! He already has!
12
-
-
-
-
R
Ryan always holds the envelopes where the results can be seen! It has always annoyed me! He needs to step clear away.
34
-
B
It looked like John saw the results before Ryan announced them. John Foster told Jamal it was an honor when Seacrest asked if the two finalists had anything they would like to say to the other. Jamal just stood there and stared at John. Not a word. That was awkward. He couldn’t even say anything nice? John Foster didn’t win but he is definitely the whole package.
21 1
-
C
I never really liked Jamal from the beginning. I thought he was arrogant. Always acting like he was better then everyone else. I hate the way he dressed to, never a shirt, ( the white deodorant under his arms looked grose, ever heard of clear gel deodorant, especially if u don't have sleeves or a shirt.) he even dressed arrogant. I thought he looked stupid half the time. I just don't think someone with an attitude like that should have won. I,m sure in his mind he thought everyone was stupid & he thought he was the best. Yes he was a good singer, but with an attitude like that he didn't deserve the win.
36 19
-
O
How was he acting like he was better than others? He barely reacted to any of the hype!! You're one of those people that like to tear black men down! Just stop!
Also, if you knew anything about show business......they have people dress them. I'm sure they have some imput but, very little! He handled himself like a pro!!
7 5
-
B
NO! Not tearing black men down . Thunderstorm was a better choice. Simple and un conceited
4 1
-
L
Totally agree..what a class act TS was. He will win in the long run. Jamal wont make it.
1 3
-
-
P
Jamal Robert’s won 🥇
-
-
R
He deserved to win because the majority of 26 million people voted for him to win!
7 1
-
O
I agree with you, I also don't understand what kind of role model he is to his students dress have naked. I feel the whole show is a scam,they already know who is the winner before anyone even votes. I won't be watching any longer. They did the same thing to Clay Aiken when he lost.
12 4
-
P
Hey it is over……..you need to move on until next season and YOU chose who u want otherwise 🧐😜
-
-
P
John Foster is the next Allen Jackson. Hold your head high John. You have a great voice and the looks to go with it.Do us all proud in Australia and sing your heart out. Best of luck. Gail
16
-
C
First I'd like to say congrats to Jamal Roberts. I wish him the success. No to rain on his parade but he is NOT my cup of tea. His vocals are like nails on a chalkboard and his stage presence and attire is just painful to watch. Again not to rain on his parade , just like 95% of all the winning contestants, he will have very little to no commercial success with the likes of Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood. It seems like the non winning contestants are the ones who breaks the barrier to commercial success. That's most likely to happen for John Foster. I personally believe the Idol show is a waste of time for using it as a tool for primetime entertainment and nothing is to come out of it . It's getting painful to watch. This also goes for The Voice. Have you seen any commercial success from any winning contestants AT ALL?
NEXT TIME they need to figure out how to overturn this outcome on the behalf of the networks and it's crew.
23 7
-
C
Totally agree, the winners of these shows seem to fade into obscurity not like the old days when they actually went on to have a career.
5
-
R
Most are not successful, only a tiny percentage have done anything in the real world of music and the others have no Billboard verifiable success. Only 2 huge stars, Kelly and Carrie.
-
-
R
Agree. Like a lady killer wannabe. Foster is a Star. Period.
9
-
C
ABC wanted Jamal to win. It was so obvious when they showed Jamal holding his child on stage before voting ended. John Foster will become a star for sure and hopefully American Idol can't hold him back as the winner in contracts. If im speaking honestly there isn't a big audience for the type of music Jamal does.
13 3
-
C
Seems like your raining on his parade
1 2
-
O
The truth
1
-
-
O
I agree, Jamal did not dress good, act good, or even sing good. I muted the tv when he came on, could not stand him and have NO clue how he won and beat John Foster.
Jamal will go as a teacher and nothing more...not a singer.
And I do not know how in the Hll Jamal won
7 2
-
R
Actually, most do nothing; only a very small percentage do anything in the real world of music, yet this false narrative remains.
-
-
R
I thought it was sad when Ryan asked if they wanted to say anything to each other and Jamal instantly looked and shook his head no. However John graciously offered positive words.
And yes he probably saw the answer but all that mattered was how John handled the decision and he handled it with grace and dignity. John will go far no matter his career choice!
14 1
-
B
That's true John had kind word's. Jamal with his ungrateful self shook his head no. Terrible on Jamal. But that's what ABC wanted. John Foster will go far.
3 1
-
R
Yes, this was blatantly obvious, low class, sorta arrogant move by Jamal, I wasn't surprised tho, guy was stuck on himself
1
-
B
Jamal Still IS AMERICAN IDOL 2025 & you reading Action not his heart. None of that matters Both were good BUT Jamal was Great according to America. John can re try. Jamal did. 🥰
-
-
-
G
They were all good . 2nd and 3rd place will do well and they won't have to share there income with Idol.
13
-
R
John will stay in school at LSU and become a surgeon in the real world and the rest will fizzle out and do nothing as usual, this everyone will get signed stuff is fantasy land.
-
-
G
I think john did see the results before Ryan announced but it does not matter as john will definitely have a career
12
-
R
Exactly. What real difference did it make? He didn’t see the results by accident…he was trying to see them.
3 2
-
-
O
John had a smile on his face not a disappointed look.
11
-
O
The only thing I noticed and mentioned immediately was that John was so mature and sincere in congratulating Jamal. That is an act of a true winner (John).
10
-
C
Breanna was my pick but all were stupendous. YES, I agree, John is going very far in life. What a mature, respectful young man. He reminded me of Scotty McCreery. Good luck and happy success to all.
10
-
B
Breanna Nix will have a successful career in Christian music if she is able to secure a successful management team. She has a tremendous natural voice that is, as yet, untrained. With training, her voice could become generational. Bear in mind, she has a four-year-old son and is only 25-years-old, so it's very likely she has no education beyond high school. She'll really require management that focuses on her as a future Christian music star, and not focus on her American Idol visibility and push her to tour and record before she is ready.
6
-
-
B
John Foster won in my book! He’s headed for great things!!
11 2
-
P
Glad I don’t read your books 🤓
1 1
-
-
L
I thought it should have been John. They all had amazing voices in their genres. However, I look at the whole package. B. Nix did not have the stage presence and confidence that John did. Jamal was amazing but ZERO personality or grace which was never addressed. He did not even appear happy to win. The good thing is that I think both B. Nix and John will go on to have a much better career than Jamal. He came off as arrogant and not grateful. Best wishes to all of them, in the top 14. Great voices this year!
16 7
-
P
Glad you were not a judge……someone is always going to win whether we like them or not…..move on
1 1
-
-
O
John Foster has an amazing voice He is my American Idol! I will definitely buy his records🥰
10 1
-
C
We love John Foster he is the new rising star that will be making great country music!!! He’s the real deal. He’s the real winner he didn’t need to win no contest!!! We will definitely see his future explode into major success!
9 1
-
G
Yes; I saw his look & he immediately turned & looked for Jamal's reaction because he knew who Ryan was going to announce as the winner.
This has happened a few other times. What really needs to happen is that the announcement is made five minutes before the end of the broadcast, so we can enjoy the final performance in its entirety. I hate how the show gets cut off & we cannot enjoy the final song or excitement.
So happy Jamal won! Congrats Jamal! He has an amazing voice & presence! John Foster is also an amazing country singer & I'm sure he'll be picked up by a country label.
7
-
O
I thought the same thing that he saw the results. I even hit the replay button just to be sure. But nonetheless congratulations to both of them
6
-
R
I think John will be a star he’s got what it take. There were a lot of really good singers this season I wish them all the best
6
-
R
All 3 Finalists will have big Careers, American Idol does not guarantee success so all 3 deserve Recognition
6
-
B
John Foster your such a real man, with dignity. I so hoped and wished you would have won because you deserved it!! I hope to see you out there and I will in the future without a doubt!! You'll be another George Strait or similar. Please don't change, you got it!! Jamal is great and I wish him congratulations as well! All of you top three will continue to rise to stardom!! Never ever give up!!! You can still make your dreams come true!! ❤️🙏
5
-
R
Congratulations to all 3 finale contestants. They are all winners cause they have a future now awaiting them and their families. I didn’t like the way Jamal didn’t want to say anything to John before announcement of winner. He somehow already was letting it go to his head. John was more maturity about himself. I know I voted the first round but when it came down to last vote during the commercial break it wouldn’t accept my votes. I think they had the machines already turned off and they knew who was going to win before it happened.
9 4
-
P
Could it be he was in shock….because you know how you people think you are always suppose to win 😡🤓
1 2
-
-
B
Ryan Seacrest may be a nice guy, but he seems more intent, on any show he is on...to be in the spotlight! That has led to AI contestants seeing the results early, "Wheel" contestants with misinformation and "Live" guests dealing with his insecurities. Maybe he needs to be directed more closely in these shows to help alleviate these blunders. His personal life seems to be having it's difficulties too. Maybe he is trying too hard to be a trillionaire!
8 3
-
O
Did anyone else notice these things?: (1) Before the winner was announced, John walked over to Jamal and said some kind words to him. Jamal all but ignored John.
(2) Almost every time Jamal was interviewed, he was holding his kids? He kept saying over & over, it's for my kids. Playing up the sympathy card? Subliminal messaging? Apparently it worked. If I was ro buy a CD from any of these contestants, it would be John Foster. He is the complete package. The judges could have done a better job of mentoring-- like suggesting that Jamal & Breanna smile & engage with the audience. The show dragged out & got boring. Why bring bk all these should-be retired artists? Not particularly relevant.
7 3
-
P
So……is that strange he love his kids….hater 🧐🤪
1 1
-
-
P
All three finalist were great. We will see more of John Foster and Brianna Nix. All 3 have a future. If Foster saw the name of the winner, seconds before Ryan announced it, what does it matter?
5 1
-
R
Defiantly think he seen results with the look on his face. All three were great in their own way . Best of luck to all ! 😊👍
4
-
C
John saw it but no matter. I loved his reaction.
I knew Jamal was going to win. He is very talented but I love to hear a few notes and know instantly who is singing. That would be John. I believe Jamal got the black vote , John and Breanna split the white with John getting the most. It's the way of the world now
5 2
-
R
Does it even matter?
JF was incredible throughout as were the other two. Breanna Nix was amazing. They are all going to do great things in life. Congratulations!!
3
-
O
I said the same thing sitting right here on my couch!! “He just Saw the Results!! “
3
-
O
✨️JOHN FOSTER🎊🎈❤️❤️❤️
4 1
-
G
Something quite similar happened when Ryan read the results to Clay and Ruben. Clay saw something, then turned to Ruben, watching him win as his name was announced. I think there was a story going around then that Clay saw the results on Ryan’s card.
3
-
G
From What I understand the Winner is commited to American Idol for one year and can't sign any recording contracts until then. John will and probably has a contract and will be making more money right out of the gate. Please correct me if I'm wrong.
3 1
-
P
People are complaining? Why! What’s the problem….🧐
-
-
G
Jamal was a poor winner, with bad sportsmanship. How can someone have nothing nice to say to their opponents? Not even a "good game" or "the competition was tough, they did well"?? Nothing? The network wanted Jamal to win. I don't trust the network to be honest about the votes. If they choose a winner, that's who it's going to be.
3 1
-
P
Wow it’s over………………move on….John was good …..let this go….Jamal was excellent because he was very quiet does not make him a loser 👏👏👏�
🧐🙏
1
-
-
C
I do think John Foster is the future of country music! Not only does he have an amazing voice, he is a songwriter, has great stage presence, and just comes across as a kind and sincere young man. I hope that the current country singers will get behind him and help him be successful. I'll be the first one to follow him all the way!
2
-
P
Yes please follow because it is so many great singers in this great 👍 world I know I follow more than one 👍🧐
-
-
C
Yes it was clear that he saw that the name wasn't his. I guess he couldn't resist a peek. But you absolutely saw the look of disappointment on his face.
2
-
P
If he saw it or not the votes was not going to change. They both did a great job. They both have God on their side, where ever they are God will be with them both.
2
-
P
Jamal is good nothing bad to say. But my opinion he was not the best. It should have been John. In one year America will see they got it wrong when John is blowing up in country along with slater and no one remembering Jamal. Like I said no disrespect to Jamal I love his passion and stage presence.
6 4
-
P
26 million people voted…..guess what some voted for Jamal 😎❤️
1
-
-
C
My votes for John would NOT SAVE OR REGISTER. ..IDOL got the winner they wanted
1
-
O
Jamal was only for himself, very rude to not say anything to John before it was announced. John will go far.
1
-
B
It really did seem like John saw Jamal's name as the winner, but to me, it really doesn't matter. Just my opinion, but Ryan doesn't need to stand facing the finalists because whether one sees the winners name or not, they will hear the winners name whether they see it or not.
1
-
P
Exactly, it doesn’t really matter who won. Many contestants that didn’t win went on to have great success.
Idol has proven to launch so much careers.
.
1
-
-
B
what's the BIG DAMN deal of John saw or not? There wasn't going to be any change! They producers KNEW what they had to do! John will and probably already has a contract..maybe even Carrie Offered to Manage him?? Who knows! Jamal will carry on..regardless of why he won!
1
-
R
I prefer people who sing their songs, not scream them. John sang every single song as they should have been sung.
1
-
O
I will definitely buy John Foster's album. I think he will sell a lot of them. Just because he didn't win doesn't mean he won't be a huge star, because he will!!!
1
-
P
John should have won!! He was the best out of the two for sure.
1
-
O
So who of your so-called DEI picks did not deserve to be there?! Maybe this site should ban jerks from commenting...
1
-
G
Johs Foster should have won The American Idol !!!!!!!!
2 1
-
O
Does it REALLY. Make a difference if he did see the results before it was announced???
1
-
O
I voted for John 100% and he's going to have a career beyond his imagination. Everyone did great and the judges were awesome too.
1
-
O
Anyone else find it interesting when Lionel Richie would say vote vote vote but when it came for Jamal, he said vote vote vote for him….
1
-
O
I think the judges were very persuasive in the decision.
John is a class act always congratulations to the other person, Jamel ?
2 1
-
B
Yes he saw the results..but he definitely has a career he was good..Carrie Underwood will make sure he does..
2 1
-
O
I think American idol picks who they want to win they can say anything but how do you know start showing voting live to TV audience just to show voting is legit I've always wondered if it was just saying
1
-
O
What's the difference if he saw, yes I think he did. What a guy though, could not tell it. A little smile. Class the whole way. And to me he was the winner..... great singer and person,
1
-
C
The best man won. I’m a John fan and honestly he’s better off being in second that way he will have control on his singing future. I say go back to school and follow your dream being a doctor. You can always sing.
1
-
P
I love John’s music because he is classic country plus he delivers other genres as well not because he sounds like anyone else s
1
-
R
Rigged again
3 2
-
O
Yeap unfortunately you are right.
2 1
-
-
G
John will have a better chance at success because Jamal will be stuck in a contract with Simon Cowell and AI for a while. He’ll be owned by AI.
2 1
-
P
Soooo that’s the name of the game. 😛
-
-
G
Jamal Roberts won the season. I am here wondering why this article is not about him, his talent, his journey with his picture.Why is this article, written the day after a memorable finale not about the winner but mostly about John, with John’s picture, honoring John’s talent, under the excuse that he might have seen a result card?? To me this is disrespectful to Jamal Roberts.
13 12
-
O
Because Jamal was not great like John. That outfit he had last night was something Diddy would wear. That is what I think of him when I see him. He can not sing, no personality (like John) or stage presence.
That is why you see so much of John...he is going to be a huge star and Jamal will be nothing
Does that answer you question?
4 2
-
B
Great answer 💯 %,
2 1
-
P
Right now JAMAL is the winner….. they both are good…. Who cares about your opinion. America voted did you?
1 1
-
-
P
Sore losers JAMAL ROBERTS WON 🥇 THEY NEED TO GET OVER IT
1 1
-
-
P
I've been watching Idol since the beginning. This was so obvious. The judges stood for Brianna and Jamal. Not John. And Carrie's extensions are such a diversion! So Rapunzel!! The stylist needs to rethink this!
3 2
-
P
Just remember Adam Lambert coming in #2 he certainly has had quite a career- he was better off not winning
7
-
O
I love Adam Lambert & he is one of the best singers in my life time. He's done great & probably glad American Idol didn't have control over him.
2
-
L
You are spot on. I remember in an interview they said the runner up is positioned much better. They do not have all the AI hoops to jump through for year (Taylor Hicks syndrome). John is poised for a wonderful career as he is relatable, distinctive and humble. Jamal...not so much.
1
-
-
O
Dabbwi1, I'm totally with you, I've been watching since the start & I still miss Simon. To me, Carrie should get herself a new stylist. She's been dressing tacky since her audition on American Idol & I personally don't like the way she sings or performs since she's become successful. She over does it jerking her microphone around & she & her performance look totally fake. I will say she did show a little more personality on American idol. She usually acts cold & looks pissed off when I've seen her on TV. I'm not a fan so I won't spend money to go to her concerts.
-
-
G
The last 5 or 6 contestants were all excellent. They will each go on to make it in the industry they just need good role models and a chance. Really hard to pick just one winner, since I think they are all winners.
1
-
R
But no one had the swag of Foster. John is more than a . good singer.
129 12
-
P
Being runner up you are free to sign with any record label that offers whereas the winner is tied up all year with only American idol options.
15 1
-
-
O
Absolutely. They had a lot of talent. There were several artists that I am excited to see what they do next.
8
-
-
G
John didn't have a disappointed look on his face! His immediate reaction was a slight smile!
-
B
Yes. It was clear that John saw th winners name on th card . He looked down at it, gav a sweet lil smile, n then turned his head to watch Jamal . EXACT same thing happened on Seas. 2, when Clay saw Rubens name ... he told about it later ... that he saw it, n wanted to watch Rubens face when he won !
-
R
John will stay in school at LSU and become a successful surgeon in the real world and the rest will go on to do nothing in music, that's the way this television show has gone for a decade or more now. Where these people come up with this "everyone will be stars" hooey is beyond me, lol,just never happens anymore on this television show. That's what it is, not reality.
-
G
I hope the top three are all very successful!
-
G
Ryan Seacrest always lets the loser see the card before he reads the card. On the Voice the host stands further away.
-
G
The same thing has happened in past American Idol finales. Hasn't Ryan Seacrest figured it out yet? And why would either of the finalists want to know the results before they are announced? Just look down or forward!
-
P
so what if he saw it, doesn't change anything, all of them are great.
-
P
I was really proud of all three of them and honestly the top 10. They were all amazing. It's nice to see young people following their hearts. I also was happy for the judges and of course JellyRoll!
-
G
Cmon. Let's not be dumb. Jamal clearly had the WHOLE package. He could sing lights out high, mid and low notes.
Vocally one of the most gifted voices this year. Much better than the one trick ponys.
-
O
I agree Jamal deserved to win !
-
-
C
John was the best of the best he is a real good person and has a voice that will say the best to me. All of the last 5 people will be doing something great I feel if the music world gives them a chance they are the best. To me John was the best and had a heart of kindness and a voice so smooth and great.
-
C
I think John Foster should have won!!! He was the best!!! Good luck John in your career I know you'll be awesome!!! Can't wait tohear more music from you!!! I'll get your CD when it comes out!!! Love ya!!🥰💖😻🤠
-
O
I saw when John saw the winner!!
He won in my book.
-
B
It was déjà vu… this is exactly like Clay Aiken and Ruben‘s final moments. Clay admitted he saw Ruben’s name and he turned to watch Ruben’s reaction and was happy for Ruben and that is just what John did.
-
G
Luke Bryan gave John Foster difficulty of the task throughout....... He realizes he's great from the very beginning ! Most likely playing the game to make it a show and to detect if John is able to overcome - Stop it ! It's hard enough for the natural, talented contested to keep pulling through that need the so called experts (Judges) to help guide them. Please, voting needs to include if the judges should be around next time.
And Yes, John Foster saw the results - Many of us taped the entire show. Ryan Seacrest knew what he was doing.
It's A Show !
-
O
Why does it matter if he seen the results it's not like he was gonna shout it out. People discuss me making a big deal over that.
Really American
-
O
At least one contestant saw the results. May Clay? Not sure but you would think Ryan could properly open an envelope by now.
-
G
John Foster most definitely saw the result card!! So obvious!
-
C
His young eyes definitely saw Jamal’s name.
-
B
That happened in season 2. Clay Aiken saw Ruben Studdard had won before Ryan announced it.
-
O
John saw the name and immediately smiled. He looked genuinely happy for Jamal.
-
G
Clay Aiken also saw that Rueben was the winner for that season, the EXACT same scenario happened and clay looked just like John, difference here is CLAY has admitted he saw Rueben’s name ( clay like John should have won..,)
-
S
I do think he saw the results but I don’t think he looked disappointed at all. While I’m sure he’d have loved to have seen his name, he was still pleased for Jamal. Yes Jamal is the winner but top 3 truly were the champions (and it never matters what place you come in on for the show. It’s what they do with their career going forward. The door is just more open to them now). So many people who didn’t come in 1 have gone on to do great things!!
-
G
It's what happened with Clay aikens . He said he saw the results too. You could see John glance
down and his expression changed.
-
O
The card that Ryan Seacrest was holding. The writing was not facing John Foster. He must have XRay vision to see it.
-
O
Clearly John saw who the winner was. Looked disappointed but smiled for Jamal. I feel that God wanted it that way so he could be the singing doctor he wanted to be. If Dr. Ken Jeong can do it he surely can. I know he will be good at what every he does. He is just a good guy.
-
C
John and Breanna will definitely make it in the musical world
-
C
I really thought John was gonna take it I was shocked. John was just a naturalist so smooth every song he did. Breanna was amazing too.
-
O
It isn't the first time Ryan has stood too close to the finalists while making the announcement.It's admittedly happened before. Also, John need not worry. Adam Lambert, Jennifer Hudson, Daughtry, etc. didn't win either & they're doing just fine...
-
B
John will always be the winner in my eyes!
-
C
I agree with you
-
-
P
I think John saw the results too! But he's such a great guy_ that lil look of sadness turned quickly into smiles for Jamal & even Lionel looked SHOCKED! John's ending song was beautiful & the rendition was excellent! Jamal's new song Heal was a beautiful song, but the rendition was a bit off. All of his other performances were better
-
R
Disney is so WOKE, John got screwed in the name of DEI
-
P
It really should have been double winners this year...first time I have ever said that! Both were/are outstanding! Jamal's buttery voice will go far and Lionel should be his mentor. Luke should take John under his wing and on tour with him.
-
B
Jamal is good but I think John is better, hopefully someone sees him and sign him up
1 1
-
R
Jelly Roll was on the live show in LA with live voting. He also appeared live on stage at Ford Field in Detroit at the Post Malone concert on Sunday 19th. How does appear live at 2 places at the same time?
-
O
4 seconds messed up ... sometimes it's better coming in second. With the history of the shows 1st. Place winners ....
-
C
Yes he did. Ryan opened the envelope and he glanced that way and made a grim expression then looked at Jamal.
-
B
You could tell he saw it, but was a trooper for sure. He smiled and I saw no sign of negativity. He’s an amazing young man!
-
C
i think oh. should of won !!!!
-
O
I think John saw the results as well. He should have won.
-
B
Both good. I would have picked the country singer. Double the votes this year. I wonder ...
-
R
They are proper nouns.
-
R
Aren't first and last names supposed to be capitalize.?
-
O
Totally agree. As I was watching it, I thought john knows who the winner is
-
G
Jamal stole my heart from day one being a singer myself Jamal out shined them all but this was the best Idol of all time all of the contestants where good.Glory be given to God
-
P
He saw it. Seacrest has done this before. Clay Aiken saw it too when he was runner up to Reuben Studdard. I'm glad he saw it. Everyone knows he was the real winner so it just gave him a moment to accept he lost.
1 1
-
C
LOL!! It's evident what you really want to say...
-
O
Maybe he doesn't need to stand there and make it another suspenseful holdout reveal. We've been watching for how long? We're already viewers, we're all watching, just say the name. Not to mention, they couldn't even finish the winner's song because of these dumb pauses. It's just so dramatic and lame.
-
G
The best person doesn't always win. I'm much happier that John lost and he will have a bigger career. Same thing I thought for Thunderstorm he will have a bigger career as well.
1 1
-
B
Thunderstorm is a niche performer. He was on The Voice a few years ago and he's pretty much the same performer. I doubt that he'll ever have any national recognition. He entered American Idol because The Voice got him nowhere.
-
-
B
Why would I care?
-
G
He did see it. But maybe that moment he needed for resolve.
-
G
Compete sham, John should be the winner. I don't believe the vote counts i think it is rigged to push the black contestants to the top. I'm done watching this show.
4 4
-
C
LOL. Then the vote rigging is a failure - Jamal is only the 5th black winner out of 23 seasons.
-
-
P
Jamal is a class act, a man short of word's. This was him throughout the season he didn't say much when the judges gave their comments. Jamal just smiled and said thank you. John was good but Jamal is the next American idol stop trying to make something out of nothing.
14 14
-
B
Unfortunately what Lionel Ritchie intended as a complement will be a detriment to any success Jamal Roberts may have. Roberts needs a distinct musical lane in which to fit to squeeze into radio and streaming play lists. American Idol's demographic is largely female and middle aged or older. What appeals to A.I.'s viewers is not going to resonate with younger people.
3 1
-
P
True he never said much at all just smiled and said thank you
1
-
-
G
I love how articles about a TV show. Don’t have a clip of the moment that they’re writing about so we’re reading nine paragraphs but can’t watch the three second moment. Bad journalism
-
T
For two very talented people in Jamal snd John it was one of the best Idol finales that I can remember. Jamal with his R&B talent that I so love. I am so happy to see and "hear" R&B coming back in with so much new talent. I am a big Smokey Robinson follower. He has kept R&B popular for many years. And John, a new voice with a new sound and a great talent for Country. I believe he will pull people into the love of Country music that have not been Country music followers in the past..he is a boon for Country music with that Louisanna spice into it. I just love his voice, his sound and the musical talent of writing new songs. This should bring new interest for American Idol and new talent for R&B and Country music.
1
-
B
"Token" winner so AI didnt get a riot started! I'm not watching any more! The winner was obvious weeks ago! Even before the final announcement I looked at Viewer Responses! Jamal was at 657.. Johns were 748... Not rocket science!
1 2
-
P
Are you suggesting it was fixed? That would destroy any credibility this show has.
-
-
O
as someone else mentioned, this season definitely had a strange "praise the lord" vibe repeatedly...? Maybe Trump Bible Company (Hwang Zhou, China), was a sponsor>?
1
-
G
Regarding whether or not John saw the card Seacrest was holding with the name of the winner on it, i personally believe he did. The same thing happened years ago as Clay Akin and Ruben Stuttard waited to see which one won. Seacrest opened the card right next to Clay in a way that Clay had a clear view who the winner was. Clay lost. Clay even acknowledged a few days later that he saw the winner on the card before the winner was revealed. I dont know if Seacrest is just being careless or if he's trying to give the loser a heads-up. Interesting.
1
-
G
This season of American Idol was painful to watch. The emence amount of Christian songs and references to god was offensive and to much. I don't watch Idol to watch them push the Christian agenda. One or 2 songs fine, but the whole season was terrible. The judges and Jellyroll were overtly pushing Christian Nationalist. The whole show was a disappointment.
1
-
R
I think Gabby should have won, best vocalist of all the contestants and beauty queen also!!! I believe she will have the best career of any of them!!!
1
-
C
No matter who won should be happy for them. I think John Foster should have won but it wasn't meant to be but I know he still has a wonderful future ahead of him.
-
C
Just like I think Megan Danielle should of won in 2021 but Iam tongi won but I love his music too.
-
-
-
O
Omg, really I just watched the finale on streaming John was literally over 5-6 feet from Ryan Seacrest really people, just watched the clip posted on here also just because he had a look on his face or his eyes rolling omg guys get real. He even stated that he's very happy with being runner up he's has a wonderful career ahead of him. Enough with the negativity it's over now move on.
1
-
R
Whatever, Jamal was clearly the winner and Gabby should have been in the top 3
1 2
-
P
Jamal did a fantastic job as did John but I thought Jamal has more to his voice to give
Than country singers
4 5
-
O
Jamal was HORRIBLE
2 1
-
-
P
Even if he saw the card which I doubt he did, it does not change the results America has spoken with their votes an Jamal is the winner and very deserving of the title.
11 12
-
R
Exactly. What real difference did it make? He didn’t see the results by accident…he was trying to see them.
1 1
-
-
P
Really people? You think your votes count? They pick the winner from the minute auditions are done. It’s up to whoever the producer and judges wants not the people. Judges knew from beginning he was the winner that’s why he was so cocky all thru competition. Jamal gonna be one of the winners who will only do what he wants and won’t go anywhere in the industry. this will be last time im watching idol. A rigged singing competition??? Who knew?
3 5
-
O
Mr apple pie lost
Bad song choices
The best singer by far won. The church lady also lost with bad song chouces.
2
-
B
She tried to stay true to her desire to be known as a Christian vocalist. The constant hand signals of I love you to her husband became a sign of her immaturity as a performer on a national stage. In reality, had she come to A.I. fifty pounds lighter and concentrated exclusively on contemporary country songs, she'd have easily won this show. She's a beautiful young woman with an amazing voice. A.I. stressed her backstory as a young mother who questioned herself. I think people got worn out.
1
-
-
P
America didn’t get it right. Not watching ameican idol anymore.
1 3
-
R
Sore loser.
1 1
-
-
G
Ryan is always making mistakes, he’s immature and needs only 1 job to concentrate on . American Idol needs to make it right and bring back John Foster to tie with Jamal Roberts with 1st place! That would be a Class Act Recovery, as both were excellent singers. Then send Ryan packing ….
6 8
-
R
26,000,000 Votes!
Jamal won fair and square.
1 2
-
-
C
Jamal said to John there's only one way up referring to John's career. He is not a man of many words which is not a bad thing. I wanted Jamal to win from the first time he sang.
8 12
-
O
Jamal can't sing!!!!!!!!!!! He is awful and I do not know who was voting for him.
1 2
-
-
G
I dont think he saw and who cares. Im glad jamal won, I think Jon sounded too much karaoke and old country like George strait. I wasn't a fan. Sorry. He will do something. The top 5 or 10, we will hear them somewhere
4
-
R
Exactly. What real difference did it make? He didn’t see the results by accident…he was trying to see them.
1
-
-
B
As usual Ryan Seacrest screwed up, he is just a highly overpaid clown.
1 5
-
R
I am so disappointed withe results of American Idol. I’m still a big Fan of John Foster. I don’t remember an original Song from Jamal.
Oh well Jamal needs the win cause he has 2 children.
4 9
-
P
When you see a performer like Bad Bunny for example or Megan Traynor or even Taylor and then you see these sanitized American Idol finalists, they have a long way to go to make it big. It is like wearing a Kirkland tee-shirt or some Nike swag. I think the judging or the voting process takes the contestants down to the least objectionable for the most number of people and I don't think that makes a big star.
14 26
-
G
I WILL NEVER WATCH AMERICAN IDOL AGAIN BECAUSE A DRUNK WON I THINK IT WAS FIX FROM THE VERY START JAMAL ROBERTS SHOULD NEVER BEEN KEEP MAYBE BECAUSE THEY THOUGHT HE HAD A GOOD BODY THAT IS ALL HE HAD
HE DIDN'T WARE A SHIRT ARE EVEN LOOK GOOD AT ALL
I THINK I CAN SANG BETTER THAN JAMAL ROBERTS
24 38
-
G
Wow...Your illiterate remarks are full of hatred and underlying racism. Why not just be happy for all of the contestants and wish them well.
12 1
-
B
How do you know he’s a drunk? Any proof …that is a very big allegation!!!!!
5
-
O
I'm suspicious of that illiterate post. It's so poorly written and over the top that I think the writer might be a John Foster hater trying to make Foster's fans look bad.
-
O
Here's a news flash, they have every right to make comments, even if it is in poor grammer & spelling. It's their parents & teachers fault that they haven't been educated. Not everybody has that in their lives.
1
-
-
R
Learn to spell first before making your hateful comments . And of course you will watch Idol again. You all say the same thing every season. You just make fools of your teenage selves. See ya in the comments next season lol. If you THINK you sing better then get your ass up there and let's see the audition unless you are cut before you even get to go audition in front of the judges. The producers will surely get a kick out of booting your ass out!
30 1
-
O
I love me some pastry chef 😋😍
-
-
C
So sad this segment has been reduced to first grade level. Poor Grammer at its best.
-
-
G
NEVER WATCH AMERICAN IDOL AGAIN
1 17
-
C
Aw, I'm sure American Idol is heartbroken
-
-
G
WILL NEVER WATCG AMERICAN IDOL AGAIN
16
Watchlist Easy access to only the shows you care about — all in one simple place
Alerts Only important notifications — when a show is returning, when it becomes available to stream, and more.
Special Offers Exclusive products we release related to your favorite shows and streaming services