How ‘Sanditon’ Handled Sidney’s Season 2 Exit — And Why It Happened That Way
Spoiler Alert
[Warning: The below contains MAJOR spoilers for the Sanditon Season 2 premiere.]
Sidney Parker is dead! The long-awaited Season 2 premiere of PBS drama Sanditon wasted no time revealing his fate: The fiery Regency gentleman, who had been ready to propose to Charlotte Heywood before fate intervened at the end of the first season, succumbed to yellow fever on a trip to Antigua.
The episode opened with Sidney’s funeral (even before the opening credits). Shots of his coffin being carried to his grave were interspersed with a buoyant Charlotte (Rose Williams) dancing up a storm back home in Willingden — until Sidney’s sister-in-law Mary (Kate Ashfield) brought her the news of his death.
Viewers have known for a year that Sidney’s portrayer, Theo James, wouldn’t be reprising his role for the Masterpiece series’ sophomore season. His departure dashed hopes that Charlotte and Sidney would eventually live happily ever after. Season 1 of this adaptation of Jane Austen’s unfinished novel ended with Sidney deciding to marry his former fiancée to save his brother from debtor’s prison. But did Sidney have to die?
New head writer Justin Young told a Television Critics Association panel in January that Sidney’s untimely demise would reverberate throughout the season. “It gave us this enormous emotional event at the beginning of the [season] that sets up all the stories,” he explained. “Really, the season becomes about that in a way — how everyone moves on from Sidney.”
Bringing in a new actor to play the role didn’t seem like a viable option. “Obviously we couldn’t recast because that would have destroyed the integrity of the world,” Young said. “It would have been implausible. We thought we needed to make clear to the audience right from the beginning that he’s not coming back, although [Charlotte] waits for him to come back, and we needed to let the audience grieve along with Charlotte.”
That’s how another PBS series, Downton Abbey, handled the departures of two of its popular characters, Dan Stevens’ Matthew Crawley and Jessica Brown Findlay’s Lady Sybil Branson, when the actors playing them wanted to leave the show: by killing them off and depicting how their loved ones dealt with their grief.
More recently, the network’s All Creatures Great and Small recast the supporting character of wealthy, dog-pampering Mrs. Pumphrey with Patricia Hodge after Diana Rigg, who originated the role, passed away.
Do you think Sanditon made the right call? Sound off in the comments below.
Sanditon, Sundays, 9/8c, PBS (check local listings at pbs.org)
Rose Williams
Anne Reid
Kris Marshall
Kate Ashfield
Jack Fox
Charlotte Spencer
Crystal Clarke
Lily Sacofsky
Turlough Convery
Alexandra Roach
Mark Stanley
Matthew Needham
Elizabeth Berrington
Kayleigh-Paige Rees
Adrian Rawlins
Sarah Belcher
Mollie Holder
Tom Weston-Jones
Frank Blake
Maxim Ays
Eloise Webb
Flora Mitchell
Ben Lloyd-Hughes
Alexander Vlahos
Rosie Graham
⨁Full Cast & Crew
Conversation208 Comments
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Comments are closed on this story.
-
O
Theo James drew me to Season 1, hands down. He was absolute perfection as Sidney Parker. His mannerisms, looks, & sultry masculinism drew me back week after week. There can be no replacement for that. I also grieve along with Rose for the loss of Sidney. Such a loss of the once sizzling series.
99 9
-
O
Like many, I'm disappointed about the direction of the new series and the elimination of Jane Austen's last hero, Sidney Parker. That being said, I understand the writers and producers were in a difficult position with Theo James not returning. However, after reading many fan fictions with extremely creative and inventive resolutions to the Sidney/Charlotte cliffhanger, I do believe that the writers could have still found inventive ways to deliver this, ultimately. I watched the first few episodes of season 2 and I felt the scripting was weak and the new plot arcs don't feel inspiring or original to me. They feel like repetitions of other Austen stories or other classic authors (Bronte). I know that many people worked hard on this second series and I appreciate their efforts. However, I can't pretend that the new series is inspiring and engaging to me, when it so clearly lacks the originality of Season 1 and so drastically departs from the way a true Jane Austen narrative would have concluded (with the very compelling hero and heroine together). Jane would never have had her hero be forced into a loveless marriage and then die an agonizing death alone. Sidney Parker did not deserve that. I do respect that other people are enjoying it, though, and are happy that it's back. I'll stick with Season 1 and look forward to another screen adaptation at some point that follows the spirit of a great Jane Austen narrative and with her original Sanditon characters preserved.
89 10
-
R
I need my Austen happy ending with all characters preserved!!! 😄
28 2
-
G
I most wholeheartedly agree with you. He should have been lost at sea, which is entirely plausible. That way, when Theo James wants to return there could be a restoration of the romance and a perfect ending as it should be.
It's bad enough they have to incorporate today's liberal corrosiveness into historical settings when it did not exist.
I wouldn't watch it at all if there was anything other than drivel on.
14 5
-
-
P
Very disappointing. I don't even want to watch after waiting so long for the second season. I had my heart set on Sidney and Charlotte getting together. I think it will be a big mistake.
80 13
-
R
I was totally brokenhearted when Theo James did not return for Season 2. I really wanted Sidney and Charlotte to have a second chance. However, if not Sidney, would have loved to see Young Stringer as Charlotte's new love match. It was very upsetting when he did not return as well. I'm not a fan of Edward returning and Charlotte's sister was annoying. I was disappointed with the first episode of Season 2 and the two possible love interests for Charlotte. They are not even tempting! The next episode will have to offer more to keep me watching.
56 4
-
O
Extremely disappointing to lose Theo James as Sidney. His relationship with Charlotte actually made my decision to watch Season 2. Now there is nothing to look forward too. I'm not sure the reason why, but a really bad decision made by both the actor and the show.because of this the first episode of Season 2 was a big let down.
65 23
-
O
I'm very happy Theo didn't accept it, the script clearly wasn't good enough to entice him. Justin isn't good enough to be a head writer. Why come back to a downgraded show?
4 5
-
B
I just wish they had bent over backwards and written him a decent script and paid him the earth to do even one or two episodes. That's all we needed! Then the other characters could have continued their story.
7 1
-
-
R
I enjoyed the first episode, but I definitely agree with you on losing Theo as Sidney. Bad decision all around. They should not have killed him off. Yellow fever! Such a horrible death! RIP Sidney 😢
1
-
-
R
Sanditon - letting Sidney is a terrible decision. Ruins the story. I will probably not watch the rest of the season.
46 11
-
G
I agree!! If I had known Sidney was dead, I probably would not have watched Sanditon.
13 5
-
C
Totally agree. Very disappointing. I will not watch further.
2 1
-
-
B
You don't seem to have read the article - the only "choice" was made by the departing actor, NOT PBS.
2
-
-
O
Given that Theo James chose not to come back, this felt the most natural and authentic way to carry on with the story. No one else could have played Sidney. Looking forward to seeing Charlotte's journey.
38 4
-
O
I don't mind a new love story for Charlotte but so far all the candidates do not even come close to Theo James. They must fine a gorgeous suitor for us to all fall in love with. None will do so far. Hopefully they have him waiting in the wings for us.
38 7
-
E
With the potential suitors introduced in Episode 1, I'm thinking maybe she is right to consider staying single forever! Theo James is just too perfect and irreplaceable.
38 5
-
-
G
Theo James forced Masterpiece’s hand; he left them no choice. They make lemonade and I think the story so far is lovely and compelling. I’m thankful that they didn’t scrap the series altogether! There are so many other beautiful characters and I hope that Sidney’s sacrifice is not in vain.
40 10
-
P
SIDNEY's sacrifice was in vain. His loss has ABSOLUTELY killed this story. I cannot even watch it. This is maddening. He own every scene he was in. Imagine Pride and Prejudice without Darcy. INSANITY! Crazy decision to let him go.
28 8
-
G
The didn’t “let him go”. Theo James chose to leave.
5
-
-
-
C
Sidney's death was a bit of a shocker, but I was most disappointed by the new cast. There was absolutely no chemistry between them and Charlotte, her sister (who I found annoying!) , or Miss Lambe. I also missed Babbington! I will continue to watch and hope things improve, but if no "spark" develops, I will find other entertainment.
46 17
-
G
My exact feels about Season 2 I couldn't have put this better
9 1
-
-
C
Sydney was key to the magic but i will give it a chance. I hate to see Charlotte with anyone else.
28
-
B
I am very sad to lose Sidney but at the start of Season 2 it looks like she has a couple of other possible suitors. I will continue watching for sure.
32 4
-
G
The opening scene when Charlotte is dancing, there's a very handsome man that I think is the farmer that Charlotte and and her sister reference later that Charlotte's father wants her to marry. He actually looked really cute. But they just only showed him for a minute, so maybe he shows up in a later episode.
9 11
-
-
B
It makes me sad that Sydney had to be written out of the story. I was so hopeful that he and Charlotte would find their way back to each other. Now there’s not much interest for me to watch Season 2.
29 6
-
C
He might as well be dead, since he’s decided no longer to be in the series. A good decision by the writers. Charlotte can move on.
29 6
-
R
I understand why Sidney's absence was explained by death. Sometimes it's hard to replace a favorite actor with a new one. Since Theo James opted to not return then something had to be done. I personally liked the actor who played Mr. Stringer. In Season one after the cricket match, it was evidently stated he was interested in Charlotte. I'm happy to see other beloved characters reappear. Hopefully Charlotte's sister won't become an embarrassment to all who know her. To those who said they won't watch, it's only episode one. Give it a chance.
28 8
-
B
None of the new characters, in Sanditon, were likeable tonight. I knew that Sidney would not be coming back, but the possible replacements were not interesting or even very attractive, (and even the attractive Mr. Stringer seems to be gone), and her sister was almost hyperactive! I hope the new season will prove to be better than it was tonight. Fans were so anxious for Sanditon's return and even contributed toward it, so I hope we won't be disappointed! I'm don't like to be negative, but it did not live up to expectations!
29 11
-
C
I think the producers didn't have much choice once it was definite that TJ would not return to the show. The characters are shown dealing with their grief, especially Charlotte - Sidney was the love of her life and I think vice versa for him. Neither were likely to feel that kind of love again. But decisions were made and Sidney chose to save his family from financial ruin and likely debtor's prison. Fans fought so hard to get a Season2 (myself included) so it's only right to give S2 a chance. Having said that, the first episode was underwhelming. You can tell the writers have changed, I don't think it was nearly as good as S1. The sister is annoying. The lack of Stringer and Babbington, both compelling characters is a disappointment too. Actors have their own projects though. I agree with others that the new love interests are very unattractive and not interesting so far. It took only minutes to feel drawn into characters from S1, even returning characters seem more flat and uninteresting except Arthur. But I'm willing to see the series through as I feel getting the surprise of a second season is better than no Sanditon at all.
15
-
B
Kept hoping Sidney's death was misreported. Huge mistake after all of season 1 built up his relationship with Charlotte. I can't accept or forgive killing him off. It stinks! Ruined the show!
20 7
-
G
I’ve not watched the second season and not sure I will. The whole handling of this show seemed off from the start. It had some great characters, chemistry and moments in the first series, but with very little promotion it was always going to be a slow burn with audiences, especially with on-demand viewing habits. Just as it started building a fanbase with catch up audiences, ITV seemed to lose patience and prematurely pulled the plug. Stars understandably went elsewhere, either because they were sold on the idea of the original ending, or perhaps because of more promising opportunities and prospects. There seemed to be a complete lack of understanding by TV decision-makers about why and how audiences watch period romances - to enjoy a slow but rewarding build up. There also seemed to be so much focus on getting quick viewing figures and public indecision about whether or not to continue the story, which seemed at odds with other classic, well thought through period productions and couldn’t have been easy for the cast. This new series is largely the result of impressive campaigning by fans and opportunism by on-demand services, so I doubt it will have the quality and craftsmanship of the first series. However, I hope I’m wrong and it delivers for fans who just wanted the well-crafted escapism and spirit of an Austen story, even an unfinished one. It’s not much to ask - is it?! Verdict: Initially promising but painfully mishandled.
14 2
-
G
Underwhelmed! Sidney’s demise and too many departures from Season 1…none of the new characters have the intrigue and panache of dearly departed Sidney!
15 3
-
B
It's really bizarre to have been one of the first viewers and fans of Sanditon in 2019, one of the biggest campaigners to renew the show and fix that heartbreaking ending and do justice to Austen's legacy. Bizarre because I haven't watched this first episode of Season 2 and I don't think I ever will. I might catch up later to see what happens to the other characters, but for me Sidney and Charlotte's story ended on that clifftop. I simply can't allow this story to trample all over my heart, yet again. First time, watching Episode 8 of series 1, second time when they brutally announced that Sidney would not return. I hope all the new "Bridgerton" and "Austen-lite" viewers enjoy the show. I'm not bitter as I had a really fun time being a fan (for a while anyway) and I don't blame Theo James. I think he's great and I sort of understand why he didn't want to come back. But it's back to Austen's books for me 🙂
15 5
-
O
Sidney dying was the right choice. As devastating as it wasn't, It was the only way for the story to continue. I think it was handled perfectly and honoured Sidney the way he deserved.
13 3
-
C
Do you think the way the writers showed his death left it open that there could be a mistake and it’s not Sydney and the character could return in the future? It would be an extremely difficult recast.
-
-
B
I’m disappointed that Theo James did not return as Sidney -Parker, and that the writers decided to have him pass away. This romance is one of the reasons i’m tuning in to season 2… however i do enjoy Jane Austen films … so although disappointed in what the outcome maybe at the end of season 2; I will continue to watch a couple more episodes to figure out whether Sanditon Season 2 is binge worthy !!
12 2
-
P
Terrible decision to kill off the most appealing male character to appear in a series in Years. Won't be watching any further. Charlotte's new love interests are bland and unappealing, no passion or charisma.
17 7
-
C
Personally, since they didn't show a body, I have hope that Sydney faked his death to escape from a marriage he didn't want to be in, while still helping his brother's dream
14 4
-
G
Unlikely
-
E
Yes. A publicity stunt that Theo was leaving and his death on the show is faked. Hope for Sidney springs eternal! Love it.
3
-
-
G
Even tho I loved Theo James as Sidney Parker I wish the character had been recast and the storyline continued. The first episode was disappointing to me, Sanditon doesn't feel like Sanditon, and I just didn't feel inspired by the lack of chemistry amongst the remaining characters. The military presence is incongruous and off-putting. Sadly, killing Sidney off is probably the best way in which to allow Charlotte's character to continue but I'm not looking forward to sad allusions of his death and being gone. Meh
11 3
-
G
While I am heartbroken by Sidney's death, I can think of no other plausible way the writers could have had him exit, without ever showing him again. After Season 1, I was still hoping they could end up together. I think it's a testament to the actors' chemistry and their excellent acting, as well as the story.
While it is sad to see the Sanditon world without him, that is how life goes, sometimes. I will still watch with fervor.
11 3
-
R
With Theo James not returning, producers could have gone in a different direction. Young love gone awry brings quiet grief but can come with a smidge of hope. By killing him off, producers gave us "Beautiful Sadness" an easy ploy for writers but not particularly appealing to viewers. We all have experienced enough grief these past couple of years and look forward to something thoughtful and uplifting, not sadness.
11 3
-
O
I think it was the correct call. It would have been hard to recast the role. Everyone would be expecting the same kind of chemistry with Rose.
9 1
-
B
So instead she has no chemistry with anyone? The correct call would have been to get Sidney back for one episode to fix the mess of season 1 and actually make this series worthy of Austen's name.
10 5
-
-
O
Too bad Sidney will not appear. Is there a chance he might appear later on. Was there a mistake in who was buried?
11 3
-
O
I hope so too, that they will realize of their huge mistake and they bring him back, even if they cast another actor.
1 3
-
B
I thought it was a mis-identification too. That it is not Sidney in the casket but an imposter so he can come back some how. Where is the creativity with your writers? In any event, the young architect vowed to stay,and now he is gone? What is with that? The new love interest for Charlotte is not very attractive. He is a bit full of himself much like Sidney was but without looks. Not interested in continuing.
2
-
-
G
Unlikely.... new storyline
-
-
P
Okay....so help me to understand this. The REASON why FANS (like me) wanted to see Sanditon to live on was to see SIDNEY and CHARLOTTE together. So...you get fans ALL EXCITED about seeing Part 2 (we wait for over a year) and in the first scene, SIDNEY is DEAD. You have got to be KIDDING ME. I am NOT WATCHING! OUTRAGEOUS DECISION!!!!! Jane Austen would NEVER had made such a decision. This is akin to killing off Marc Darcy in Pride & Prejudice. Makes ABSOLUTELY no sense. To me, the writers needed to do something creative....like write a good plot. Figure it out to keep the character intact. What a sloppy, careless decision. No imagination at all. INSANE Decision!!!!
8 1
-
O
It is very disappointing to lose Sidney and Theo James. The new potential suitors have no problem little chemistry with Charlotte. And bring back Lord Babbington also! I wish there’s a way Sidney can come back in Season 3!
7
-
G
I think that while it was disappointing to lose the handsome Mr Parker, it certainly doesn't throw the show down the drain. We, like Charlotte, must grieve the loss and be open to new possibilities. After all, he'd already married someone else so he was "off the market" anyway. Yes, I liked Mr Stringer as well. He actually treated Rose much better than Mr Parker. Rose was young and nieve in Season 1. Let's see how she develops as a young woman in Season 2.
(And this is coming from someone who never got over Matthew Crawley dieing in Downton Abbey.)
As for the sister and Ms Lamb, they're young, nieve, and yes, a little annoying. It'll be interesting to see how they mature and what is the catalyst that makes them do so.
9 2
-
G
Charlotte [Rose]
-
-
G
Not that seeing Sydney stuck with the woman who callously broke his heart and sent his life on a downward spiral a fate worst than death, I just wish fans had been left with the possibility of Charlotte and Sydney eventually living happily ever after. One good thing came out of this for me was looking several other Theo James movies than gave me a broader picture of his acting ability and an understanding of why he could make a wise career choice when the future of the series was in question. Wishing the best to Theo James and to the serires.
10 3
-
P
I am done. Sidney's death killed the show for me. First we were told there would be no more seasons. I felt let down and betrayed by that fact, then I lean there will be a season two. I looked forward to seeing how Charlotte and Sidney would find a way to be together only to see Sidney being buried in the first scene of season two. I would have prefered a different actor in favor of killing Sidney off.
11 4
-
R
I was looking forward to season two of Sanditon. After killing off Sidney I’ve lost interest.
12 5
-
G
I think that it should have had a suitable ending, in the first series.
If this was a tribute to Jane Austin, she must be spinning in her grave.
Having not completed the story successfully, in the first series, I believe that the part of Sidney, should have been recast.
It is unlikely that Pride and Predudice, would have been such an enduring masterpiece, if Mr Darcy had been bumped off half way through!
8 2
-
G
If they were playing true to Jane Austin’s books, we know she would have brought them back together. So no they did not make the right decision!
6
-
G
I have only watched about 10 minutes of season 2 and I am bored and disappointed. Season 1 should have had a true Jane Austen happy ending. All's well that ends well. This new season is too little, too late.
7 1
-
O
I’m so disappointed I’m not sure I want to continue. Why don’t they get contracts from the very beginning from the lead actors? Did they really think a Jane Austen (sort of) would only have one season?
7 1
-
C
The show was cancelled in 2019. But Theo wasn't optioned for a second season anyway, they would have had to renegotiate. Unfortunately it took too long to get the renewal and he had moved on to other roles. But yes, it was ridiculous to write a cliffhanger ending like that without any guarantee of a second season and without the main actors under contract.
6
-
-
B
After it was announced that Theo James would not reprise his role as Sidney Parker, I had no doubt the best way to handle the situation would be the death of the character. Although there were other options such as recasting, the character's end was the easiest one, really. But I had hoped his death would be as a hero, perhaps rescuing another person(s) from a harrowing situation, a death befitting the man who sacrificed his own happiness for his family, a sacrifice Charlotte shared.
Instead, the whole opening montage felt cold and impersonal -- his death in a faraway place surrounded by strangers who seemed not to care. Even the woman pulling the bloody sheets off the bed (was that really necessary?) seemed blasé, unmoved by the death of someone she didn't really know. And that set the tone for what was to come: A story leaning heavily on recycled plots and character types cobbled together from across the genre that seems to have little if any connection to the first season, and even less connection to Austen's fragment than the first season did.
7 1
-
B
I agree with AuntieEM, it should lend itself to some new twists and turns, and the first episode was very well done.
8 2
-
G
I will add Colbourne is an interesting storyline ... both he and Charlotte grieving (why he recluse since wife's passing). Just wish the character was a tad more handsome. I suspect he has depth. And a worthy prospect.
I hope she does not become involved with the colonel. Military wife is not desirable as he said.
The sister seems terribly immature ... and I hope not headed for bad decisions. Her being in Sanditon is distracting. Better she was not included in their stay or at least had more depth. Not fond of sister character or storyline.
Georgiana would be better off in Parker household ...not the restrictive environment a horrible stifling place for her that adds to rebellion. When she is around Arthur you see how she responds to his caring warmth.
8 2
-
O
So Sidney joins Mr. Pamuk. Perfect!
6
-
B
There was no way to recast someone for Sidney. He would be constantly compared to TJ and those are big shoes to fill. I was disappointed and angry that TJ chose not to return. After watching Ep 1 & 2 of S2 last night, I am glad he didn't. The story is new and full of surprises. I am intrigued by Colbourne's character and can not wait to see more 😍
10 4
-
B
I agree. I miss my Jane Austen happy ending too. Sydney and Charlotte deserve another chance. Season 2 hasn't drawn me in.
6 1
-
P
They didn't need to kill him off. There were other creative alternatives to explain his absence. After all, most ex's don't die. I've noticed that sometimes when actors leave shows because of failed negotiations, their characters get killed off as the "solution" and the show execs get the last word. I wonder if that was what happened here. In any event, it sure "let the air out" of the show and traumatized fans. And when fans are traumatized, sometimes they just don't want to watch anymore.
6 1
-
G
We will miss Theo As Sidney. A few of us were wondering where Sidney will go in the new series. He will be missed. Seeing the casket at the beginning of the show, all we did was to call each other and ask “ Is that Sidney?” Sad start to series 2.
5
-
O
Right call. Life is messy but goes on. Loved the 1st episode. Looking forward to the rest.
6 1
-
C
I hadn't been aware that Sidney's character wouldn't be returning to Sanditon before watching the second season's first episode. I was hoping that this was some kind of plot or something until reading the above information. Like others I'm not certain whether I'll continue with it since I'd been so sad over the first season's ending! And, while I know that life does continue after a love one's death, I like watching such shows to put a smile on my face. This isn't happening here!!
7 2
-
P
Sidney made the show!! I watched the 1st episode of season 2 w/out Sidney and needless to say. I will not be watching. Killing Sidney ended Sandition for me.
7 2
-
O
I think the role should have been recast, they used to do that on the soaps all the time and viewers would readjust. What happened to the other almost love interest with the other man who is becoming an architect?
13 8
-
O
He ran from this as fast as he could.
2 3
-
G
It was thought there would not be another season and James had other opportunities. Then later the show was trying to get funding for another season. It was all timing and if the next season was decided at the end of season one, things would been different.
4 1
-
B
He's in Valhalla being a Viking!
-
-
G
Bad decision to not recast the role…..I have watched many movies that had actors with the same swagger if not better…..unfortunately Charlotte and Sidney were the main characters people watched….with that said I did not even finish episode 1 in season 2. Very big disappointment in the show.
4
-
G
Like others I too am very disappointed that TJ was not returning. I was shocked with the opening of S2 and saw his name on the casket. I watched the first 2 episodes but stopped there. I couldn't get into it without the thought of Sidney and Rose not being together. I loved their bantering. Their scenes together made the show. The rest of the cast were good also but every movie needs that sexy, sultry scenes between 2 love interests. Sidney just didn't know how to take her frankness, they were quite cute to watch together. The same thing happened in Bridgerton too. S2 was't as good after the main character left. I'm still curious as to why Theo James decided not to return. Did he have another commitment?
4
-
O
I’m not sure that I can watch Season 2 without Sidney Parker!
4
-
O
Seriously, I don't get why people are suddenly so surprised that Theo James did not return to reprise his role as Sidney. It has been in the media for ages now!
The show was cancelled after Season One with no real chance of a renewal in the near future, so it's only natural that he and some of his colleagues looked for other jobs and moved on. When a second and third season were surprisingly announced more than a year after the end of Season One, it was due to scheduling clashes that Theo - and some of the other actors - didn't return. It was quite a blow that he didn't even WANT to return, though.
I personally am hugely disappointed that there won't be any HEA for Sidney and Charlotte now, and I don't care one jot for Charlotte's unappealing new suitors. But at least there's a chance that she might find happiness eventually at the end of the series. Who knows, there even might be a new and "worthy" character entering the ring in Season 3... 😉
However, I agree with some of the other commentators here that "Season 2" of Sanditon should rather have been marked as a Spin-off and not a proper continuation of the original story.
4
-
P
I wish they would have kept him on the show. He was her true love and I too like others was drawn into the show. Their love was unique and exciting. Seems like everything I find a good show the kill off the characters or the show.
5 1
-
B
They had to kill Sidney. Charlotte would not have been able to move on if he were still alive. If they had recast him then I'm sure many people would be unhappy with the chosen actor, and as they said, recreating the chemistry is nigh on impossible. This is Charlotte's story, so let's see where is goes; I'm keen to find out!
5 1
-
O
Loved his character, but I don’t blame him for taking another opportunity in this crazy world. I certainly don’t blame show runners, because in this crazy world we all could be a little less angry and a lot more positive. I love this series and Charlotte is the hub and glue that brings it all together. Maybe we should all give it a chance and see where it goes. I will not give up on this series because it has so much potential. I hope the people who made such negative comments will give everyone a chance and see how things unfold. The total cast is so impressive and can’t wait to see where the writers take us from here! !
7 3
-
P
Even though I knew that Theo James and Leo Suter would not return, I was looking forward to watching the new season but the first episode didn't win me over at all.
While there might be a chance of seeing Young Stringer again, the door seems to have closed forever for Sidney to make a miraculous return.
That said, I must admit that I found Sidney not particularly likeable, especially in the first half of the first season (I would have preferred Charlotte ending up with cute Mr. Stringer...). BUT! Sidney was certainly very dashing and interesting AND there was loads of chemistry between him and Charlotte. He is definitely missed.
Maybe except for that artist guy the new male characters just don't make any impression on me. Charlotte's new "love interests" do not have an ounce of that chemistry or attractiveness of Sidney (or Young Stringer). I really wonder who was responsible for casting them. Ugh!
As far as the storylines are concerned, I found everything a bit rushed and slightly soapy, at least in the first episode. Things could improve with time, however.
So on the whole I am quite disappointed - the show has just not the same appeal as with its original cast.
9 5
-
G
I liked how Charlotte heard his voice in her head. He will always be with her. I'm invested to see how what he was doing over there was for Georgiana and maybe investigating that will uncover something that will give closure for Charlotte to move on.
4
-
R
It feels like I'm the only one who was more interested in Mr Stringer in S1 than in Sidney. (I always wanted something new and found Sidney too derivative of Darcy.) But my favorite man in the series was Babbington. Him and Esther are my favorite pairing in Sanditon. Glad that he's not dead and am enjoying the plot with Esther wanting a baby with him.
Not feeling the new guys yet. None of them are my type, but I am willing to give it some time.
3
-
G
No, you are not the only one! Even though I eventually got to terms with Charlotte choosing Sidney in Season 1, I always preferred Young Stringer as her ideal suitor. He was such a gentle soul, respecting Charlotte as an equal - AND he was incredibly handsome!
When I learnt that Theo wasn't returning for Season 2, I was really hoping that finally the time had come for Mr. Stringer to make his move with Charlotte - only to find out that Leo Suter was also not coming back for a second season. 😒
The new guys are definitely not making me swoon either...
4 1
-
-
O
The series lost its chemistry and my interest when they lost Sidney. It was a wonderful Season 1 and I will just move to something else.
3
-
O
Big mistake killing Sydney off. You could have done a lot more with that story line.
4 1
-
O
Love the new season!
3
-
B
So many people whining about Sidney’s character not being in season 2 and blaming the producers or James Theo for moving on. Sorry to be the one to tell you but life doesn’t always go as expected and just because that’s how you wanted it happen doesn’t really matter. Even more people complaining they wouldn’t have watched season 2 if they’d have known, well it was pretty obvious in the first 2 minutes so at least they didn’t invest much time and could exit the show at any time, unless of course they just really like complaining about every little thing which I suspect is probably the case.
9 6
-
B
True, but I think some people are still annoyed that the producers milked "Sidlotte" to get their renewal and the crazy campaigning fans were oblivious for at least 8 months (probably longer) before the renewal was announced.
8 3
-
O
I so totally agree. Tonight’s episode was great. Regency era dramas on pbs are always good. Go find a game or reality show if you want to be bored to death!
1 2
-
-
R
Bad decision. I was hoping Sidney’s wife would pass away from some disease and Sidney would return to Sandition. Same bad decision with Downton Abbey when Matthew wanted out. The first episode did not hold my attention and I’ve lost interest in the show.
6 3
-
C
I knew in advance that Theo James would not return. Totally bummed by that, as, he played Sidney to perfection. I agree that the new season is 'off'. And even, young Stringer is gone! Hard to imagine such a strong and healthy young man could even possibly succumb to yellow fever. Charlotte's sister is a distraction, indeed. Mr. Colburne actor is not very handsome indeed. I will continue to watch just out of curiosity but Sandition should have rested with S1 and let the story go in peace. I will always remember Sandition with Theo James as Sidney.
5 2
-
O
I told myself I would watch S2, give it a chance. However I watched ep 1 of S2 tonight and it's just not as good as S1. My grief was really acute over the loss of my show,it cannot be replaced. It was a huge mistake for the powers that be to let Theo James ever go, then kill him off. Tonight I feel so much grief over the loss of my show. It will never be the same. Sidney Parker will always be #1 for me and always live in my mind and heart. I have to accept that S2 might be good, just not as good without Sidney.
6 3
-
O
Sidney is just irreplaceable. I could not even deal with the level of chemistry he and Charlotte had, it was smoking! By the end of S1 they really understood each other down to their very souls. It was unbelievably cruel to kill him off like that. Not when he'd gone through such an enthralling transformation. And Charlotte would not fall in love a year later with someone who brings absolutely nothing to the table. Colbourne does not feel like an Austen character in any way. He's completely self-absorbed and can't carry on any normal relationships. I don't count his housekeeper or his dog or horse! I'm not sure whether to bother to watch S3. What's the point when you don't like one of the main love interests? I'm so glad I found this page where so many feel the same about S2. I absolutely loved S1, it is so disappointing to feel this way now. I know it's only a TV show but S1 really touched me. So sad.
2
-
P
Maybe Sidney Parker never die, He did it to make people think he’s dead so he doesn’t have to go back to his wife because he still in love with Charlotte and he’s trying to find a way to get back to Charlotte
2
-
O
It doesn't bother me when a character is replaced with another that is similar as possible. I was hoping they would do that with Sidney. I wanted his new wife to die of some sickness on the honeymoon and him come back and spend the 2nd season trying to get back with Rose. 🙁 Whoever was picked to complete Jane Austen's story does not know what Jane Austen fans like or want. My heart dropped on the opening scene.
2
-
R
I meant Charlotte not Rose.
-
-
B
I had hoped that the storytelling would have at least had Charlotte & Sidney elope, and she returned to Sanditon as his widow, same story but at least the fans of the pairing might have had a smidgeon of satisfaction that they had a short-lived 'happily ever after'. Oh well, what can you do, Theo James opted to not return.
3 1
-
O
It is not acceptable!!! He could have had a change of heart and not married and gone to Antigua to make his fortune and with mistaken identity doesn't come back til end of season 2 o or beginning of 3.
3 1
-
E
Sanditon will not be as appealing to me without the "perfectly exquisite in every way" Theo James as Sidney. I grieve his loss in reality just as Charlotte does on the screen. But it was absolutely the right call NOT to try to replace him with another actor. IMPOSSIBLE to replace Mr. James. Judging from the first episode of S2, I haven't yet seen anyone or any plot line that has captured my attention. I'll watch a couple more episodes and decide whether to continue with it or not.
3 1
-
G
It was brilliantly written & handled respectfully
3 1
-
G
Sidney was a main character! No he should definitely not have been written out 😞
4 2
-
R
Should have found a good replacement. I also feel he is a much needed character.
5 3
-
G
The only person responsible for no Sidlotte is Theo James and his refusal to return, even the writers said they planned on the two having their HEA.
4 2
-
B
They should have written their HEA in the first season then, instead of making such a huge gamble with no insurance (much like Tom Parker).
2 2
-
-
C
I stopped watching the show. Charlotte’s sister was annoying and the other suitors were boring. How hard would it have been to cast another good looking, charismatic actor? If I wanted to see someone I could easily run into at the local Target I wouldn’t need the fantasy of these period shows!! We want the Fantasy!
1
-
B
What’s the point of watching it now.
1
-
G
Loved season 1, sadly I did not enjoy season 2. They should have recast Sidney Parker, instead they have a character who is not right for a Jane Austen story. Colbourne is a weak man who is insecure, the actor is fine, it's the writers who erred. What was the reason for season 1???? Stupid mistake for all involved, especially Theo James. It was his best role that showed his acting abilities to perfection. What I see him in now does not do him much credit. Sadly
1
-
O
Why couldn't they just have Charlotte married to Sidney off screen like they did with Esther and Babington? This Colbourne guy is just a straight no. There's no way Charlotte would be into him! Ugh! We wanted Sidney and Charlotte happy, not this nonsensical new "romance". Or just stay cancelled if you can't deliver on the gripping storyline from S1. So sad to see how the opportunity of an epic love story was just wasted.
1
-
B
After watching season 2, it is obvious that there is no replacing Sidney. He was perfection because Theo James just played him so well. His acting was heads and tails above the rest. Such a serious loss to the series.
1
-
C
I am watching season two and enjoying it but have to ask why they did not secure a second season contractually with Theo James from the start. Terrible! Too many shows seem to be cancelled after one season or don’t have the ending in mind from the start leaving viewers wondering why they even bothered. The show has gone a totally different direction with characters that had been developed just disappearing. This is disappointing to be sure as viewers like myself were looking forward to seeing what their futures would hold but now understand that we have been led along for nothing. Maybe someone else will write another ending to Sanditon and actually know the story from beginning to end.
1
-
B
It is horrible, I hated it that they killed off Sidney. I am so disappointed, they should have done that . I am so upset
1
-
C
disappointed not to have Sidney Parker return to the series, however seems Theo James has other commitments the writer had no choice to have him die in the beginning, even though I'm disappointed. Charlotte will meet another Dashing young man.
So far none of the Men in season 2 have been very impressive! I liked the Architect handsome young man that moved away! mmm ?
1
-
O
No you did not. I was disappointed.
1
-
O
well after seeing the NEW characters and with Theo James gone, i have no interest in watching this 2nd Season. Horrendous!!!!
1
-
O
I don't think Jane Austen would have ended it that way in season 1. And I don't think she would killed Sidney off in 2. I think it was her plan for a love story. It probably would have been better to replace Sidney. Kinda disappointing.
2 1
-
B
I totally understand they were left no choice when Theo did not return…much easier in book format when author decides if a character will return or not! Interesting storyline! I will give S2 a chance! 🤷🏻♀️
1
-
B
I miss Sydney! Watched the show because of him and Charlotte’s possibilities.
1
-
G
Not a good idea! Huge mistake. Better to recast the character rather than killing him off.
1
-
O
I hate they killed off Sidney! He was one of my favorites! I'm very disappointed in Season 2 now!
1
-
P
I thought Theo James did a great job with the character—but I hated the character. He was a brooding jerk for most of the season and I was definitely rooting more for Mr. Stringer, who actually behaved much more decently to Charlotte from the outset.
3 2
-
O
I think it was very Dissapointed that Sydney Theo James not returning And I wish It was Liza that Died and He was Free to come back and Marry Charlotte I thinknk in the 1st Episode several times he was interupted when he was about to propose to her.and it never meant to be.To save his Brother from the Damage he Did .How And where he would have gotten the Money From. I wish Charlotte ended up with him .But Love is a Hit and Miss Patern it's all in the Game.
1
-
O
I wasn’t aware that the actor wasn’t coming back!! When I saw them putting Sidney’s coffin in the ground I was hoping they had the wrong person!! He must come back!!! I loved How the relationship between Charolette and Sidney was developing!
2 1
-
O
They can still bring him back by season 3 with being stuck in Antigua and mistaken identy and his rich wife died. So he can be free to marry Charlote. This would be more of a Jane Austin ending. I am so broken hearted about Theo. Was there politics involved. I hope he comes back in season 3. No one can take his place for Charlotte. I am so heartsick I am mad at this rediciulous non Jane Austin ending!
2 1
-
B
He was only signed for one season, the show was 'cancelled' and when they got a shot at more seasons he said 'no thanks', probably because he had other projects. Maybe they can lure him back at the end of season 3? I'm not counting on it though.
1
-
C
Season 3 is already filmed (they filmed back to back last year). He's not in it. If he is, it will be a miracle!
-
-
-
O
They did what they could with what they had, and I think they did an excellent job with it! It’s Charlottes story anyway!
2 1
-
B
Actually, it's the story of the town, the Parker family (5 siblings, not 2) and the Denhams, and Charlotte's just a visitor. It's Charlotte's story now, by force of circumstance.
1 1
-
-
C
I just want to add like a lot of you I was extremely upset by them not replacing the actor playing Sidney with another actor. When I begin to watch the new season, I changed the channel when hearing of Sidney's death. I eventually went back to it and believe that they are doing a good job! Nonetheless, I'm still disappointed but I'll continue to watch the show because I love BBC's productions!!
2 1
-
G
Very disappointed that Sydney was totally written out. I'm assuming this was because of Theo James' decision, that he was not interested in pursuing the role. After seeing first new episode, I'm holding off passing judgement. Trying to keep an open mind.
1
-
O
So disappointed. I was looking forward to seeing Theo🥲
3 2
-
B
This series died with Sidney, I'm afraid. Almost everything that made S1 stand out (and even magical in parts) has been erased. It's now weirdly melodramatic yet bland. Charlotte and Sidney’s story was so believable, Charlotte falling in love five minutes later with her bland, depressed, and seriously emotionally damaged employer was not. Honestly, the writers just lost the plot here.
-
P
Season 1 was good. Season 2 was underwhelming "The lack of Stringer and Babbington, both compelling characters is a disappointment too." Agreed with this statement. I don't think they should have killed Sidney character off. He was a main character created by Austen and should not have been written off this easily. Losing these 3 good male leads and replacing them with the ones they added was not a good decision. I don't really care about this show anymore. What if Mr. Darcy actor didn't want to come back. What would Pride & Prejudice be without Darcy? Austen's characters deserve a little more respect and shouldn't be written off so easily. I am looking forward to seeing the chemistry between Jamie & Claire In Outlander and hope that this series continues for several more seasons.
-
B
I agree, best to write him out of the series2 script…. a substitute never works for me!! Might as well change the character rather than replace with a stand in…. not fair to either !!!
-
O
The spark is gone from Sanditon in S2 sadly. The chemistry cannot be matched. Sidney and Charlotte built up believable to true love and compatibility. Colbourne is such an unappealingly drab character, why an earth would our amazing spunky, dynamic Charlotte be interested in him? Should have recast, it had to be better than this. S2 was trauma after trauma, not enjoyable.
-
C
I was very disappointed that Sidney was not returning for the rest of the series. I understand that he had other commitments but he could of been written in as lost in Antigua while looking for Georgina’s Mother’s and his wife dying of an illness. Later in one of series bring him back when he had time between other roles. To have him reunite with Charlotte and have their happily ever after life once and for all for both of them.
-
G
Is the maid at the home of the mansion where Charlotte is the teacher going to end up as the mother of Miss Lamb??????
-
P
My first time watching a period romance story and instantly I was transported into that place and time! Heartfelt to know handsomely Mr, Sidney won’t be coming back. But for what ever reason he left. He took my heart with him. After this, I am sure many opportunities will come his way, Wish him well and hope to see him again soon! PS: Ladies and Gentlemen! Please do not lose hope! Maybe there is a positively that Mr Sidney fake his death..to get away from his fix marriage:) Let’s pray! Amen!
-
O
As much as I tried, I could not like the character of Charlotte's sister. Too impulsive, too embarrassing, frankly. My favorite this season was Miss Lambe. And I love the brother, who is her good friend. I hope he finds love in Season 3. Liked the ending for everyone except Charlotte. I was so angry (because I really, really liked Mr. Colbourne) that I think she should go ahead and marry Ralph out of stupidity.
-
G
imo they should have recast him with a similar type. I'd have rathered that then go in this whole new different and uncoherent direction that is absolutely unAustenesque.
-
R
I learned about Sydney's death 5 min. ago right after I paid for season 2. Had I known prior I wouldn't have bought it. I binged season 1 straight through to 4 AM this morning. Sooo disappointed.
-
B
Well, I must say (for me) that Ben Lloyd-Hughes topped Theo James in Season 2.
1 1
-
R
I don’t think the second series compares to the first. A great shame that the original creators of the show took such a risk. Unfortunately it makes what could have been a really lovely series, far inferior.
The construction of the romance between Charlotte and Sidney was finely planned and executed in keeping with an Austen novel. There is no way to come back from that. I agree with many, it would be hard to replace Theo James, but I would have preferred someone else to take on the role so that all that build up could be given it’s Austen conclusion. Much less integrity in the narrative trying to construct a second best romance for Charlotte. It will never be as satisfying, I’m afraid. Disappointing.
I would love to know what the original plan was for the end of their story- would happily read it if Andrew Davies ever decides to novelise it -as Kate Riordan did with series one.
-
R
We don't know the whole story with Theo James as an actor or employee. If he left for more ambitious projects, we can only observe that has not been met with success. All that aside, there was so much personal growth ahead for Sidney and Charlotte. Both outliers, it would have been enlightening as well as entertaining to watch their mutual progress in love as a couple moving and making sense of their world.
The writers would do best to re-engage James when the show exhibits signs of faltering. A well-faked death to get out of a loveless marriage, save his brother from debtor's prison, and win the one he has always wanted - Charlotte.
-
C
Wrong call all the way...
Should never have left it up in the air. No true to Austen's writing. Lots of copying going on: Jane Eyre clone regarding the new love interest. Shades of Pride and prejudice as well. Why not bring back the architect who was in love with her instead--would have made much more sense and even been true to the story.
Plotting definitely weak. needs a major overhaul. BIG Disappointment and cop-out--a novice could have written a better plot. As far as I'm concerned you should end it in season 2 with a classic happily ever after for the young heroines as well as others and poetic justice for the not-so-deserving...😒😒
-
R
I don’t care for the second season at all to boring if miss Austin wrote this she had to be in pain it’s nothing like what she has written
-
R
I agree. Everyone can be replaced, between the writers and casting director I would have thought they could have figured it out without killing off a character that we all invested in season one. Unfortunately I paid for season two before finding this out. I truly hope they find someone with the same charisma that Theo James has, otherwise it’s not worth watching. If you’re going to create writings in the style of Jane Austin at least try to do it as she would have.
-
C
Opening, shocked they had killed Sydney Parker off! The spark has been lost.. they have lost that element that he could return, 2 episodes in & the magic just isn’t there I’m afraid, I will continue to watch but I don’t feel 2 will live up to 1 & besides only 6 episodes in this series so feel things will be rushed.
-
P
I think they were wrong to kill off Sidney, but maybe they can work him back in and claim it was not Sidney in Antigua after all. They’d also have to kill off that snobby wife of his too however. Alas, anything is possible for true love (Sidney and Charlotte forever)!
-
C
I am terribly disappointed. I watched anxiously each show to see Sidney and Charlotte get together. I have lost interest unless the architect Mr Stringer and she get together.
-
C
I think they should get a commitment from the actor for the whole series. He was great and the series suffers without him, unfortunately. Why did the actor not want to do the second season?
-
G
I have watched the three episodes of season 2. I hate season 2. I hate that Sidney is dead. I hate Charlotte’s sister. I hate the army. And Tom is an idiot. I am not happy. 😢
1 1
-
G
Well…I guess I was the lone viewer that had no idea Theo wasn’t returning for Season 2. Imagine my surprise…horror and yes, grief, when Season 2 opened. Ack…I loved his character and the idea that some way, somehow…he would find his way to Charlotte. A difficult position for the writers to be in, but in the end I think their decision to do it this way will work out. I’m looking forward to the rest of the season.
-
R
By killing off Sidney, Sanditon has moved from pretending it was somehow in the spirit of Jane Austen (which it never really was) to embracing the melodramatic Bronte sisters. Quelle pastiche!
-
G
I may be one of the few that think Sidney could have been recast. It would be hard but they are actors so I think it’s possible to find someone. Season one ended so heartbreakingly and I knew NOTHING about Theo not renewing. I rewatched the first season and as I was still wiping my tears and pulling myself together, telling myself season 2 would make it all okay, episode 1 of season 2 did an extra special stomp on my heart. Uffff talk about a sucker punch. The entire episode I’ve been trying to figure out how Sidney could still be alive but then I googled and found this. I’ll absolutely watch season 2 but I’ll remain heartbroken. Like come on people Austin’s stuff revives our faith that everything will turn out okay in the end. I’ll hold out hope and keep watching with an opened mind. While I don’t particularly feel chemistry between the two possibles and Charlotte, maybe they are slow burns. Fingers crossed. Hopefully it will turn out Austin-ish in the end and it just took the super sad long way around.
-
O
I think Sidney faked his death to get out of a loveless marriage to Eliza. He borrowed money from her to help his brother rebuild Sanditon. In exchange, he agreed to marry her. He will come back from the dead in some future episode.
-
G
Still trying to come to terms with Sidney character not returning and a couple of others, but giving it a chance. Charlotte already seems more mature and a bit more depth...Rose is doing a superb job of portraying her emotional growth with an air of sadness. Only thing I think is that it's only 9 months passed....seems it should have been at least a little over a year to better match the growth in Charlotte, Sidney's marriage, sailing to Antigua, and them subsequent death. But besides that, looks promising. Who knows., maybe Theo James will make a cameo in season 3 im that he faked his death to get out of his marriage. He returns to Sanditon with a beard and an assumed name. He asks Charlotte to run away with him. Now, Charlotte has to choose between a life incognito with Sidney, or a stable life with one of her new suitors! 😄
-
O
So upset that Theo James made the decision not to come back. Most girls like the ‘bad boy’ (and Edward was too extreme). He was the reason that drew me into the show. I wished he would reconsider, and he might later down the road. It was shocking to see Sidney’s funeral procession within the first minute of the show, but if Theo decides to come back, it could be decided that he faked his death. One can always hope. But I’m not too impressed with the 2 proposed suitors for Charlotte. They seem to be a cop out.
-
B
Given the circumstances it makes sense but it definitely makes me sad. I loved the dynamic between Sidney and Charlotte.
-
C
Worse than there being no season 2 at all. Complete waste of money to continue this series at all without the character Sidney.
-
B
waiting to see how the story will evolve.. death such as was portrayed common in those days.. and people moved on.. so am curious how things will develope
-
R
REAL not happy. Season 2 seemed weak without sidney. There was no excitement Nothing to anticipate. It's like we got an alternative story. 10mins into the 1 episode I was bored. Please try to select a man for Charlotte that's a step up. No one in episode one will do. I really don't want to watch it again BUT I waited too long to get nothing. I hope the series can recover. Right now it seems carbs free, sugar free & salt free ...TOFU😑
-
C
I am gutted that Theo James has left. I guess he must have put them on the spot; asked for pay rise perhaps?
-
C
The show was cancelled and took over a year to renew - he got other offers from HBO. Also he said he liked the ending. He read the storyline pitch from the new writer but he turned it down.
1
-
-
R
I'd say Theo James pulled a Mr. Pamuk in Sandition, in keeping with his heretofore Masterpiece Theater MO -- draw in fans with his sexy style only to have the character die.
Not to worry, I am still all in. Miss Heyward is the complete Austenian package. I look forward to her journey.
1 1
-
B
They absolutely made the right choice not to recast and to move on. I’m sad Theo James did not come back but this was truly the best way to handle it.
-
B
The new character Alexander Colbourn has a sort of Mr. Darcy feel. I like it. Maybe this new season mirrors Jane Austen. She also did not marry.
-
P
I just rewatched Season 1 Episode 1. We talk of the chemistry between Charlotte and Sidney, but he was a total jerk to her at that first ball they attended, had her in tears. So let’s give these new suitors a chance and see where it takes us.
1 1
-
O
I even wanted to write to the writers of Sanditon and give them my opinion
-
O
What new series is Theo James in?
-
B
The Time Traveler's Wife (based on the book and the movie) on Netflix, and possibly the 2nd season of The White Lotus on HBO/Max.
1
-
-
O
I was so surprised and disappointed they killed off Sidney. He and Charlotte were the biggest reasons I tuned in. The show is going into a completely different direction. I think I’ll lose interest.
3 3
-
O
I am not happy about the decision that Theo as Sidney was not returning. It does ruin Season 2 for me as I was looking forward to the rekindle of love. I would not want him to be recast either. I don't think I will continue watching Season 2. My interest has left.
2 2
-
P
OMG..I was devastated for poor Charlotte and Sidney's family. I understand that this will bring a new AR to her character and it will be interesting to see how her suited woo her.
-
P
Did they know Theo James would bow out after 1 season? If so why did they cast him? If they did know that was a bad casting and should not let him out of contract.
-
B
He only signed up for one season in 2019. The show didn't have a guaranteed second season, it was cancelled. It took nearly a year to find funding to renew it. He was not under any obligation to return - they pitched him a storyline for season 2 and 3 but he turned it down. He had other roles lined up too, I guess.
1
-
B
Yup, he's doing The Time Traveler's Wife with Rose Leslie on Netflix and I think I read he's going to be on the 2nd season of The White Lotus? So his plate was full when time to film finally came. I think the majority of fans knew he wasn't returning to the show, when they announced we'd have 2 more seasons of Sanditon, so the shock of his not being there is kind of surprising to me.
-
-
-
T
It was handled well, and it would have been jarring, to say the least, to have someone else step into the role. Charlotte now can move on and, although she swears she will not, I think she will.............
1 1
-
C
This was the fitting end for an actor whose ego was bigger than the role.
3 3
-
C
I will continue to watch we can see how she remembers Sidney and is trying to move on in her own way the little parts. Her remembering keeps him alive. I will keep watching.
1 1
-
C
Season 1 ending was tragic enough but to wait with great anticipation for Season 2 to see what unfolds was a total disappointment-
The whole flavor and tempo of the new season is so unlike the first-
New characters are very bland-no charisma-definitely not handsome none of them stand out or worthy of Charlotte’s love and time—Nothing from the first new episode holds my interest-Adam Parker is the only fun-lively character left—
May just get the DVD and finish the remaining 4 episodes of Season 2 and be done—When you kill off one of the main characters—who made the “show”—what’s left—there’s no glue holding the series together?? No hope?? No fun!!
4 4
-
O
They should have recast, it does not change the integrity at all of the series. Jane Austen would have found a way to reunite Sidney and Charlotte despite the impediment of his marriage to someone else. That is AUTHENTIC Jane Austen. Actors can be interchangable and in a middle finger to Theo James and his decision as to how the story should end a recast would have been CLASSIC!
5 5
-
B
They should have recast the character of Sidney. Feels like a whole waste of Season 1. I don’t want to watch now.
4 4
-
G
You lost it with the liberal comment
1
-
P
I think we all should get over seeing Sydney he's gone, I'm hoping that they let the the foreman come back let her know his feelings for her and that he has made a success of himself I think they would make a nice looking couple.
1
-
O
Theo James wanted to leave? He expressedly said he wasn't interested in continuing Sidney's story in Sanditon? Amen. The writers have done their best with what they had.
Honestly, I'm enjoying season two so much more than season 1, and I was fond of Charlotte and Sidney's love story! But now I'm moving on, I truly appreciate all the new additions and I'm grateful to all the returning cast.
1
-
R
Frankly, I am very disappointed that Sidney's character is dead. I kept hoping it was a ruse and he would be returning eventually some how. I don't feel the same way about watching the show now. There was such a build-up in Sidney's and Charlotte's relationship, then with Covid 19 absence from the screen, I anxiously awaited the return. I think Tom needs to grow some, and am totally turn off by the Colonel, and I can't see how Charlotte is falling for this new guy. He hasn't the same draw that Sidney had. I'm not impressed with the casting. It's becoming a bit boring week after week with those soldiers and the bickering over the ladies. l am losing interest in the story. Now World On Fire is a series I would love to see come back. That is a nailbiter for sure, and the characters are real. Not this petty nonsense of balls, and parties to find a suitable partner.
1
-
G
Why couldn't they convince Theo James to stay? Maybe he can come back and there be a huge mistake regarding his characters death? Totally disappointed why he didn't come bacl.
1
-
R
I agree. The creators should have searched for a replacement with the same charisma of Theo James, everyone can be replaced. Killing him off was lazy and short-sided. Maybe getting better writers would have been a better choice.
1 2
-
O
I loved episodes 1 & 2! (Thanks to PBS Passport for making episodes available a week early!) So far, of the newbies my favorites are Fraser, Alison, and Miss Hankins. Lockhart is very entertaining; Lennox seems very gallant; and even with his brusqueness, Colbourne is still much nicer than Sidney was for most of season one, but I'm reserving my judgments on them for a few more episodes - I've got to see if their motivations are pure. As for Sidney...Theo James decided not to return. He's moved on. I have too. I can't wait to see what the rest of seasons 2 and 3 have in store!
2 3
-
O
If theo James sees these reviews maybe he will reconsider coming back. It is the only way I will be satisfied.!!!! Please Theo and producers think of your loyal fans. Bring him back. Come on Theo, it would not required that much time in your life to come back.
1 2
-
P
They would need to seriously improve the scripting and the plot in order for him to come back and make his story arc so appealing to him that he couldn't resist it. I think Andrew Davies would need to write it, not Justin Young.
2 1
-
C
That, I imagine, was a key factor. Also it's not even on mainstream TV in the UK.
-
-
-
M
I was very confused during the first few minutes of Season 2. I did not remember all of the characters due to the length of time since Season 1 ended. Seeing a coffin being carried through what looked like a sugar cane field made no sense even when the name on the coffin was quickly shown to the audience. I have lost some of my interest in the series at this point. I will continue to watch and hope that the characters can bring the story back to life. The audience needs more in-depth information about what is happening in each scene rather than relying on people remembering everything that happened in Season 1.
1 2
-
G
So Happy to have 2 more seasons to Watch! 🎊🎊🎊
1 2
-
R
Disappointed without Sydney
2 3
-
G
I really enjoyed this show so much. So happy it is back on my screen even without Theo James. I’m glad for the new storylines!
3 4
-
R
A terrible decision and what a disappointment at the beginning of Season 2. It is not half as interesting now.
3 4
-
P
I am sad. I planned to start watching the series because of Theo James. Guess I won't be watching it.
2 3
-
G
Should have recast and gone on with original storyline .... killing off exiting characters not always the best choice. A recast would have been far more acceptable to viewers. If characters leave how many do u extract from storyline.
3 4
-
G
Should have recast the character, bad secision
1 3
-
G
I was hoping Sidney would reappear at the end of season 3
if the pep woild
1 3
-
O
I was recently discussing with a friend how so many actors in British TV disappear easily and are either replaced or written off shows. This does not happen in the US-most actors hang in with a show all the way through. It is frustrating to have favorite characters leave.
The loss of Sidney will be tough to grapple with, even though I did not feel that he and Charlotte made a particularly believable couple. I will watch the first episode or two of the second season and see if I can adjust.
1 3
-
B
Theo only signed up for one season in the first place. The show was cancelled and took over a year to renew. The backers changed, the head writer changed - you can't really blame him for taking other opportunities, especially during 2020 when everything was so uncertain.
3
-