Ask Matt: ‘Emergence,’ ‘Evil,’ ‘Jeopardy,’ ‘Stumptown’ & More
Welcome to the Q&A with TV critic (also known to some TV fans as their “TV therapist”) Matt Roush, who’ll try to address whatever you love, loathe, are confused or frustrated or thrilled by in today’s vast TV landscape.
One caution: This is a spoiler-free zone, so we won’t be addressing upcoming storylines here unless it’s already common knowledge. Please send your questions and comments to [email protected] (or use the form at the end of the column) and follow me on Twitter. Look for Ask Matt columns on most Tuesdays and Fridays.
The Answers Aren’t the Point of Emergence
Question: ABC’s Emergence is by far my pick for the fall’s best new network drama. But at 55 years of age and with at least a couple of decades of watching these sorts of shows, I do not really care about the resolution. I just want to enjoy the plot and characters. Whatever the final “answer” the writers come up with will almost certainly disappoint! (Aliens? Evil scientists? Mutant human beings? Who cares?) So they just need to keep up the quality of storytelling for a couple of seasons and I’m good! — Mike
Matt Roush: Good point, and this expresses my initial reservation about the show as well. We’ve been burned so many times by shows that string out a mystery for far too long, either inevitably disappointing us with a trite conclusion or (worst case) being yanked off the air before even getting there. With the terrific Allison Tolman (as sheriff Jo) leading a strong cast through the muddle over the plane crash and what makes little Piper tick, there’s plenty here to sustain a series if it doesn’t get too bogged down in conspiracies and exposition and the like. It seems like they’re moving pretty quickly to get to the origin of Piper, especially with the introduction this week of Terry O’Quinn‘s character, so maybe you’ll get your wish.
What’s in an Evil Name?
Question: I am giving Evil a chance because 1) your review was encouraging; 2) CBS has created some great dramas when it goes beyond the procedural model (The Good Wife, Person of Interest); and 3) I’ll watch anything with Michael Emerson. That being said, what moron came up with the title of the show? The show plays like a cross between The X-Files and a panel discussion on EWTN, and I can see some interesting possibilities. But that title! What message is that trying to send? – Rick
Matt Roush: I remember people taking issue with the title of The Good Wife as well (also from Robert and Michelle King), but they eventually got used to it. This is such an intriguing series, with no two episodes quite the same — which is a good thing — and the way I look at it is the title is taking a long view of the nature of evil in its many manifestations: not just demonic, but also in society at large, in social media — or, as we saw this week, even in a hacked digital assistant. (Some fun and playful ambiguity in that non-resolution.) The series is clearly designed to generate debate between matters of faith and the supernatural and science and pathology, with some creepy night terrors and drug-enhanced visions thrown in for good measure. I feel like I’m still in the process of figuring out just what Evil is, and the fact that it can’t be pigeonholed or the title easily explained is a plus in my book. (Alternate titles: God Unfriended Us? The Why Files?)
Acknowledging the Long History of Jeopardy!
Question: I’m a big Jeopardy! fan, and certainly a fan of Alex Trebek, but why do they always seem to forget that there was a Jeopardy! before Alex Trebek? It’s been around a lot longer than 36 years, with Art Fleming the excellent quizmaster before Alex Trebek. – Barbara
Matt Roush: This is true, though in my faithful watching of Jeopardy! over the years, I have often heard Alex and the contestants (especially those with a family history of appearing on the show) acknowledging the great Art Fleming and the previous versions. There wouldn’t be a Jeopardy! without it. But as memorable as the daytime version was (and to a lesser degree the earlier syndicated spinoffs), the current iteration is the one that will go down in the history books for its longevity and sustained excellence. And here’s to Alex Trebek for staying in the game for as long as he feels capable. We wish him all the best.
More Stumptown Love
Question: I just read your review of ABC’s Stumptown and I wanted to say thank you! I especially loved your line, “It’s not important TV but it’s important for TV” because you are correct that it’s enjoyable and doesn’t feel at all like something we’ve seen before. I’ve been getting a little tired of the “been there, seen that” feeling with some procedurals. I had only seen Cobie Smulders as Agent Hill in the Marvel-verse, so I am really happy she gets a chance to shine on her own and carry a show. — Gwen
Matt Roush: Thanks for that feedback. I’m always intrigued which new shows will spark the most interest in my mailbag — hardly a scientific measurement, but it does reflect a certain degree of engagement — and by that metric, Stumptown is this season’s winner so far.
Giving Credit(s) Where It’s Due
Question: Too bad that there is not an Emmy category for opening credits. I think that AMC’s Lodge 49 is not only a charmingly quirky show, but their opening credits artwork and music knock it out of the park. This week’s mariachi rendition of the theme song was absolutely perfect. Kudos to everyone associated with the show. It is a gem! — LAF
Matt Roush: Actually, there is an Emmy category for this. (There’s a category for just about everything, except distinguishing broadcast from cable/streaming shows, to some people’s chagrin.) It’s called Outstanding Main Title Design, and this year it went to Game of Thrones (a second win for redesigned titles). There’s also a category for Main Title Theme Music (this year’s went, quite appropriately, to HBO’s Succession.) I agree the Lodge 49 title sequence is a good one, and so is that of its AMC companion piece, The Terror: Infamy (both end their seasons on Monday). Everything about Lodge 49 is so wildly original and offbeat it feels like a small miracle.
You Break It, We Don’t Buy It!
Question: I find it unbelievable when a character in a TV show breaks a glass against a wall in their own place or throws their cell phone and breaks it or really trashes their own place. It makes no sense in that they would then have to clean up the mess. I would never consider doing that in my own house, and some of the things they break are very expensive to replace. Especially in a drama. can they keep it real? Your thoughts? — Bob in Portland
Matt Roush: So many TV pet peeves, and this is absolutely one of them. I’ll take it a step further. Whenever I see someone get bad news in their office (work or home), I count to three in hopes they won’t swipe everything off the top of their desk in a fit of messy rage. I am almost always disappointed in that regard. Who are these people? It would be more realistic if they slammed their palms on the desk (as I have done) in an expression of pique and then cried “OW!” (as I have done) and moved on (as I have done). But that probably wouldn’t make “good TV.”
That’s all for now. Thanks as always for reading, and remember that I can’t do this without your participation, so please keep sending questions and comments about TV to [email protected] or shoot me a line on Twitter (@TVGMMattRoush), and you can also submit questions via the handy form below. Please include a first name with your question.
Conversation18 Comments
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Comments are closed on this story.
-
O
I'm sorry but I've tried three episodes of Stumptown and while Cobie Smoulders and Michael Ealy are great actors and do a fine job with what they're given. The show is a bit too formulaic and familiar to really stand out to me. I think I'm gonna let it build up on the DVR and watch it whenever I feel like it to see if it gets more interesting and compelling. To Rick, I'm sorry Person of Interest lost all quality and relevance when they horribly killed off Carter and threw in Shaw who was as interesting and complex as watching paint dry.
2
-
G
My favorite new shows this season are Prodigal Son, Evil, Emergence and Stumptown in that order (so far).
Stumptown is the most disposable of those but I find it entertaining enough to watch every week.
1
-
O
To me they just need the time to develop things, make the supporting cast more interesting. The biggest issue is that the main character seems like the stereotypical female pi. Super masculine, basically a guy etc. You rarely see a feminine female detective tbh besides the iconic Jessica Fletcher. I hope they manage to flesh Dex out and give her actual personality.
1
-
P
Agree - tried it, just can't get into it.
2
-
-
G
I find the lead character in Stumptown to be unlikeable. And if I don’t like the lead, I don’t want to watch the show.
1
-
G
I feel like On Becoming a God in Central Florida should at least be nominated for Outstanding Main Title Design, hopefully winning it in the end.
Excellent intro sequence.
1
-
O
First Off - this webiste has become so unbearable to navigate, I can barely manage to read an article any more, let alone actually COMMENT on one! First the site bogs down, and then, my entire PC! But i better get my comment in b4 it crashes altogether?!
Stumptown is my Fav of all the New Shows I've tried, so please People, give it more time?! It entertains me, is fun, and keeps moving. But it also doesn't leave me so stressed that i can't fall asleep easily, later. Meaning, i have quit on the shows that are so sinister (The Haves and Have Nots comes to mind) that i still feel unnerved by the time i try to fall asleep. Its just real nice escapism 4 me, and that's what i watch TV for, afterall!!
Oh, so ya gotta know, after what all i just went thru to even post this....
1
-
R
If you haven't already, get a pop-up blocker. Keep your ad-blockers and other stuff updated. It makes a world of difference. Also, see if your browser is one of the good ones. I like Chrome. Firefox isn't bad either, as far as I know.
-
O
Thank You Jena! and i do use Chrome, and i gotta go as i'm crashing again....
-
O
I am also having trouble with the site crashing when I try to comment. It has happened three times now.
-
O
Tonite, i clicked on this link in a totally separate Window, and found much better success... so we'll see ....
-
-
G
So happy to hear! Enjoy!
-
O
At your suggestion... i decided to try Prodigal Son and now i have to go back and watch missed Eps on OD... ie, i like it, so thank you!
-
O
I really enjoy Stumptown, I don't know if my pleasure will last, but I am happy now. I really like Emergence a lot, it shows a lot of promise, the actors are good, the story seems to be moving quickly, especially with the big reveal in episode 3. Terry O'Quinn is a great addition! Emergence is my favorite so far.
I also like Bluff City, Evil is interesting, especially with Michael Emerson as a satanic like character, I like it, Prodigal Son is fun, but I wonder if it has legs, it could end up getting on my nerves.
-
O
I wouldn't say I disliked her more like was mildly amused. She needs more color to her. She's too familiar to Jessica Jones for me.
-
P
We certainly do wish Alex Trebek well but for a long time now I have thought it is time for Mo Rocca to take over.
-
G
Lavar Burton would be far superior to Mo Rocca.
1
-
P
Another excellent choice.
-