Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping Suspect Made ‘Rookie’ Error, Says Expert
What To Know
- A private investigator revealed that the suspect in Nancy Guthrie’s kidnapping made a “rookie” mistake.
- The released surveillance images show a masked individual tampering with the camera and carrying a weapon incorrectly.
As the search for Nancy Guthrie continues, a longtime private investigator has revealed a “rookie” mistake the potential abductor made that led to the release of the doorbell camera surveillance footage.
Private investigator Andy Kay discussed with Page Six how law enforcement likely retrieved the footage, explaining it was due to the suspect’s own error of tampering with the camera.
“The cameras will record to the servers as long as they have internet,” Kay said. “According to Nest, without a subscription, usually they are quickly overwritten by next images. But if the camera is disconnected, there should be nothing to overwrite on the server.”
Nancy, the 84-year-old mother of Today host Savannah Guthrie, was taken from her home on the evening of January 31, according to law enforcement. She was reported missing the following afternoon after friends noticed she did not attend her usual Sunday church service.
On Tuesday (February 10), investigators released new images and video of a masked individual approaching Nancy’s property. In the footage, the suspect is seen tampering with the camera, covering it with flowers ripped from the entranceway, and, ultimately, removing the camera from its holder and disconnecting it.
The disconnecting of the camera is what Kay believes resulted in the police being able to retrieve the footage. Basically, if a person doesn’t have a subscription to the Nest service (which Nancy didn’t), the images will continue to be overwritten with new images. But because the camera was disconnected, the last images, featuring the suspect, were never overwritten and therefore able to be recovered.
Kay also noted the potential kidnapper appeared to have his weapon holstered to their pants incorrectly, which he believes is another sign that the suspect is a “rookie.”
“Over the last eight days, the FBI and Pima County Sheriff’s Department have been working closely with our private sector partners to continue to recover any images or video footage from Nancy Guthrie’s home that may have been lost, corrupted or inaccessible due to a variety of factors — including the removal of recording devices,” authorities said in a statement released alongside the new images and footage.
It continued, “Working with our partners — as of this morning, law enforcement has uncovered these previously inaccessible new images showing an armed individual appearing to have tampered with the camera at Nancy Guthrie’s front door the morning of her disappearance.”
Hours after the footage was released, investigators detained a delivery driver from Rio Rico, a small community 60 miles south of Tucson. The driver was later released without charges and told reporters that he was “innocent” and had never even heard of Nancy or Savannah.
Conversation28 Comments
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Register or sign in to join the conversation.
-
J
yeah he's a "Rookie" thats clowning the entire FBI
20
-
G
Exactly. I see all the so called ex law enforcement folks making fun of this Rookie and his lack of preparation or trying to cover the camera with flowers. It’s possible that’s the impression he wanted to convey. Catch me if you can vibe.
11
-
R
She's probably dead, and the FBI are clowning because they need to keep looking until the body is found.
1
-
-
S
The eyes are from a women not a man
16
-
M
why a women?
2
-
N
The eyes. I agree that those are a woman’s eyes.
4
-
R
Pronouns these days, so confusing!
1
-
D
Pronouns?
-
-
D
That's a man with nice eyes. Dark thick eyelashes. Look at the VP's eyes and lashes. If that was all you saw you'd think he was a woman also.
-
-
-
A
I’m pretty certain you could see a beard..
3
-
R
A woman beard? Tomorrows NYP headlines "Illegal Mexican Transgender Athlete Kidnapper Identified By Sad Woman Eyes"
-
C
Didn't that already win an oscar award?
-
-
R
Beards can be put on and taken off like a ski mask. Smarchen has a good point. I thought something was unusual but couldn't place it until they pointed it out. When I saw the video the other day I also thought there was something strange about the person's gait. Women have wider hips. That might be worth reviewing as well. Perhaps it's her own daughter, pulling a Jussie Smollet stunt.
3
-
-
E
L00ks like eyeliner ar0und the eye
1
-
-
F
Why would you call tampering with the camera a 'rookie' mistake? Allegedly the tampering is what made it stop recording over previous data, but if she had had a subscription to Nest it would not have done that. Is he suppose to have known she didn't have a subscription? Of course he didn't know, that's why he did that. Nothing to do with being a rookie.
9
-
H
I have a different theory. I believe Nancy was murdered in her home during the 41 minute time lapse on the night of her disappearance.
The intruder's back pack was 'very full' and maybe contained a tarp or plastic to wrap her in. The blood found on the porch was just 'drips' that escaped the plastic wrap.
This is a non-kidnapping like we saw in the case of JonBenet Ramsey; a hoax, a cover-up.
No kidnapper is going to sit around and entertain Nancy for 12 days without trying to arrange for
payment of the ransom and transfer so they can get rid of her as quickly as possible.
My guess is a family member tired of waiting for their inheritance, if not one of her kids then a spouse.
To the family it doesn't matter if they get the money from a ransom payment or just from her estate when she turns up deceased.
I think the investigators should take cadaver dogs along on their searches. She's out there.
5
-
M
So whomever will not show proof of life. She is probably dead. What is the motive?
4
-
G
To me it seems personal, against Savannah, or her sister. Like a personal grudge and wanting to inflict emotional pain on the family. He is just too non hurried and casual in his moments seen on camera. As if he doesn’t care at all. That’s what scares me, a person with nothing to lose.
5
-
G
Or it's a test run. For something on a larger scale. None of us know who did this, his vocation etc. Rarely, people who get away with crime are on the fringes of society. See: Epstein and his unnamed multiple uncharged accomplices
-
-
C
If she died, maybe it was when she was being transported, but he/she/they continued with the ransom plot anyway.
Remember she was in the really poor health. I'm not sure why someone in such poor health was living alone.
-
-
G
Crazy, but do the lashes and eye shape kind of look more female?
3
-
A
Well look whos ahead of the FBI. He flies his girlfriend on a government jet.
3
-
V
Everyone says he, assuming the perpetrator is male. How about a woman?
2
-
E
I BELEIVE IS NEEDED TO ANALYZE THE EYES.
1
-
W
Footage looks like two different people. One is wearing a camouflage jacket with full front zipper and other wearing a solid color jacket with a half zipper and has a backpack. Surely I’m not the only one who’s noticed this??
1
-
K
I think the guy is wearing glasses under the mask, because that's not a pupil shine, that's much bigger! What's with the mouth shine, does he have a grill?
-
E
Totally agree I look up the face up close ,yes i beleive that is a women hidding under the hoodie, the eyes speak for itself.
-
1
People eat fake ice cream evidence too
Watchlist Easy access to only the shows you care about — all in one simple place
Alerts Only important notifications — when a show is returning, when it becomes available to stream, and more.
Special Offers Exclusive products we release related to your favorite shows and streaming services