Hallmark Star Tyler Hynes Weighs In on ‘It Was Always You’ Sequel Possibility

For many Hallmark fans, It Was Always You with Tyler Hynes and Erin Krakow is among their favorite Hallmark movies. The 2021 film chronicles Elizabeth’s (Krakow) journey in figuring out who and what she truly wants out of life. When her fiancé’s free-spirited brother, David (Hynes), returns home, he steps right into the path Elizabeth is on.

Ultimately, Elizabeth’s heart lies with David, not her uptight fiancé, George (Giles Panton). Seriously, who didn’t swoon over David’s declaration of love: “For me, it’s always been you. I loved you yesterday. I love you today. I’ll love you tomorrow.” So, could we get a glimpse of David and Elizabeth’s tomorrow in a sequel? Swooon went straight to Tyler Hynes for the answer.