Ask Matt: Shows That Deserved a Second Chance (and in Many Cases, a Second Season)

Adam Baldwin, Alan Tudyk, Nathan Fillion, and Gina Torres of 'Firefly'
20th Century Fox Film/Courtesy: Everett Collection

Welcome to the Q&A with TV critic — also known to some TV fans as their “TV therapist” — Matt Roush, who’ll try to address whatever you love, loathe, are confused or frustrated or thrilled by in today’s vast TV landscape. (We know background music is too loud, it’s the most frequent complaint, but there’s always closed-captioning. Check out this story for more tips.) 

One caution: This is a spoiler-free zone, so we won’t be addressing upcoming storylines here unless it’s already common knowledge. Please send your questions and comments to [email protected]. Look for Ask Matt columns on most Tuesdays.

Why Not Reboot Shows That Were Axed Too Soon?

Question: I have a suggestion for all the TV producers digging around in the vast television graveyard, looking for ideas. Instead of exhuming and trying to revive, reboot, or clone series that were originally successful — the most recent announcements include Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Malcolm in the Middle, and Scrubs — why not take another look at series that were unceremoniously axed after just one season, but are now considered by many to have been “canceled too soon” and ahead of their time?

If you’re intrigued by this idea, here are a few suggestions:

  • In 1995, the show VR-5 starred Lori Singer as a computer hacker who discovers she has the ability to psychically connect with people in virtual reality. The show co-starred Anthony Head pre-Buffy and David McCallum pre-NCIS and abruptly ended with a giant cliffhanger.
  • Other one season ‘myth-tery’ series that tried and failed to ride the wave of The X-Files‘ success were The Visitor, Invasion, Point Pleasant, Threshold, Surface (whose subtext of ecological disaster is more relevant than ever) and X-Files creator Chris Carter‘s own failed follow-up, Harsh Realm, another “virtual reality” series, this time featuring soldiers. Another futuristic series way ahead of its time (but edging closer to reality) was Dollhouse, wherein volunteers had their memories wiped clean (shades of Severance) and their brains implanted with other personalities.
  • And I’d like to see CSI: Cyber given another shot. The original series ran during the Internet and social media’s early “honeymoon period” and I think the show’s earnest attempt to educate viewers about the web’s Dark Side (themes included hacking people’s devices, identity theft and cyber blackmail) frightened people away from watching, yet now are commonplace storylines. A series that specifically focuses on cybercrimes could now be a Hit.

I’m sure you and your readers can identify many other “one-season wonders” that deserve a second chance. What do you think? — Maurice

Matt Roush: I think your timing was excellent, because this dovetails with a recent column in which I was asked to pick one show that was canceled too soon that I’d love to see revived. I chose Pushing Daisies, but it was a tough call, and I asked readers to submit their own choices. Many of their responses follow (we’ll get back to regular questions and answers after the holiday weekend), with occasional comments from yours truly. Quite a few sent in lists of shows, and in some cases, I asked them to pick just one favorite. It’s harder than it looks. But what memories these shows bring back! And as fun as this trip down memory lane can be, the chances of most of these shows getting a second life is slim to none.

The Shows We Miss the Most

Comment: In the discussion of shows canceled way too soon, the answer is Firefly, and always Firefly. Not only canceled but mishandled in every way possible to prevent its success. I rewatch it annually (in the proper order!) and it is a gem. Every character fully formed from the beginning. It’s a shame we didn’t get more of it, but at least we got the movie Serenity to give us some closure. — Bill A, San Antonio, Texas

Matt Roush: This was a very popular choice, and it’s especially painful when considering a show with so much promise where the network had no idea how to handle it.

Comment: There are three shows that I still miss and wish had longer runs. Now and Again is the one I miss the most. It had me from the first episode. Perhaps the premise wasn’t to everyone’s liking, but I found the story different and interesting, and the cast was engaging. Homefront on ABC was a warm story of diverse families in the Midwest, facing life after WWII, with the great Kyle Chandler among its stars. Then there’s Freaks and Geeks, often mentioned as canceled too soon. What a great cast, most of whom went on to have much success. The episodes were so relatable. We may not have known someone like every character on the show, but we certainly knew, or perhaps even were, one of them. — Adrienne, Vernon Township, N.J.

Matt Roush: All great choices, and Freaks and Geeks probably deserves to be in the Hall of Fame for this topic. But oh how I loved Homefront.

Comment: The TV show that came to mind right away was Soap. I think it was one of the funniest shows of all time. It made me laugh out loud even when I was by myself. In more recent times, The Kids Are Alright and So Help Me Todd were canceled too soon. (P.S. Like you, I loved Knots Landing, and even though it ran for 14 years, I was sorry to see it canceled. But I agree that this should not be revived as it would dilute the original.) — Deborah B, Bayside, N.Y.

Matt Roush: Soap, in every way a groundbreaking series, actually had a decent four-season run (1977-81). But no question that The Kids Are Alright deserved a second year — I’m rarely shocked anymore by cancellations, and that one took me by surprise. And it’s no surprise that CBS’s cancellation of So Help Me Todd last season is still an open wound for many and was mentioned in quite a few responses.

Comment: My interest runs toward science fiction and there are many shows of that genre that got canceled early in their run. Star Trek: Enterprise was the only show besides the original series not to make it to seven years and I would love to see it brought back, mostly to rewrite that God-awful series finale they had. Terra Nova is another show I would love to see brought back. This was the series that had an overpopulated Earth sending residents back in time to live during the prehistoric era, while still keeping their current technology. There was an interesting cliffhanger that was left unresolved. Fortunately, there is a DVD set that I bought. (It’s my top pick.)

I would also love to see the revival of two shows that were also revived from previous versions, V and Dark Shadows. I loved the originals and enjoyed the new versions. While the new Dark Shadows only lasted one season, ABC did bring back V for one more season, but again, they left us hanging with the final episode. And finally, I would love to see two old Irwin Allen shows come back, The Time Tunnel and Land of the Giants. I thought both had interesting concepts and would enjoy seeing a satisfactory finale for both series. — Rob R.

Comment: The following canceled shows come to mind:

1) Party of Five (the reboot): I can’t recall how I heard about the show-maybe it was from you. I never saw the original version but I enjoyed the writing/acting and the story lines for the reboot. The show aired during the pandemic, and it appears it was quietly canceled afterwards.

2) Zoey’s Extraordinary Playlist: The first season was great, but the second season experienced a sophomore slump. At least the show got a Roku Channel movie to wrap up storylines.

3) So Help Me Todd (my top pick): Thursday nights aren’t the same without Todd. The WGA/SAG strikes probably didn’t help the show’s fortunes. Maybe one day, whoever owns the rights to Todd will show some mercy to fans and produce a Todd cartoon show like Star Trek: Lower Decks. — Stanley A

Matt Roush: I would watch an animated So Help Me Todd! Or any version.

Comment: The one show I wish could be revived, and still could be, is Showtime’s Web Therapy. (Matt: It ran four seasons, but they were short and always flew under the radar, so I’ll accept it.) The other, but which cannot be revived in the same way, is the 1960s Batman! I’ve always loved that show, but it could not be the same without Adam West and without a youthful Burt Ward. Still, a Batman-type series with a sort of What We Do in the Shadows sensibility could be awesome! — D.P.

Comment: I nominate ABC’s Forever (one season) which starred Ioan Gruffudd and Alana de la Garza. It had an interesting “hook” (the main character works to solve crimes while trying to uncover the mystery of his immortality). We liked the chemistry between the two main characters, in addition to the intriguing immortality element. — Gwen

Comment: Of course, the first show that jumped to my mind was Firefly, probably Joss Whedon‘s best work (I do like Buffy, but Firefly had such a great cast and world). However, I will show my age here, I would also like to bring up a little gem called When Things Were Rotten. Terrific cast, funny writing (Mel Brooks, need I say more?), yet it got only 13 episodes. — Karen W.

Matt Roush: Mel Brooks’ Robin Hood parody aired in 1975, when things were much tougher for marginal shows to stay on the air when only three networks ruled the airwaves. Many years later, Brooks revisited the premise in his 1993 feature film Robin Hood: Men in Tights.

Comment: So glad you asked for input on too-soon-gone shows! I really enjoyed The Company You Keep, never saw This Is Us so became a new fan of Milo Ventimiglia. I liked the entire cast and the story arcs were fresh. The two core families were intriguing! — Lil W.

Comment: Here is my short list of broadcast shows that were canceled too soon. I didn’t include Pushing Daisies, since you already covered that one (but I still miss it). The “oh-so obvious but still so true!” answer: Firefly (Fox); the “was there ever any hope for this show to begin with?” answer: Pitch (Fox); the “anti-sentimental family sitcom that left a gaping hole in my heart” answer: The Kids are Alright (ABC); the “I saw it coming … but invested anyway” answer: Alaska Daily (ABC); the “I took the leap and Fox let me down … again!” answer: The Big Leap (Fox).

If we can go beyond broadcast, I would add these: The “I’m too unsurprised to talk about it” answer: Schmigadoon! (Apple TV+); the “I’m too ticked off to talk about it” answer: Warrior Nun (Netflix); the “I’m too depressed to talk about it” answer: My Lady Jane (Prime Video).

May I suggest we make a list of TV shows that went way too long? The problem with that list is that it would be … way too long. — Kelly

Matt Roush: Not such a short list, but a very entertaining one. And while I do open this column to many gripes about TV, complaining about a show’s staying power would put me in a negative head space I’m just not willing to risk these days. And here’s an even longer list!

Comment: My answer to your question of what shows that were canceled too soon that I’d love to have continued: Freaks and Geeks, I’m sure this will be a popular answer. (Matt: It was.)  HBO’s Rome: the writing, the cast, everything was superb. NBC’s The Pretender. Is four years too long to qualify? (Matt: Yes.) All I know is the show was great, and Miss Parker is possibly the most complex, dynamic character in history of TV, The A story main antagonist, and the B story sympathetic protagonist. Probably one of the last shows to air Saturday night. Also from NBC: Life. Two seasons of this (2007-09) was not enough. The dynamic between Damian Lewis and Sarah Shahi made this a very enjoyable, different type of procedural. Jay Leno doing 10 pm killed this, and I get angry just writing that. (Matt: I get angry reading it.)

Also: Showtime’s It’s Garry Shandling’s Show: Just brilliant. (Matt: True enough, but it also ran four seasons.) The CW’s The L.A. Complex: The name alone is genius and had some great stories. MTV’s I Just Want My Pants Back.Was very funny and captured the platonic best friends’ relationship perfectly. NBC’s Awake. It was such a cool premise, I’d love to see how it would have grown. Dark Justice and Sweating Bullets (Tropical Heat), two great “Crimetime after Primetime” shows on CBS. A real bummer they couldn’t find another a home like Silk Stalkings did after Letterman took the late-night slot. If you don’t know, look up how insanely huge Sweating Bullets is in Serbia. Found that out in line at Disneyland one day! (Matt: Who knew?)

UPN’s Nowhere Man: This show was so good. I need to know what happens. It’s not often Bruce Greenwood plays a good guy. (Matt: The one UPN show I remember getting hooked on, besides the first seasons of Veronica Mars during the network’s final gasp.) Fox’s VR5. This was very cool. NBC’s Sister Kate. This was a very good family comedy with some very original stories woven in. Fox’s Dark Angel. This would also require erasing the ridiculous second season’s “Beauty and the Beast” storyline from existence and starting over after the fantastic first season. Fox’s Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles. This show was great, the only thing after T2 in the franchise that is worth a damn, and it left on such a great cliffhanger to lead into the 3rd season. So so soooo good. HBO’s Hello Ladies. Maybe I’m just not in tune with what’s funny, because this show cracked me up. Stephen Merchant was fabulous. Prime Video’s Red Oaks. I’m pretty sure when this show was pitched, they held up a picture of me and said I am the target audience. NBC’s Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip. Yes, I know too much of it was too “inside Hollywood” lingo, but outside of that, it was still top-notch storytelling with some great performances. Hulu’s Reboot. This one is still too fresh a wound, and I keep hoping wiser minds prevail.

Okay, that’s all off the top of my head. I’m sure I could think of 50 more, but I’ve wasted enough of your time as is. — Rob

Matt Roush: I asked Rob to pick just one, and after his head stopped exploding, he went with Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles.

That’s all for now. We can’t do this without your participation, so please keep sending questions and comments about TV to [email protected]. (Please include a first name with your question.)




Conversation35 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Comments are closed on this story.

  1. O

    OliveGrapes

    Let’s hear it for The WB’s Jack & Bobby (2004), featuring Logan Lerman, Matt Long, John Slattery and a never-better Christine Lahti.

    6

    1. O

      OliveTooth

      Oh, I forgot about that show! I was so disappointed when it didn't get a season two.

      4

      1. O

        OliveGrapes

        Same. I’m still not over it!

        2

  2. A

    Arben70

    Forever, absolutely yes. I'd go for Wonderfalls in addition to Pushing Daisies; Bryan Fuller always does interesting stuff. Keen Eddie and Karen Sisco come to mind — I'm pretty sure I mentioned them in comments to the column that spurred this one — as does Boomtown.

    6

  3. A

    Antonio Montealegre

    Once again, my pick for "Cancelled Too Soon" is the unmentioned "My So-Called Life" which, unlike "Beverly Hills, 90210" and "Saved By the Bell" didn't make teen life fun and inspiring but realistic and, perhaps to its detriment, maybe a little depressing. Still, it was most relatable to me and I wished it hadn't ended on a cliffhanger. I also miss the two shows that were mentioned: "Homefront"-a post-WWII-set family drama and "Freaks and Geeks" which was a more humorous take on teen life with characters that weren't so glamorous like "90210" or stereotypical like "SBTB".

    4

    1. A

      Arben70

      My So-Called Life was almost painfully good.

      2

    2. O

      OliveTooth

      I'm surprised it wasn't mentioned. It was an excellent show and is usually near the top of too-soon cancelled TV show lists.

      2

  4. O

    OliveTooth

    This was a great "Ask Matt" column -- loads of fun! Thanks for giving us a all a chance to share our most-missed, short-lived series!

    4 1

  5. G

    GoldCar

    Wow. A lot to unpack in this article. Other than agreeing that SO HELP ME TODD was cruelly cancelled waaaaay too soon, I want to totally agree about Star Trek: Enterprise. A major, major, MAJOR storyline was so ludicrous and ridiculous that it needs to somehow be retracted or glossed over. (Actually it could be part of the reason for its cancellation.) I also agree that CIS Cyber probably terrified the stereotypical CBS viewer back in the day: too technical and yes, too scary to contemplate-- and people just didn't understand the tech stuff. But again, the topics are so commonplace and familiar today that it would probably get a better reception.

    3

  6. T

    TUF

    A few shows I can think of that definitely ended too soon:

    Whiskey Cavalier (ABC)

    Kevin Probably Saves the World (ABC)

    Rise (NBC)

    The Kids are Alright (ABC)

    Relic Hunter (the Before The CW became The CW days)

    Recovery Road (Freeform, alongside basically 98% of shows that Freeform made that they never gave real endings to)

    Cedar Cove (Hallmark)

    3

  7. M

    Monique

    One show I'm surprised that hasn't been mentioned is the wickedly funny Galevant. I guess we were lucky to get two seasons of this very under rated musical comedy, but I would have loved to have seen more.

    2

  8. B

    BlueChefHat

    Don’t know why my original post was deleted. Let’s see if I can remember the shows I listed.

    Big Sky -ABC

    Forever-ABC

    V - ABC

    Pan Am-ABC

    Whiskey Cavalier -ABC

    Not Dead Yet-ABC

    B Positive-CBS

    Lincoln Rhyme -Hunt for The Bone Collector-NBC

    Terminator -Sarah Connor Chronicles -FOX

    Exorcist -FOX

    Honorable mentions:

    The Passage-FOX

    Marvel ‘s Agent Carter-ABC

    2

    1. M

      Monique

      FYI your original comment is still showing in my feed, so it wasn't deleted.

      1

  9. G

    Gavin Sims

    "stupid", "boring", these are just your opinions which in my opinion are stupid and wrong. It's a bit of fun, no need to get so triggered.

    1

  10. B

    BlueBox

    I loved both Keen Eddie and Karen Sisco!

    1

  11. G

    GoldFlame

    The political satire BrainDead was too hot to handle I guess, but should still be going strong! Tony Shalhoub was wonderful in it.

    1

  12. O

    OrangeFries

    It's ridiculous that we are getting Suits LA when what we clearly should have had is a second (at minimum) season of the criminally underrated spinoff Pearson starring the great Gina Torres.

  13. T

    TigerNightmare

    I'll throw in a few titles I haven't seen anyone else mention yet. The Knights of Prosperity, where a bunch of misfits ineptly try to rob Mick Jagger. Eli Stone, a show where a lawyer keeps having visions of George Michael and other things. The Jeremy Piven version of Cupid, although I know that actor shouldn't be inflicted upon anyone and I didn't for whatever reason vibe with what I saw of the Bobby Cannavale version. John Doe, where an amnesiac uses his powers of possessing all human knowledge to solve crimes while searching for the truth about his past. The Nevers, which was buried in the wake of the Joss Whedon scandal, but was still truly fascinating. Finally, there was The Maxx from MTV's Oddities, an incredibly stylized animated story that only covered some of the comic it was based on and never really got a proper ending.

    1. T

      TigerNightmare

      One more! The Middleman!

  14. T

    Teh Landstander

    Relic Hunter was a syndicated show, not specifically The CW. There were a lot of great ones in the 90s.

  15. T

    Teh Landstander

    Surprised to see VR5 suggested more than once, while they've never released it on DVD, Blu-ray or licensed it for streaming.

  16. G

    Gavin Sims

    Space: Above and Beyond

    Profile

    Profit

  17. G

    GreenSushi

    Not even sure it's been officially cancelled, but I loved "Wayne," which started off as a YouTube Original Series. Give me season two!

  18. R

    RedCarrot

    A few from the long-ago memory banks.

    Boomtown - in the traditon of The Wire (which people eventually discovered later) and Homicide (hoping that'll happen now that music rights have been figured out), another in the long line of the best, most complicated police/crime dramas that had a hard time attracting an audience during its original (just one season + 6 episodes) run

    American Gothic - I mean, Gary Cole as a southern sheriff who is also (maybe) the devil. Come on, how great is that? Only airing for two seasons, it was like a current FX series that aired 25 years ahead of its time (and on CBS). Hey, maybe even Cole, Lucas Black and Sarah Paulson could all be available at some point to right a wrong.

    More recent:

    B Positive - they had a TV-star-to-be in Annaleigh Ashford, who could do just about anything, and it was just thrown away.

    The Owl House - something a little different, a Disney animated series with more layers than most live-action network

    shows. It was rushed off the air and the creator had to jam way too into a few extra-long episodes in order to complete the storyline.

    Also:

    Alias - no, it doesn't fit the four-year run paramenters (it ran for five), but it would work so well as a reboot/sequel.

  19. O

    OrangePumpkin

    My choices go farther back.

    NBC had a show called "Shannon's Deal" with Jamey Sheridan and Elizabeth Pena that I thought was one of the Best on TV

    "The Powers That Be" (1992 NBC) with John Forsythe, Holland Taylor and David Hyde Pierce was wickedly funny and

    "Grand" (1990 NBC again) with Pamela Reed and Bonnie Hunt. First season was hysterical, second season was bad.

    1. G

      GoldCar

      Wow, I remember both The Powers That Be, and Grand. (I must have watched them in utero, lolol. )

  20. B

    BlueChefHat

    Big Sky (ABC)

    Whiskey Cavalier (ABC)

    Forever (ABC)

    Pan Am (ABC)

    V (ABC)

    Not Dead Yet (ABC)

    B Positive (CBS)

    Terminator :Sarah Connors Chronicles (FOX)

    Fantasy Island (FOX)

    Lincoln Rhyme: Hunt for the Bone Collector (NBC)

    1. G

      GoldCorn

      Great call on Lincoln Rhyme. I thought its first/only season Bone Collector story was told far better than the movie had been (w/ Denzel Washington and Julia Roberts, no less), but NBC never seemed committed to it as a series. It had so much potential.

      1

      1. R

        RedTurtle

        Not Sure what Movie you're referring to. Denzel & Julia were in The Pelican Brief together. The Bone Collector was Denzel & Angelina Jolie.

  21. G

    GoldCar

    Another note: at least one or two of the series mentioned were not 'cancelled too soon,' and some were not left high and dry on cliffhangers.

    Sometimes a viewer will put a series in this category because it's a favorite of theirs, even though the show had a respectable run.

    1

  22. P

    PurpleBug

    Bringing back shows that were canceled "too soon" is stupid. It's not like these shows were cancelled recently. They've been gone for several years. As for the show Pushing Daisies. I tried to watch that show once and it was very boring. I don't see how anyone could watch that show. I believe it was a half hour show but it seemed more like 2 hours.

    5

    1. A

      Antonio Montealegre

      Actually, it was an hour.

      2

      1. P

        PurpleBug

        Either way the show was extremely boring.

        3

    2. G

      GreenToast

      Oh, it's just a fun pushback against all the unnecessary rebooting and reviving of successful series. None of these shows are actually going to be revived, certainly not as they were at the time they were originally on.

      2

    3. O

      OliveTooth

      No one is saying we expect these shows to come back. It was just a bit of "I wish ..." commiserating within the TV fan community. No harm in that. I find it quite entertaining to see which shows fans miss and compare their lists with mine. Pushing Daisies wasn't your cup of tea, but it certainly was mine.

      4