Matt Roush's 10 Best TV Shows of 2014

Matt Roush

Clockwise from left: Matthias Clamer/FX; Mark Schafer/SHOWTIME; HBO

The critic's take on the year's top television.

2014 Best-Fargo

Matthias Clamer/FX

Fargo

You betcha we loved FX's sensational miniseries, inspired by the iconic film, which triumphantly mined new depths of icy evil amid heartfelt humanism. Noah Hawley's fable gave fabulous star turns to Billy Bob Thornton (a hit man), Martin Freeman (a mousy murderer), and newbie Allison Tolman as a deputy who stole a meek cop's (Colin Hanks) heart. And ours.

2014 Best-The Good Wife

Jeff Neumann/CBS

The Good Wife

In its sixth season, CBS's wonderfully entertaining and engrossing drama of legal, personal, and political morality never stops surprising and shocking us. So much juicy conflict for Alicia (Julianna Margulies): the devastating death of former partner/lover Will Gardner (Josh Charles), a possible jail term for new partner Cary (Matt Czuchry), a turbulent campaign for public office. This show always gets my vote.

2014 Best-Jane The Virgin

Greg Gayne/The CW

Jane the Virgin

If you're a Jane virgin, here's what you're missing: the season's most delightfully outrageous yet sweetly romantic (in every sense of the word) comedy. The CW hits the critical big time with this exuberant spin on the telenovela, in which every lurid and wacky twist is made credible by the genuine warmth of Gina Rodriguez as Jane, whose surprise pregnancy (the result of an accidental artificial insemination) has given birth to an instant favorite.

2014 Best-Game of Thrones

Helen Sloan/HBO

Game of Thrones

How satisfying it can be to watch a few of the bad guys finally bite the Westeros dust. The dragons are bigger and more unruly than ever, and so is the bloody and sprawling plotting as HBO's epic fantasy vividly dramatizes pivotal events in the finest volume (A Storm of Swords) of George R.R. Martin's enthralling saga. Long may those dastardly Lannisters (King Joffrey and grim grandpa Tywin) rot.

2014 Best-The Roosevelts

The Library of Congress/PBS

The Roosevelts: An Intimate History

Leave it to Ken Burns, PBS's poet laureate of impassioned historical storytelling, to upstage a mediocre fall season with seven immersive nights of personal and presidential lore, illuminating and humanizing a political dynasty that transformed government through two world wars and the Great Depression. The night devoted to FDR's battle with polio was as moving and uplifting as any classic tearjerker.

2014 Best-Jimmy Fallon

Douglas Gorenstein/NBC

The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon

Studio 6B in 30 Rock is TV's giddy party central, and we're so lucky to be invited every night into Jimmy Fallon's playhouse. The genial host transformed what had become one of NBC's stodgier institutions into an anything-goes opportunity for celebrities to loosen up, playing hilarious games (like lip-sync battles) or submitting to slapstick stunts. Under Fallon, Tonight has become a viral phenom that happily revives the time-honored traditions of true musical-comedy variety.

Craig Blankenhorn/FX

The Americans

Spying on Mom and Dad carries potentially lethal consequences in FX's bracingly original espionage thriller. The riveting second season ratcheted the tension up a notch by focusing on the fallout within the family of the suburban Soviet agents and masters of disguise, played with intense subtlety and chameleon virtuosity by Matthew Rhys and Keri Russell. The foundation of lies on which they've built their lives and covert careers has begun to crack, leaving us in breathless suspense.

2014 Best-Transparent

Amazon Studios

Transparent

Jeffrey Tambor graduates from great character actor to sublime leading lady, giving the year's standout performance as Maura, formerly Mort, in Amazon's poignantly human comedy of self-realization. Creator Jill Soloway's transcendent empathy extends to Maura's adult kids, each on his or her own rocky, often erotic, journey of discovery.

HBO (2)

The Normal Heart and Olive Kitteridge

A shattering AIDS drama and a memorably quirky character study gave HBO bragging rights once again as the most consistently powerful of TV-movie/miniseries producers. Ryan Murphy's all-star adaptation of Larry Kramer's explosive polemic teemed with sorrow and anger, while Frances McDormand brought feisty, cranky Olive (from Elizabeth Strout's Pulitzer-winning novel) to vibrantly uncompromising life.

2014 Best-The-Affair

Mark Schafer/SHOWTIME

The Affair

In another banner year for Showtime - introducing the baroque Victorian-era monster mash of Penny Dreadful, delivering strong second seasons of Masters of Sex and Ray Donovan, and rejuvenating Homeland with 24-like vigor in a Pakistani hot zone - the network's boldest drama was also its quietest. In The Affair, the illicit lovers (Ruth Wilson and Dominic West, superb) are unreliable narrators of their tempestuous love story, as each episode relives events from their separate perspectives, which rarely jibe. The only truth we're sure of: the pain they've caused their spouses (well played by Maura Tierney and Joshua Jackson).

< >