Who Should Play Bill, Hillary & Other Real-Life ‘Impeachment’ Figures? (PHOTOS)

arrow - left
arrow - right
Clintons at New Home
Chris Hondros/Getty Images
Untitled design
Jesse Grant/Getty Images, Pool/Getty Images

Neal McDonough as Bill Clinton

The Suits and Justified actor is around the same age as Clinton was at the time. Then again, he was reportedly fired from a project for refusing to do sex scenes, so…

Untitled design-7
Lily Lawrence/Getty Images, Mark Wilson/Getty Images

Carrie Coon as Hillary Clinton

Coon steals scenes in whatever TV show she’s in, no matter if it’s The Leftovers, Fargo, or The Sinner. We could totally see her as a jilted First Lady.

Untitled design-6
Rich Polk/Getty Images, Win McNamee/Getty Images

Tracy Letts as Ken Starr

Perhaps Coon could convince her husband, this Homeland and Ladybird actor, to play Starr, the independent counsel who investigated Clinton.

Untitled design-4
Brad Barket/Getty Images, New York Daily News Archive/Getty Images

Audra McDonald as Betty Currie

There’s not a whole lot of resemblance between McDonald and Clinton’s former personal secretary, but we’ll take as much of this Tony Award queen on TV as possible.

Untitled design-2
Paul Zimmerman/Getty Images, Getty Images

Margo Martindale as Lucianne Goldberg

The author and literary agent who advised Linda Tripp to record conversations with Monica Lewinsky? What about this Emmy winner from The Americans?

Untitled design-3
Scott Wintrow/Getty Images, Peter Kramer/Getty Images

Frankie Faison as Vernon Jordan

This alum of The Wire — who also starred in Banshee and The Village — is our pick for Jordan, an advisor to Clinton at the time.

Untitled design-5
Ben Gabbe/Getty Images, Tim Boyle/Getty Images

Noah Emmerich as Al Gore

This actor, another Americans vet, could portray Clinton’s second-in-command, if the script calls for it. He’s almost the right age, too.

1 of

Ryan Murphy and the other American Crime Story producers have already filled three of the roles for the FX anthology’s third season, Impeachment, which will chronicle the sex scandal around then-President Bill Clinton and then-intern Monica Lewinsky.

Booksmart star Beanie Feldstein will play Lewinsky, Sarah Paulson will play Linda Tripp, and Masters of Sex star Annaleigh Ashford will play Paula Jones. But what about Bill himself? And Hillary, for that matter?

We’ve done some dream casting for the upcoming season, so flip through the gallery above to see our picks.

Impeachment: American Crime Story, Premiere, Sunday, September 27, 2020, FX