Why Didn’t 3D Television Catch On?
Ten years ago this month, ESPN 3D launched to great fanfare, offering sports coverage broadcast in 3D for viewers with compatible TV sets. “ESPN 3D marries great content with new technology to enhance the fan’s viewing experience and puts ESPN at the forefront of the next big advance for TV viewing,” then-ESPN President George Bodenheimer raved when the channel was announced.
Except … it wasn’t the next big advance. ESPN 3D shut down three years later “due to limited viewer adoption of 3D services to the home” — though ESPN vowed to be ready “if or when 3D does take off.” The following month, BBC announced it would be suspending its 3D programming due to a “lack of public appetite.”
So what happened? Why did 3D television die a slow death?
For one, viewers had to have a 3D television set to enjoy 3D content, and manufacturers had a hard time persuading consumers to shell out extra money for a feature that wasn’t universally supported — especially when so many U.S. consumers had just purchased new televisions a couple years earlier to accommodate the shift from analog to digital TV broadcasts.
The technology was far from perfect, too. 3D glasses were typically expensive and brand-specific. The 3D image often appeared too dim. Some 3D televisions had a narrow viewing angle. Many viewers suffered eye strain while watching 3D televisions. The market was saturated with movies and TV shows retroactively converted to 3D in post-production or even in real time, with jarring results. And frankly, many people watch TV passively, multitasking with the TV on in the background. In a 2019 obituary for 3D television, Wired’s Brian Barrett argued that the 3D television industry “steadfastly ignored how human beings actually use technology, because doing so meant companies could charge more for it.”
By 2013, industry watchdogs were declaring that the fad was over — and rightly speculating that 3D TVs would soon be replaced by 4K, 8K, and OLED TVs. LG and Sony, the last two holdouts in the 3D TV biz, dropped 3D support in 2017, following in the footsteps of Samsung and Vizio.
Then there was the dearth of 3D programming. Aside from ESPN 3D and select other channels dedicated to three-dimensional programming, 3D content was mostly limited to 3D movies on Blu-ray. Plus, the content that was available wasn’t exactly revolutionary, as Mike McGuire, VP Analyst for Gartner, explained to Computerworld in 2013. “If the actual experience was so staggeringly cool, if a baseball or football game, or a TV drama, took on new meaning and was much more enjoyable than standard TV, we’d all have 3D TVs and 3D TV content,” he said. “I just don’t think the 3D TV experience ever managed to blow the minds of enough people.”
(Even 3D cinema has lost its luster. 3D box office revenue in the United States and Canada fell from $2.2 billion in 2010 to $1.3 billion in 2017, and then a 2018 MPAA report revealed global 3D box office dropped 20 percent between 2017 and 2018.)
So yes, 3D television is dead. But don’t count out a resurrection. A company called Light Field Lab has been developing a true holographic display that can bring 3D holograms into viewers’ living rooms, according to a 2018 Variety dispatch. Nine months later, the company had raised $28 million to build large holographic displays, per VentureBeat.
Perhaps 3D television will have a second chance, if holographic displays can woo consumers and content creators. And perhaps ESPN 3D will live to see another day.
Conversation8 Comments
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Comments are closed on this story.
-
G
I have an LG 4K 3D OLED TV and love it. Just as the end was near, for 3D, LG mastered passive 3D technology. The thing that really killed 3D was those stupid active shutter glasses. Everyone HATED them. By the time the passive stuff came around, it was too late. I wish LG would bring 3D back so I can upgrade the size of my display.
23 1
-
R
"many people watch TV passively, multitasking with the TV on in the background"...
I bought a 3D TV 1-2 years after it appeared...when the Vizio TV I bought was only $20 more expensive...(including 4 glasses)...then its NON-3D equivalent...
Also...Verizon offered a fair amount of content...(especially movies)...
But once the novelty wore off...we rarely watched 3D because not only did it eliminate multitasking...it also made it it somewhat difficult (with the 3D glasses on) to even look at the clock, look out the window to check the weather or see the bologna sandwich you were eating...
6 2
-
G
There was also a lot of misinformation surrounding 3DTV's. Most people thought if you purchased a 3D TV you had to watch everything in 3D. And manufacturers like Samsung took the gimmick route using shudder glasses, instead of putting in the extra panel required for passive 3D viewing. Allowing them to charge more for 3D, even when no hardware was added to their models. Then charge again for expensive glasses that caused headaches & sometimes seizures. For them, it was about their bottom line not the viewers enjoyment or comforts. Also the post production of films that wasn't meant for 3D but was done for profit, and rarely done well. 3D when done well, looks AMAZING, and can be a breathtaking experience. But too many stars had to line up in just the right order for this to happen. There will always be a need for more life like tv experience. So if the holographic projectors can be made for an affordable price they will be the next HDTV. 8K, TVs are gimmicks that will never catch on. Most people can barely see a difference between 1080p and 4k. Especially with today's upscale tech. But there will always be the next big gimmick trying to squeeze extra bucks from buyers pockets. However, the 3DTV at its truest intention, offered an enjoyable experience that will be sought by fans in the future. A previously owned 3DTV in good working condition, could rake in some high $$. So if you have one. Hang on to it and take care of it. You hold a piece of nostalgia that many will envy.
2
-
W
3D is one of those things that's neat in certain circumstances, but just those circumstances. I doubt it ever gets beyond IMAX film houses for true event films. Outside of that, the experience is too watered down to be really enjoyable once the novelty effect wears off. In all three distinct 3D eras, the mid 1950s, early 1980s and early 2010s a few films were well done, or at least done well enough to spark interest and then there was a widespread effort to try to add 3D to too many films. In the most recent case, it was often added in post production leading to a very underwhelming effect, and then the enthusiasm fades as the extra cost to do it right is rarely justified. I don't see this changing.
4 3
-
G
That is probably one of the best one. Keep it in pristine condition. It will tipple in price as more and more get disposed. It will be very rare.
-
C
Such bs this could have been great had they never released active 3d first.....if everyone experienced passive 3d with cheap non battery operated glasses with 4k resolution u wouldn't be able to buy anything else on the market today.....if they broadcast football games etc the same way again this market would dominate to the level of digital broadcast people wouldn't even be able to buy just a 4k TV let alone 8k which is about 15 years away from being useful.....just amazes me how the same companies who invested so much also invested so little and messed everything up and then quit makes me think a bunch of amateurs were running the show across the board or someone very powerful was putting their money against 3d....who wouldn't want to pay same price for a 4k TV as a 4k 3d TV? You don't have to always use the 3d but when u want to you have that option it was like buying a blue ray disc player and a ps3 instead of just buying the ps3 it makes no sense yet here we are being sold 16k tvs that are 40 years ahead of its time but can't watch movies in 3d at home unless we pay thousands for a 6 year old used TV that product is no longer produced for....makes much more sense to remaster 40 year old movies into 4k with fuzzy resolution because it was never even filmed in 4k resolution to begin with but I guess that's the market it's just so disappointing to know what could actually be rather than what we are stuck with I've been bored of 4k for 4 years now it's overrated
-
P
I drive all over the country and when this first came out I stopped in a few Best Buys and Wal-marts to check it out, most of them never had any of the display models set up correctly to see any 3d affect. When I finally found both passive and active working, with a film made in 3d, the realism and color for the active blew away the watered down affect of the passive, not really 3d experience. Those stupid shutter glasses allowed for two images that weren't tampered with and polarized to give the 3d affect.
2 2
-
P
I agree. I have a LG 65" 3d 4K, and it wows everyone who watches 3D movies on it. Have over 230 3D blur ays. Bought for the LG 2 grand and see now they are selling (in demand) for 7 grand or more... For sports I will be watching watch an LG G1 77".
2 2