‘Marshals’: Mo Brings Plenty Calls for Justice After Episode Dedicated to Late Nephew Cole

Mo Brings Plenty as Mo in 'Marshals' Season 2 Episode 6; Cole Brings Plenty as Pete in '1923' Season 1
Q&A
Fred Hayes/CBS; Emerson Miller/Paramount+

What To Know

  • Marshals Season 2 paid tribute to Mo Brings Plenty’s nephew, 1923 actor Cole Brings Plenty, who was found dead in April 2024 after going missing.
  • Inspired by Cole’s case, the episode follows Mo and Kayce Dutton as they investigate the murder of Mo’s nephew, Troy.
  • Brings Plenty shares the emotional impact of this episode and his family’s continued fight for justice in Cole’s death.

Marshals Season 2 dedicated a storyline to the late Cole Brings Plenty, nephew of Marshals actor Mo Brings Plenty. Cole, who played Pete Plenty Clouds in Yellowstone spinoff 1923, was found dead in April 2024 after going missing. While police declared that there was no indication of foul play in Cole’s death and that he acted alone, his family has publicly disputed the conclusion and are still seeking further investigation. Here, Brings Plenty unpacks the Marshals dedication to Cole with TV Insider. Warning: Marshals Season 2 Episode 6 spoilers ahead.

Marshals Season 2 Episode 6, “Roughstock,” involved a storyline directly inspired by what happened to Cole, except this story got more answers for the family. Brings Plenty’s Marshals and Yellowstone character is named after himself. His nephew in the series, Troy Brings Plenty, was played by Will Strongheart. In the episode, Troy went missing and Mo asked Kayce Dutton (Luke Grimes) for help in the search.

Cole Brings Plenty as Pete Plenty Clouds in '1923' Season 1 Episode 7

Cole Brings Plenty as Pete Plenty Clouds in 1923 Season 1 Episode 7 (Emerson Miller/Paramount+)

Kayce worked outside of the parameters of his position as a U.S. Marshal. After he and Mo found Troy dead on a mountain, he asked Andrea (Ash Santos) to find a way to make this the Marshals’ case. Their hunt led them to a pair of poachers who didn’t hurt Troy, but bonded with him in the moments before his death. Their efforts proved that Troy’s death was a murder, not suicide. The identity of his killer is still unknown, and Mo said he will avenge his nephew. The episode ended with an Indigenous ceremony honoring Troy’s life.

“Before pursuing it, I spoke with Mo to see if he’d be comfortable with portraying the story and he was welcoming to the idea,” Marshals executive producer Spencer Hudnut told TV Insider. Hudnut had the idea for a story about a former teammate of Kayce’s dying in a mysterious way that would require Kayce to prove it was murder, not suicide. That idea evolved into the adaptation of Brings Plenty’s family story.

“The obstacles they’re facing are the prejudice and ignorance surrounding these issues facing the reservation, and the difficulties of processing a crime scene in a state park without cameras or witnesses to help them gather direct information and solve the case,” Hudnut explained. “Troy’s murder is definitely an engine that will be resolved later in the year and could potentially be tied to a larger conspiracy.”

Brings Plenty shares what this episode means to him in the interview below.

This is a very moving episode. I know it is a very emotionally impactful one for you because it’s inspired by your late nephew, Cole. I’m so sorry for your loss first and foremost with regards to that. And I would like to know first, did you pitch this story to Marshals or was it pitched to you?

Mo Brings Plenty: No, we shared our experience. My brother and I, Cole’s father, we shared our experience and what we’re going through and we know how we feel. And there’s a lot of families that are in the same situation throughout Indian country.

We just talked about our experiences and what we were going through and Spencer and the writers, such amazing group, they created the story and how this would go about. And so they asked me if I would be OK on a personal level and I said, “Absolutely. We need to be able to get this kind of information out there.”

Mo Brings Plenty — 'Marshals' Season 2 Episode 6

Fred Hayes/CBS

Given that it was such a personal topic, did you have any hesitations about it?

I prayed about it just for the fact that I was going to be reliving some moments in which I did, but it’s not about me. All I kept thinking about was not just my own family, but all the other families, again, throughout Indian country that [are] going through the same heartache. And so it was about them as well.

How much of this story was pulled directly from your own experience?

A lot. A lot of it, but the positive side of it is that we had a department from the division of law enforcement that got involved, and so that was helpful. I wish that was the case in real life.

What are you hoping that viewers take away from this episode?

What I hope that viewers take away is that this is an ongoing issue and it’s a legitimate issue that people can make a difference at by speaking to their governors, to their congresspeople, to their senators, and getting them to know that, hey, we as American Indian people, we’re taxpayers too. First responders gets tax dollars. As we’re paying taxes and the wheel of justice doesn’t turn for us, it’s even more of a heartache. It’s more of a slap in the face than just alone them not doing the proper investigations in cases like my nephew’s.

Mo Brings Plenty and Luke Grimes as Kayce Dutton — 'Marshals' Season 2 Episode 6

Fred Hayes/CBS

It must have been intense to film this episode for you. Was there any part of it that was cathartic?

Yes, in the discovery of [Troy’s] body. That is — excuse me [takes a moment to collect himself]. That is still a moment in real life that will never go away until justice has occurred, until the wheel of justice has turned for us as American Indian people.

I imagine talking about this all day is difficult, so I appreciate you taking the time to do this and the vulnerability that you’re sharing. You’ve been a cultural consultant on Yellowstone and most Taylor Sheridan shows with Indigenous storylines ever since Yellowstone, so your personal experience has been so valuable already, but what did it mean to you to have this personal story in particular adapted in Marshals?

It means the world. For me, after we got done filming, it was somewhat a small example or a small sample of healing and I’m not going to say triumph, but the ability to stand up again. Because when nothing is being done in accordance to the law, then you feel battered and beaten. I was feeling that way for a long time.

Grieving is a lifelong process, but it sounds like this helped you process some things a bit. Is that true?

Well, it gave me a glimpse of hope that maybe this will inspire people throughout the country to begin to voice their opinions and their concerns to their senators, congresspeople, and governors, to their political leaders that, hey, this is the original inhabitants of this country and why are we ignoring them when we take into consideration other groups throughout the world and other countries. We are considerate of what’s occurring to them, but we’re not so considerate to the original people of this country.

Mo Brings Plenty as Mo, Luke Grimes as Kayce Dutton, and Ash Santos as Andrea Cruz

Fred Hayes/CBS

This has been something that Yellowstone touched on from the early seasons, so working with Luke Grimes on this, having your history together as costars, what was that like for you?

It was good. That’s what gave me the ability to be vulnerable, but it also gave me the ability to be strong and courageous to have Luke there and to be able to do those scenes with him.

Same question, but about Gil Birmingham.

It’s same thing. They’re both aware. Gil’s very much aware of what has occurred and what my family’s still going through, and so to have him there as the brother, both him and Luke, it was good. Very good.

What was your family’s involvement during the filming of this episode?

I talked to my brother, Cole’s father, and we discussed it. And of course, we’re always in prayer, so they had a ceremony and kept us all in prayer and being able to bring this to life, to relive it all, to go through it all again. And kudos to Will who portrayed Troy. He’s very much aware of what occurred as well.

Is there anything else you’d like to highlight about this episode that you want people to take away?

Again, what I really want people to take away is that we’re still here as American Indian people and we need your help. We need your voice. We need you to be able to speak up and to share and give us that space and ask people to get involved, especially law enforcement.

There’s a lot of good officers out there, but they’re not given opportunity. And just like anything, there’s good and bad in everything. And so hopefully the good officers will begin to push away the bad and truly investigate a lot of these cases that are going unsolved or not even worked.

Marshals, Sundays, 8/7c, CBS




Conversation

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Register or sign in to join the conversation.