‘Are You My First?’ Host Colton Underwood Reflects on Being Labeled the ‘Virgin Bachelor’

When it comes to talking about your sex life—or in this case, lack thereof—on national television, it’s clear that a lot has changed since Colton Underwood made his reality TV debut back in 2018.

To celebrate the launch of Hulu’s new show, Are You My First?, co-hosted by fellow Bachelor Nation alum Kaitlyn Bristowe, we sat down with Colton Underwood to discuss many of his reality TV firsts, including the day when The Bachelor star learned that he was being marketed as the “Virgin Bachelor.”