‘The Way Home’ Finally Reveals Truth About Casey’s Identity

Vaughan Murrae as Casey — 'The Way Home' Season 2 Episode 3
Spoiler Alert
Hallmark Channel

[Warning: The below contains MAJOR spoilers for The Way Home Season 3 Episode 7 “Tell Me Something Good.”]

Who is Casey (Vaughan Murrae)?! That’s the question that has been prevalent on The Way Home since Season 2, and now, we’re finally getting some answers.

Alice (Sadie Laflamme-Snow) has been so certain all this time that Kat’s (Chyler Leigh) intern is actually from the future; with Casey saying they’re a Goodwin (and Cassandra and variations a family name), Alice has also been wondering if she might marry Max (Dale Whibley) and avoiding him instead of working on a school assignment together. Well, by the end of “Tell Me Something Good,” Alice has confirmed that she was right about Casey being from the future!

Del (Andie MacDowell), now in the know on all things time travel and the pond, uses an opportunity to ask her boyfriend Sam (Rob Stewart) about seeing him with Casey to get clues. “They called, said they were in town,” he shares. “We were just catching up.” Casey’s one of his clients; they came to him last year for legal advice. Del, of course, wonders why someone so young would need legal advice. Unfortunately, Sam can’t help due to attorney-client privilege.
Alice does finally meet up with Max at Lingermore and asks to see the attic, where she finds a coffee cup as well as a burner phone and a chess piece hidden. There was a squatter, he reveals. But why would a squatter leave those things behind?

Alice then fills Kat in on that and her new theory: Casey was the squatter. Kat argues there’s no proof … which is when Casey shows up and confirms they were the squatter. They know they haven’t been entirely truthful: Lewis is their second cousin, not father, and things had been really bad at home for them last summer. “By that, you mean the summer of 2024, right?” Alice checks. The internship was more than a job for them —it made them feel like family — so they came back to say thank you. They had their parents call Lewis to change his mind about buying their land and got legal help from Sam, Casey shares. The Landry’s did so much for them that they wanted to do something in return. They then beg off (just passing through town) and leave. Kat thinks that should put Alice’s theory to bed, that they’re not a time traveler, but her daughter wonders who was in the field the night she was pushed in the pond if not Casey?

Well … Alice is on her way back to the house from her own trip back in time via the pond when she runs into Casey on the Landry property. Casey claims they remembered something to tell Kat but she wasn’t there. But as they walk away, Alice asks about the ring (Kat’s engagement ring) around their neck. “It’s a family ring,” Casey says. “Goodwin family?” Alice checks. “No,” Casey says, then runs. Alice follows them … into the woods … to the pond … where they jump in and don’t come back up!

There’s the proof: Casey is from the future! After all, the pond is about reflection and has only taken people (Landrys) to the past… But does this mean that Alice’s future is with Max? Is Casey Alice’s kid? That’s still very much up in the air.

What do you think of the reveal about Casey? What’s your theory about their connection to Alice? Let us know in the comments section below.

The Way Home, Fridays, 9/8c, Hallmark Channel




Conversation146 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Comments are closed on this story.

  1. B

    BlueCone

    Ok Sam is coming off suspicious. Who is this client Thomas Coyle or Cyrus Goodwin. As for KC maybe she's Jacobs daughter but I'm still so confused. Wait maybe Sam knows about the pond and maybe met Colton. This episode left me confused lol. This show needs 2 hours lol ☺️ 😂 🤣

    74 4

    1. C

      CyanController

      Could be. But, the ring seems more likely to be a family ring because of Alice. It was Kat's wedding ring and passed to Alice when they divorced. So, I doubt it's a family ring related to Jacob.

      8 1

      1. C

        CyanBucket

        I was thinking that why does it have to be from the laundry’s side maybe it’s from Alice dad’s side. It also could be Elliot and Kat has a child or it could very well be Jacob child. He did say he wanted to find love and start a family one day. I just pray they don’t leave us hanging with the unanswered questions after this season. Does anyone think that when Jacob confirms that Calton was the kid that taught him on how to plant the rye and the wheat that calton is actually the child in the basket.

        8 1

  2. G

    GreenLobster

    I think, we all need to rewatch both seasons during the daytime, when our brains are more awake, and are fully sharper than at night, cause we all are missing something. Ya know? Unless, the writers are doing this, to keep everyone confused, so they must watch the next episode, to hopefully have a season 3? Don't forget, right before Cole died in Kat's arms, he said her name!

    39

    1. P

      PurpleGlasses

      We are in Season 3 currently

      4 1

    2. H

      Harlow

      It’s a good idea, but I just really don’t wanna watch three episodes all over again. But he is a really good idea because I am really confused.

      2

    3. C

      CyanCandy

      Didn't he call her My Katherine ?! Like the painting

      6

      1. G

        GoldDucky

        Maybe Suzanna and Colton had Catherine...they were the young couple that left the baby (Catherine) behind. And the "lie" in the anonymous letters is that Catherine really isn't Del's biological daughter. She's the baby left behind that Del took in as her own...

        5

  3. G

    GreenButton

    Casey must have a connection to Sam. The squatter (Casey) left a chess piece behind—it’s a bishop—Sam’s last name!

    30

    1. H

      Harlow

      Great catch. That makes sense.

      15

    2. B

      BluePlanet

      And Sam and Del were playing chess.

      2

      1. C

        CyanFries

        I bet his name isn’t actually, sam. Because Casie stammered in the cafe when she was questioned about getting help

        From Sam. She said, yeah. Sam. And he’s trying to keep someone in jail. Maybe Sam was the guy that Colton met at that hotel. The private investigator he was paying to look into things. (Maybe the past, to see if his son was in the past) back in season 1. Maybe he is trying to unlock the ponds secrets so he can use it.

        2

  4. B

    BlueGrapes

    I’m blown away about Cole teaching Jacob back in the 1800’s about farming

    28 2

    1. B

      BlueCone

      Right

      10

  5. L

    LJ

    It would be great if Hallmark would draw me out a family tree! It’s getting hard to keep up with the new members when we need more facts about the ones we already know. Del knows more than she’s letting on. Love the time traveling theme of the series though! I watched last Friday's episode twice & am still left with questions.

    24

    1. B

      BlueFlower

      There was one posted on one of the The Way Home FB groups I think.

    2. R

      RedLobster

      I've watched some twice too because it's so easy to miss something or try to figure something out!

  6. B

    BlueCone

    One last thing then I gotta tune into dateline ok Nick ummm on a double date with yet still teenage Alice. I couldn't let that go. Also who is sending those type notes to Del. My husband said he doesn't think it's Sam. He says Rita

    26 2

    1. G

      GreenLobster

      I agree, with it being Rita. You know, someone so close to you, that you wouldn't expect.

      26 2

      1. B

        BlueBox

        Rita talks too much and can't keep a secret. I don't see how it could be her sending the notes

        2

    2. O

      OrangeStrawberry

      I am so happy that I am not the only one who had this thought

      2

    3. O

      OliveBandAid

      Plus she literally showed up when she was at the mailbox and got another letter!!

    4. R

      RedBowtie

      It can’t be Rita because in S3 episode 7, Del tells her about the letters she’s been receiving. In fact, Rita is genuinely shocked and tells Del it’s probably the last person she least suspects that’s sending them..

  7. G

    GreenGoggles

    Wow! I think this was probably the best episode ever! OK I just have to mention I'm so happy to see Thomas again, although I know it will be short-lived. But the Caesy revelation- her jumping in pond in front of Alice- epic!! She must be from future how else would she have got family ring. But the loophole is, why doesn't Kat or Alice have it in their possession now? When did Casey get it?

    On to Sam. I don't like him now. He accused Del of hiding something about Jacob. He knows about traveling! And the final zinger reveal: young man Cole helping Jacob back in 1800s farming! Wow!! What do thing about Sam being Cole's father back then?

    26 4

    1. O

      OliveBoomerang

      I have lots of trouble with time travel rules, for example, how could young Cole in the 1800s as a late teen/early 20s be interacting with his son Jacob who he hadn't spawned yet?

      10 1

      1. G

        GreenCloud

        I don't get that either..

        (Jacob being taught by teenish Cole)

        Every time travel story or show has very different rules..lol

        4

      2. C

        CyanCoathanger

        Because Jacob went back there as a boy in 1999. Colton goes back when he's a teenager in 1974. And probably in 1999, he'd forgotten and didn't realize it was his teenage son that he'd seen in 1800s.

        2

      3. O

        OliveDice

        Alice went back in season 1 before Kat ever had her.

        1

    2. O

      OliveBoomerang

      Delilah sleeps with her husband's father? Hallmark wouldn't do that to us.

      7

      1. O

        OrangeCandy

        It is getting confusing. What about in episode two when Sam came to dinner and the coins came up he seemed very suspicious to me anyways remember the look on his face. He is hiding something. Also I can understand going back to the past but if the future hasn’t happened yet for Alice then how can anyone from her future come into the picture but the fact that she had the ring is confusing. And if Cole died or we thought he did did he manage to get himself to the pond and has been somewhere else all this time?

        5

        1. B

          BlueBandAid

          The Casey Alice situation would be no different than Kat meeting Alice in the past. Same situation.

          8

      2. P

        PurpleRing

        I thought the old woman said Cole had a brother...maybe sam is coles brother...

        2 1

    3. C

      CyanGuitar

      Alice does have the ring in her possession, go back a couple of episodes in season 3 when Alice asked her mom did she have a picture of Casey. Alice shows it in her hand while she is looking at it on Casey’s neck on the picture

      8

    4. B

      BlueSailboat

      Alice does have it I'm her possession as well

  8. O

    OrangeBasketball

    How about Elliot Augustine? Did I miss something in the beginning? We know he’s related to Susanna, but who is his male ancestor that carries his name? Or has Susanna given a son her maiden name?

    So many loop holes.

    20 1

    1. B

      BlueCone

      Right because when traveling to 1800 we have never seen any other Augustines.

      16 1

    2. G

      GreenGoggles

      Very good point!

      4

      1. G

        GoldPopsicle

        Samuel Augustine is Susanna's father who supposedly died hence maybe Sam Augustine and Sam Bishop have something in common. And perhaps, the chess piece found in the Lingermore attic is a bishop.

        13 1

    3. B

      BlueBullhorn

      Maybe Susanna is Elliott's mom. Since his mom disappeared and the baby left is Elliot which is why he was able to time travel with Alice.

      19 1

      1. B

        BlueBullhorn

        Or he is one of her brothers ancestors.

        5

  9. O

    OrangeController

    I think you should just say Casey instead of They- the show is confusing enough don't need the added b.s. She is a person and should be addressed as such. That's what I think. You asked.

    19 4

    1. H

      Harlow

      Thank you because I was confused about the “They” when I thought it was only Casey in the attic. I was like what who else was there? What am I missing now?

      13

    2. C

      CyanRaindrop

      Exactly. I only use they or them when I'm talking or writing them. Plural.

      3

    3. G

      GoldCocktail

      Casey is non-binary, which is why they’re referred to with those pronouns. I think the writers did this as another clue that Casey is from the future, and not the past.

      3 4

    4. B

      BlueSnow

      Exactly. A lot of older people especially are not aware of the non-binary b.s. and are very confused. It's almost like Sam and Del were laughing just trying to get their lines out when they were talking about Casey as "they"!

      1 1

  10. G

    GoldAnchor

    I'm trying to figure out who the baby was, that they showed in the basket the young couple left by the pond when they jumped in.

    The young girl said he will be fine. I'm going to take a guess it might be Casey.

    17 2

    1. C

      CyanBus

      I keep reading about this baby. What episode was this in?

      7 1

      1. R

        RedLobster

        Season 3 episode 1 very beginning.

    2. R

      RedCupcake

      Casey is a girl

      2 1

    3. B

      BlueCactus

      I don’t know if a girl who doesn’t want to be a girl would be having babies

    4. B

      BlueRadio

      The baby is Elliott.

      1

  11. H

    Harlow

    I think it takes forever for Saturday to come to watch the show. I watch it on Peacock. Lol.

    I’m trying to keep up, I really am. I was doing really well until the last two episodes. I really like what I’ve been reading here. You’re all helping me understand more. I appreciate every single opinion on here please keep them coming.

    This is one of my very very favorite shows now.

    Thanks, Harlow

    15 1

    1. R

      RedTurtle

      I am so confused which

      Makes me not want to watch

      2 1

  12. B

    BlueDice

    I'm so confused!! But I absolutely love this show, can't wait until next Friday

    8

  13. O

    OliveFan

    The comment of the timing of unraveled mysteries coming across "flat" is right on for me. At that point, I have invested too much of my time wondering & it comes across as an 'old issue' by the time it is revealed. Timing is what it's all about and here timing goes on a little too long .

    9 1

  14. R

    RedCloud

    ¿Is Sam Colton's Brother?

    6

    1. H

      Harlow

      They haven’t said that comma have they?

    2. O

      OrangeScissors

      His brother did disappear if I'm remembering correctly so that would be a good theory! I just want Colton back and with Del. And it would seem Colton knew what happened to Jaob all along.

  15. B

    BlueCone

    Does anyone think that Max knows about the pond

    7 1

    1. B

      BlueGrapes

      Maybe because he seems very defensive when Alice questions him

      4 1

      1. B

        BlueCone

        Facts. And speaking of Alice. I really wish she stop with this obsession about Del and Cole in 1974. She's making poor Evelyn think she got a chance with him

        6

  16. O

    OrangeCherries

    So who is she!?!? AHHHH the suspense

    7 1

    1. B

      BlueCone

      This episode left me more confused than last week 😂

      19

      1. G

        GreenLobster

        Right?!

        2

  17. G

    GreenGoggles

    I have a new revelation. In season 2 Vic told Elliot their ancestors is Samuel Augustine. Could this be Sam? And remember at Del's birthday party Jacob said to Sam "surprised to see you HERE"

    Sam said "yes surprised to see you HERE too". At first I thought they meant the party. I think they know each other from 1800s. Susanna mentioned once her father and Thomas used to smuggle in the tunnels beneath lingermore. Could Sam be Suzannas dad? I know that's not the popular theory, but that's mine. So far it seems everyone travels but Thomas and Susanna!

    5

  18. G

    GoldCar

    I think Sam is a Goodwin. Cyrus and Sam both have eyes that are kind of close together and to me they look as though they could be related...gosh...this show is soooo good that I can't wait for season 4!!!!! Congratulations to all the actors, writers and producers and Hallmark for such a great show!!! Make me want to find a pond and jump in it😁

    4

  19. G

    GoldTrumpet

    Casey's a girl not a "they" but a "she" or a "her!"

    5 1

  20. O

    OrangeBottle

    I wish kat would go back to thomas

    4

  21. O

    OrangeCandy

    this show is great, but calling a single person them is just silly.

    5 1

  22. L

    Lori Leung

    Rita is writing the notes. Casey is Kat's daughter with Thomas in the past and that is why she has the ring. Thomas raised her and told her about the pond and that her mother could time travel. Not to sure about Sam and how he fits into all this mess.

    6 2

    1. G

      GreenGoggles

      But there were two people who left the baby at the pond. How would Thomas and Casey be there if the pond only takes you back in time?

    2. B

      BlueProcessor

      Kat told Alice Casey has Max's eyes.

      1

  23. P

    PurpleCorn

    I was enjoying watching the series with my 13 yr old since it first started. It has been enjoyable to watch together until the story took the turn it did with Casey’s character and all the they/them pronouns. Ugh! It’s like when Hallmark ruined the whole Good Witch finale to add “Joy” to the cast. Miss the old Hallmark values.

    3

  24. O

    OliveBandAid

    I think that Casey is a great addition to the show especially if they are Alice/Max goodwin

    Or maybe Thomas/Kat child. Casey seemed more interested in Kat (then Alice) and has Kats ring. Plus Kris holden-Reid is incredible talented and hopefully will become a series regular. He would be a fantastic asset to the show.

    4 1

    1. B

      BlueGrapes

      Yes

  25. R

    RedBee

    The review would make more sense if the writer dropped the WOKE "they"/"them" BS!

    5 2

  26. G

    GreenQuill

    If Casey is from the future maybe she’s Alice’s daughter since she has Kat’s ring. Wasn’t it given to Alice by Kat? So how else would Casey get it? Sam is very suspicious & creepy now. Not sure I’m trusting him.

    3

    1. O

      OrangeScissors

      I think she is Alice's daughter also. I never liked or trusted Sam.

      1

  27. O

    OliveFlower

    It is becoming a bit confusing to keep up with for this old gal. Confusion leads to frustration, leads to change the channel! Wish there was sometype explanation AFTER (so no spoilers) each show to help us dum dums "get it"!

    6 3

  28. C

    CyanMagnet

    What's with the they, them, their? Is the character supposed to be gender fluid? 🤔

    4 1

    1. G

      GreenGoggles

      It's confusing! I keep thinking they are talking about multiple people.

      10

    2. O

      OliveGrapes

      Makes sense that they’re gender fluid if from the future. Good on Hallmark if that’s the case.

      5 3

  29. R

    RedSeahorse

    Question- Susanna marries the wealthy and prominent Cyrus, yet in the cemetery, her grave is marked with a barely visible marker and “Susanna Augustine.” Shouldn’t it have been with Cyrus and very prominent?

    2

    1. B

      BlueGrapes

      Yes it’s suspicious

      1. C

        CyanBike

        Susanna could have gone back to her maiden name and that is why her grave was visible marker with the name of Augustine if anything does happens to Cyrus.

  30. G

    GoldPuzzle

    I love the show but it is getting too complicated. In my opinion if it continues down this path it will lose viewers..too muvh

    2

  31. C

    CyanWeights

    I'm not usually a fan of shows jumping around thru time but this series has great writers creating great characters.

    2

  32. O

    OrangeTag

    I think it would be cool if Casey was from the future.?? Relationship. Could she be Kat and Elliot's daughter?

    2

  33. P

    PurpleChilli

    I think Casey is a future daughter of Kat, and is Alice's little sister.

    2

  34. C

    CyanRaindrop

    Casey is someone's daughter in the Landry family. The obvious is Alice, but I think we'll be surprised.

    2

  35. B

    BlueBeer

    I think Casey is Kat and Thomas Coyle’s kid. I think Jacob will go back and try to bring him to the future or Kat will end up hooking up with him and get prego.

    I also think Sam is Cole’s older brother. The grandma mentioned him to Kat when she traveled back to the 70s. I think Sam is sending those letters to pressure Delilah to just tell him about the pond. The grandma mentioned the boys couldn’t time travel but we found out Cole definitely did so maybe Sam was the one who couldn’t.

    4 2

    1. C

      CyanBucket

      I don’t remember fern saying that they couldn’t time travel. I remember fern saying that she thought the two boys was special but she was wrong. She said calton is a rule breaker.

      3

    2. H

      Harlow

      That would be so super awesome. I hope you’re right.

      1

  36. M

    Mary McDonough

    Casey lied from in the way home

    1

  37. R

    RedPalmtree

    The one person who has ALL these answers we all asking iiiiis drum roll please 🥁 GRANMA FERN!!!! 😂 Unfortunately she isn't really super senile at the moment to tell the tale🤷🏼‍♀️ bummer! 😔

    1

  38. C

    CyanBike

    I think that Casey is connected to Jacob and Susanna, She may be their child. I can not figure how in regarding to time period but if when we saw a young Colton at the pond in1800's along side a lady at pond. Susanna's painting of a young Colton and Jacob perhaps they were friends at the time period. Perhaps that child at the pond was a young Jacob and Susanna as young teens leaving a child near the pond. What if someone told them to leave the baby and someone raised Casey's great-great grandparent or something like that I not sure how many greats especially dealing with the time period.

    1

  39. R

    RedWrench

    Why is the article referring to Casey as "They". She's a woman. Can we just stop this insanity.

    1

  40. R

    RedCloud

    I think Sam is also a time traveler and Colton's long lost brother. Casey might be a granddaughter to Alice.

    1

  41. C

    CyanGuitar

    I loved it in the beginning but now it is so convoluted and so off in different directions I can barely hang on to watch.

    I don't think that I'm the only person who feels this way.

    1

  42. O

    OrangePopcorn

    The Show is Starting To Become Confusing. So Thomas Is A Time Traveler Which Makes Hom A Landry-But From What Year And How Close A Family Member? Kat Is Rightfully Upset With Elliot Kissing Another Woman Yet The Whole Time She Is With Elliot She Is Wishing It Was Thomas. Kat Does Not Have The Moral High Ground On This Point. Who Is Elliot's Mother Is A Good Point. Wouldn't It Be A hoot If Kat Turned Out To Be His Mom-But Then Victor Would Know Her And HallMark Would Not Go There. It Is A Shame Things Are Complicated With Kat And Elliot-These Two Hurt Each Other So Much It Is Going To Be Impossible For Thes One Thing IsCleare Two To Be Friends Let Alone Lovers. One Thing Is Perfectly Clear-Casey The Time Traveler Is Not A Confidant Of Elliot. She Has Not Talked To Him In The Present So That Means In The Future She Has No Contact With Ello Elliotiot Either Because He Is Dead Or Not In Her Circle. Elliot Reminds Me Of George Jpnes Song From1983 He Stopped Loving Her Today. He Is So Hooked On Kat Not Even Taylor Swift Could Get Him Over Kat, Only Death Will Do That.

    3 2

  43. P

    PurpleCar

    Why is Lewis' last name Goodwin if he was Evelyn's son? His last name should be his father's name. Same for Max.

    1

    1. C

      CyanBucket

      He could have took Evelyn last name or maybe he isn’t her son. He’s the grand son

      1

  44. O

    OliveBox

    I think people traveling from the future has made it too confusing though I’m not giving up on the series. So Casey is probably Alice’s daughter which people have been saying for a long time. Now that it has been possibly revealed does it become “ flat” like Jacob finally being found?

    Also, don’t like Jacob’s character anymore. Sorry Hallmark .

    1

  45. B

    BluePlanet

    What if it was Alice and Nick dropping off the baby…. It seems wrong but what if? I agree about it being confusing because there are too many loose threads that don’t naturally flow together and the writers need to answer more of these so there are some absolutes. Here’s a few: who dropped off the baby, how could the baby travel through the pond or did they come through the pond to leave it there-that actually might work, Eliot’s family connection to Suzanna, who is Casey, what’s on the burner phone and can we get a dna sample from the tea cup???, where the hell is Cole, will Kat ever be able to undo Cole’s death, what about the clock Elliot found in the wall, again who was his Mom with the family ring, did Cole know Jacob fell into the pond because you’d think he’d go after him which I believe he did. Remember how Delia thought he was having an affair because he was gone all the time. He probably couldn’t get him back and that’s why we see him popping in and out of timelines. Why was Suzanna so fond of Kat that she wrote My Katherine on the painting? Probably have more questions but that’s enough. Ugh.

    1

  46. W

    William F

    I knew there had to be a reason why Suzanna had a sketch of Cole and Jacob! Every episode reveals more chaos lol! Love it! Sam is very suspicious now. What is the real reason why he has been getting so close to Del? 🤔 Finding the truth about Jacob? His whole demeanor now has changed, he was super aggressive with Del.

    1

    1. B

      BlueCone

      I had to point that sketch from last week out to my husband. And yeah what's up Sam acting sketchy. I need to go back to the first season no second season when they did the founders day. Remember when Sam was first introduced he said his family has land in Port Haven. So let me see if I See anything about BISHOP FAMILY.

      58 2

      1. W

        William F

        Another thing to think about too: The pond brings a person back in time to where they need to go. So then, the few times Casey has been in Alice's timeline it's been for reasons worthy or important enough to be sent back. But I can't think of anything important except ensuring the farm stays in the family.

        15

        1. B

          BlueCone

          Valid point you making my friend. Yeah so who knows maybe next week we'll get a glimpse as to why Cassie is coming to 2025. But what's the connection with Sam and Cassie it's more than attorney client

          9

          1. C

            CyanLamp

            Could Casy be close to Sam because he’s married to Del and it would make him her step grandfather if she’s Alice’s daughter?

            7

      2. R

        RedCupcake

        I think, Elliot and Kat get married in the future and Casey is Alice's sister. Their mom (Kat) gave Casey the necklace.

        6 3

        1. O

          OliveUmbrella

          I thought that also

          1

    2. C

      CyanCoathanger

      Did you also notice the sketch of Fern?

      1. W

        William F

        No I didn't! Really? I gotta go back and look.

        1

        1. W

          William F

          So I went back and watched it again. There is no sketch of Fern.

          1

    3. R

      RedPlane

      I’m gonna have to rewatch that episode, I don’t remember the sketch of Cole and Jacob.

  47. S

    Stopthebull

    Don't think so. Characters can only go to the past, then to their present time. So, Casey can't be from the past and go to the future. She has to be from the future and go to the past.

  48. S

    Stopthebull

    Exactly! When characters say they or them, I'm thinking of several characters being referred to cause it's plural.

  49. L

    LF

    Maybe Casey is the daughter of Elliot and Kat, making her Alice's sister, I only thought of this because Elliot had said something to Kat about having their own child.

  50. B

    BlueFan

    Exactly what i'm thinking about it being Jacob's child from the future and Casey's father is his son

  51. W

    William F

    Ok so new question unless someone else already posted this: At lingermore there was a Bishop chess piece behind the hidden door in the attic. In one of the last scenes there was a chess board all set up. What is the connection? Is there? There are never coincidences with this show. I just can't figure this one out!

  52. B

    BlueGrapes

    Maybe Casey Is Kay’s and Thomas’s daughter

  53. R

    RedSeahorse

    I also think there is something to do with the “stars.” Ceiling of jacobs room, the constant quote about explorers using the stars, Elliott had a telescope and is interested in the sciences. When Del and Alice and Kat went to the estate sale after Evelyn died, Del looked over to a desk with all the pill bottles and there was a telescope. The emblem on Susanna’s brave snd the My Katherine portrait looks like a sun/star. But could be nothing.

  54. G

    GoldBottleOpener

    Why do you refer to Casey as they? What am I missing?

    1. V

      Vimbai Zihanzu

      She identifies herself as a nonbinary. When she first meets Kat at the Herald she introduces herself as a Goodwin and Kat says so you must be Evelyn's granddaughter she then says no grandchild. So she (because well she looks and sounds like a she 🤷🏼‍♀️ lol) does not identify herself as a male or female so the nonbinaries call themselves "they/them"

      1

  55. O

    OrangeFries

    I think Casey is Alice’s daughter

    1. B

      BlueGrapes

      I think Casey is Kay’s daughter

      1. B

        BlueGrapes

        Kat’s daughter

  56. R

    RedSeahorse

    Maybe Casey is Susanna or related and the ring is the Augustine family ring that Vic comes back for in a previous episode but it isn’t there. Casey looked up Kat to work for, Susanna married Cyrus, and Casey brought the papers to Del to nullify the sale of the farm although none of the Goodwins acknowledge knowing Casey? Susanna also made the comment she would never find a man she’d love, so maybe she did not prefer men (hence the “they” reference by Casey).

    1. R

      RedSeahorse

      Sorry the Augustine ring was there and Susanna is wearing it at her wedding reception. Not the one Casey has.

      1

  57. P

    PurpleAnchor

    I love the show but it is getting very confusing in my opinion. I feel like i need to do some binge watching from episode 1.

    1 1

  58. P

    PurpleAnchor

    The show is getting more convoluted and the characters annoying..like Elliott and Kat are such a stupid couple!

    2 2

  59. O

    OliveCactus

    What episode is it where this baby in the basket is left? I feel like I missed something.

    1. G

      GreenGoggles

      The start of season 3 episode 1.

  60. P

    PurpleTrumpet

    She could be Kat and Elliott's daughter--a bit of a stretch, maybe, but possible? Or Alice's daughter, but not with Max. The ring is Elliot's, after all

    1 1

    1. O

      OrangeScissors

      The ring is Cat's engagement ring from Brady.

      2

  61. R

    RedHat

    I think Casey is Jacob’s future child.

    1. C

      CyanBike

      I agree after seeing the promo for the season finale the way she was looking at Jacob makes me think she is his child.

      I still think that Susanne and Jacob have a child and Casey is connected to them in some way

  62. G

    GreenGoggles

    Oh I forgot to say. The writers made a point of saying Sam's last name is Bishop several times now. Is that a fake name or will it's origin be revealed in time like everything else?

  63. G

    GreenFlask

    Elijah and Rebecca had a child go missing like Jacob did. Could that child be Colton or Sam?

    1. G

      GreenGoggles

      I thought that child died. That's why they were so happy when Jacob showed up.

      1

  64. G

    GreenLobster

    Wait. Who's Lewis?

    1. C

      CyanDog

      Evelyn’s son

      1

    2. R

      RedSeahorse

      The one who hired Jacob to help him develop the winery.

  65. R

    RedQuill

    I think Casey is Susanna in the future. Cause now she is a Goodwin and now can time travel

    1

    1. G

      GreenGoggles

      Huh? Susanna wouldn't get younger

      5

  66. R

    RedSeahorse

    When Casey first entered the show in the newspaper office, Kat referred to Casey as her and Casey corrected Kat and said “they.” This is a science fiction TV show snd would appreciate being able to participate without politics (woke comments) thrown in. If you don’t like it, don’t watch or write to Hallmark specifically. The show is great irregardless and trying to figure it out and keeping us guessing is the appeal.

    1 3