‘Jeopardy!’ Bosses Told Mayim Bialik to Change Hosting Style Amid Backlash
In the latest episode of the Inside Jeopardy! podcast, Jeopardy!‘s longtime producer, Sarah Whitcomb Foss, shared the advice she gave to Mayim Bialik when she first began hosting the show, and the ways they asked her to change.
Bialik was named one of the official hosts of Jeopardy! in 2022 alongside former super-champ Ken Jennings. It was a bit of a learning curve for both, but particularly for Bialik, who found it difficult to hide her astonishment at the contestants’ vast knowledge.
“I did not expect to enjoy watching while I’m up there as much as I do, and it’s hard not to get honestly starstruck by the contestants up here,” Bialik said during a Q&A with the Jeopardy! studio audience, a clip of which was shared on this week’s podcast.
“And I have to remember that I can’t be exceptionally surprised when they get things right… which I used to be,” the Big Bang Theory alum continued. “I used to be: ‘Wow, yes, you got it!’ So I try to be more chill about it.'”
After listening to the clip back, Foss shared, “I can say this is really true for Mayim. She is constantly impressed and often even surprised at how many things our Jeopardy! contestants can recall so quickly.”
But there was some fan backlash for Bialik’s hosting style, especially her frequent surprise at the contestants answering tough questions correctly.
“So it was something we talked about in the beginning. That, as impressive as it is, just say ‘Yes, correct, you got it,'” Foss continued. “Because they are amazing, and you are going to be continually impressed by their knowledge.”
In another Q&A clip, Bialik was asked what advice she received before stepping into the role of Jeopardy! host.
“Well, usually, when people say ‘be yourself,’ that’s supposed to be encouraging,” the Blossom star said with a laugh. “But here, being myself is actually not what I want to be. I want to be the best Jeopardy host I can be, which means curbing a lot of the inner monologue and, in many cases, inner criticism about the way I say things or the way I speak or the way I’m trying to facilitate what we’re doing here.”
To sum it up, Bialik said the best way to approach the show is, “Be like Alex Trebek, I think is the best advice that I think about, to the best of my ability.”
Bialik is currently on hiatus from Jeopardy! as she sits out in solidarity with the ongoing WGA and SAG strikes.
Jeopardy!, Weekdays, check local listings
This… Is… Jeopardy!
Get absolutely everything about Jeopardy! in your inbox!
Conversation54 Comments
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Comments are closed on this story.
-
B
Of all the criticisms of her hosting style, I don't know if I ever heard anyone say "she's too surprised" when contestants get a question correct. If she hosts in the future, the bigger question will be whether they told her to stop the forever-long pauses before affirming a correct answer, interjecting herself into the middle of a contestant's answer, etc. Was she critiqued on any of the things that people actually criticized her for?
15 2
-
G
30 seconds must seem like an eternity to you!!LOL
2 6
-
-
M
I believe that Ken Jennings has been the best host since we lost Alex. I think that he has earned the job for being knowledgeable, witty, he knows when to make a joke or comment about a player or an answer. I just feel comfortable watching the show when he hosts. Mayim, to me is a good understudy, but somewhat robotic and slow with the yes or no to an answer. IMHO
14 2
-
M
Ken Jennings should be the only host.
10 1
-
R
I don't understand why Jeopardy! needs two hosts. Is Ken wanting a stand-in or does Sony feel obligated to keep Mayim on? If not, I personally see no reason why Ken is not the full-time permanent host of Jeopardy! After all, he is the one and only that can honor Alex Trebek properly. Mayim can say anything she wants but she had no rapport with Alex, no love for him as Ken does, really no relationship whatsoever! So why her? This is a conundrum!
On another note, does Mayim really earn in four (4) episodes as much as Ken earns yearly? If so, terrible!
11 2
-
R
She wants to be the best host she can be and I want her not to be a host at all. She's an actress, Ken Jennings is the Jeopardy guy. That's it.
17 8
-
O
Ken sucks. Plus he’s a SCAB!
2 12
-
O
Ken is not a SCAB! Game show hosts are governed by different rules than writers and actors. So do you think Pat Sajak and Michael Strahan are SCABs as well? Because they’re all doing the same thing as Ken. So I think you need to recheck your information.
9
-
-
B
I agree about Ken being the Jeopardy! guy. But Brooke is an excellent host on Master Minds and was an excellent host on the original "Chase." And you are correct, she is a wonderful actress as well.
3
-
-
B
Brooke Burns is certainly a fantastic game show host as well as a wonderful actress! I love her on Master Minds and I loved her on the original Chase (BTW don't know why she wasn't hired for the new Chase on ABC!) I have also been a fan of hers from all her Hallmark movies including the the mystery series "Gourmet Detective!"
8
-
O
I think that Ken Jennings does a fantastic job as host, he's smart, very witty and knows when it's proper to make a joke or a comment on someone's answer. IMHO, he should be the only person to host. As far as Mayam goes, I think that she is a decent host, but, to me she comes across as I little bit robotic, not as smooth as Ken. Of all the celebrities that hosted the show she's #2 behind Ken. I don't expect everyone to agree with me. That's fine.
9 2
-
O
Brooke Burns is the best game show host on the air right now. Her trivia reading skills are second to none, and she's brilliant. She kills it over on Master Minds, but Jeopardy might be a little bit slow paced for her skill set.
8 1
-
B
But I still love Ken for Jeopardy!
8
-
-
G
Bialik is simply too full of herself. She needs to study the concept of humility assiduously.
13 6
-
C
I wouldn't say she is too fun of herself. Actually, Ken has that problem more than Mayim. Ken is the better host, but given his vast experience with the show and the game, he should be. Not sure if Mayim will ever be back but I have enjoyed the enthusiasm she brings to the show. Jeopardy! desperately needed a female voice and she provided that.
4 12
-
-
L
That is the only thing you found wrong with her hosting? Keep looking. She has gotten to the point of really being annoying. Since she has taken over she has not grown with the part like Ken Jennings has. She has just become more obnoxious. Again, that is the only thing you found wrong? The list is growing.
12 6
-
O
Actually, YOUR the annoying one.
2 11
-
-
K
The bialik should be fired. Now. As in, immediately. Go back to the stupid little sitcom on fOX. We intelligent people do not want to see you at all. smh
10 7
-
G
Great. Now you want her fired. If she gets fired, I hope you get fired from your job you selfish loser.
1 4
-
G
So you think you’re intelligent, oh PLEASE Jealous maybe,envious without a doubt!! One thing I’m sure of you will never ever be as smart and successful as she is!!!!
1 8
-
K
Who cares. She sucks. I hate her. And interestingly, so does Jeopardy!
-
-
-
P
Just pull the trigger and either go to Ken 100% or give someone else a 1 year trial contract. I vote for Robin Roberts. I also like Buzzy, but realize there are reasons to keep trying to get the right woman for the job.
The writing is on the wall. I think Mayim herself may back down if the criticism continues. She's is simply not good.
8 6
-
B
Why does there need to be a woman. There are many women hosts. Check out GSN. Ken is so deserving of the Jeopardy! title. Look at who they chose for Wheel of Fortune! Really? Ryan Seacrest needed another job like a hole in the head!
5 1
-
-
G
That is the only thing you found wrong with her hosting? Keep looking. She has gotten to the point of really being annoying. Since she has taken over she has not grown with the part like Ken Jennings has. She has just become more obnoxious. Again, that is the only thing you found wrong? The list is growing.
4 2
-
O
Actually, YOUR the annoying one!
1 5
-
-
G
Ken Jennings is far and away the better host! When Mayim is at the podium, the game drags and it appears that she is always waiting for a producer to tell her the contestant was correct. Ken is waaaaay more personable, witty, and warm. Mayim appears to be faking her way thru the interactions with the contestants. Please give Ken the hosting job exclusively!!! PLEASE!!! Watching Mayim is no pleasure.
-
R
Be more specific,what disgusting acts or questionable views enlighten us! No need for research if you seem to know what they are!! Do tell!!!!! Make it short and sweet!😜
-
R
Ahahahahahahaha
-
R
I wouldn’t, go that far!lol
1
-
G
Auto correct dumb***
1
-
K
It would be so much better better if the bialik was simply fired. Jeopardy! fans do not need that silly, dumb host. Then, I could begin watching ALL Jeopardy! shows again, not just ones that are hosted by Ken Jennings.
PS Bob you should "go to hell."
1
-
G
It’s people like you that prove to me how much of a petty selfish jerk yin are. You want her fired because you just don’t like her as a host of a game show. If she gets fired. I hope you lose your job and you can see how it feels you piece of garbage.
1
-
-
R
Mike Davies did not sign on mayim,she was already hired when Mike Davies took over for Mike Richards!!Get your facts straight before posting! She was also hired before ken Jennings ,he was not their first choice!! Google it !!!
2
-
R
If they wanted to get rid of her they could do it easily if she violated the contract!
2
-
R
You can’t be that stupid, what makes you think you can just walk in and take a student’s place.IT doe’s not work that way,if it did any dummy could go to college! Mayim was smart enough and could afford it!!! Besides, what she doe’s with her education after that is really nobody’s business!! Ken was a software engineer but gave that up to be a co host of jeopardy!!!! You go where the money is!!So ken is just as unethical as you put it as mayim!!!!
2
-
R
If it’s all about the game then what’s the big deal of who the host is!! Oh I see it’s ok when ken hosts but when mayim hosts it,s a different story!So before you tell us he’s better then mayim don’t, WE KNOW BETTER!!!!!!
2
-
G
Be tried for the longest time. I’ve defended a Mayim constantly and all I get is this hatred for her. This complaining has gone on for well over two years and these fans want her to see her get fired. That’s why I finally went off. I do agree that Ken is a better host but she’s still solid and doesn’t deserve to lose her job. If fans are going to be this petty then why not cancel the show. This show is about the contestants not the host.
2
-
R
Hey, we agree here!
2 4
-
R
That surely deserves a down vote!
-
-
R
Now you bring her son into it!!!! SHAME ON YOU!!!Didn’t think a ken troll would stoop that low!!!!Not surprised tho!!!!!!!!
3
-
R
I guess you haven’t seen the nasty and vulgar comments about mayim from the ken trolls!!Give that little speech to them. Practice what you preach pal!!!!
3
-
R
According to Mike Davies the ratings are the same, no matter who the host is!!!!So I wouldn’t count the chickens before they hatch ok! Let’s see
3
-
G
Embarrass myself. I haven’t been complaining about Byrne host for two years like you loser fans have, I only suggested it because if you hated her as host, try and do something about it. You hate fans like you that won’t stop complaining for over two years an about the host. It’s a game show. If you all you fans are that earth about a host of a game show then I couldn’t care less about any of you loser fans. You’re all embarrassing.
3
-
R
Love her hosting style, brings a lot of positive energy to the show.
10 13
-
G
For everyone that wants Mayim fired from her job because you don't like her as host shows me how petty you are. She hasn't done anything to do to deseved to be fired. The only way she leaves the show is on her own or whenever her contract is up, then maybe they won't renew it. ou should never want someone to get fired from there job if they haven't done anything wrong. You might not like her style but she does her freaking best because it's probably no the easiest show to host.
If by some chance Sony fires her because of pressure from you fans, then I hope two things happen. One they eventually cancel the show because you jerks got your way and second, for everyone that wants her fired (and Ken as well) then I hope someday karma hits you in the backside.
1 6
-
G
Really? If Sony wanted her gone, she’d be fired by now. Another loser comment by a loser fan.
5
-
G
There are three sure things in life. Death, taxes and people still complain about wanting Mayim gone. Based on this article, if Mayim didn't correct her issue, I seriously doubt she would've been named one of the two host. So unless something drastically changes when the strike is over, she's going to eventually return. So I guess as I long as she is host, you fans will continue to complain as long as she is host. Even a decade from now, this is going to go on.
I put a challenge out to all you Mayim haters and no one had the stones to respond back or even consider it. If you want her gone that bad, either put out a petition to have her removed or contact Sony. All your crying isn't going to get you anywhere. Have the stones to do something about it or you'll continue to look like a bunch of 2 year olds as long as she is one of the host.
2 7
-
O
What's all the fuss? She's been a good host from the start. Get over yourselves already.
9 15
-
G
TO ALL YOU FANS THAT WANT MAYIM OUT. GO TO HELL
7
-
C
I love the fact that there is diversity. Just as water seeks its own level, different personalities will naturally be attracted to the their own, particularly from a judge's seat.
1 9
-
P
I thought she was great.
5 13
-
O
So sick of the A Hole Ken trolls!
10
-
O
Your sick or full of yourself😂
2 12
-
K
I much prefer Mayim to Ken, as he can be condescending .
2 12
Watchlist Easy access to only the shows you care about — all in one simple place
Alerts Only important notifications — when a show is returning, when it becomes available to stream, and more.
Special Offers Exclusive products we release related to your favorite shows and streaming services