Which CW Show Do You Most Want to See Renewed? (POLL)

Meredith Jacobs
114 Comments
'Walker,' 'Kung Fu,' and 'The Winchesters'
Rebecca Brenneman/The CW; Justine Yeung/The CW; Eliot Brasseaux/The CW

Change is underway at The CW, and chances are we won’t see all of our favorite shows back for the 2023-2024 season.

After Nexstar acquired 75 percent ownership of the network, first season shows Walker Independence and The Winchesters did not receive orders for additional episodes; each ended with 13. Nexstar executive vice president and chief financial officer Lee Ann Gliha said there would be “minimal” carryover to next season.

So far, the only current CW scripted series to be renewed is All American. The Flash and Riverdale are currently airing their final seasons. Nancy Drew will be ending with its fourth season, which will premiere on May 31. (Stargirl ended after three seasons in December 2022.)

The CW has also turned to unscripted shows, such as with the pickup of FBOY Island and the addition of a spinoff FGIRL Island. Plus, the network has partnered with CTV and Fremantle for Sullivan’s Crossing, set to make its U.S. debut in fall 2023.

That leaves the futures of the following shows still up in the air: All American: Homecoming (wrapped Season 2 in March), Gotham Knights (in Season 1), Kung Fu (in Season 3), Superman & Lois (in Season 3), Walker (in Season 3), Walker Independence (wrapped Season 1 in March), and The Winchesters (wrapped Season 1 in March).

All American: Homecoming is a spinoff of the only show to be renewed. Walker Independence and The Winchesters are both spinoffs of established series (Walker and Supernatural) for the network. And Superman & Lois is the only show connected to the Arrowverse left with The Flash ending.

And so, we’re asking you to vote in our poll below and choose which show you most want to see renewed. You have two weeks, until Wednesday, May 17, at 4/3c.




Conversation114 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Comments are closed on this story.

  1. R

    RedGoggles

    I absolutely love All American: Homecoming. I think it should be renewed

    19

  2. R

    RedBone

    All American Homecoming needs to be renewed. Love the show and the peope

    18

  3. R

    RedBone

    All American homecoming by far!

    17

  4. G

    GreenFlask

    I love all American homecoming definitely needs another season

    15

  5. G

    GreenCarrot

    All American Homecoming really needs to stay. It really is popular and watched by many people

    15

  6. P

    PurpleTeepee

    All american and all American homecoming

    15

  7. O

    OliveFan

    Renew All American Homecoming, PLEASE!!!! One of my favorite shows! Renew! Renew! Renew!!!

    14

  8. R

    RedPlane

    All American and All American Homecoming off top. Those are my top choices. I would love to see another season of the Winchester as well to.

    14

  9. C

    CyanPin

    All American:Homecoming should be renewed. I absolutely love this show

    13

  10. C

    CyanTree

    All American homecoming please renew great show so love it!!!

    13

  11. O

    OrangeDog

    All American Homecoming for sure!!

    11

  12. O

    OrangeBike

    All American homecoming

    11

  13. B

    BlueChefHat

    All American and All American Homecoming are the BEST!!!!!

    Please renew!!!!

    11

  14. G

    GreenSushi

    All American Homecoming definitely shouldn't have been on the chopping block. Renew this show!!!

    9

  15. O

    OliveLocomotive

    All American and all American homecoming

    8

  16. P

    PurpleBlowdryer

    All American homecoming!!!!!!!! I need to know who she picks!!!!!

    8

  17. R

    RedCupcake

    All American & all American homecoming !! We need both

    8

  18. O

    OliveBeer

    Save all American homecoming for sure

    8

  19. C

    CyanBottle

    All American and All American Homecoming

    8

  20. O

    OliveBullhorn

    Keep All American and All American: Homecoming!!

    8

  21. O

    OrangePopcorn

    I hope they renew All American Homecoming. I enjoy the show and everyone in it. We got to know who Simon picked

    7

  22. P

    PurpleSubmarine

    All American Homecoming need to renew it's a must

    7

  23. E

    Ebone

    Plz renew All American Homecoming…love the show

    7

  24. C

    CyanFish

    All american homecoming and all american

    7

  25. O

    OrangeTag

    Alll American. Love that show.

    7

  26. G

    GreenCarrot

    All American Homecomig

    7

  27. B

    BlueSnow

    All American Homecoming!!!

    7

  28. C

    CyanBike

    All American Homecoming

    7

  29. G

    GoldAnchor

    All American Homecoming

    7

  30. G

    GreenRocket

    All American and all American homecoming are my fav two because all my superheroes are ending

    7

  31. O

    OrangeCherries

    All American Homecoming For Sure

    7

  32. B

    BlueBullhorn

    All American homecoming for sure!!

    6

  33. O

    OrangeCherries

    I like all American home coming

    6

  34. O

    OrangeCoathanger

    All American: Homecoming a billion percent

    6

  35. B

    BlueBandAid

    Please keep All American Homecoming 🙏🏾🙏🏾

    6

  36. O

    OlivePaw

    All American Homecoming!

    6

  37. C

    CyanFish

    All American homecoming

    6

  38. B

    BlueCactus

    All American home coming

    5

  39. C

    CyanBus

    All American: homecoming

    5

  40. P

    PurplePizza

    All American: Homecoming PLEASE

    5

  41. G

    GreenElephant

    All American homecoming!

    5

  42. P

    PurpleDucky

    Keep all American and all American homecoming

    5

  43. R

    RedTurtle

    All American HC needs to stay.

    5

  44. O

    OrangeTree

    I absolutely love Walker Independence. Grew up watching westerns, so I'm older. Very intense, twists, a great ensemble cast. We need this western. So many stories lines to be told.

    6 1

  45. P

    PurpleBattery

    All American Homecoming!

    4

  46. B

    BlueChefHat

    All American Homecoming, ALL AMERICAN HOMECOMING, ALL

    AMERICAN HOMECOMING

    4

  47. R

    RedFlask

    Please renew All American Homecoming! We deserve to know who Simone ends up with at the very least

    4

  48. B

    BlueRadio

    All American: Homecoming!!

    4

  49. C

    CyanStrawberry

    All American Homecoming

    4

  50. B

    BlueFan

    There is no poll so I’ll comment… all American homecoming!!!

    4

  51. G

    GreenGoggles

    Renew All American Homecoming!!

    4

  52. O

    OliveCone

    All American Homecoming

    4

  53. B

    BluePlanet

    All American

    4

  54. O

    OliveSword

    All american Homecoming

    4

  55. O

    OrangeBottle

    All American homecoming

    4

  56. O

    OrangeAirBalloon

    All American Homecoming

    4

  57. O

    OliveBoomerang

    All American and all American homecoming renew renew please

    3

  58. G

    GoldBottleOpener

    All American homecoming by far is the best hands down it’s truly amazing please renew it

    3

  59. R

    RedCloud

    All American Homecoming!!! My favorite and we need more!

    3

  60. C

    CyanWeights

    All American homecoming and All American

    3

  61. T

    Thabo Lekganya

    All American should be renewed. I really love the show.

    3

  62. C

    CyanStrawberry

    All-American Homecoming!!! Please and Thank you

    3

  63. O

    OliveBullhorn

    All American Homecoming

    3

  64. O

    OrangePopcorn

    ALL AMERICAN HOMECOMING PLEASE!

    3

  65. P

    PurpleChilli

    All American: Homecoming

    3

  66. O

    OliveBandAid

    All American and All American Homecoming for sure. My favorites.

    S.W.A.T. As well

    2

  67. O

    OliveBeer

    Homecoming I love this show

    2

  68. B

    BlueSword

    All American Homecoming!!

    2

  69. B

    BlueFlower

    My top choices are All American & All American Homecoming! The others can go!

    2

  70. P

    PurpleMustache

    All American homecoming Damon needs is chance with Simone finally 👀👀🫢

    2

  71. O

    OrangeCandy

    All American Homecoming 🥰

    2

  72. G

    GreenRocket

    all american homecoming

    1

  73. R

    RedButton

    Renew All American Homecoming!

    1

  74. O

    OlivePaw

    All American and all American homecoming

    1

  75. P

    PurpleCorn

    Renew All American Homecoming! It is such a great show

    1

  76. R

    RedApple

    All American and All American:Homecoming

    1

  77. G

    GreenElephant

    I really like the show watch it with my family they definitely 💯 need too renew it so good I also watch all American homecoming just absolutely love 💕 both the shows

    1

  78. G

    GreenElephant

    I love watching All American and All American Homecoming

    1

  79. C

    CyanScissors

    All American Homecoming and Superman and Lois

    1

  80. C

    CyanFish

    All American, All American Homecoming, and Superman and Lois

    1

  81. C

    CyanCoathanger

    I really want Kung Fu to be renewed, but I feel like the new owners of the CW network aren't going to want a show with so many Asian and Pacific Islander actors on it.

    1

  82. R

    RedPretzel

    All American homecoming !!!! Can’t leave a show off like that !!!!

  83. P

    PurpleMustache

    Renew All American Homecoming

  84. C

    CyanBottle

    All American definitely!

    Want to see where Spence and Olivia end up and Layla and Jordan. 😊

  85. B

    BlueProcessor

    All American Homecoming please.

  86. G

    GreenSushi

    All American and All American Homecoming

  87. B

    BlueSword

    All American.. All American Homecoming and East New York…I LOVE THESE SHOWS

  88. P

    PurpleDucky

    All American homecoming !!

  89. P

    PurpleFlame

    All American homecoming !! Renew pleaseeee

  90. O

    OrangeCherries

    All american homecoming

  91. C

    Chelsea Brinkley

    Love the show

  92. G

    GreenWrench

    ALL AMERICAN AND ALL AMERICAN HOMECOMING!!!

  93. G

    GreenTurtle

    All American EVERYTHING!!!

  94. C

    CyanAirBalloon

    All American homecoming, for sureee

  95. G

    GoldRing

    All American Homecoming !

  96. R

    RedApple

    All American Homecoming

  97. B

    BlueChefHat

    ALL AMERICAN HOMECOMING

  98. B

    BlueCone

    All American: Homecoming

  99. G

    GreenPretzel

    AA Homecoming for sure. You definitely can’t leave viewers hanging like that, and by the comments it’s pretty clear 👀

    1 1

  100. B

    BlueBoomerang

    All American Homecoming

  101. R

    RedLobster

    All American and Home coming BOTTTHHHHHH

  102. B

    BlueHelmet

    All American Homecoming

  103. C

    CyanPumpkin

    All American Homecoming

  104. L

    Lynda

    I really enjoy All American Homecoming

  105. G

    GreenPalmtree

    All American homecoming

  106. R

    RedPlane

    Keep all American

  107. O

    OliveBoomerang

    And save Superman and Lois. My family and I gather to watch it.

  108. O

    OliveBoomerang

    Save All American:Homecoming

  109. B

    BlueCactus

    All American Homecoming

  110. O

    OrangeTree

    All America Homecoming

  111. O

    OrangeDog

    AM HOMECOMINGGGG !!!

  112. B

    BlueDice

    All American ❗️❗️❗️🫶🏽🫶🏽both of them I love them they should stay and go on and on baby it’s getting good

  113. E

    Erica Brodie

    None of them to be honest. To be honest no offense but back in my day The Archie's was a wholesome comic strip book or paper Archie Andrews was interested in two girls Betty and Veronica not Betty, Veronica, Sabina, Josie, Victoria, Melody, Sally, Suey or Joey in Riverdale I've went gee whiz Archie whom haven't you slept with or gotten with romantically? I know that's the Adult version of the Archie's or Riverdale but I love wholesome TV shows and movies exspecialy when children are watching these shows.

  114. K

    Kate Sullivan

    I don't have much faith in much being renewed at all, but I'd like the current Tuesday night to be renewed. I love Superman and Lois, but I am also finding myself liking Gotham Knights a lot more than I thought I would, though, the way they are going, they could have a satisfactory single season if they more or less deal with the Court of Owls. Harvey may make his transition but they don't have to deal with him yet, but I could also see Two Face playing a longer game with them by sort of aiming the Knights at certain targets and like Stephanie and her father are a longer story that they could just hint at. And like, you figure that Duella is probably not the Joker's daughter, but I imagine that will come at a point when she realizes that particularly Carrie and Turner, don't care about that at all.

    I think Kung Fu ended its story, so, I would be fine with that going away, sure there are things to be curious about, like was there more to the show's insistence on keeping Nikki and Henry apart. Or did Nikki and Zhilan get any of their powers back or are they gone too?

    1