Who Wore the ‘Magnum P.I.’ Hawaiian Shirt Best: Tom Selleck or Jay Hernandez? (POLL)

Tom Selleck as Magnum, Jay Hernandez as Magnum in 'Magnum P.I.'
CBS/courtesy Everett Collection; Karen Neal/CBS

The aloha shirt is always in style on the island, and Thomas Magnum has long been a fan.

We’ve seen the iconic TV character wearing the tropical style numerous times, both on Tom Selleck in the role on the original Magnum P.I. (eight seasons, from 1980 to 1988, on CBS) and on Jay Hernandez in the reboot (four seasons on CBS since 2018, saved for a fifth premiering on February 19 on NBC). In fact, sometimes an identical fashion statement has been worn by both actors, nearly four decades apart, thanks to the styling department!

Back in 2019, during the reboot’s first season, Hernandez told TV Insider, “in the seventh episode, Higgins [Perdita Weeks] presents Magnum with his first aloha Hawaiian shirt. That was a cool, earned moment.”

Keep reading to take a look as well as find out where you can buy each for yourself, then vote for who you think wore the Hawaiian shirt best: Selleck or Hernandez!

Does this Calla Lily Purple shirt from Paradise Found look better with Selleck’s chest hair or buttoned up à la Hernandez? According to the company, Selleck picked out the shirt personally from their showroom in downtown Honolulu in the ’80s.

Tom Selleck as Magnum, Jay Hernandez as Magnum in 'Magnum P.I.'

CBS/courtesy Everett Collection; Karen Neal/CBS

First of all, this Jungle Bird shirt from Paradise Found is in the Smithsonian Museum of American History! But who wore the parrot and foliage pattern better?

John Hillerman, Tom Selleck in 'Magnum P.I.'

CBS/courtesy Everett Collection

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by MAGNUM P.I. (@magnumpi)

Both Selleck and Hernandez have worn this Star Orchid Black shirt from Paradise Found as Magnum. Whose arms do you prefer in it?

John Hillerman, Tom Selleck in 'Magnum P.I.'

CBS/Courtesy Everett Collection; CBS

Both actors also wore this Magnum Bamboo Navy shirt from Paradise Found on the procedural. The shirt actually went out of production in the ’80s, but they brought it back in 2018 (just in time for reboot fans to buy it).

Tom Selleck as Magnum, Jay Hernandez as Magnum in 'Magnum P.I.'

But who do you think wore the Hawaiian shirt best? Let us know in the poll below.




Conversation76 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Comments are closed on this story.

  1. G

    GreenPalmtree

    Hands down Tom Selleck! He is gorgeous then and now!

    22

  2. O

    OliveUmbrella

    There was, is and always will be ONLY ONE MAGNUM P.I. with Selleck, Hillerman, Manetti and Mosley.

    End of discussion.

    25 4

    1. G

      GreenWrench

      Truer words were never spoken

      1

    2. O

      OliveHelmet

      I was at the Cantalas night club at the top of Waikiki, when Frank Sinatra, Tom Selleck, Hillerman, Larry Manetti and Roger Mosley all walked in, Frank Sinatra was in Hawaii for a week doing shows and this was his last night. Best of all, they were ALL in whilte tuxedos. Jay Larrin at the piano, I thought I would faint, it was a sight to behold. This was about 1983, I lived there a long time.

      2

    3. G

      GoldPuzzle

      Amen!

      1

  3. B

    BluePlanet

    Tom Selleck, hands down and no question about it.

    17

  4. B

    BlueBullhorn

    Tom sexy Selleck did. Love him.

    16 1

  5. B

    BluePaw

    Don’t agree with the results. I think it depends if you remember the original. While jay is good, Selleck is better all the way around. Just find it hard to imagine the police commissioner rocking the Hawaiian Shirt today😂

    12 1

  6. O

    OliveBullhorn

    Loved the original and the reboot, too. But Tom Selleck was/is the sexiest of the two Magnums, especially in those short shorts back in the day!

    10

  7. B

    BlueUmbrella

    Tom Selleck Hands Down. He is the only Magnum.

    9

  8. P

    PurpleTeepee

    I've been a fan of both shows!

    I think Selleck looks better in the shirts than Herandez does.

    I even own each of the shirts mentioned in the article myself along with a few other colored versions. Bought the 1980's versions at Paradise Found on Oahu during a mid 80's visit to the islands & bought the more recent versions in 2018 from the store via phone order with the store.

    Have always been partial to the comfort of the older style version especially the black & red ones.

    9

  9. C

    CyanStrawberry

    Tom Selleck no doubt about it!!

    8

  10. B

    BluePlanet

    Selleck

    8

  11. G

    GreenElephant

    Tom Selleck hands down wears the shirt best! And portrays Magnum best too!!

    6

  12. B

    BlueBoomerang

    Tom Selleck of course!! No comparison!!!

    6

  13. O

    OliveClover

    Tom Selleck. A lot of the people who would vote for Selleck are no longer around, so the voting is not really indicative of his popularity. I watched about 1/2 hour of the new "Magnum PI," and tuned in to something else (probably a book.) I simply did not like the new interpretations of the characters.

    11 5

    1. F

      Fran Breece

      Hey there are lots of around were not that old. I don't like the new Magnum series. Higgins in the original was awesome. He had that dead pan humor that was so delightful. Why did they feel the need to replace Higgins character? Why not an all male cast? They ruined the new one with her. I watched one episode and that was it.

      1 1

  14. G

    GoldScooter

    Absolutely Tom Selleck!!

    6

  15. G

    GoldMustache

    Jay is handsome…but too young for me! Tom Selleck wore a Hawaiian shirt with a Hawaiian attitude, and it looks great!!

    6

  16. B

    BluePaw

    Selleck

    6

  17. B

    Bob

    I liked both shows individually....TS is 14 years older than I; in the 80's he was 38 in his prime; I was 24 and could only dream of ever looking that good! Different era...Two different body types in comparing these shows....Selleck oozed testosterone-ic maleness and athleticism.....On the opposite-Jay is sleek sophistication and his sexiness (Im a hetero sexual male-I lust after Perdita Weeks! Haha), so he is not "Hunky", but sophisticated "James Bond"....Its unfair to the actors to compare the two...Two diffferent body types/two different eras,two different shows....I like each actor in interviews...classy....I am 65, selleckis 78....I used to dream to look that good!....Jay H fits the modern era male put out by media perfectly for this time....So I value each on its own merits.

    5

  18. P

    PurpleRing

    Tom wore it better.

    5

  19. R

    RedBee

    Tom Selleck hands down. If he wasn't the best, why do the new creator's copy so much of the past.

    Paului A. Ferrari

    Zoom zoom

    5

  20. C

    CyanRaindrop

    Tom Selleck..He will always be the better Magnum.

    5

  21. G

    GoldPuzzle

    Tom Swllic of course. He would look good in a paper bag. Three piece suits on Blue Bloods also look fantastic!

    4

  22. O

    Olive8Ball

    Tom Selleck. He is the MAN!!

    4

  23. P

    PurpleChilli

    I love the new show, but do not ask me to vote against Tom Selleck.

    4

  24. O

    OrangeFish

    No contest...Tom Selleck and that sexy eye wink still makes me quiver!!!

    4

  25. P

    PurpleCar

    I'm a big fan of the reboot with Jay Hernandez. He wears the shirts very well!

    6 2

  26. R

    RedHat

    Don't like new show. Tom Selleck looks best, wears the shirts best and will always be Magnum, hands down!

    5 1

  27. O

    OliveHelmet

    Tom Selleck absolutely looks the best. I lived in Hawaii for 16 yrs, and all anyone wears is aloha shirts and still do. Both men are look fabulous.

    3

  28. R

    RedElephant

    Definitely Tom Selleck. I was a fan of his throughout his show and there is no one better at playing Magnum better than Tom Selleck.

    4 1

  29. G

    GreenWrench

    No one can ever hold a candle to Tom Selleck ever!

    3

  30. G

    GoldMustache

    Selleck all the way! Jay is god but Thomas was supper!

    3

  31. O

    OrangeBike

    I'm an 80s girl so for me it's always going to be Toms Magnum for me.

    3

  32. G

    GoldAnchor

    Tom Selleck hands down!! He was the idol of that era!!!

    3

  33. O

    OliveTooth

    Tom Selleck!!!

    3

  34. R

    RedSushi

    Tom Selleck.

    3

  35. R

    RedCoffee

    Tom selleck

    3

  36. G

    GoldWheel

    Jay is FINE, but there is no substitute for TOM SELLECK! I love him on Blue Bloods.

    2

  37. P

    Pam Olson

    I have been a diehard, Tom Selleck fan from day one. When he’s on the front of the TV guide, I cut his picture out and keep it in my dresser drawer. He will always be the best magnum to me

    2

  38. G

    GreenGoggles

    Selleck for sure

    2

  39. O

    OliveProcessor

    Jay Hernandez

    2

  40. C

    CyanController

    Tom Selleck!!! Jay is good but Tom is way better and carries the Hawaiian shirt look the best!

    1

  41. P

    PurpleCar

    I like both Magnums but I have to go with Tom Selleck looking the best in the shirt. WOW!

    1

  42. O

    OrangeScissors

    Definitely Tom Selleck wears the shirts better!! Had a huge crush on him then & now!!

    1

  43. O

    OrangeStrawberry

    I love both shows. Great reboot. But you just can't beat Tom in his shirts..

    1

  44. P

    PurpleHammer

    Jay Hernandez, for sure!

    1

  45. G

    GreenApple

    Tom Selleck

    1

  46. O

    OliveBandAid

    Without a doubt it’s Tom Selleck, is and always will be my favorite Magnum.

    1

  47. G

    GreenElephant

    There has always been only one Magnum!! and it can only be Tom! Still sexy on Blue Bloods.

    1

  48. O

    OliveBeer

    Tom Selleck looks good in the shirts.

    1

  49. R

    RedButton

    Tom Selleck looked better in everything

    1

  50. B

    BlueBullhorn

    Tom selleck. He could wear a paper bag and make it look sexy. Hernandez is very good though

    1

  51. O

    OrangeStrawberry

    Tom Selleck. No contest!!

    1

  52. G

    GoldBlowdryer

    Jay Hernandez

    1

  53. C

    CyanLamp

    I prefer Hernandez in this shirt. He does not need to show his chest to wear the shirt well.

    2 1

  54. T

    Teri Root

    Jay Hernandez wears the shirts best. He is handsome and in terrific shape. Although I have nothing against Selleck, he always looked like a pornstar on Magnum. Hairy chest, the mustache, and those ridiculous high wasted short shorts - yuck! Jay is classy and fun to watch!

  55. G

    GoldHammer

    Tom Selleck of course. He will always be “Magnum”! Although I am kind of shocked when I see those short shorts.

  56. F

    Fran Breece

    I prefer Tom Selleck in the shirts, he looks better than Herandez

  57. O

    OliveClover

    Hands down--Selleck always!!

  58. R

    RedBowtie

    Definitely Jay because he wears it the correct way. My father was a Pearl Harbor Survivor and was stationed there again in 1960 for 3 years when I was a baby. He was a big fan of the Hawaiian shirt. He liked the original Magnum show but it drove him crazy that Tom Selleck wore the shirt tucked in. He said that's not the way to wear it and defeats the purpose of a cool airy shirt. So now when it drives me crazy too. Tom is handsome, true, but he wore it all WRONG!

  59. G

    GoldGlasses

    Tom Selleck is and always be MAGNUM!

  60. C

    CyanBottle

    There is only one Magnum and it is NOT Hernandez!!

  61. R

    RedBulb

    No-brainer....Selleck!

  62. O

    OliveSnow

    Tom Seleck. No contest

  63. O

    OliveBoomerang

    Selleck even today did not lose his sex appeal..

  64. G

    GoldBlowdryer

    Jay all the way!!! Luv more the new Magnum and with a Higgins in it. Old Magnum to much of 'childish' manner and Tom Selleck not like Wow as Jay. Just how i feel.

    1 1

  65. B

    BlueTooth

    Tom selleck of course

  66. P

    PurpleTrumpet

    They both wear it well.

  67. G

    GoldRing

    I love Jay in the Hawaiian shirts. I watched the original Magnum and always thought it pretty good but I also like the newer version. The storylines are more interesting and I like the cast better.

    3 3

  68. C

    CyanPin

    Tom selleck of course

  69. R

    RedBee

    Tossup

  70. B

    BlueBandAid

    I love both Magnums... but I love Jay Hernandez.. the entire cast has great chemistry & the episodes are great!! Please keep Magnum PI on forever... I really enjoy watching this program...

    1 2

  71. B

    BlueCactus

    Jay wears it best it looks better on his tanned arm. Jay Hernandez is the best.

    4 5

  72. J

    Jena

    I think a lot of people regard the original Magnum via rose-colored glasses. It was a good show back in the day, but watching it now, it's not that great. The current Magnum isn't perfect, either, but it's entertaining. I think Jay Hernandez is good as Thomas Magnum.

    5 8