Roush Review: Board Syfy’s ‘Ark’ at Your Own Risk

Richard Fleeshman as Lt. James Brice and Christie Burke as Lt. Sharon Garnet in 'The Ark'
Review
Aleksandar Letic/Ark TV Holdings, Inc./SYFY

The Ark

Matt's Rating: rating: 2.0 stars

Not since the SS Minnow of Gilligan’s Island has there been a more ill-fated vessel than the hapless title spacecraft of The Ark, a proudly cheesy sci-fi potboiler from Independence Day’s Dean Devlin. If it were a B movie (which would be a step up), I’d expect to see this Poseidon Adventure in orbit cheerfully mocked on Mystery Science Theater 3000. At the very least, it gives NBC‘s La Brea a run for its money as the most stupefying and imbecilic sci-fi show on TV.

'The Ark'

(Credit: Syfy)

 

Those with a hearty appetite for crisis-of-the-week storytelling will most enjoy this overheated yarn. Set a century in the future, the show opens with the exploratory Ark One interrupted mid-flight by a catastrophe that wipes out the part of the ship carrying all of the elite command. The overwhelmed Gilligans left behind, jolted awake from cryogenic sleep a year early, are a motley bunch of cardboard characters, forced to rise to the occasion upon acknowledging, “Everyone who was qualified is dead.”

It’s one calamity after another: limited food and water, oxygen depletion, hallucinations, a collision course with an asteroid, a murder mystery, inane dialogue (“I won’t lie to you: We’re in a tight spot”). By the fourth (felt like 40th) episode, I couldn’t help think that the officers who never woke up were the lucky ones.

While the few ranking lieutenants squabble over leadership — only Richard Fleeshman (The Sandman) as cocky navigator James Brice shows star potential — it’s up to the ship’s nerdy youngsters, including breathless chatterbox Alicia (Stacey Read) and gung-ho horticulturist Angus (Ryan Adams), to save the day.

What they all could use is a good Noah.

The Ark, Series Premiere, Wednesday, February 1, 10/9c, Syfy




Conversation5 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Comments are closed on this story.

  1. R

    RedTurtle

    Couldn't disagree more. I really enjoyed it!

    2

  2. P

    PurpleBattery

    Sounds like fun!

    2

  3. G

    GoldDucky

    I enjoy this series, and hope it sticks around. What's more, my husband likes it and he isn't a sci-fi guy. A little slow at times but they are in need of nearly everything, all at once. Gotta remember part of the ship exploded and most of the command crew got killed. So some of the others needed to step up. If syfy is smart,(given the name change several years ago from Sci-Fi to the anacronym SYFY thus dumming it down) not sure what they are likely to do.

  4. V

    Vorksigan

    Currently, The Ark is the BEST show in TV in my opinion. The show is over way too fast because each episode is a cliff hanger and make me excited for the next!

  5. O

    OrangePopcorn

    I’ve enjoyed every episode. It’s fun watching them overcome the impossible in every event. The characters are interesting, too.