5 Ways ‘Chicago Fire’ Could Fix Its Truck 81 Dilemma With Kidd & Pelham

Miranda Rae Mayo as Stella Kidd, Brett Dalton at Jason Pelham in Chicago Fire
Adrian Burrows Sr/NBC

Chicago Fire has a bit of a dilemma on its hands at the moment: two lieutenants qualified to lead Truck 81, but only one spot.

Following Captain Matt Casey’s (Jesse Spencer) move, Deputy District Chief Wallace Boden (Eamonn Walker) was under the assumption that Lieutenant Stella Kidd (Miranda Rae Mayo), who thought she’d have to leave 51 with the promotion, would take over. But she was off busy with her “Girls on Fire” program, and floater Jason Pelham (Brett Dalton) became a permanent addition to the house.

When she came back, she wasn’t leaping at the opportunity to take over as lieutenant, but she also was uncertain of Pelham. But she successfully led the charge in fighting his termination against a chief who had it out for him. And she was the one to deliver the good news: He was (still) in as Truck 81’s lieutenant. “You’re a part of 51, Pelham,” she told him. “We got your back.”

But as Kidd showed when she was filling in as acting lieutenant, she can do the job. So what does this mean for 81 going forward? How might Chicago Fire resolve this issue?

Pelham Leaves 51 by the End of the Season

The facts are simple: Mayo is a series regular, Dalton is not (though that could always change). Because of the chief who had it out for him, Pelham spent his time floating until he landed at 51 — and they were clearly the first ones to fight for him (when he wasn’t even doing so for himself). Now that the truth has come out about the chief, maybe he’ll be able — and want — to find a new home at one of those houses.

Pelham Becomes 51’s New Battalion Chief, Kidd Takes Over on Truck

Sure, it probably would be too soon for Pelham to make that jump — he’s not even a captain yet — but this is a TV show and that would be one way to keep both at 51 and onscreen. After all, they haven’t filled that spot following Boden’s promotion (though he is back in his old office and at times seemingly still taking care of those responsibilities).

Brett Dalton at Jason Pelham, Miranda Rae Mayo as Stella Kidd in Chicago Fire

Adrian S. Burrows Sr./NBC

Pelham or Kidd Moves to Another Shift or House

Anything can happen, including a transfer, for any of these characters (though, again, Mayo’s status as a series regular does seem to suggest she’s not going anywhere).

Kidd Does “Slow Things Down a Bit”

Just because Kidd’s now a lieutenant doesn’t mean she needs to take command; Christopher Herrmann (David Eigenberg) didn’t for years after he passed the test. And she did tell Boden when she returned from her extended leave, “I’m still very excited to become a lieutenant. I just want to slow things down a bit and take advantage of everything I can do now, too.” She now knows she can do the job, but that doesn’t mean she has to just yet.

Kidd or Pelham Dies

After all, this is a dangerous job, but would it be too dark in both cases — Kidd, with the upcoming Stellaride wedding, and Pelham, who has finally found a firehouse?

Chicago Fire, Returns, Wednesday, February 23, 9/8c, NBC




Conversation18 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Comments are closed on this story.

  1. C

    CyanPopcorn

    If anyone be promoted to captain it should severide, maybe transfer Pelham to squad lieutenant and kidd take over truck

    9

    1. B

      BlueCactus

      If Severide does get promoted to captain via passing the captain's test, he'll still be in charge of squad 3 as Squad Captain. Pelham cannot take over Squad 3 as he's not certified nor trained for it. You need to be certified to be on a rescue squad unit. It's likely Pelham would be transferred to either another shift or another house once Stella indicates she's ready to take over command of truck 81. Until then, Pelham is staying on in charge of T81.

      1

  2. O

    OliveRadio

    Matt casey needs to come back, not the same!

    4

  3. G

    GoldTrumpet

    I miss Casey so much!

    4

  4. C

    CyanFish

    bring Matt back

    2

  5. R

    RedCarrot

    There another scenario, and that's if Hermann retires. I'm reality,he's way past the age where most firefighters retire. That would free up another spot. And maybe even a Molly's spinoff 😀

    2

    1. R

      RedTurtle

      Yea. That could be possible and it'll be interesting to see Herrmann retire to have more time with his 5 kids and managing Mollys full time. It would give Stella reprieve from co-managing it with Herrmann, allowing her to continue on Girls on Fire if she decides to become Lieutenant by taking over Engine 51 from a retired Herrmann. In reality, I believe both Mouch and Herrmann are approaching retirement age already. They're both in their late 50s/approaching 60s.

      1 1

  6. C

    CyanGuitar

    What dilemma? Stella said herself she wants to step back from Lieutenant for now. She just raised chaos to get Pelham his job back. Pelham is a good lieutenant, he deserves to run Truck 81. Herrmann passed the lieutenant test in season two and didn't accept a lieutenant position until season seven, when Boden promoted him to Engine lieutenant.  

    The whole reason Stella ghosted Kelly for MONTHS was because of the pressure, she told him that herself. She liked being in charge when Pelham was suspended and said it was fun. But when she returned 10x10, she told Boden she wanted to step back from being a lieutenant.

    3 1

    1. C

      CyanWeights

      Stella is the lieutenant of 81, Pelham to go elsewhere.

      1 1

    2. B

      BlueCactus

      Yes, while Stella wants to step back from taking command of T81 and her duties as lieutenant, it's not just because of the pressure and her fear of not living up to everyone's expectations of her. It's also because it has something to do with her Girls on Fire program: she doesn't want to abandon it because of the impact it had on young female teens. She wants to make sure she can have someone take over and handle it for her once she becomes lieutenant of T81 because her duties and responsibilities of command prevents her from continuing on the program full time as she doesn't anymore have time to do any of that. On top of her responsibilities as an officer, she also helps Herrmann in managing Molly's and both are in addition to doing personal things such as errands and groceries and sharing home duties and chores with Kelly. I believe eventually, once Stella has indicated she's ready to take over T81, Pelham would probably make way for her by transferring to either another shift or another house. Until then, he's staying on T81 as its officer while Stella continues to test the waters so to speak and get a feel on whether she's really ready to take over command of T81. I think there's also one other possible reason why Pelham is gonna continue on T81 for a while: If Sylvie does leave for a while to visit Matt again maybe for a shift or two, there's a chance Stella could temporarily become Violet's ambo partner as she did previously serve w/Brett on ambo 61 temporarily

      3

  7. R

    RedApple

    Hey, Stella had plenty of opportunity to grab the position and SHE chose NOT to call Boden back. Pelham won fair and square. I LOVE Stella as a character, but I also think Pelham should be given a fair shake!

    1

  8. C

    CyanLamp

    Oh and I also forgot they also got rid of hottie Clark, Jones and also Capp’s girlfriend, the nurse, they could’ve made a nice little love drama with Capp and his girlfriend there. Capp and Tony don’t get too many lines in the show, why is that? Like I said, they get rid of all the good looking actors, this is entertainment for crying out loud! Writers get with it! Bring some excitement to the show! Or I’m going to stop watching. 😞

  9. O

    OrangeBottle

    I love Chicago Fire,but they need to bring Matt Casey back.I miss seeing him.

  10. R

    RedBone

    A lot of people have missed that they kind of did fill Boden’s spot as Batallion Chief. There was a throw away line by Gallo I think at the beginning of the season that mentioned the Batallion Chief 51 would now fall under the command of. Of course TV magic could just undo that throwaway line.

    1 1

    1. B

      BlueTooth

      I think that after Season 5 when Kelly's dad set him up to become Battalion Chief in Springfield, then groomed to become the Fire Commissioner,it showed that Kelly could take over as Battalion Chief and take over the Blue Office at 51 Headquarters. It would mean he would have to give up Squad, which he may not want to do, but it would be an interesting plot arc. Also, why can't Stella get Squad certified and take over as Squad Lieutenant, Kelly becomes Battalion Chief, then Pelham stays as T81 Lieutenant, makes for another interesting plot arc.

      1. R

        RedTurtle

        It wasn't Kelly's dad who tried to set him up to move to Springfield to be a battalion chief there, it was Commissioner Grissom. Also it was quite a form of corruption in a sense as Grissom was gonna use his connections to make Kelly jump the shark over others by directly becoming chief by bypassing captain rank and Kelly saw right through it. Kelly has shown no interest in higher rank due to the fact he doesn't want to be buried in paperwork seeing how it makes Casey frustrated much of the time. Kelly loves being in the thick of the action in command of squad 3. Also, to answer your question as to why Stella can't be squad certified? Well, she hasn't indicated she wants to and T81 is undermanned already and will even be more if she leaves. Also again Kelly cannot be Battalion Chief as he has to go through captain rank first before becoming chief.

        1. C

          CyanWeights

          It was not Grissom, it was Kelly’s dad. He said as much in Season 5 when Anna went back to Springfield after the bone marrow transplant and Kelly stayed in Chicago. I don’t remember the episode but it was in Season 5.

  11. G

    GreenWrench

    Stella will fill a LT. position when she's ready..not the case right now that's why she never called are came back to claim it..she dont want to do the position right now.I think it would be better if she did a LT. position at another house to allow some space with her and kelly..that would be better.Pehlam doing a good job he deserves the position..he earned it.Anyway Stella and Kelly getting ready to get married..focus on personal life first..then deal with professional.

    1