Poll Results: Will You Keep Watching ‘NCIS’ Without Mark Harmon?
NCIS fans are entering new territory with the October 18 episode, “Face the Strange”: What will the show look like without Mark Harmon’s Leroy Jethro Gibbs?
Harmon’s character exited the drama in the October 11 episode, “Great Wide Open,” with Gibbs deciding to stay in Alaska and not get his badge back following his suspension in Season 18. A series of farewells to the team culminated with Gibbs telling McGee (Sean Murray) his plan and the two saying goodbye before the agent left his former boss fishing and returned home.
And so we asked you, the fans, if you’re planning to still tune in to the long-running CBS procedural without Gibbs. It is, after all, a major change. With 2930 votes — so far, the poll is still active — on Monday, October 18, the clear winner was “No, there’s no NCIS without Harmon/Gibbs,” with 1040 votes (35.5%).
But coming in second is “Yes, every episode” with 838 votes (28.60% of the vote). The series has seen quite a few cast members come and go and people are still tuning in each week (even with a night and time change), so it sounds like some people are planning to stick with the show itself.
Coming in third is “Maybe, it depends on the first episode without him” with 669 votes (22.83%). Will “Face the Strange” convince these people to stick around? Or might it be the last episode they watch?
And coming in fourth and last is “Yes, but it’s no longer a priority,” with 383 votes (13.07%). After all, there are plenty of other options, whether people want to watch something else live (like The Voice, The Big Leap, and Dancing With the Stars), see what’s streaming, or perhaps clear their DVRs.
NCIS, Mondays, 9/8c, CBS
Conversation131 Comments
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Comments are closed on this story.
-
O
Nope. They've gradually lost all their best characters, but without Gibbs, it's not even NCIS anymore! They need Tony, Ziva, Abby, and Gibbs back!
58 7
-
B
I love the show and I love all the people on it. I will definitely miss Gibbs, but they have a great cast and I think they can hold up their end with good writers. Been watching since the beginning.
33 4
-
G
Will keep watching as long as writing is good and plot is interesting!
21 1
-
R
Inasmuch I like Mark in his role as, “Gibbs,” I will continue to watch this very creative show. Seriously, when “Kate” died, I couldn’t fathom her replacement. But this show did not “replace” her, but created a new character, Ziva. Then when she left, they created another new , Bishop. Same with the character, Abby. When she was leaving, many thought it would be done because how do you replace Abby!!? You don’t; you bring in Kassie who has established her character as someone original. She owns it and does an outstanding job!! Tony was irreplaceable but Torres brought his character into the light and he’s awesome.
The show will not only survive, but it will be better!! Have to say the only other NCIS that works just as well is LA. Never liked New Orleans nor does Hawaii work so far. But it’s my honest opinion.
24 5
-
C
No, I will stop watching without Mark Harmon. There's no one who's as compelling or interesting. Lovely, talented...but not Gibbs. He was the glue. NCIS will go out like "Mom" without Anna Faris.
22 4
-
G
Tonight’s show was excellent and very well written. Thoroughly enjoyed it. I believe there will be no problem keeping a strong audience with episodes like this one.
18 4
-
C
Loved tonight’s episode with Gary Cole. Yes, I miss Harmon, but the show is too good to pass on it.
15 3
-
C
No. I’m done with NCIS. Love McGhee and Vance, but it ends there. Plenty of other programs to explore.
9
-
G
It’s always been about the franchise, from J. A. G. onward. Some of the spin-offs have wandered but never the core. I’ll be watching.
11 5
-
O
J a g was an amazing show
1
-
-
G
I really think CBS has very little respect for the actors or the fans of their shows. They moved CSI Miami to Sunday night knowing full well football games would knock it out. Moving NCIS to Monday was bad enough, but the loss of Gibbs on top of it.....it won’t last.
5
-
R
Will watch until they go away..great show
5
-
C
I won’t be watching the show anymore if he’s not on!
6 1
-
G
Rest of the cast can't carry the show.....good bye!
6 1
-
O
Nope. You cannot have NCIS without Gibbs.
They are his rules, it is his team, no one else can do the kids slap, no one else can be Gibbs and no one can fill his shoes... Gibbs is the face of the show
4
-
P
I will watch tonight to see how the show goes just because I’ve watched the others in which Gibbs didn’t appear. I do not like Gary Cole as a replacement for Gibbs, he doesn’t have the spirit, the personality, the good looks or the charisma.
6 3
-
O
I will keep watching to see how it goes
3
-
C
Pleasantly surprised by last night's episode. I liked the touches of humor and it felt right for a new guy in charge. I'm not ready to make a commitment yet, but will keep watching for a while. Still better than NCIS Hawaii.
4 2
-
R
I was on the fence until McGee didn’t get the team lead job. Very poor choice by the writers to go this way. Nope. Not the way it should have gone.
2
-
G
After last night's episode, I will give it a chance. Especially since I saw the intro with all the pics of Gibbs.
2 1
-
G
I will continue watching
1
-
O
I will continue to watch. I like the cat but will miss Gibbs.
1
-
O
Change is what life's about. I'll miss Gibbs on NCIS, but I do like Gary Cole and the energy he brings to the role.
1
-
R
Will probably keep watching until it gets cancelled.
1
-
O
Definetly would keep watching. I’ve been watching since there very 1st episode with JAG.
1
-
O
Yes, I will. I have watched this show from the very beginning. I like Gibbs, will miss him, but hopefully he willl return in cameo appearances. All the other casts are great too, even the new ones.
1
-
G
I've been watching since the JAG days. I will always be a Gibbs fan and understand completely when it comes to new characters being introduced. I will continue to watch and give Gary Cole a chance, just like everyone else who came along. After tonight's episode, I definitely want to see how he does.
1
-
P
agree
2
-
-
G
Shoot I stopped when Tony left!
1
-
R
I plan to keep watching. One of the few clean shows left on television. Thus far, they have stayed mainstream without trying to make statements. Has kept me a fan for years while I’ve watched less and less television series.
1
-
G
They have made statements but it's always in context of the military. They just didn't get political.
6
-
-
O
Need to change back to Thurs. or Fridays
-
G
NCIS LA is still ok even without Hetty tho I miss. Her and would like her back. I miss NCIS NOLA and don’t get why it was cancelled tho I do like NCIS Hawaii.
-
G
NCIS without Gibbs is the final straw. It already was awful without Ziva, Ducky, Abby, Denozo. But his is it. No longer worth watching.
-
P
The show has turned into “milk toast”. There’s no convincing camaraderie with the team, agent Knight appears to be there to be cute. There’s no chuckle factor without Ducky. Kasie’s part is a tenth of what Abbey’s was. I believe because she doesn’t have the personality to pull it off. And where’s Vance? No “oversee” of the team lately. To much “personal”, while there was ‘personal’ before, it didn’t take half the episode and definitely not each week. And last night about Cole’s hair?? PLEASE!!!
There are a few reasons, we still watch —- —- for now: few new programs over the entire week ( excluding game and reality shows); nothing else but repeats, repeats, repeats. Some cast changes are in order of Cole and Law would be suggested.
-
O
While I like Gary Cole, his persona on this is more like Tobias Fornell. You need somebody that can play A leader, a hard ass, with a little bit of comedic sarcasm. While I’m not a fan of Ted Danson, he did a great job on CIS. Gary Cole doesn’t fit the bill. I love Jimmy but there isn’t that intimacy of speaking to the dead like ducky. Ducky had a lot of great stories, some great information that is factual. The episodes now, there are no Dynamics. Katrina Law doesn’t portray someone like Bishop who was analytical. Caitlin and Ziva and Bishop are regular agent. Katrina Law is model material. She’s a good actress but she’s better suited for model material roles. Right now Gary Cole comes off as a modern day and a little bit more animated than Joe Friday..
-
R
No l will stop watching and buying dvds without Gibbs
-
R
I think the last episode was AWESOME, I love mark Harmon, but Gary Cole brings a renewed freshness to the show. Haven't missed an episode and with Harmon gone I still plan to watch.
-
C
The only ones left are McGee and Jimmy so My family are not excited about the new characters or the show as a whole!!
-
C
I gave it a chance since Gibbs exited. I'm sorry, it's not the same. Even the acting seems less professional. The show has no life to it. I've started watching from the beginning for the third time.
-
B
The new shows are simply not up to prior standards. The show has gone from excellent to mediocre.
-
G
It's just not the same without Mark Harmon at the helm.. sorry CBS but I'm tuning out.
-
P
This Unhappy Camper is better satisfied watching re-run channel. Liked Cary Cole better in other shows.
-
O
NCIS will be very easy to pass up now. Miss all the past cast. Don’t enjoy Gary Cole or other newbies. We will probably continue watching reruns, not not the new season.
-
O
No show will not make it..maybe this season part of next but after that NCIS without Gibbs will forever be gone unless he returns. As for myself and wife it's over for us. Bring Gibbs back
-
G
I don’t like the actor Gary Cole in anything I have seen him in so if the writers make him in charge instead of McGee which it should be!! I will not be watching NCIS. I’m already done with the NCIS franchise because they took a perfectly great spin-off NCIS New Orleans off and I dvr that show every single week. So now with this Gary Cole as lead nope not gonna watch! NCIS Hawaii no good. I gave it a few episodes and it’s good they put a woman in charge but no means. So I’m done with NCIS. Best wishes for McGee and Torress kacie. They are all great. Oh Ducky and Palmer love yall too. The best thing for NCIS now would be put Vance and Gary on a ship and BLOW IT UP!!
-
R
no - you lost me!! No one will ever replace Gibbs - and your ratings are going to go through the floor!!
-
G
Yes l will liked the humor too
-
C
I have already given up watching but not because Gibbs left of the job didn’t go to McGee but because you replaced Gibbs with Parker. I despise Gary Cole and won’t watch anything he’s in.
-
R
No boring and do under any circumstance like Gary Cole never have never will. I will never watch again not worth my time
-
G
That’s a BIG NO! It’s had a very successful run w/Gibbs @ the helm. When they lost Ziva, Dinozzo, Abby, etc the show lost it’s rapport. Time to move on & find another show…
-
C
It seems a large percentage of people weren't watching the same show I was. "Without Gibbs there is no NCIS"? Really?
-
C
I MAY WATCH BUT WITHOUT GIBBS I WONT BE IN A HURRY TO WATCH .THEY NOW HAVE LOST ALL THE PEOPLE I WATCHED FOR TONY , SEVA ,BISHOP, AND ABBY ☹️😞😭
-
O
Will miss Mark Harmon he was why I watched the show along with Ziva. Will probably not watch the show not a big fan of the 2 new actors.
-
R
Gary Cole is the perfect replacement for Mark Harmon. Great job!
-
B
We need Gibbs,
-
O
I'm undecided. I have always loved the show and didn't watch it just for Gibbs but, to be honest, I've never been a Gary Cole fan. I'll catch an episode now and then but I don't anticipate it like I used to.
-
G
I'm not really sure.....I would miss McGee and Torres...but it is just not the same without Gibbs!!! And I never was a fan of Gary Cole....I'll watch it and see how it goes....but it is no longer my priority any more!!!! That was my all time favorite show...I watched it from day 1 !!!!
-
O
I like Gary Cole, but he is not Mark Harmon. I will probably watch the first one or two, but at this time it's a firm no for me.
-
G
Yes, I will watch. The writing is still strong and Gary Cole is a strong actor and will fit in quickly. I hope and expect Mark Harmon to reappear..infrequently.
-
C
Yes I will watch
-
G
Probably not. Too many characters I liked are gone. Gibbs was last straw…
-
R
yes i will still watch sorry to see him go.
-
C
Nope. It got boring and stupid. I quit following long ago.
-
G
I have watched the show for many years. Gibbs will be missed. The future of the show depends on the story line. Keep it interesting and it will survive.
-
O
Love, love NCIS!!! Will never miss a show!!! I will always be a Gibbs fan and understand he is probably tired and has a right to retire. I wish him and his wife the best life has to offer!!!
-
B
No, the show has been changed too much. Kate left, Ziva left, Tony left, Gabby left and now Gibbs. The new actors just can’t replace what was. Should have just started a totally new show. Thanks to these actors for making such a wonderful show!
-
B
Yes! I liked the episode I just watched. The other team members are strong
-
O
Yes, I’ll keep watching. Change is good.
-
O
No don't think I will. He made the show. Love him.
-
P
Bring Ziva and Tony back.
-
O
No I will not I have felt for the past few years the show has gotten old and very stale .
-
O
i had lost interest even with Gibbs so probably not. TV in general has really gone down hill for me at 84.
-
B
I love Gary Cole and while I liked Gibbs. I love Gary and am happy with the way things are going <3
-
O
No, to many have gone
-
G
Will watch reruns. It’s not NCIS without Mark Harmon.
-
B
I have watched the show from the beginning I believe he is the main character holding it together. Will not be much interested in it from now on. He made the show
-
O
I love the show! I will miss Gibbs! I sure will still watch it!! Been watching this show forever!!!
-
G
First Bishop left, now Gibbs and I do not like Gary Cole - he acts arrogant!
-
O
He will be missed but Gary Cole is a great addition to the cast
-
G
Once Gibbs is gone , no I will not watch it
-
O
No. Mark Harmon made it NCIS
-
O
Yes and if I need a Gibbs fix, There are reruns!
-
G
Yes, I will continue to watch however Torres has to stop whining so much.
-
O
keep watching
-
G
No ! it’s goin down hill, most of original cast is gone, now Gibbs ! 👎🏻
-
O
keep watching
-
O
I love Gibs character. No, will not watch the show. NCIS and NCIS LA is the only 2 show I take my time to watch reqular. I missed Tony character..
-
B
Not only will I not watch it without him, I won't, and never have, watch it with him.
-
O
Gibbs should stay on he makes the show, with him not on there is know show. I am from Canada.
-
O
Yes I will
-
G
Haven’t watched the show in years. Around S8 it was too much about families, emotions and tears. It totally lost the NCIS edge that attracted me originally. Even now I only watch the first few seasons on Netflix.
-
O
I feel like Jimmy when he said he’s seen too many come and go. Me too! Too many people gone. Done.
-
G
Yes I’ll continue to watch.
-
R
i quit after tony left
-
P
I'll continue watching to give it a chance. Gibbs was the center piece and the constant. His "culture" needs to remain the glue. Actually, the writers will determine the future of thisnshow. Have they changed?
-
C
I’m sorry. I’m trying to be supportive and did watch tonight but I’m not likely to continue. There was too much that just didn’t fit. I miss Mark Harmon terribly!
-
P
I definitely will continue watching NCIS, hopefully Gibbs will do some cameos! Enjoy your time off Mark (Gibbs) Harmon you will be missed
-
P
No, love McGee, disliked Tony, but watched all the shows & reruns. Don’t care about new people & Gibbs truly was the show. Too bad.
-
O
Hell no! Without Gibbs, there is no point in watching anymore. It was a great 18 years!
-
O
I’ll keep watching until I get tired and bored it won’t be the same without Gibbs so I’ll see
-
B
Sad to see him leave, but he didn’t die, so it’s possible he can return for some other episodes.
Yes, I will continue to watch NCIS. Still a very good show.
Tonight’s show, Ducky had a great response, so yes. Will continue
-
G
Nope... cancelled in our home... loved it with Zika... not as committed without her, now No... 100% no
-
G
I will miss him love the show watch every Season I wish he could stay and be happy
-
O
No I won't keep watching because the ratings are going to go down hill now that the main person left
-
G
Was very surprised. I liked Gary cole. I’ll watch.
-
R
I’ve been watching the show since day one and seen many people come and go. I was upset when they lost Jenny, and Kate and was really upset when Abby and Ziva left. They brought in Bishop and Kassie but they couldn’t and didn’t replace Abby and Ziva they didn’t have the chemistry. And I continued to watch but when I saw Gibbs bidding goodbye to McKee as he wept so did I, it was just too much. Now I hear Gary Cole could possibly be replacing Gibbs big mistake he always plays a creep or crook in what ever show he has a role in and he just doesn’t have the Gibbs vibe or class or chemistry. If he shows as a leading spot to replace Gibbs I’m done with NCIS. I don’t believe the show will do well without Mark “Gibb” Harmon.
-
B
Nope
-
P
No I will quit watching
-
O
Not the same show wo lead role
-
G
I'll continue watching.
-
P
Not good without Gibbs do not like Cole
-
G
Nope, I'll get the current season when it comes out on DVD and that's it.
-
C
He makes the show , no , I will not watch no more
-
O
It won’t be the same
-
G
I dont like that Mark Harmon is gone. He was great in the role. Personally, I do not care for Gary Cole. He is always a pushy and obnoxious character. So far with the couple of episodes he's been in, yep still the same type of charter.
-
P
I will continue to watch until the end. I’m a die hard NCIS fan.
-
O
I will continue to watch NCIS. It was Ducky that drew me in on the pilot. Been watching ever since. When David McCallum exits, then I'm done.
-
G
No it’s not worth watching without Mark Harmon
-
O
I love them all but it’s not the same with out Gibbs!!! I love Gibbs❤️❤️❤️
-
O
No I will never watch it again.
-
R
No thank you. I’ll watch reruns or something else. Can’t stand Gary Cole and the rest of the cast can’t carry the show. I’ll find some else……
-
R
I will keep watching but honestly the newest NCIS LA episode was awful. NCIS without Gibbs may be the only thing left to watch.
-
P
No .... I will watch until his last episode. But, then I think I will be done. It won't be the same without him. No offense to his replacement.
-
T
Yes
-
O
I stopped watching when they starting preaching which was a couple of years ago.
-
O
I don’t believe Gibbs made the show. He was a part of ncis a well written show. I greatly appreciate it how they represented our service man and woman. There has been a lot of amazing actors on the show. I personally appreciate ducky and McGee.It was like you could feel their heart. I will continue to watch NCIS.
1 2
-
O
Sorry !
No Gibbs and Im not watching! there is a new NCIS and Im not watching that one either! Sooo BORING!
1
-
G
I stopped watching after Ziva left.
1
-
R
Haven’t watched since Ziva left
1 2
-
P
Haven’t watched when that new last woman came on after Ziva’ left
2
