15 Worst Best Picture Winners
With days to go before the 97th Academy Awards, this year’s Best Picture race is still a tossup. Anora is our pick to take home the biggest prize in movies, but Conclave could pull off a holy upset.
Whatever the result is on March 2, there will be critics and moviegoers who will certainly say another film deserved the Best Picture Oscar more. And in the spirit of naysaying, we’re voting for the following films as the worst winners of the Best Picture prize.
Before you get too riled up, know that many of these selections were good films, just not the best films of the year. Here are the Best Picture winners we’d put back in the envelope…















Conversation27 Comments
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Register or sign in to join the conversation.
PurplePuzzle
"Dances With Wolves" and "Driving Miss Daisy" are great movies, too and they both deserved to win Best Picture.
RedBowtie
How about the shape of water it's good NOT. A Fishman that's the worst best picture ever. And you are a idiot every one of these movies are better than a shape of water
GreenBulb
“Gladiator” makes “The Shape of Water” look like “Citizen Kane”.
OrangeTag
In absolutely no way should Out of Africa be on this list.
PurpleCocktail
Dances With Wolves is a gorgeous film and beautiful story and audiences embraced it. You can shut up.
GreenBulb
I never saw “Dances With Wolves” but seeing that many top critics that year placed “Die Hard 2” as a more highly acclaimed movie than “Dances With Wolves” I am assuming I saved myself 3 hours of my life. Nick
Antonio Montealegre
The Greatest Show on Earth winning the same year the more enjoyable Singin' in the Rain wasn't even nominated is # 1 in this particular list for me!
OliveCactus
And Kramer vs Kramer over Apocalypse Now? Crazy
GreenBulb
I never saw “Kramer vs. Kramer” but it was more highly acclaimed than “Apocalypse Now” when it was released. Gene Siskel did not even give it 3 stars or a even a 2.5 star marginal “thumbs up” review and although I did like it I can see where he is coming from because “Apocalypse Now” is one of the most overrated films ever made and Gene Siskel figured that out from the beginning and obviously The Academy agreed. Nick
RedTurtle
American Beauty should’ve been on that list
OrangeBike
I have to disagree about Birdman and Argo. Both were great films that deserved the win, as did others those years.
GreenCarrot
While many of the films on this list may be undeserving of the top prize; many of the films suggested as replacements are inferior as well. "Citizen Kane" was not mentioned in the attack on the splendid John Ford film, "How Green was My Valley." A number of films were attacked on political grounds. This review seemed more intent on checking virtue boxes than addressing the merits of the films. In addition. there is little understanding of film history contained in this analysis.
Antonio Montealegre
CK is mentioned in the version of the article I'm reading.
OrangeTag
Oliver! instead of 2001: A Space Odyssey
Michael P Powers
Titanic.
PurplePuzzle
I know that there can only be one winner for each category for the Academy Awards, however, I think that both "Singin' In The Rain and" The Greatest Show On Earth" are great movies."Singin' In The Rain" is a great musical, and a great, wholesome movie for the whole family and "The Greatest Show On Earth" is also a great circus movie and also a great wholesome movie for the whole family. I do agree, however, that "Birdman" and "Around The World In 80 Days" should not have won.
Josh Johnston
I admire the effort behind BOYHOOD, but I don't get the love for that movie. Most of the acting is weak, the story is weak and rather dull.
"It took a decade to make." Technically, so did (all of) "HARRY POTTER."
GreenBulb
Yes but “Boyhood” took a decade to make on purpose and typically that kind of accomplishment / requirement would have been shunned by studios especially since it was obviously not going to be a money maker. So just the fact that enough people thought that it was an important enough of a film and one that had to be made is astonishing in its own right. “Boyhood” was one of the “better” films I saw that year and honestly if I had never seen it I would say I would not have missed out on all that much. It’s not like anyone really came out to see it when it was released simply because the finished product was a very good movie but far from a great one and it’s Best Picture nomination isn’t exactly for the film itself but more for the history of film. Nick
OliveCactus
What about Chariots of Fire? Snooze fest
PurpleDucky
Why isn't Cavalcade on your list? Plus while I agree Broadway Melody was not a great film you fail to mention what film should have won in 1929. Pretty much all films made that year were not that great due to the studios still transitioning to sound.
GoldHammer
You're absolutely wrong about 'Out of Africa's and 'How Green was My Valley.'
GoldBlowdryer
There is a difference between a list of the worst winners and the worst choices for winners. This list seems confused by that concept.
I have made the effort to see all of them (still to see Coda). A handful of these are clearly better than several not listed. Three that come to mind are Cavalcade, Grand Hotel and Tom Jones.
How Green Was My Valley is an average winner against other best pictures but it clearly should not have received the award against Citizen Kane. Rocky is in the same boat.
GreenBulb
If the Academy will give the Oscar to “Parasite” over “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood” and completely ignore “The Hateful Eight” then there is no telling what they will do. Tarantino should have a Best Picture Oscar for every film he has made since “PULP FICTION” (I do not count “Death Proof” as part of his 10 official films because it was something put together for the Grindhouse project and meant only for grind house type entertainment for the sole purpose of a good time at the movies) and they would not even nominate a masterpiece like “The Hateful Eight” to begin with. They could not even give “The Hateful Eight” all 3 of the measley Oscars it was nominated for and instead gave 2 of them to who knows what. If his “final” film “The Movie Critic” does not take Best Picture the year it comes out then it will be a travesty. Nick
GreenBulb
And I suppose “Parasite” is not at the top of this list because everyone has already forgotten that movie even existed. I walked on that movie about 1 hour in. What a travesty that Tarantino’s masterpiece “Once Upon A Time in Hollywood” didn’t take everything that year. Not to mention his “The Hateful Eight”, the greatest western ever made and one of the 10 greatest films ever made period, was almost completely shunned at the Oscars just to pave the way for a bunch of other films that no one will ever remember. Nick
GoldBlowdryer
Goodfellas is way over-rated. The acting was over the top.
GreenBulb
It is ridiculous that “Shakespeare in Love”, one of the greatest movies of it’s kind ever made, keeps getting backlash over winning the Best Picture Oscar in what was essentially the final year The Oscar actually meant something. “Saving Private Ryan” did not stand a chance against “Shakespeare in Love” and Steven Spielberg should not have won the Best Director Oscar over John Maden’s flawless direction of “Shakespeare in Love” and it was pointless to give it to him when his picture wasn’t going to win anyway and it just made the director Oscar that year look like a consolation prize. Movies like “Shakespeare in Love” are why I go to the movies and while it was not my choice for the absolute Best Picture of that year either it was in my top 3 behind “Life is Beautiful”, which had it’s own high scale praise at the Oscars that year anyway, and “Happiness” which is one of the 10 greatest films ever made but would never see the light of day at the Oscars because of it’s unofficial X rating. And where is “Gladiator” on this list? That is definitely the worst movie to ever win Best Picture and was one of the worst movies of that year altogether and goes with my statement that 1999 was the final year the Oscars meant anything. So anyone who can’t see the greatness that is “Shakespeare in Love” probably shouldn’t bother with seeing great movies in the first place. Nick
GoldPopsicle
Idiot