Which ‘When Calls the Heart’ Characters Will Be Back for Season 9?
When Calls the Heart‘s Season 8 finale may have just aired two days ago (May 9), but since we know it will be back for more, why not look ahead?
Characters have come and gone from Hope Valley over the years. Elizabeth Thornton (Erin Krakow) has made her choice — businessman Lucas Bouchard (Chris McNally) over Mountie Nathan Grant (Kevin McGarry) — but that doesn’t mean the town will lose one of its own, right? And just because a certain doctor has left doesn’t mean he won’t be back.
Who’s Definitely Staying?
We feel safe in predicting that Elizabeth, Lucas, Nathan, Faith (Andrea Brooks), Bill (Jack Wagner), Rosemary (Pascale Hutton), Lee (Kavan Smith), and Fiona (Kayla Wallace) are staying, given the way Season 8 ended for them.
After all, they were all still in Hope Valley when the finale ended. Plus, there’s just too much left to explore with them there. How does Nathan move on after Elizabeth chose Lucas? And since she made that choice, there’s no way that When Calls the Heart isn’t going to show them exploring a relationship. What’s next for Rosemary and Lee both career-wise (her paper, him as mayor?) and family-wise (will they have kids?)?
And considering how happy Faith was to be staying in town and not going with Carson (Paul Greene) to Baltimore (where he had been offered a fellowship at Johns Hopkins Hospital), we expect to see more of her in Season 9.

Crown Media
Whose Future Is Up in the Air?
As previously mentioned, Carson left town, but we have a feeling he’ll be back. After all, Faith looked like she wasn’t too happy that he had actually left in the stagecoach (even though she wasn’t quite ready for his proposal). Greene has been retweeting fans’ messages about his character’s (apparent) exit and even replied to one telling him to “get back here right now” with “okay.” We’ll have to wait to see if the Season 8 finale was truly the last time we see Carson.
We’re also wondering about Henry’s (Martin Cummins) future considering he also left town. He did also take a look at Abigail’s Café, suggesting maybe there could be something in store for him and Abigail. (Due to Lori Loughlin’s legal troubles, her character left town to take care of her sick mother.) The door is open for his return and this might be due to scheduling because of Cummins’ work on Riverdale.
Ok 👍🏻 https://t.co/UgQbfcu1t5
— Paul Greene Official (@paulgreenemedia) May 10, 2021
When Calls the Heart, Season 9, TBA, Hallmark Channel
Conversation70 Comments
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Comments are closed on this story.
-
B
Oh and bring back Abigail. She served her time and that has nothing to do with her acting ability. She is a great actress
60 19
-
O
canada laws will not allow her as a conficted felon to return there. So most likely will not return!
-
-
R
Nathan is a respectable mounty and great father. Lucas is a shady evil saloon owner. The show was a modern day Little House on the Prairie BUT lately been going down hill just like society.
39 14
-
R
Yay for Elizabeth choosing Lucas.
9 10
-
-
O
Just feel sad at the poor writing choice of Elizabeth picking Lucas. I’ve just lost my love for the show now. The whole show was about a Mountie and school teacher. First Jack dies so they never get to explore that relationship but she had another chance yet they had her chose Lucas. Just sad to me. I have no desire to watch it ag.
50 28
-
C
But didn't they explore the Mountie and the school teacher for 5 full seasons?? When Daniel Lissing decided to leave the story changed. I don't see why it had to be another Mountie for her to fall for. It would have been too similar. She told Nathan that it wasn't fair for her to keep looking for Jack in him. I thought that was very wise of her. Besides if the "spark" wasn't there for her with Nathan like it obviously was with Lucas in the scene in his office then it wasn't meant to be. I like Lucas and Elizabeth's easiness with each other. They were friends first...... they deserve a chance together. I'm excited to see their love story next season.
12 11
-
R
Lucas is a shady evil saloon owner. Nathan is a respectable mounty and great father.
1 3
-
-
-
B
I am so disappointed. I even said if she doesnt choose nathan, I quit WCTH. Lucas is just after Elizabeth like it is a game. Nathan is real. Lucas even used that book to draw Elizabeth. Lucas has money and flaunts it.
51 32
-
O
While I was Team Nathan, I WILL be watching next season. I love all the OTHER characters too & there are more stories than Elizabeth & Lucas to enjoy. I hope they find a new love for Nathan, but not Faith, I want Carson to come back to her.
8 5
-
-
O
I am looking forward to watching the next season. I am not sure Elizabeth has made the right choice. Lucas has been known to pull some shady deals before & I just don't fully trust him. As for Carson & Faith that could really be a interesting story.
32 14
-
O
So disappointed in the last three seasons especially season eight, the scene on the bridge was so out of character for Elizabeth. That kiss was so Sloppy! how can you kiss like that when you barely held hands? Usually her characters so prim and proper Trying to fix everything and please everybody not being spiteful. I used to go back and rewatch the show during the week I can’t even stand to watch IT now especially that final scene on the bridge. I can’t even go back and enjoy older seasons because of the way this season ended. It took a Turn for the worst, Elizabeth characters is just absolutely pitiful, she turned into a hateful, tease. The fight she had with Rosemary didn’t even make sense Rosemary was only being concerned for Elizabeth. I wish they’d send Lucas and Elizabeth back to Hamilton and make the show around Rosemary and Lee. That would be a fun storyline. But it doesn’t matter I’ve lost my love for the show I won’t be back next season.
53 40
-
O
Absolutely correct. Not in line with Elizabeth’s former character at all.
17 8
-
-
P
I was hoping Elizabeth would choose Lucas. However, I find it funny how fans will stop watching the show because of this. It is not REAL life, it's just a story!
20 10
-
E
Tell the fans that watches this show that and the ones on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram that and see what type of response you'll get back. And I happen to agree with you on that note and even if it was real life we all need to respect Elizabeth decision on whomever she chooses to love and to be with it is her decision not ours so we all need to chill out, it's not your life or your wife for that matter about Elizabeth and Lucas, she never loved Nathan in that way ok whenever she sees him he reminds her of Jack too much and she doesn't want to re live that life again with Nathan like she did with Jack, she needed to let him go and move on from him and the ghost of him with someone new like Lucas.
4 3
-
-
G
I think Elizabeth choosing Lucas is a bad choice. She is in love with Nathan. But the writers will do what they want, now if they would just write a scenario about Lucas leaving town for whatever business, possibly another woman from where he came from, and have her show up maybe Elizabeth can rediscover her love for Nathan. Also, I think its about time for Lee and Rosemary to have a child. Carson needs to return because of the love he has for faith, I know the opportunity is great for him but I think the love he has for faith is a greater option.
40 31
-
C
I don't think Elizabeth can "rediscover" her love for Nathan when she's never been in love with him. She loves him as a good friend only! And he is a great guy. He will find someone special. Maybe a new character?? I will be excited for that story also.
9 7
-
-
C
i think Lucas was the right choice for Elizabeth. He has a past that is for sure, but I believe that he is moving forward to do the right thing in his business deals and with Elizabeth, especially since he was willing to let her go to be with Nathan. That was truly unselfish on his part. I would like to see Abigail return with Henry, I think that relationship needs to be explored. Henry has been making amends for his past and as Abigail said, everyone deserves a second chance.
13 6
-
B
I'm glad Lucas and Elizabeth are together
40 33
-
B
We have not seen the last program of the season in Australia yet but I understand Elizabeth has chosen Lucas. I am very pleased. Lucas has shown over the season that he is, in fact, a very decent person. He always shows concern for Elizabth and always says he wants her to be happy. He never puts pressure on her. He supports her life interests particularly her writing, the library, the school and education, friendships and, of course, little Jack. He is very understanding of her need to have time to make her decision. Nathan seems to think that by just to saying "I love you" is sufficient to win Elizabeth's heart. He has no understanding of her joy in writing, or books or the joy she gets out of the school and teaching. In fact Nathan may be a good Mounty and a caring Uncle but he has very little else going for him. We learned at Christmas that Elizabeth loves big family gatherings and Nathan disclosed he does not like crowds. How would that work. I believe Lucas is by far the better partner for Elizabeth in life.
11 5
-
B
Wow, I loved the ending. As a single mom and a teacher, people assume all we are good for is taking care of children- our own and others. I love that Lucas has always supported her- the woman- and her dreams whatever they were. She and Nathan were not a good mix as far as chemistry goes. Did he even know she was writing a book? She was too serious with Nathan. And what- he was going to buy a place outside of town and have her take care of his niece and family? I never saw her smile much with Nathan. I like who she is with Lucas and he does a lot of good around the town- money isn't evil, and I haven't seen any evil going on in the saloon. Have we been watching the same show?
17 11
-
O
Maybe Henry left to go get Abigail.
4
-
P
I cant believe that she chose Lucas it turns me off the show.
10 6
-
P
I think it's awesome that Elizabeth picked Lucas. I think during the last couple of seasons he has proved that he has changed and I think he is a good guy. Nathan lied to her and I think he was using his daughter to tug at Elizabeths good heart string's.
8 5
-
O
I think season 8 episode 12, was my last WCTH ! The school teacher, and bar owner deal was the last straw for me, unless they pack up and leave town, if they don't leave town in season 9 episode 1, I'm leaving WCTH, and not looking back !
20 17
-
C
I won't watch next season.
It made more sense for her to pick Nathan. Sorry to see that the writers didn't see the logic.
5 3
-
B
LOVED that finale!! Lucas offers Elizabeth more in life than Nathan could - and she grew up affluent so Lucas was the best choice to give her and her son all the opportunities. I don't think she could "risk" her heart on another Mountie and lose him like she lost Jack. Great choice, Elizabeth! Can't wait for the next season! Hope Henry returns with Abigail and can't wait to see what trouble the Pinkertons are gonna bring.
9 7
-
O
Lucas was the best choice
7 5
-
C
I was hoping I was not the only one disappointed in Elizabeth's choice. There was so much more chemistry between her and Nathan than Lucas. Not quite understanding why it went down this way. Hoping she will change her mind next season - we'll see.
19 17
-
R
PLEASE PLEASE, find a way to “BRING JACK BACK”. I am still soooo sad over his death and departure. So many Hearties are STILL emotionally invested in their great chemistry and the authenticity of the relationship. They look like God made them for each other. I know you can find an ingenious and moving way to “BRING JACK BACK”. His return would ensure another 20 years on the air. It would take he and Elizabeth into Retirement. All of us would see Little Jack graduate from the Academy and take his
Dad’s place as Mountie of Hope Valley and marry Rosemary’s daughter.
Just DO IT—-BRING JACK BACK!!!!
1
-
G
I think that they should bring back Jack from the Dead . He was a better Fit for Elizabeth and a much better Actor than any other Mountie …
The writers could just say that he was Missing In Action . Who’s with me on this ?
2 1
-
O
If Elizabeth gets together with Lucas, I will not be watching this show, anymore.
2 1
-
B
Elizabeth made wrong choice. Lucas is a shady businessman and Nathan is a repected Mountie and family man. Hope Carson and Henry return.
2 1
-
O
I think I am done with the show.... nothing like the books...
4 3
-
B
Carson! We want Carson. Town isn’t the same without Carson. Let Hope Valley build a small hospital & have Carson running it!
1
-
R
Just SO disappointed in Elizabeth's choice of Lucas not too excited about this next season.
14 13
-
B
Love Elizabeth and Lucas together. He loved her enough to set her free.
15 14
-
O
Really!? I think Lucas was manipulating the situation. Did we all forget, Elizabeth almost got killed because of Lucas and another women. Lucas is not trust worthy.
4 3
-
-
P
Elizabeth made a poor choice. I will stop watching . Nathan was real.
27 26
-
P
I hope both Carson AND Henry come back, more so that Henry returns with Abigail.
1
-
G
I want Abigail back! I don’t care what she did, everyone deserves a second chance. She was good on When Calls The Heart.
-
G
My opinion of Jane doe's comment is that she really has not considered the character of each of the two people. I cannot recall any incident which indicated that Lucas was 'scum'. He has always shown that he is polite and caring, not only for Elizabeth but even the Church Minister during the heavy rain-storm, when he offered to send over coffee to the Church for those attending the meeting.
I also found Jane Doe's comment about 'maybe Elizabeth might whine if her heart was broken by Lucas'. This is another misunderstanding of the character. Elizabeth could never be seen as a whiner. She is a strong but caring person who has coped well at having lost her husband. She displayed an honest heartbroken young person but there was no whining.
I feel Jane Doe's comment is possibly a reflection on her personal life experiences rather than a considered view on the actual characters of the people in the show.
-
B
Are you kidding me? Best ending, kiss, ever!! If you didn’t like that kiss then you must have not like Jack either because they shared many kisses like that!! SMH..
-
B
Remember the scene with Bill and Nathan on the porch when a strange guy rode up to Lucas? Either Bill or Nathan said something to the effect....there's someone to keep track of or something like that......I think there will be many twists and turns in the upcoming season. Perhaps Elizabeth and Nathan have a chance if Lucas is not the guy Elizabeth things he is???
-
R
Daniel Lissing & Lori Laughlin will be on When Hope Calls Christmas 2 parter Dec 18 on GAC Family
-
R
Lucas is is scum Elizabeth will get her heart broken by him hope she does not whine about it
1 1
-
R
I think they should end the show permanently. They made Elizabeth into a awful character and Lucas is pure evil Nathan is better off without the town teaser wont say what i want to call the character of Elizabeth but she no class
-
O
That's just it...it's a story, so if we don't like it, we can just stop watching. It's not like they're beloved family where we're stuck with their bad choices.
-
B
Happy she picked Lucas
4 4
-
R
Why did Lucas smuggle his money into hopevally in a fish box? Something shady about him
4 4
-
O
No but her working ability in Canada is in jeopardy. Also shes on probation for 2 years yet
-
P
She got her passport back. Probably depends on her desire to come back & Hallmark's measure of forgiveness, redemption ,& 2nd changed they espouse. I would like to see her return with Henry.
2
-
P
chances*
-
-
-
B
I am disappointed in Elisabeth choice
I don't trust Lucas. I am interested in watching season 9u
3 3
-
R
I would also choose Lucas.
11 11
-
O
The character of Abigail could come back but not Lori Laughlin. Her character was so full of integrity & it would no longer be believable to have Lori Laughlin portray that person. Replace her then return her character to the show.
11 11
-
R
I think she made the right choice
16 16
-
G
I want be watching anymore!
Elizabeth has chemistry with Nathan not Lucas! She came from money but wanted to make it as a teacher on her own, and she was a fit in Hope Valley. She is down to earth and learned to love the simple life. Lucas does not fit Hope Valley. The writers are ruining the whole show with Lucas and his affluent life style he
is pushing Elizabeth back into! I hope they make him have a secret past and she ends up with Nathan. Nathan doesn’t need to be with Faith either. No chemistry there she is a Carson woman. I will be told by another friend if Elizabeth goes to Nathan. If not, I can only hope it’s not renewed after season nine!
They ruined it with Lucas! Never liked him from beginning!
2 3
-
B
We have not seen the final chapter in Australia yet. I believe Lucas is far more genuine about supporting Elizabeth and caring about her interests in all things particularly her writing and interest in books and education and, something very important, they have similar backgrounds. Lucas is proving himself more and more to be a decent person who has a better understanding of for interest, little Ally's concerns about Elizabeth's relationship with the two sutors. He is being more than understanding of Elizaabeth's situation and, as he keeps saying, he wants her to be happy. He is not putting pressure on Elizabeth which is very admirable. Nathan on the other hand seems to think that by just to saying 'I love you" should win her affections. He never seems to actually do or contribute to her life in any way. He has done nothing that indicates he even understands what is important to Elizabeth and to her life. This is important in a relationship and this appeals to me. Nathan just seems to want to WIN Elizabeth and they do not appear to have any common interests. She enjoys big family gatherings whereas Nathan does not like crowds. He appears to be too submissive of Ally and has not even tried to develop a relationship with her other than a common interest in fishing, which is not really a 'girl' thing.
Ann in Australia.
1 2
-
C
I too am off the show. I was quite surprised Elizabeth chose a "snake in the grass," but I will not be a fan anymore. The storyline has taken a turn toward boredom and keep loosing all the regulars. I did enjoy the addition of the black family and their sweet spirit. Hopefully they will add something to the storyline that is lacking.
3 4
-
C
i really wanted nathen she did not make a good choice!!😠
4 5
-
G
I am so disappointed with Elizabeth's choice!!
5 6
-
O
I am so happy Elizabeth chooses Lucas. He waited patiently for Elizabeth. He is a true gentleman who has a lot to offer.
14 15
-
B
Terrible season - Lucas and Elizabeth is a terrible idea! Won't watch next season. Such a loss use to be a great show that I couldn't wait to watch.
3 5
-
C
What has happened to the writing on this show? Throughout the season we noticed and commented that the characters we had come to know and love seemed to do "out of character" things - especially the women. If the writers were new to the show, that would explain it. They obviously don't understand the beloved characters or the historical time period. Elizabeth was behaving strangely throughout the season. She seemed much less interested in her teaching and students. She was always running around town and was rarely home with her child - odd for a single mom and teacher. Her treatment of Rosemary and the men in her life were out of character for her.
We were hugely disappointed in the final scenes. The ridiculous open mouth, endless kissing was completely out of place for the series and for a Hallmark show in general. The final "private reading" scene was especially disgusting and inappropriate. It seemed more like a soap opera or porn flick than a family show. Elizabeth choosing Lucas doesn't make sense for the series, but it was certainly made much worse by the overly sexy display in the final scene. Why not a lovely, closed mouth kiss and a passionate embrace?
And finally - where in the world did Elizabeth find the fancy dresses and low cut blouses she showed up in this season? Again - out of character for the series and time in history.
I hope Season 9 will be an opportunity to correct the mistakes from this season and bring the show back to standards.
9 11
-
O
happiness. How can you get better than that?
4 6
-
E
I want Abigail back maybe Bill might change his mind about Molly and get with Abigail instead. I love that Elizabeth picks Lucas and it wouldn't be fair for her to choose Nathan she sees Jack in him too much and it'll be like loving idea of Jack in him instead of loving Nathan. And it wouldn't be fair to him either thinking she was actually in love with him. The story was about a School Teacher and a Mountie and they're names were Elizabeth and Jack now that Jack's died why should she get with another Mountie and relive that story with Nathan like she did with Jack all over again? It wouldn't make sense anyway, besides this is a new story and a beginning for Elizabeth with a new love with Lucas and I'm happy that she found that in him.
7 9
-
G
Ii am also Very Disappointed with Elizabeth's choice!! May not be watching anymore.🤨
6 10
-
G
I loved the finale, Lucas is a true gentleman and loves Elizabeth deeply! The ending was truly amazing and so passionate, now that's a kiss!! Team Lucas won....Yay!!
42 49
-
R
Bravo! I loved her choosing Lucas.
7 9
-
-
B
I would like to see Faith and Nathan get together. They have both been dumped and understand how it feels.....
9 33
