Should Elizabeth Choose Lucas or Nathan on ‘When Calls the Heart’? (POLL)
Spoiler Alert
[Warning: The below contains MAJOR spoilers for the Season 6 finale of When Calls the Heart, “Two of Hearts.”]
Elizabeth Thornton (Erin Krakow) may be ready to move on after losing Jack (Daniel Lissing) on When Calls the Heart, but which man will win her heart: saloon owner Lucas Bouchard (Chris McNally) or Mountie Nathan Grant (Kevin McGarry)?
This season has hinted at the potential for either man to become her next new significant love interest, but it appears that Lucas may have the edge after the finale. Hope Valley celebrates its Founder’s Day Festival, and she shares moments with each, but the episode ends with the odds seemingly in the saloon owner’s favor. The last event of the day is a dance, and when it’s ladies’ choice, it sets up Elizabeth to pick between the two men.
Neither has another possible partner, but it’s Lucas Elizabeth approaches. But as they dance, she sees Nathan in the doorway, alone, and they exchange a look before the Mountie leaves. She may be dancing with Lucas, but that doesn’t mean Nathan is out of the running.
“I hoped to develop these two new, very different characters in such a way that both would be worthy of Elizabeth’s love,” executive producer Alfonso H. Moreno told ET. She makes the choice she does because in addition to being “charming, witty, vulnerable, and good-hearted,” Lucas “pursued her a little bit more than Nathan did.”
(Hallmark Channel)
But the EP also made it clear that Elizabeth hasn’t made her choice yet between the two, and he wasn’t even sure that will happen in Season 7. “I believe that there is a lot of humor, romance, and emotion that can arise from Lucas and Nathan seeking to win Elizabeth’s heart and Elizabeth having to decide who is the better man for her,” he said.
Elizabeth grew closer to both Lucas and Nathan throughout the season since they first arrived in Hope Valley. She has watched and helped Nathan with his niece, Allie, and after a couple conversations about the matter, has moved on from her life being in danger because of Lucas’ past. She and Lucas also worked together on the library that opened during the festival, but she and Nathan also shared a moment when he brought her a gift for the addition to the town.
Though the two men haven’t been overtly in competition with one another, they do test their strength in one of the festival games, only for Carson (Paul Greene) to be the one to ring the bell and win the fishing pole for Allie in front of Elizabeth.
Both men have their pros and their cons — Nathan comes across as a bit more clean-cut, but he is a Mountie, just like Jack was, while Lucas and Elizabeth have been bonding over books — so it’s not necessarily that easy of a choice, for Elizabeth or fans. Moreno “hoped that the social media fan base would be engaged enough to be split as to who was the worthiest choice,” and they are.
What an ending – yikes Elizabeth ….Lucas (hurt Nathan) Nathan (hurt Lucas) such a dilemma @ChrisMcNally_ @kevin_mcGarry @hallmarkchannel @WCTH_TV #Hearties
— Lynn Tourangeau (@tourangeau_lynn) June 3, 2019
Ok I can’t make up my mind @ChrisMcNally_ or @kevin_mcGarry. I hope Elizabeth has more insight tonight. @erinkrakow @hallmarkchannel @thebubblysesh #hearties #WhenCallstheHeart
— Beverly Heslin (@bheslin1) June 3, 2019
If #Elizabeth had chosen Nathan to dance with…we would be here feeling sorry for #Lucas and his sad eyes…it’s a triangle people, someone will lose! #hearties #WhenCallsTheHeart
— Rose🌹 (@rosilleri) June 3, 2019
Vote in the poll below and sound off with your thoughts on Elizabeth’s love life in the comments below.
When Calls the Heart, Season 7, Coming Soon, Hallmark Channel
For Hearties Only
Get absolutely everything about When Calls the Heart in your inbox!
Conversation154 Comments
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Comments are closed on this story.
-
R
Elizabeth should be with Nathan. Always and only Nathan
38 11
-
R
Debbie Blackman - Please no no no. #TEAM LUCAS says, "No Way"
10 15
-
R
Nathan ALL THE WAY
2 4
-
-
G
TEAM NATHAN!!!
17 5
-
-
P
Team Nathan all the way
33 7
-
O
No not Lucas, they just dont mix. She belongs with Nathan. Even though you tried to make Lucas look honest I just dont see that. I dont trust his character anymore. Nathan his more her type.
40 14
-
O
Y'all are HATERS Nathan is AWESOME.
He Never Got Elizabeth Killed
#NO MORE BAD BOYS
Lucas could be like that bad boy poet in the earlier seasons.
JEEZ TEAM NATHAN ALL THE WAY
GIVE THIS A BIG THUMBS UP IF U AGREE:)
31 13
-
C
Lucas will challenge Elizabeth for sure. The only thing that makes me take a step back is how secretive he is with his past. He either has to open up or leave, or maybe leave once we know his past. He almost got Elizabeth killed... yes he said he’d protect her, but she shouldn’t have been in that position in the first place. His gestures are grand and he seems to be pursuing her more, but for Elizabeth it was never about the grand gestures, it was the little things... or at least that’s how it was with Jack. She fell for Jack because he was himself, not because he bought her love. I feel like because of these grand gestures Elizabeth feels like she owes Lucas a chance because he’s done so much for her. However, Nathan is simple. He brings out some great qualities in her, and she seems to challenge him a lot. I’m worried about the whole “well it is just another Jack ending.” But, Nathan also has a niece, someone else that depends on him besides a women. I feel like that right there might keep him from having an ending like Jack. Also, Nathan’s character seems to be honest and true. That’s one thing I like about him. I just see Lucas putting in more effort and I feel like we need to see a little more of Nathan and Elizabeth to really make some kind of determination. I’m too conflicted. I love them both. In the eyes of who would be better for Elizabeth, I would say Nathan. I just feel like he is ultimately the better choice for her and for baby Jack.
25 8
-
O
Elizabeth should be with Lucas. They have so much in common: love of books, travel, family and other cultural things. Lucas is so loving and giving. He is good with little Jack. He and Elizabeth would have a wonderful, loving life together. Lucas all the way!
25 10
-
G
Team Lucas all the way! Lucas has better chemistry with Elizabeth! He has more authenticity and a better actor! He is more believable then Nathan! Nathan seems fake, less passionate! I love Lucas for his outstanding good looks and for his passion as an actor! I love his intensity and his on screen chemistry with Elizabeth! Nathan seems boring compared to Jack! I also don’t want more Mounties!
31 16
-
C
She needs to pick Nathan hands down!
There's just something about Lucas that I don't trust!
20 6
-
B
yes queen
1 2
-
-
G
Elizabeth should absolutely be with Nathan. Not sure I will continue watching if this doesn't happen. She should never be with a saloon owner. Always a mountie!!
18 6
-
G
Team Lucas always!
25 13
-
O
#Team Nathan always
16 5
-
O
TEAM NATHAN
14 3
-
O
Elizabeth should be with Lucas. They have more chemistry together. It would be too weird if she was with another Mountie just like Jack. You would think the life of a Mountie, the danger and being transferred around, would scare her off this time.
17 7
-
C
Team Nathan all the way
12 3
-
P
I think it’s time for Elizabeth to make a choice. All this going back and forth with 2 men. One week Lucas one week Nathan. Time out for me. She is leading them both on. She has them at odds now with each other. Please! MAKE A CHOICE
9
-
O
Team Nathan!
12 3
-
R
#TEAMLUCAS says "Just loved this last episode". Felt like it ended to soon. So hoping things Blossom more between Lucas and Elizabeth next season. Looking forward to it and the Chemistry between them. 💘💕
16 7
-
R
I am #TEAM LUCAS all the way.... I want Lucas to have Elizabeth and baby Jack. He is falling in love with her. He told her he would give all to save her and protect her. He also donated the building to her so she could have the town Library in it. He also help build the book shelves for the books and helped put the books on the shelf. He took a real interest in helping her out.
Someone said that Nathan gave her a plaque. Ok thats nice, but Lucas gave her do much more (see above) because hes falling in love with her. I'm ROOTING for you LUCAS. Go get her.....won her heart. 💞❤💘❤❤❤❤
19 10
-
O
I agree, I am also rooting for LUCAS.
5 5
-
-
P
Lucas is charming and Elizabeth should pick him
11 3
-
C
Team Lucas he’s hot
20 12
-
B
Nathan please! He is the best!!!!
10 3
-
R
NATHAN IS THE MAN FOR Elizabeth.
11 4
-
R
TRUE Nathan is the man.
11 4
-
-
G
Nathan is the best choice!
11 4
-
O
I'm team Nathan all the way! I think Lucas tries to hard...he is overly charming not for me. Nathan more suited for her!
15 8
-
B
Nathan, there is just something about Lucas I don't care for.
13 6
-
P
Love Lucas, but Nathan is a better fit for Elizabeth.
11 4
-
C
Elizabeth should be with Nathan of course!
13 6
-
P
Team Lucas please
18 11
-
G
Elizabeth should choose Nathan. They have way more chemistry and I will stop watching the show if she chooses Lucas. However, I do hope they bring in another female character to add some spark to Lucas’s love life.
11 5
-
B
Nathan - a selfless person - so much more of a family man -
7 1
-
P
i choose nathen he is so sweet and kind and would make a great match for Elizabeth
8 2
-
G
Team Nathan, don't you all want to see her marry a red serge. # bring back the classics
12 6
-
G
Nathan
11 5
-
O
Team Lucas he’s so hot
11 5
-
G
Elizabeth should be with Lucas. Nathan is good too but not another Mountie please. She would have to worry about him. We can't replace Jack...... Thank you for a great season .
12 6
-
R
Heartie at Downunder. . . Yay, another #TeamLucas person. So liking your comment you made. You right, " No more Mounties". Lets move on to bigger and better....Yes, nathan is a nice guy but, I just can't see him with her. The CHEMISTRY between Lucas & Elizabeth is very strong and I'm personally I'm loving it.
10 5
-
C
Yes Lucas will challenge Elizabeth. It will be fun to watch. Not another mountie, the story will repeat itself.
Team Lucas
12 4
-
-
P
She should go with Lucas only.
He is such a gentleman and kind and will take good care of her. …
Nathan is a good man but he is a Mountie and may go off and/or get killed like Jack did. She doesn't want to go through that again. Thank you for another season. It is such a good show.
Peggy
11 5
-
O
Lucas 100%
7 2
-
G
I AGREE!!!!!!
1 2
-
P
Lucas seems like he is hiding something, he wouldn’t make a good father, and he put her life at risk. Nathan does have a dangerous job and I understand why she would be scared. Lucas also seems like he is trying to hard and I see that Nathan doesn’t seem like he is trying much but he is shy.
1 2
-
-
G
I say Lucas he is kind and very good looking and helps in every way he can even those he has a past but who don't my money is on Lucas all the way !!!
9 4
-
G
Lucas! He is so in love with Elizabeth and loves baby Jack. He is very thoughtful and giving. Elizabeth has been with a Mountie and knows that his job can be dangerous, and she does not need to put her and baby Jack back in that position.
9 4
-
O
I say Team Lucas! Boring is she ends up with another Mountie! I say change it up a little bit . Lucas is by far the best choice and so easy on the eyes! Do the right thing Hallmark!
11 6
-
G
Has to be Lucas and here is why! When watching the sweet chemistry between Lucas And Elizabeth it makes me smile and feel the love between them. When with Nathan I struggle to feel the connection between he and Elizabeth, due to no spark; definitely no chemistry! Also why would Elizabeth be with another Mountie knowing the danger and pain she continues to have after loosing Jack !
9 4
-
R
Nathan
10 5
-
G
Lucas ALWAYS Lucas!!
9 4
-
O
Nathan
10 5
-
C
Team Nathan always!
13 8
-
B
Hope she picks Lucas, Nathan seems fake and arrogant.
14 9
-
O
#TeamNathan. Lucas almost got Elizabeth killed and Nathan tried to save her. Also, Nathan is raising Allie so he knows what it feels like to raise a kid.
8 4
-
G
Nathan all the way!!!!!❤️
8 4
-
C
That's EXACTLY what I say. Lucas allows her to expand her world. He offers mystery and emotional excitement. She has experienced the Mountie mentality; the red outfit has become tired and tedious.
4
-
G
Nathan!!!!!!! I feel like Lucas is a fake and a fraud!!!!!
10 6
-
R
Elizabeth needs something new and exciting so nathan just needs to leave. Lucas for the WIN!!
11 7
-
B
Nathan in my opinion is simply a bore. Lucas can give Elizabeth a much more exciting life. That would be my choice if it were me choosing. As far as looks , Lucas hands down. Nathan is kind of goofy . But looks aren’t everything. Beauty comes from within .
7 4
-
G
Nathan doesn’t do anything. And he is simply too childish. Lol he wines a ton!! Lucas is everything a girl could ever want. Plus Lucas is the one who saved Elizabeth from that guy in the saloon not Nathan. (But of course.. Nathan takes all the credit)
3 4
-
-
O
Well said! I think the show would lose that authenticity if they put her with Nathan and lose respect for her character. I would anyway.
5 2
-
P
Disagree. Nathan always has time for allie. Christmas, walks her to school, picks her up, girls sleepover, town gatherings. Christmas tree picking. With any profession when you have to go to work you leave your kids home if old enough, take them to day care or a friend or relatives. That's anyone. But I understand that's your thought and opinions. I agree he always 1 step behind but that can be a number of things. Shy, his better judgment pursuing a mountie widow, or he feels Elizabeth has more feelings for Lucas. Who knows it's a TV show. Don't know how the producers will spin it in season 8. Either way I'm sure they know they will lose some viewers. Risk I guess they were willing to take introducing 2 suitors.
4 1
-
C
Nathan its how to book goes pleaseeeeee stay with the Mountie he has a 1000000000 times better personality
6 3
-
O
Nathan all the way
8 5
-
G
Elizabeth should choose Lucas, Nathan is just boring and plus she was already married to a Mountie
7 4
-
G
its. It even a contest. If you’ve watched Elizabeth from day one her heart will only chose the best man and that’s Nathan. A wholesome mommy of a toddler, schoolteacher and main character of goodness will ever chose the saloon owner with an unrepeatable past, no matter how they spin him changing his was. It’s Bsthsn.
9 6
-
P
Team LUCAS!!!!! 😍😍💙💙😘😘
7 4
-
O
Team Lucas all the way!
10 7
-
C
Elizabeth has really gotten on my nerves. She has become such an egotistical brat. If it were up to me, I would have the two men finally realize that she isn’t worth fighting for. Screw Elizabeth let’s go woo Fiona or molly cause even she is a better choice than scandalous Elizabeth. I mean come on! I can’t be the only one thinking this!
2
-
R
Team Lucas all the way, because they communicate well and have chemistry between them. Elizabeth with Nathan is not a good fit because he says he loves her, but Lucas shows her he loves her through his deeds. Elizabeth with Lucas would be exciting and Nathan would be boring. Please pick Lucas for Elizabeth because when she looks at him her face lights up with joy and love, plus she is attracted to him.
3 1
-
G
I do think you have some good points but, I do want to correct you on one thing. Lucas wasn’t being a bad kind of secretive about his past! He didn’t tell anyone about it because he didn’t want to get anyone hurt. Nathan on the other hand... he is actually hiding something about his past and the director of the show said that it would be revealed in season 8. If he is going to keep that a secret for 2 seasons then I can’t imagine it’s anything good.
3 1
-
C
Lucas.. Nathan is just another Jack.
4 2
-
G
Really want her to pick Lucas❤️Team Lucas❤️
5 3
-
O
Elizabeth should choose Nathan. Not only will he love her unconditionally he will love little Jack as well. He will understand that part of her heart will always belong to Jack. Lucas is buying her love and would never understand her love for Jack.
6 4
-
C
Elizabeth should choose Lucas. She already was with a Mountee that has a dangerous job and leaves time to time. Plus Lucas is a better match
6 4
-
R
Without a doubt Nathan. Lucas is putting on a show. I don’t trust him. Nathan is genuine.
7 5
-
B
She needs to be with Lucas a change instead a goodie montie
5 3
-
B
team nathan but i see why she might want to be with lucas because jack died as a mountie and as much as she loves nathans she is still maybe a little scared
4 2
-
R
No one but Nathan. He loves Elizabeth. He is so shy.H reminds me of a friend I once had. His love is real. He just don't know how to Express himself. He afraid of disappointment.
9 7
-
B
Lucas, he really cares for her and thinks about what she would like VOTE. LUCAS
7 5
-
G
Has to be Lucas and here is why! When watching the sweet chemistry between Lucas And Elizabeth it makes me smile and feel the love between. When with Nathan I struggle to feel the connection between he and Elizabeth, due to no spark; definitely no chemistry! Also why would Elizabeth be with another Mountie knowing the danger and pain after loosing Jack
8 6
-
G
That’s a name not a word but ok…
1
-
G
I think Elizabeth got a taste of the rich life and she would rather be wine and dined live in a big house than live a good life with Nathan who would give her security love without having to buy her with candle lit dinners horseback riding and a Library not to mention a Mother who could add to her writing life. She is a to me not worth watching anymore. Watched for 8 yrs. She no longer wants the life of a Mounties Wife even though I believe she is lying to herself and taking the easy way out. How many times did she tell Nathan she loved him. Goodbye to a terrible ending you have lost my 35 WCTH fans. Your writers chose wrong. I will never watch again.
1
-
O
kieElizabeth's decision was a disappointment. Her personality seemed to change and loose some of her wholesomeness!! I don't trust Lucas, he seems to have dark side. Hopefully this will come to fruition before they get married. While Nathan is more like the gentleman you would think Elizabeth would see as a wonderful, caring husband as well as a good father for little Jack. It seems that a book deal was at the top of her list for making the decision to sway her towards Lucas. Any of the other feelings she portrayed seemed shallow. Just hope the writers see that this decision can determine if they can hold the public's interest in the story.
1
-
C
Nathan is the only choice. He is the quiet trusting honest man that has loved her for so long & has been patiently waiting for her to be ready to love again. Lucas was a snake in the grass & I still don’t trust him.
1
-
P
Lucas was talking about running out on her just as Nathan the awesome good guy told him that she loved him. Now which one would I choose? Nathan hands down! There's not any choice to me! He's the only choice! I just hope that she finds out all of this stuff about both of them before she does anything else!
-
-
O
I believe Lucas has more chemistry with Elizabeth and he is a better actor. Nathan is too fake and boring. Team Lucas all the way. Lucas is hot and handsome.
2 1
-
C
PREACH IT MY FRIEND!!!!!!!
1 1
-
-
G
Nathan is the family man Elizabeth needs. She was involved with a guy much like Lucas from her hometown. Then when she moved to Hope Valley, she met Jack and fell in love because he was so down to earth and solid. a protector. Nathan is the same kind of man. You can see the way she looks at him. She loves him. I don't see that spark with Lucas. She likes being courted, but the look of love is not in her eyes for Lucas. Nathan, Elizabeth, Allie, and baby Jack will be a loving family. That is what Hope Valley is all about.
1
-
C
Ummmm is the purpose of that long comment to try and convince yourself that your team still has a chance? Yeah respectfully I’m going to say that Nathan has no hope. I’m sure he is a decently nice guy for Allie MAYBE but around Elizabeth he is soooo wrong!!! My personal opinion on the matter is for both the guys to finally realize that she is not worth fighting for. If I was a character the only reason I would be around toxic Elizabeth would be either to try and get lucas’s attention or to see baby jack.
1 1
-
-
C
I want Elizabeth the choose Lucas because he is so nice to Elizabeth
1
-
G
I am team Lucas all the way. But I think the producers will have her pick Nathan. They will settle down and live a normal life together. As far as story lines you can only have Nathan in so many dangerous situations. With Lucas there's so many story lines. They could have exciting adventures traveling. They could also offer their little town so much. I think Elizabeth and Lucas are good for each other. She offers him a stable family life which Lucas needs. He offers her an exciting life of adventures which Elizabeth yearns for.
3 2
-
B
I agree. This is very intelligent. What an astute observation.
1
-
G
I believe that Elizabeth belongs with Lucas. Yes, he has a mysterious past and yes, she could have been killed because of it. But despite that, he has so much in common with Jack it’s scary!! Jack gave her a schoolhouse for teaching. Lucas gave her a library. Jack and Elizabeth had a catch phrase. “Walk with me.” Lucas and Elizabeth have a catch phrase. “Shall we?” Jack always encouraged her writing. Lucas ALWAYS encourages her writing. There are so many similarities that can’t be over looked! Yes Nathan is a Mountie and some would argue that she belongs with a Mountie. Well I think it’s high time she moves on! The director says that Elizabeth’s character knew who she was going to give her heart to in the 7th season. Take a second look at that season and you’ll see (no offense!) Nathan has no chance! His character is super needy and nosy. They made him very irritating and demanding. He only asked her out once in the last episode and you could tell that Elizabeth was uncomfortable because in her heart she chose Lucas and was starting to date him. When Lucas asked her to meet him at the library she looked like a lovesick puppy ! And let’s be honest... she instantly agreed. (Unlike with Nate) Plus she has a son now. I believe that when she hugged Nathan she knew that she could never be with him. She knew she wouldn’t be able to handle losing another loved one. Her baby boy needs a father who is going to be there for him. That man is Lucas. He loves that boy! ♥️
3 2
-
C
I think she should pick Lucas not Nathan she already had a heart break with a Monty
6 5
-
O
Nathan for sure. He is responsible and doesn’t flaunt money or connections like Lucas, Elizabeth only has 1 thing in common with Lucas and that is his wealth and her family’s wealth and he uses his to impress her with the library, fancy shows and connections for her book. Other than that there really isn’t anything there. If she chooses Lucas the show will lose it’s authenticity. She may as well married her old rich boyfriend instead of Jack in the past. Nathan has it all looks, noble job, experience with kids and truth. He’s himself like Jack was, so I’m not even sure why they would put Lucas in the mix, when Elizabeth wasn’t really interested in his type from the beginning of the show and please stop making Elizabeth look like she is clueless all the time. She’s an educator for goodness sake. How does she even think twice about any feelings for a man who put her life in danger, she was portrayed to be dumbfounded and too forgiven. There’s something crooked about Lucas and I don’t like him for Elizabeth or baby Jack at all! I can say I wouldn’t watch WCH if she’s with Lucas . He’s cute and rich but that’s it. Nathan has it all!
5 4
-
C
She should be with Lucas for sure.. Nathan looks old and expired and is just too old and grumpy for her..
4 3
-
B
Lucas all the way !!
6 5
-
B
Lucas only Lucas!!!
5 4
-
B
why do the same thing over again Lucas yes
7 6
-
G
Yeah I totally agreed! She was pretty annoying the way she led Nathan on the whole time. Pretty disgrace tbh. I wish she stayed the sweet innocent teacher like the first season instead of turning into a player. I’m disappointed in who she has become.
-
P
Yeah she just led Nathan on and she has become Lucas' low caliber of person.
-
P
Really? Now be nice...They both are manly but Lucas is the one sipping tea! LOL! 😉 ☕
-
P
Yeah especially like when he's tried to run out on her...
-
O
I disagree Lucas challenges Elizabeth to grow all Nathan does is play emotional games. He came to take care of her because he is guilty about Jack. Elizabeth is strong enough to take care of herself. With Lucas she is a partner with Nathan she is a baby sitter.
-
A
I really feel that they are giving TL a carrot right now, because they know nathan is going to be picked. Very discouraging! They should have ended the triangle already. If Lucas does lose and nathan wins. This is another reason i would not be able to watch the show. I loved Jack and feel that Nathan cannot compare to him. I also would not want to handle the Mountie trips and the fear that E will have to endure every time N goes away. I really feel that Lucas could bring some Mystery to to her life. Yes, i could still watch for the scraps of Lucas, but he will be broken hearted and i prefer not to see that. Also how much acting time will he get. Gosh! E, N, A, lj and all of the other characters it would not be worth watching in my opinion. There is only 40-43 minutes a show.
-
C
I want Lucas to be the one for Elizabeth
1 1
-
O
against team lucas, nathan is a better man.
1 1
-
C
Lucas or I am done. Need a change.
1 1
-
P
Lol I thought it was so funny when Elizabeth in the first episode of season 8 said I can’t continue to keep seeing both of these men as romantic interests. LOL SHE HAS ONLY BEEN DATING LUCAS NOT NATHAN. 😂😂
1 1
-
P
Yeah but something about Lucas just seems like he is hiding something. I don’t trust him no matter how honest they try to make him look.
-
B
Nathan
1 1
-
O
Has to be Lucas, he so adores her and the seem very loving and sensual together. Nathan is kinda boring and he acts a bit immature. Elizabeth deserves romance and longing looks at which Lucas will send shivers up and down hers and our spines.
1 1
-
P
I agree. Lucas makes Elizabeth feel weak in the knees and they are always flirting with one another! If she doesn’t end up with Lucas, then they would have completely messed up.
3 1
-
-
G
I think she should pick Lucus. She was married to a monte the first time. Should switch it up. It would be more interesting with Lucus. He has secrets but doesn't mean it's bad. Nathan's should get with the telephone girl. I think if she picks Nathan it would be boring. It would be following the other when she was married.
1 1
-
G
I strongly agree with you. I never thought about Nathan and the telephone woman! I would actually ship that!!
1 1
-
-
P
I can't imagine Elizabeth with Lucas in the long run, whereas Nathan I could definitely see in her future.
3 3
-
R
i cannot see elizabeth hanging around a salloon, she would be bored and not enthused by the mood, she would need better stimulation for learning and living, maybe fishing with nathan, or on horseback, or just out walking, or doing things with the children, or just enjoying nature, not stuck in a beer drinking, stinky salloon.
2 2
-
G
Team Bill all the way
2 2
-
B
please not lucas he almost got her killed
7 7
-
C
lkjlkjafadsf
-
G
Nathan is way too immature for Elizabeth. However, Lucas is madly in love with her and would do anything for her and has. Like Lee does for Rosemary. Rosemary is the wisest of woman on the show. I don't feel will be happy with Nathan as, he will undercut her career as it grows, He needs a woman he can control from the git-go. Lucas is successful, patient, smart and polished, like her father and her way of fair-mildness. Nathan is a troubled boy, with a lot of anger in his past. She doesn't need him.
8 8
-
G
Just watched Season 7 Finale. Loved the sweet romantic moment with Elizabeth and Lucas in the Library! You can tell Lucas cares for her so much. The rest of tonights show was a Total Bore. Ending was as expected but hopefully Elizabeth was acting in the moment when she saw Nathan and embraced him with Lucas watching! Hopefully Season 8 turns things around and Elizabeth makes amends with Lucas after tearing his heart on the ground, if not and the show continues with a Mountie that will be the same as the other seasons. Carry your Mountie storyline in When Hope Calls! Just a suggestion. Really disappointing!
4 4
-
C
Just watched Season 7 Finale. Loved the sweet moment with Lucas And Elizabeth! Lucas is a total romantic! Rest of tonight’s show was a total Bore. No chemistry with Nathan. Elizabeth tore Lucas heart at the end. She needs to realize what she just did to Lucas by falling in Nathan’s arms, and make amends. If season 8 has her with Nathan another Mountie the show will hurt.
5 5
-
C
This is a tough one. I think Elizabeth probably pick Lucas. She seems to be intrigued by him, and being very easy on the eyes don't hurt. Nathan don't communicate how how he really feel about Elizabeth except for tonight's episode. Elizabeth probably would be afraid that he might get shot like jack did. Forgot to mention Nathan is easy on the eyes too especially with that red uniform. I would pick Nathan for her they have more in common.
6 6
-
G
I feel in the end they're going to put her with Nathan but I think in season 8 or 9 maybe Lucas will experience a great love with possibly a new character. I love Lucas and would love for her to end up with him because he appeals a little more to the paternal side, I could really see him being a great dad to Jack. But I could see Lucas with another woman but Nathan, there is possibly no one else but Elizabeth, however at the same time it feels like a safe choice, going with a classic, the mountie. I think the producers can't help it, I can already see episodes of Elizabeth fearing for Nathan's life like she did Jack's and just having a total meltdown. Because a big plot of past seasons was Elizabeth's struggle with Jack being a mountie and even though she doesn't regret it and seems to have moved on I think the moment she and Nathan are finally together and he is in danger a fragile patch in her heart will open, a wound that will never completely heal with much pain still to torment her. But I could totally see WCTH doing that, the stories have become very light but this IS a drama series. So in conclusion I adore Lucas and he would be a great lover to Elizabeth and great dad, he would be the unconventional choice and a great plot twist. Though my theory will be that Nathan wins in the end but I possibly see Lucas and Elizabeth becoming a couple and then maybe realizing they're too different. Who knows the series might bring in a NEW character that Elizabeth just falls for.
3 3
-
R
I think Nathan. If she doesn’t I will not watch it anymore. Lucas over reacts.
7 7
-
P
Lucas ALL THE WAY..... NO MORE MOUNTIES.... PLEASE.
16 16
-
P
YES, I TOTALLY Agree. Plus, Nathan has responsibility already for his niece!
3 1
-
R
He needs to get out of Elizabeths way! 🙂
1 1
-
-
-
P
I will die if she doesn’t choose Lucas. They have done so much together !! He has been so nice and patient with her
1
-
C
Lol you wish!!!!
1
-
C
I LOVE NATHAN HE IS SO MANLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1 2
-
P
I don’t think Lucas would be a good dad. He taught a kid how to gamble and doesn’t seem like the kid type.
1
-
P
I understand the part about Nathan’s job but Lucas just doesn’t seem trust worthy and not good with kids.
1
-
P
Lucas would not make a good father and seems too secretive. He almost got Elizabeth killed. I feel like Lucas is trying to hard.
1 2
-
B
I hope Elizabeth would choose Nathan because he is very nice and protect his town. He cares about Elizabeth deeply and loves his niece Allie. I don't trust Lucas because he hide something in his past. Please let her choose Nathan. If not I will not watch this show anymore.
1 2
-
R
Team Nathan smother wY
1
-
C
Lucas is hiding something. Team Nathan all the way!!
1 2
-
G
Are you kidding??! Nathan is hiding something about his past and it is going to be revealed in the next season! Lucas always talks about his past with Elizabeth he never lies to her!
1
-
-
G
Nathan
1 2
-
P
Elizabeth should be with Nathan a man in uniform like Jack was she loves the action Lucas should be with someone else on the show he doesn't fit with Elizabeth
2 3
-
G
I am sorry, but Elizabeth is incredably boring and without a soul.
1
-
R
Lucas seems so secretive and I am concerned that these secrets will popping out of nowhere. The secret that Elizabeth will not be able to accept. Or the real bad Lucas will come out! Nathan seems like a genuine man but he can’t win a woman’s heart with a 2-minute conversation every time. He is always one step behind Lucas. More importantly he doesn’t even have time for his own niece so, let alone Elizabeth! Although Nathan is a definitely a good guy but he is also slow poke!!! LOL!!
1
-
B
I have one word for you Nathan
2
-
P
Team Nathan all the way!
1 3
-
O
Me either, they will ruin what her character is about. Honesty, caring and not being influenced by money. That’s all Lucas has to offer her. He’d make a horrible parent. He puts up with baby Jack to look good for Elizabeth. I don’t trust him.
2 4
-
O
I agree it makes her look thirsty as if Lucas his buying her affection and she disregards Nathan’s trueness and just being himself. I’m praying her character isn’t changed.
1 3
-
O
You judge character by action. Go back and watch what Lucas had done not only for Elizabeth but Hope Valley. He is there by choice. He’d do way better financially elsewhere. Library...etc. etc. etc.
6 8
-
G
I've enjoyed this show for years. Please, please get rid of Elizabeth as a main character. It is so painful to watch her horrible acting and we know she would not be in the spotlight if Lori had not been arrested. Please casting directors make a better choice so this show will last. This girl cannot carry this show! The fired telephone operator would be a good main character.
1 3
-
R
To be honest the only guy for Elizabeth is jack it’s sad he is gone I don’t like the character of Lucas .
2 4
Watchlist Easy access to only the shows you care about — all in one simple place
Alerts Only important notifications — when a show is returning, when it becomes available to stream, and more.
Special Offers Exclusive products we release related to your favorite shows and streaming services