‘The Traitors: New Blood’ Finalists Wyatt Gillespie & Abbey Benjamin Talk Emotional Ending & More

THE TRAITORS (NBC) -- The Traitors: New Blood -- 'Who Do You Truly Trust?' Episode 512 -- Pictured: Abbey Benjamin and Wyatt Gillespie
Q&A
Euan Cherry/NBC

Wyatt Gillspie and Abbey Benjamin were on two different sides of the house on The Traitors: New Blood, but they became close friends and bonded over being Faithfuls. The two of them made it to the final three of the first season, but lost out to Traitor, Shane Beatty.

Abbey laid pretty low throughout the game. She was a part of the Doll’s Alliance with Ben McDonnell, Clyde Moser, and Michael Foote. Both Ben and Clyde made it far into the game, with Michael being banished early on.

Wyatt was part of the Boys’ Alliance with Shane and Victor Vollbrechthausen. All three of them made it to the final four. Wyatt’s name was brought up a few times by Abby L and Kriste Lewis, but no one ever seemed to banish him.

When Wyatt and Abbey made it to the final three with Shane, after banishing Victor, they thought they had won. They thought they were going to split the $246,300 in three ways and celebrate, but Shane threw everyone for a loop when he revealed that he was a Traitor, which meant he took home all of the money.

The finale was emotional, with everyone crying. Wyatt and Abbey break down the emotional finale, their thoughts, and more.

THE TRAITORS (NBC) -- The Traitors: New Blood -- "Who Do You Truly Trust?" Episode 512 -- Pictured: (l-r) Wyatt Gillespie, Abbey Benjamin, Shane Beatty -- (Photo by: Euan Cherry/NBC)

Euan Cherry/NBC

Going into the game, did you guys want to be Traitors?

Wyatt Gillespe: Yeah, I mean, I wasn’t even a Faithful up until I was chosen to be. Not at all.

Abbey Benjamin: Yeah, I wanted to be a Faithful. Yes, I wanted to be part of a team. I wanted to figure it out. I was going to be so good at it.

Wyatt: I begged Alan. He was like, “I would just want to be evil, man.”

You both had emotional reactions when you found out Shane was a Traitor. Was it because you found out you lost? Was it because he inadvertently kind of lied to you? Can you guys kind of talk me through that?

Wyatt: Yeah, it was a full emotional breakdown from me. I mean, in my mind, there was never a chance that an ultimatum happened, and even though it did, I looked over at my best friend in the castle, and the feeling of guilt that he had was way worse than the feeling of loss that I experienced. So, to be the person in that moment to take your emotions and go help your boy out is what happened there. So, I couldn’t be happier with the class that we both demonstrated and how things went down.

How about you, Abbey?

Abbey: Yeah, I mean, I was absolutely devastated. I had felt like we really had won.

Wyatt: Yep.

Abbey: So it was like Alan had written the checks out to us and was like, as he was handing it, dropping, like, “Haha, just kidding.” So, it just really felt like the rug had been pulled out from under us. It’s a very out-of-body experience, but that’s the game, and it’s called The Traitors for a reason, right? And we did the best with the information we had, and I’m very proud not only of the way I played the game, but, like Wyatt said, how we ended the game as well. At the end of the day, we are civilians; we are humans. And he was, obviously, I’m sure, excited, crying, but also, I’m sure some of that was from guilt. I couldn’t find the words to comfort him, but I think he needed to know we don’t hate you. This is the game, right? It is the game for you to lie, deceive, and betray us. And so, we comforted him in that moment for that.

I’m sure you guys would have done the same thing too if you were the Traitors.

Wyatt: So you have to. I mean, you have to. I say that to Shane. I literally go up to him. I’m like, “I would’ve done the same thing, brother.”

I just talked to him, and he’s like, I was like 95% guilty and 5%  happy that I won.

Wyatt: Yeah, that is honestly what it seemed. I mean, we’re crying in real life way longer than what’s on the show. It was a lot. We were all crying, and I’m looking over at Shane; he’s crying, but not an excited cry, like a sorry cry. And I’m like, “Oh, buddy, oh no.”

I know he just became a Traitor, but did you guys ever suspect him to be a traitor, Shane?

Wyatt: No.

Abbey: Just from the only thing that Clyde had told me about the heavy footsteps, but you know he had played such a Faithful game from the beginning, and just the way he used the power of the pardon. Anybody who was a Faithful, like if I would have gotten the power, I would have definitely used it, and I voted for Victor too. So I think anybody who’s a fan of the game and just reality TV in general would have used the power of a pardon because of what it is, except for somebody who’s a Traitor, because the Traitors would have wanted him gone. So, I think he just proved to him, to us, that he was Faithful from that, and always seemed very Faithful. So there was just no way. That was the only thing we had is heavy footsteps from the puzzle-making, so that was literally the only suspicion he had on him.

Wyatt, you said you were close to Shane and Victor, but you turned on Victor in the end. Was it just him lying about the shield that tipped you off, or what made you turn on him?

Wyatt: It was definitely him lying about the shield because what you guys don’t see is I probably asked him 50 times. I was like, “Did you get the shield?” We’re in the car back in the castle. It’s me, Shane, and Vic. And I’m like, “Did you get the shield?” I really was digging into him. I was like, “Somebody came out of here with the shield. I know it. There’s no way nobody found the shield,” and so for him to lie to my face, probably after me asking 50 times, was heartbreaking. But at the same time, when he explains his strategy with the shield to me, that makes perfect sense to me. Like I’m able to put that aside. But now the person I 100 thought was a Faithful is now 99 percent Faithful because he lied to me, and so going into that final fire, I really just had to say to myself, like, who do I 100 percent want to end the game with here? And Victor goes home not as a Traitor, but just as a person I couldn’t trust as a Faithful.

Abbey, what was it like to hang and fly in a helicopter on the last challenge?

THE TRAITORS (NBC) -- The Traitors: New Blood -- "Who Do You Truly Trust?" Episode 512 -- Pictured: (l-r) Alan Cumming, Wyatt Gillespie, Abbey Benjamin -- (Photo by: Euan Cherry/NBC)

Euan Cherry/NBC

Abbey: Oh, it was magical. It was magical. I’m actually terrified of heights I wanted, but, I wanted to say yes to everything in this experience. I wanted to do the hard things and do things I would never get to do in my normal life. So, I had no idea that I would actually be rappelling off the side of the helicopter. So when they told me that, I was like, “What did I agree to?” But honestly, I had this pit in my stomach, like, “What am I about to do?” And the second the helicopter took off, I immediately felt at peace and just so full of joy, and got to see sights that very few people in the world would ever get to do, and especially in the way that I got to do it, hanging off the side of the helicopter.

Wyatt: She was so excited to get in the helicopter. Like when it landed behind us, we were like, “All right, Abbey’s getting in that thing.”

You were in the Boys’ Alliance; you were in the Dolls’ Alliance. How hard was it to make alliances and friendships when you couldn’t fully trust people?

Wyatt: Ooh, good question. I mean, you never fully 100 percent trust someone, but you do 100 percent know how they’re playing the game, right? So if you are looking at someone’s true intentions and their emotions when they’re discovering the game, when they’re trying to play, that is how I was determining how people were Faithful versus Traitors. So, when Abby Lee is grilling me, right, I like it. I took it as a moment to be like, all right, who’s on to Abby L because she is obviously going after me, but she’s doing it with genuine intention, and so it helps me discover that Abby L is a Faithful, and who is now trying to pile up on me. It makes a lot of sense, and so I think a lot of the time when you’re sitting at the roundtable, it’s more important to look at not the person accusing, the person piling up, and so when Victor goes out, I say to the entire roundtable, I’m like, “How can you guys confuse this man’s genuine curiosity to play this game right now?” And I think I yelled at Shane. I think it was longer in real life too. I yelled at Shane a little bit. I’m like, “Shane, look at him!” I’m like, “Look at this guy!” Like Shane had just voted for Victor. I was like, “Shane, lock in, he’s not a traitor. This is crazy,” and that decision changed everything.

Abbey: I think for me, I mean, the relationships you build are everything in this game. You have to have a social game to stay in the game. So, even if you don’t 100 percent trust. You have to have some type of people supporting you and having your back. And I feel like I definitely did have that with the Dolls, but it was something that we had, but we didn’t parade around and stay in one circle. We definitely infiltrated all groups of people. But it is very nice to have a group. I feel like we really also had a kind of a voting bloc because we mostly voted together, and so I think it was funny. Joe made a comment. He’s like, “I knew when Abbey turned her vote over, and it was Joe that the Dolls all were voting Joe, and I knew I was gone.” So, I do think it also gave us a little power in the game to have an alliance and stick together in that way.

Is there anything about either of your games that you would change or regret?

Abbey: I’d say no. I would not change a single thing that I did with the information I had. Right? Like, of course, I would have wanted to win, but at the time, I did exactly what I would have done with the information I had. I’m very proud of the game that I played. I’m very proud of the way I made it through with no heat, and yeah, I wouldn’t change anything.

Wyatt: I would change the last two days of how I played. I believed I was doing a very, very good job in there, but I think I really should have been out and about more. I think people were coming up to me and talking to me when I could have gone to them more. There are great moments that don’t make it when Victor and I are sitting in a room together, and we’re interrogating each other. We’re like, “I think it’s you.” He’s like, “You think it’s me.” And we are just going back and forth. “Last night I was sleeping upstairs, and I just came to the conclusion that it’s you.” And I’m like, “I did the same for you.” And then we worked it out. And I wish I had that moment with more individuals. It was a great moment that wasn’t seen.

Abbey: Yeah, because I even made a point to tell you, on the last day when we’re all scrambling, I was like, “You didn’t even come talk to me.”

Wyatt: Yeah, I was like, “I didn’t need to talk to her because I know she’s a Faithful,” and she knew I was a Faithful.

Abbey: It’s just funny, like you talk to everybody, me.

Wyatt: I thought about that for like a very long time. Like something that didn’t make the cut, as Abbey was so pissed off that I didn’t go and talk to her, and I was like, “Oh my god.”

Abbey: I’m like, “Everybody else talked to me but you. What’s up?”

Wyatt: We didn’t need to talk.

The Traitors: New Blood, Peacock




Conversation

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Register or sign in to join the conversation.