‘The Traitors: New Blood’: Shane Beatty Talks Emotional Win & the Guilt He Carried

THE TRAITORS (NBC) -- The Traitors: New Blood -- 'Playing Chess' Episode 509 -- Pictured: (l-r) Shane Beatty, Joe Vanella, Kriste Lewis
Q&A
Euan Cherry/NBC

Shane Beatty beat out 21 other people for The Traitors: New Blood prize and title of winner. The ironworker took home $246,300.

He was recruited as a Traitor with only three episodes left. Shane came into the game as a Faithful and played most of the game as one. However, when only Katie Fites gave him an ultimatum — become a Traitor or get murdered — he chose to become a Traitor.

Shane, from Staten Island, New York, was part of the unofficial “Boys’ Alliance” with Victor Vollbrechthausen and Wyatt Gillespie, and stayed under the radar for most of the game. However, when Clyde Moser said he heard heavy footsteps during the shield puzzle challenge, his name was brought up, but he wasn’t banished.

The new Traitor made it to the fire pit with four other people — Katie, Victor, Wyatt, and Abbey Benjamin. The first two rounds saw Katie and Victor get banished. When it was down to Shane, Wyatt, and Abbey, they all decided to end the game with only Shane knowing the outcome.

In the end, when their identities were revealed, Shane was in tears. He had just won life-changing money, but also had left his friends to go home with nothing.

Shane talked to us about his emotional win, his time as a Traitor, and more.

THE TRAITORS (NBC) -- The Traitors: New Blood -- "Who Do You Truly Trust?" Episode 512 -- Pictured: (l-r) Alan Cumming, Shane Beatty -- (Photo by: Euan Cherry/NBC)

Euan Cherry/NBC

TVI: Hi Shane. How are you?

Shane Bearry: I am wonderful. I’m doing great.

Congratulations on your win. How does it feel?

Thank you so much. It feels so surreal. Were you crying with me?

Oh my God, it was with all three of you. It was so emotional.

Thank you. It was so emotional, so emotionally charged, and I just can’t believe it. I went on my favorite TV show, and I actually won my favorite TV show. I played both roles. I was a Faithful. I was a Traitor. I won the superpower in the game. It doesn’t get any better than that. Unfortunately, I had to betray my alliance. Tears were shed, but they forgave me, and they came in for a hug and comforted me because they saw the guilt was eating me alive. They saw the circumstance that I was dealt with. Ultimatum: Either murder or be a Traitor. I became a Traitor. I had to do what I had to do.

So let’s talk about the emotional ending. Were you crying because you just realized you won all that money? Because you realized you kind of betrayed your friends? What was going on there?

It was two types of cries. When the green stone was being thrown, I was crying because I knew I was gonna win the money. I was like, “Oh my gosh, I won!” Like, this is happening. I won, but then Alan [Cumming] says, “Reveal yourself,” and I just felt guilty. I’m like, “Oh my gosh, I have to tell them what I am,” and the guilt… “I feel so terrible. Oh my gosh, I’m a terrible person.” Especially watching their reactions, I don’t like watching people cry. I hate watching people cry. Watching people cry makes me cry, and watching somebody cry because it was my fault is even worse because I’m a nice person. I’m a genuinely nice person. I don’t like hurting people, harming people, lying to people, and it ate me up. It ate me up, and it was guilty cries. 80 percent guilt cries. Actually, 95 percent guilt cries.

I mean, don’t feel bad. It’s a game. I’m sure they would have done the same thing.

Yeah, but you know what? Yes, they would have done the same thing. Your mind knows it’s a game, but your body doesn’t know. You know it’s a game, but how you’re reacting to this isn’t planned. It’s not like “All right, I’m gonna cry.” It’s just like, “Oh, i’s happening. It’s happening. I’m crying now.” Like I’m just crying now. So yes, it’s a game, but I couldn’t help it. I couldn’t help it.

Then before the final round in the fire pit, you had voted for Katie to banish her. Did you always plan on turning against her?

Not did I always plan. The boys’ alliance was always going to vote for her, and even if I did not vote for her, Abbey, Wyatt, Victor were. She was going to go regardless. She was always gonna get voted out. It was always going to happen. I tried to defend her. I floated the name. I’m like, “Guys, you know what? Maybe it might not be Katie.” Victor wasn’t having it. Victor and Wyatt were like, “No, it’s Katie. We’re going for Katie”. So then it’s like, “All right, there’s nothing I can do.” Listen, it’s nothing I can do. Like Joe did, trying to save Tomica, trying to defend her, but when it comes down to it, “Hey, maybe it’s Tomica.” They were already going to vote for her. It would feel more of a betrayal if my vote was the deciding vote. But three votes, she’s already going. So, what am I supposed to do?

When Katie recruited you, what was going through your head? Did you want to be a traitor? Did you know she was a traitor?

When she recruited me, I knew I won the game. I knew I won the game. I was like, “Oh my gosh, I won the game. She gave me the win.” She mentioned, “I could see a path to the end with you.” I’m like, “All right, you know what? Let me try to entertain this a little.” I’m like, “Why did you recruit me?” “I think you could get the boys off my back.” Whoa, Katie, you’re trying to give me an impossible task, but I would try. I’m gonna talk to the boys. I’m gonna try. I told her, “Listen, Victor got the shield. I’m showing how I’m working with you. Victor has the shield. I’m gonna try to talk to them, see what I could do. Try to talk to them. There ain’t much I could do.” Victor is the Traitor slayer, Traitor hunter. There’s no changing his mind. We watched Victor play this game. Yes, the blinders were up. He’s flirting and stuff, but still, ultimately, what did he say? “I think it’s you.” Even through the flirting, “Yeah, I think it’s you.” I knew I was going to win the game. It was just, “Am I going to win it with her, realistically speaking?”

THE TRAITORS (NBC) -- The Traitors: New Blood -- "Who Do You Truly Trust?" Episode 512 -- Pictured: (l-r) Wyatt Gillespie, Abbey Benjamin, Shane Beatty -- (Photo by: Euan Cherry/NBC)

Euan Cherry/NBC

At the roundtable, when Clyde said that he heard big footsteps near him during the shield puzzle and called you out, did you think that your game could have been over at that point?

No, because one, Wyatt and Victor, I got in my corner. Katie, I have in my corner. That’s three people. Who are the other people? Kriste, Abbey, and Jay. So honestly, I don’t think he had enough convincing power to convince other people. And regardless, I wasn’t gonna let that happen. So I just had to murder him that night. He couldn’t convince enough people. He even said all the stuff about me but never even mentioned it at the roundtable, so, it was never going to grow legs. Nothing was ever gonna come from that. Honestly, it really wasn’t. It really wasn’t.

You won the pardon power. What made you save Victor when he was such a big target for everyone?

What made me save Victor? Because he didn’t seem guilty. He didn’t. He didn’t walk up there like Joe, like, “All right, guys, you got me.” He seemed genuinely like, “I am a Faithful, and y’all are about to vote me out. Now I’m gonna throw it in your face that y’all are wrong. Y’all don’t know how to play this game.” He wanted to throw it in our face. “So you know what? I’m gonna save you now.” You know I’m gonna save you. You’re not gonna throw that. You’re a Faithful in our face after we were wrong for what five, six roundtables at that point. But also, I was always gonna use the pardon. It’s the pardon. It’s the superpower of the game. How corny would it be for me to not use it? Like, come on, what are we doing? Yes, I’m going to use it. Pardon that man.

Seeing both sides of the game as a Faithful and Traitor, which did you like better?

I like being a Faithful, but I like being a Traitor better because it really made it a game. I’m like, “Oh my gosh, like I have to find a way to make people go against each other.” I put Wyatt against Victor.. Listen, the truth of the matter is, I’m a bad detective. You got me. I’m a bad Faithful. I’m a bad Faithful. So let me try to roll as a Traitor. I became a traitor. It was fun. I put Wyatt against Victor. It was successful. I got to murder Clyde. I got to do this, these challenges that was only tailored for Traitor. I got rid of Ben, who was suspicious of Katie. I think I like being a Traitor better. Traitors have more fun. I don’t like being paranoid. Like, “Oh my God, they’re gonna murder me. Oh, here we go again. Another night, I’m gonna get murdered.” Nah, I don’t like that. I like being a Traitor.

When you were recruited, you genuinely seemed shocked that Katie was a traitor. Did you have any inkling at all that she was?

It wasn’t that I was shocked that she was a Traitor. I thought Kriste was there, too. The boys thought it was also Kriste. Listen, I’m 6’7″. Katie’s what 5’2″? I know it’s Katie in the silhouette. I just thought it was Katie and Kristie.

Despite going against Wyatt and Abbey at the end and voting out Victor in the fire pit, do you think you’ll still be friends with everybody?

Oh, we are friends. We are locked in. We are friends. There’s no bad blood. They understood the situation, and I believe we’re still friends. Yeah, we’re still friends. I hang out with Wyatt. I hang out with Michael. I hang out with Joe. I hang out with. I don’t hang out with with Katie and Abbey as much because they live in different states, but the New York people, we hang out. We’re all in the group chats. We all talk to each other. We shoot the sh*t. We laugh at each other, watching it back. I would say we’re friends. I think people are a little upset that we’re friends. I think they want us to be more not liking each other. Like no, we’re friends. We’ve experienced this traumatizing show together in the best way, by the way. Traumatizing in the best way.

Do you have any wedding plans?

Do I have any plans for my weddings? No because I couldn’t plan anything because I was broke. And those wedding planners are expensive, and those venues are expensive because you need to make payments and all that. And I was living check to check, so no, all I have is a guest list, and the cast is gonna be on my guest list. Yes, I want the cast at the wedding. There’s some definites that need to be there. There are some people where if they don’t show up, it’s cool. But everybody in the final fire, everybody in the finale, I really, really want to be there. I really want Claude to be there. I really want Ben to be there. I want everybody to be there.

The Traitors: New Blood, now streaming, Peacock




Conversation

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Register or sign in to join the conversation.