‘The Traitors: New Blood’s’ Katie Fites & Victor Vollbrechthausen on Why They Turned on Each Other & Their Game Moves
Q&A
What happens when a Faithful and a Traitor develop feelings for each other? Katie Fites and Victor Vollbrechthausen were the flirtmance of The Traitors: New Blood. Since Katie was a Traitor and Victor was a Faithful, they were technically on opposite sides, but they were drawn to each other.
Katie was recruited as a Traitor in Episode 2 and won the right to be one after completing the task and being picked by Joe Vanella and Tomica Adams against Xavier Scruggs.
For most of the game, she laid low, but when it ended, her fellow players noticed her behavior changing. She was oddly calm at breakfast compared to everyone else, who thought they would be murdered. She never seemed to worry.
Victor was not on her as a Traitor until the very end. He clocked Joe and Tomica over “Fruitgate,” where he knew one of them was a Traitor because host Alan Cumming announced it was a “murder in plain sight,” and they both had fruit and were offering people apples, which he said he never saw them eat.
Both Katie and Victor made it to the final five around the bonfire, but did not walk away with the money. Katie was banished in fifth place, and Victor was banished in fourth place.
Here is what they had to say about their time in the game, their feelings for each other, and more.

Euan Cherry/NBC
Going into the game. Did either of you want to be Traitors?
Victor Vollbrechthausen: Yeah, but I think it was full of hot air because as soon as Alan [Cumming] started wrapping around that round table, there was no way I was. If he had tapped me, you would have seen an absolute meltdown. You would’ve seen this man absolutely crumble.
Katie Fites: We would’ve seen more?
Victor: Yeah, yeah, exactly. It would have been worse. I swear it would have been worse.
Katie: What could have been? I definitely did. I think that a lot of us did, and that made everybody’s senses heightened. I knew he went in and wanted to be a Traitor, and I think that made me not trust him. And I truly did gaslight myself into thinking you were a Traitor, majority of the time.
Victor: You thought I was a Traitor as a Traitor.
Katie: Yeah, exactly. [laughs]
Katie, then once you were recruited, a lot of people said that they saw your demeanor change during breakfast, and you were like calm during the murders. Was that a subconscious thing? Do you think that was like your overall demise in the game?
Katie: I definitely didn’t think that I was doing that. Looking at it, It’ll be like “Katie’s a Traitor,” and I take a big sip of my water. I’m like, there is just no way that happened. There’s literally no way that I look that guilty. But I will say, calm has never been used to describe me, but (to Victor) no need to laugh; I’m not an anxious person. I am very out there. I’ll figure it out. I’m adaptable. That’s a trait that I thought would help me be a Traitor is that I can be quick on my feet. So whenever people were like, “You’re just really cool, and you’re really sweet,” I was like, okay, I’ll just start being rude to all of you. I will just tap into that side if that’s what we need to do.
Then in the turret, you kind of made a deal with Shane towards the end. “I’ll stick with you if you stick with me.” Were you kind of surprised that he banished you in the end, and would you have done the same to him?
Katie: If the roles were reversed, I would have done the same thing, but going into our position, I was fully ready to commit to him. That obviously didn’t bode well for me, but I am a very loyal person. So I was like, if I could be loyal to one, and I said that if I could be loyal to one person, I want to be him, and I did help carry Shane as much as I could to that position. Abbey B. actually questioned him at one point because she was like, “It’s got to be someone in the boy band. It’s got to be someone in the boy band.” And I’m like, “I don’t think it’s Shane. I don’t. I really don’t. I think it’s Victor.” So I was just trying super hard to protect him, but I also was trying to guilt him because I wanted to be like, “I have put you in this position.” We’re almost there. We’ve got like two days. So
Victor: That’s like gatekeep, girl boss.
Katie: Yes, I was like, let me make him feel really, really bad, and he did, but in that moment, I was shocked when he flipped it around. I was about to try to square up. I was really, really upset. Now watching it back, I understand that he did everything good.
The two of you were kind of close in the game. What made you turn on each other during the fire pit?
Victor: I wasn’t gonna let this cute as a button just absolutely cakewalk me in the finals, right? I had to defend myself, and I knew that if I would have said anything before, Katie was out there taking heads like it’s no one’s business. Literally, if somebody mentioned her, they didn’t show up. So I was like, you know what? I’m not gonna tell anybody I’m suspicious. I’m not even gonna let her know that I’m suspicious of her. But yeah, so I definitely was suspicious of Katie. I just kept those cards close to the chest, and once I could no longer get murdered, then that’s when I was like, “All right, gloves are off. All right, Katie, we’re going head to head, and we’ll see what happens.”
Katie: I knew that he didn’t fully trust me because I felt like on days maybe where you were a little worried, you tried to butter me up more, and I was like, okay. I was like, he’s cooking something up.
Victor: The cups, when I went to Joe, and that’s when that was like that day I knew that Katie was a Traitor. When I looked at her, I said, “All right, you switch with me.” And she goes, “Why me?” And I was like, “Never mind. You’re so pretty.”
Katie: I was getting so agitated.
Did you suspect her at all before that?
Victor: Yeah, I think the night of the murder in plain sight happened. Katie was suspiciously close to Tomica [Adams], and that wasn’t really an alliance that I’d seen form previous to that night, so I definitely made that mental note. I actually wrote in my notebook, like, “oh boy, like I think it’s Joe, I think it’s Tomica, and I might be in hot water because Katie’s super cute, and she also might be a Traitor.”
We have to talk about the murder in plain sight and Fruitgate. Did you suspect Joe and Tomica at all before Fruitgate? What led you down that spiral?
Victor: I was a little bit suspicious of Tomica. I thought Tomica, Niyaah, Michael. I thought that would have been a strong trio. And then when she’s out, Michael’s out. I was like, okay, Tomica’s offering fruit. Like, she’s for sure it. And Joe, I wasn’t suspicious of him at all. I truly just saw him walk around with an apple, and then, like, I don’t know if it’s it’s like your bias because you think he’s a Traitor, so you start nitpicking everything he does, but then I really started analyzing him, and you look at him, and his like, when Mark was murdered, and he goes, “Oh no!” I was like, okay, you’re, yeah, that’s not genuine at all. You killed Mark.
Katie: There’s really no good way to do this because you can always throw things two ways. Because people also thought that I was a Traitor because I wasn’t super upset visibly at Mark, and Mark and I were close, and I didn’t want to be super theatrical. So I mean, it’s funny that you can always spin things two ways in this game, and that’s why everyone who sits in is like, “I would have done this like this.” It’s like you probably would have still been clocked, just for the opposite reason. It’s really kind of like a free-for-all. That’s why you have to be quick on your feet, and it’s who can argue better.
Katie, when at the roundtable, when it was shared that Tomica had said your name, did you confront her about that later? Did you think that she was turning on you?
Katie: I did. I totally thought she was trying to two-time me because Victor told me, and I was like, Victor has no reason to lie to me unless he was trying to, because he is suspicious of Tomica. So maybe he did get some read that I would be another Traitor. So he’s trying to see how I would respond to that. Am I taking it personally? Does it hit more than if I were just a Faithful? But I didn’t think that’s what he was doing. And then obviously it’s funny to watch back and hear her say that. I think that she did genuinely confuse the names, but
Victor: I think it was a Freudian slip.
Katie: I think that as well.
Victor: And that’s another thing because I said, “give me a Traitor,” and she literally gave me a traitor. I was like, thank you, Tomica. Yeah, I’m gonna just drop this at the round table and let and see what happens. Let the chaos begin. That’s why
Katie: I tried to kind of just prompt her, but that’s exactly why I voted for her because, again, if you’re a Faithful and someone who has never brought your name up before, all of a sudden they’re throwing you out because you’ve been in hot water. Now it makes me think like there’s no reason behind this other than just you trying. If you’re a Faithful, it would be really concerning that someone threw your name out who shouldn’t. So, I voted for her because if I was like, “Oh, Tomica, you said my name.” Okay, Victor, it’s you. It’d be like, “I’m sorry, that doesn’t concern you.”
Victor: That’s exactly what Christy did.
Katie: Why would I? Yeah, true. But it’s like, why would you do that? So that’s why I voted for her.
Victor, do you think when you told Wyatt about the shield, did you think that was going to be like the end of your game?
Victor: Yeah, and by no means did I play a perfect game, but I played a really good game. I’m very happy with how I played my game. I think, I don’t know, my hubris of telling him, somebody you’re in an alliance with, to tell him what I previously did before. I was really proud of that shield, and I thought that was going to be, honestly, like an olive branch. Like, “Hey, dude, like this is me offering you this as a way to us bond and come clean going into this.”
His reaction, he was so hurt that I hadn’t told him. I was like, no, it would have been silly to tell you and not incriminate him, but I’m not going to give you a burden to carry a lie that I’m doing to like help Shane right now in our three alliance. Then, when he brought it up at that round table, I looked around the table, and I saw Abbey, Shane, and Kriste, and they’re all so up in arms about it. At that point, I was like, “Ah, this is raps. I didn’t win this game. Let’s just see if we can get lucky one more time.” But yeah, I think that was — I don’t want to say silly — but I think it was a little silly that they got so upset about that because I think if you watch reality TV and you watch The Traitors, a hidden shield is better than an open shield. So I’m out there trying to use the shield to protect Shane and I, and Wyatt’s just butt hurt. I was like, “No, dude, like this is a good thing. I swear, it’s not a lie.” I’m gaming out here.
Katie: Every time something like that would happen, and it would go the wrong way for him, just genuinely, I was like a kid on Christmas. I was like, thank you, guys, so much for this, because I was over here-
Victor: That’s really weird. That’s really weird.
Katie: They were just making him lose his mind. It was great.
You guys are very flirty in the house. Are there any lingering feelings there? Any dates in the future?
Katie: We did go on a date.
Victor: We did.
Katie: The flirtation was strategy.
Victor: Was it a good date?
Katie: Oh, she didn’t ask that.
Victor: But no, I’m asking. Was it a good one?
Katie: That was a good date. I think that even though it was strategic, it was also really fun.
Victor: So we’ll see if we get a date No. 2. Let’s get Katie to New York.
Katie: I think that’s he’s gonna pay an Etsy witch.
Victor: Yeah, whatever that is.
Katie: He doesn’t even know what that is. [laughs]
The Traitors: New Blood, Season 1, Now streaming, Peacock
Conversation
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Register or sign in to join the conversation.

