Nancy Guthrie Case: Retired FBI Agent Reveals What ‘Really Struck’ Her About Crime Scene

Savannah Guthrie and her mom, Nancy Guthrie
Don Arnold/WireImage via Getty Images

What To Know

  • Nancy Guthrie, mother of Today anchor Savannah Guthrie, remains missing nearly 10 months after her abduction from her Tucson-area home.
  • Retired FBI agent Maureen O’Connell said foliage obscured the front porch, where she had hoped to examine a mat that was no longer there.
  • O’Connell said the driveway was unlikely to preserve identifiable tire impressions from a typical car.

Nancy Guthrie, the mom of Today anchor Savannah Guthrie, is still missing, going on 10 months after the abduction from her Tucson, Arizona, home — and a retired FBI agent just shared what stood out to her at the crime scene.

In an interview for Brian Entin Investigates published on November 16, former FBI special agent Maureen O’Connell visited Tucson in person and then discussed with host Brian Entin what she noticed about Nancy’s home.

“The house was a little closer to the road than I’d envisioned, which was interesting,” she pointed out.

O’Connell then shared, “The other thing that really struck me, Brian, was that foliage, even though it looks sparse from the outside like a typical desert landscape, it was very difficult to see through that foliage to get a good, clean view of the front porch. Because we were trying to determine whether or not the rug was still there, the mat. Which, everyone knows, I’m bananas over that mat.”

She explained, “And I actually brought with me a whole kit in case I could, because I was trying to find Annie [Guthrie] or Tommaso [Cioni] to ask them if we could collect the mat if it was in fact there. But obviously, it was not there.

Additionally, O’Connell addressed the possibility of investigators having been able to obtain tire imprints from Nancy’s driveway to identify her abductor[s].

“The substrate of the driveway, you know, we talked a lot, you and I, about the tire impressions and the shoe impressions,” she told Entin. “And it seems to me just from kicking it around on both sides, it seems to me that it’s one of those driveways where, obviously, some tires can leave an impression. But not really the type of impression where you can really develop an impression or pour into the impression and get a mold out of it. You could maybe use oblique lighting, different lighting and stuff like that, and photography.”

O’Connell also noted that a heavy law enforcement truck would likely leave tire impressions because they “weigh thousands and thousands of pounds more than your average vehicle.” However, a typical car probably would not have left impressions “you can really tie to a particular vehicle.”

Going on 10 months after Nancy’s disappearance, no suspect has been named in her case. The 84-year-old was last seen at her Catalina Foothills home on the evening of January 31; her family members reported her missing on February 1. Since then, investigators have released photos of a masked suspect and alleged ransom notes, and Savannah has offered a $1 million reward for information leading to an arrest.




Conversation

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Register or sign in to join the conversation.