‘American Hostage’: Tony’s Past Comes to Light as the Standoff Takes a Dangerous Turn

In the first two episodes of MGM+’s American Hostage, respected Indianapolis radio newsman Fred Heckman (Jon Hamm) is pulled into a tense standoff when Tony Kiritsis (Giovanni Ribisi), a desperate man facing foreclosure, takes mortgage broker Dick Hall (Kristoffer Polaha) hostage and demands the chance to air his grievances live on the radio. The series is based on the shocking true events that unfolded in Indianapolis in 1977. Warning: Spoilers ahead for American Hostage Episode 3 “Magic Ticket.”

Episode 3 of American Hostage picks up with the electricity being shut off at Tony Kiritsis’ apartment, giving him one more demand as the standoff continues.

Meanwhile, Ginny (June Laporte) digs further into what pushed Tony to this point. At the home of his sister Effie (Marina Stephenson Kerr), she learns that Tony’s brothers had sold family property, and Tony was cheated out of his portion, which caused him to act…irrationally.

At the Heckman house, Fred meets FBI Special Agent Cormac McNally (Jonathan Tucker), a forensic profiler called in by Gallagher. Profiling is still relatively new territory for the FBI, and Cormac is trying to understand Tony’s mentality, particularly why he chose Fred as the person he trusts.

MGM+/Sony Pictures Television

At Meridian, the Halls work on an apology, although M.L. Hall (Steven Ratzlaff) refuses to personally deliver it, even if it means saving his son. Tony, meanwhile, wants his electricity restored and understands that both sides need to compromise: “Gotta give something to get something.”

Fred’s family is also feeling the effects of the crisis. His oldest son, Ritchie, is MIA, while Fred’s wife, Barbara (Mireille Enos), is pushed to visit Dick Hall’s wife, Ibby (Kat Cunning).

Related

‘American Hostage’ Creators and Stars on How Jon Hamm's Fred Heckman Became Part of the Story

Barbara arrives at the Hall house with a casserole, where things are understandably awkward. Tony apologizes to Ibby for putting her family through the ordeal, but when Dick stays silent, Tony tells her that her husband loves her. “You take care of him, Tony,” she responds.

Clearly, there were problems in the Hall marriage long before Tony wired a shotgun to Dick’s neck.

Meanwhile, Ben (William Jackson Harper) learns about previous protests over the Hall family’s foreclosure practices. They allegedly offer mortgages to lower-income buyers, quickly foreclose when payments are missed, and then buy the properties back at sheriff’s sales. HUD regulations should prevent some of these practices, but Ginny and Ben suspect the company has found a way around them.

Steven Ackerman/MGM+

Then Ginny uncovers something far more troubling about Tony. Dick, it turns out, isn’t his first hostage.

Eight years earlier, Tony held his own sister hostage at knifepoint until his family agreed to pay him $55,000 for 17 acres of land. Tony was arrested, but his sister refused to testify and ultimately forgave him.

Back at the apartment, Tony finally gets his power restored and is told the Halls’ apology will air on television. Instead, Cliff is sent to deliver it. Tony is furious that Fred isn’t there, throwing the television.

Outside Crestwood Apartments, things nearly spiral out of control when reporter Doug spots what looks like preparations for a tactical operation. He reports that Tony has deemed the apology inadequate and authorities may be preparing to move in.

And there actually is a plan. The Army bomb squad is preparing to enter the apartment.

Gene is furious about the report and denies a raid is happening, while Fred begins asking questions about the bomb squad. Authorities clear the area around Doug and cut his feed, but Tony has already heard enough.

Cormac asks Fred to call him, but Tony now believes Fred lied and refuses to take the call. With the trust between them suddenly in danger, the FBI and Gene tell the bomb squad to stand down. Fred turns to the one tool he knows Tony is listening to: the radio.

He goes on the air, apologizes for the false report, and speaks directly to Tony. Drawing on his own experiences during World War II, Fred calmly assures him that the tactical team has been told to stand down. He tells Tony that he believes him, is ready to listen, and asks him to call.

Steven Ackerman/MGM+

Eventually, the phone rings. “We’re alive,” Tony tells him.

That appeal works because Fred isn’t just another voice on the radio to Tony. As Giovanni Ribisi explains, Tony sees him as someone he can trust, and someone whose voice carries weight far beyond the hostage situation.

“Tony was a big fan of Fred Heckman, his radio show, and everything that he stood for, which was a contrast to today’s media, where you’re thumbing through TikTok or Instagram and seeing things that are almost violent or pornographic or whatever that is,” Ribisi explains to TV Insider. “I think Fred Heckman represented an ideal, and I think that spoke to Tony. He was also a pillar of the community. A lot of people listened to him, and Tony knew that.”

In Kristoffer Polaha’s opinion, the two connected because Fred recognized there was more to Tony than just his extreme actions.

“I think that Fred Heckman, because he was a journalist, knew that there was more to the story than just the rantings of a madman,” said Polaha. “He was like, ‘Wait a minute, there’s a human on the other end of this line…’ The story was compelling, and Tony was smart. So, I think they were twin stars in some way.”

The moment further complicates Fred’s position. He’s supposed to be covering the biggest story in Indianapolis, but he has also become Tony’s trusted intermediary and someone law enforcement is relying on to keep him calm.

That conflict becomes even more complicated when Ben questions the ethics surrounding Ginny’s reporting. She has uncovered a major story, but the FBI ultimately prevents it from airing because they fear it could anger Tony and put Dick’s life in danger.

At the same time, public opinion is increasingly shifting toward Tony. Outside the apartment, supporters have even created a makeshift altar filled with PBR and teddy bears.

As the standoff enters its 11th hour, Fred has managed to regain Tony’s trust, the tactical team has backed down, and the power is back on, but Tony still isn’t satisfied. As far as he’s concerned, the Halls’ apology is “totally inadequate.”

American Hostage, Sundays, 9/8c, MGM+