‘Are You My First?’ Cast Revealed: Meet the 21 Virgins Looking for ‘The One’ (PHOTOS)

Move over, Bachelor in Paradise and Love Island USA. There’s a new dating show in town, and this one features singles who all have one thing in common: They’ve never had sex.

In Hulu’s newest reality show, Are You My First?, 21 eligible virgins will be hitting the beach to open their hearts and possibly go all the way. The Are You My First? cast members will go on romantic dates, participate in revealing challenges, and find new love interests in their search for “the one.”