‘Jeopardy!’ Fans React After ‘Badly Written’ Question Results in ‘Brutal’ Loss

(from left) Jeopardy! contestants Liam Starnes, Abigail Arnold, and Eric Cordova
Spoiler Alert
Jeopardy.com

[The following post contains MAJOR spoilers for the Wednesday, April 23, episode of Jeopardy!]

Jeopardy! fans think the Final Jeopardy question was “badly written” and it caused a contestant to lose brutally. Reigning champion Liam Starnes returned for his fourth game and tried to get his fourth win to qualify for an upcoming Tournament of Champions.

Starnes, 20, from Barrington, Illinois, faced off against Abigail Arnold, from Waltham, Massachusetts, and Eric Cordova, from Chicago, Illinois, on Wednesday, April 23. The champion’s three-day total is $72,202. He was born the same year host Ken Jennings had first run on Jeopardy!, which made the host feel incredibly old.

Arnold, an academic administrator, dominated the first round. She answered eight out of 15 questions correctly before the first commercial break. This gave her a huge lead with $6,000, compared to Starnes, an undergraduate student, who had $1,400. Cordova, a compliance specialist, had $0 after being in the negative for most of the round.

During the interviews, Cordova shared that he attended a Bears game as a kid. When his dad stood in line for a beer, the person running the booth told them that he wanted to be in show business. Turns out that person was Bernie Mac. Arnold shared that when a friendship of hers turns 13 years old, she has a bat mitzvah to celebrate. Starnes, to no one’s surprise, shared that he was a High School Quiz Bowl National Champion at Barrington High School.

Arnold found the first Daily Double of the game and made it a True Daily Double, wagering all of her $7,800. She currently had a huge lead. The clue read, “Something broadcast by a television network, for example.” “What is a program?” she answered, unsure. Jennings told her it was a transmission. She lost all of her money and went all the way back down to $0.

This gave Starnes the lead with $2,200. By the end of the round, Starnes lead with $4,200. Cordova had $1,200. Arnold was now in third place with $400.

In Double Jeopardy, Arnold took the lead as she answered the first three questions right, which were all higher amount questions. Starnes found the first DD of the round and had the chance to surpass Arnold. Only $600 under Arnold, with $4,600, he made it a true Daily Double. The clue read, “The northernmost Summer Olympics were held in this European city in 1952.” He correctly answered, “What is Helsinki?” doubling up to $9,200.

However, Arnold gave Starnes a run for his money as she continued to correctly answer clues. About halfway through the round, she surpassed Starnes by $1,200. Starnes took back the lead and had the chance to make it a wider lead as he found the last DD of the game. He wagered $4,000 out of his $14,000. “On July 24, 1857, Henry David Thoreau and 2 others set off on Moosehead Lake in an 18-foot one of these” was the clue. “What is a canoe?” he answered correctly. This raised his total to $18,000, giving him a huge lead.

By the end of the Double Jeopardy round, Starnes was still in the lead with $18,800. Arnold was not too far behind with $14,000. Cordova sadly had $0, and was ineligible to compete in Final Jeopardy.

“20th Century History” was the category for Final Jeopardy. “A 1919 Punch cartoon titled ‘The Gap In The Bridge’ showed Uncle Sam sleeping on the missing keystone of this,” the clue read. Arnold responded incorrectly with “What is the London Bridge?” She wagered $4,801, giving her a final total of $9,199. Starnes was also incorrect with his response, “What is the Golden Gate Bridge?” The correct answer was the League of Nations. Starnes wagered $9,201, making his final total $9,599, only $400 above Arnold.

Starnes put his hands on his head and opened his mouth in shock as he realized he won. He now qualifies for an upcoming Tournament of Champions with four wins. His four-day total is $81,801. Starnes will be back on Thursday, April 24, to try and win his fifth game against two new opponents.

Reddit users felt bad for Arnold as she could have won if she either wagered differently or got her DD correct. “Happy for Liam but I really feel for Abigail here. She played one of the best games of the season and could have won here, tough wagering scenario for her. Really hope we see her back in second chance because it’s a brutal way to go out. Really liked her all in bet on DD1 though, it’s fun to see people playing aggressively,” one fan said.

“I think it should almost go without saying that Abigail should be a surefire lock for second chance with THAT performance,” wrote another.

“Abigail’s 25 correct responses prevailed over her faulty FJ wager could be merited enough to secure an invitation at the Second Chance Competition?” asked one fan.

They also criticized the final question. “IMO, that’s a badly-written FJ clue. Here’s the cartoon in question. There’s nothing in the wording to indicate that the ‘this’ is anything other than a physical bridge, and there’s also nothing even vaguely hinting at the international focus of the cartoon. (The year had me thinking about women’s suffrage and the 19th amendment, though it turns out that was in 1920). ‘This organization’ might have made it too easy, but I think something like ‘this entity’ would have made for a better clue. Or even just the word ‘representing’ would have helped,” said another Reddit user.

“She has to be a complete lock for second chance. Also that FJ was brutal,” said another.

“It was definitely a tough one for sure!” replied a fan.

Jeopardy!, Weekdays, check local listings




Conversation55 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Comments are closed on this story.

  1. B

    BlueTooth

    Keystones also are part of archways.

    But..puh-lease don't even suggest that the clue was poorly written in your lame excuse to justify the loss.

    15 1

    1. G

      Gray Panther

      The clue said Uncle sam was "sleeping." Go look at the cartoon & see he was not sleeping.

      4 3

  2. G

    GreenRocket

    Well it’s true Arnold missed the daily double but that doesn’t mean she would’ve won because Liam would’ve probably bet differently if she would’ve had a lot more money. He only about $3000 on the last daily double, he would’ve bad it all if he had to and still would’ve beat her.

    14 1

  3. R

    RedButton

    The fact that it was a cartoon in Punch an English satirical publication should have clued them in that the scope eas international.

    16 3

  4. O

    OrangeBasketball

    It's also really easy for people to say that they got the answer 12 hours after it aired.

    12 1

  5. A

    Andy Frobig

    The show got pre-empted in my market, but I would have said the League of Nations. Political cartoons are full of metaphors, and the League was famously handicapped by the US's failure to join, even though Woodrow Wilson was instrumental in its foundation.

    14 6

  6. R

    RedLobster

    KARMA on the woman who took the last question, she could've let the guy with 0 get it so he could be in final jeopardy! So glad Liam won.

    6

  7. A

    Allison Williams

    Did anyone else wish Abigail had let Eric get the last (easy) question so he could have participated in FJ?

    5

    1. C

      CyanGuitar

      Yes!!!

    2. G

      Gray Panther

      Yes it would have been nice if Eric could have had that last clue but Abigail had no way of knowing whether or not he would have rung in. Imagine the pressure all contestants feel when up on that stage, under bright hot lights. Not easy to be thinking of anything other than their own needs.

  8. O

    OliveFlower

    Punch cartoons are usually political. The year 1919 was the giveaway. I'm a history specialist so it was easy for me. But in cartoons it is understood that they always represent something else. No need to have it said in the clue.

    8 3

  9. C

    CyanGuitar

    Happy for Liam and hope he wins tonight and a 5th plus more times! I found Abigail irritating and obnoxiously self-assured.

    3

  10. G

    Gray Panther

    Upon looking at the cartoon, it's immediately noted that Uncle Sam is NOT sleeping. A clue not well handled at all.

    4 1

  11. O

    OrangeBasketball

    She was really annoying. Don't know why people feel bad for her wagering, it was her own fault. She could have easily done the math.

    3

  12. B

    BlueBox

    Does anyone else think Liam resembles a young Jim parsons?

    2

  13. G

    GreenPlane

    I agree she was off-putting and then the fact she jumped in to answer the last $400 question when it really would have meant nothing for her or Liam over Cordova showed her true character. Stepping on his only chance to make it to final... Trashy. But even the worst contestants have been back for second chance so I'm sure we will see her again.

    2

    1. O

      OrangePumpkin

      Do you ever call out white people who do the same thing as "trashy" - somehow, I doubt it.

  14. R

    RedApple

    I think Liam won because of his wager....which we all know can be just that. Go Liam!!! Liam is so entertaining to watch! I hope he continues to 🏆

    2

  15. G

    GreenFlask

    I got this correct but the clue was worded horribly.

    4 2

  16. P

    PurpleAnchor

    I think Liam bears a striking resemblance to Alfred E. Neuman.

    3 1

    1. G

      Gray Panther

      Somewhat, yes. He has a very cherubic face.

      1. G

        GreenCarrot

        Something very sweet about him…reminds me of Howdy Doody! The woman reminded my sister of a hedgehog… I didn’t like her manner either…she was like a bully.

        1

    2. G

      GreenQuill

      I think it’s the scientist (Sheldon) on the Big Bang Theory.

      1

  17. O

    OliveGrapes

    So glad Liam won! I found abigail rather off-putting.

    2

    1. G

      GreenRocket

      Me too and she jumped every time she hit the button lol

      8 1

    2. G

      Gray Panther

      I wasn't too crazy about her either. Until yesterday's contest, I wasn't rooting for Starnes.

      13 4

      1. C

        CyanGuitar

        She reinforced my rooting for Liam.

        3

    3. P

      PurpleFlame

      I'm so glad he won, also. Her whole demeanour put me off too!

      8 1

  18. C

    CyanDog

    I have a question concerning the tie breaker rule and not being able to participate in the final. It is possible for there to be 3 players with zero after the final question. Shouldn’t all 3 be eligible to play the tiebreaker? 2 tied and 1 with zero going into final.

    10 8

    1. P

      PurpleButterfly

      It's happened. Trebeck was the host. He announced that the show only rewarded winners (I thought the phrasing was a little harsh). In that show there were no winners. The next show started with three new players - no returning champion.

      18 1

      1. G

        GreenRocket

        I agree, you have to have money to be a winner. I was watching that night also

      2. O

        OliveLocomotive

        The father of the boy who doesn't win has to mow the lawn in his wifes dress..

        Dead putting society

  19. P

    PurpleMustache

    I'm sooo tired of all these whiney piney complainers. Try to just watch the game and enjoy.

    1

  20. O

    OrangePumpkin

    To the author who claims the actual cartoon doesn't show anything international or political and on and on , that's BS. The cartoon explains it clearly, but I doubt any of the contestants had ever seen the cartoon.

    1

  21. A

    Antonio Montealegre

    Interesting this was the first of two shows in a row in which there were only two "Final Jeopardy" contestants. I watched both of them back-to-back when I played them on my DVR last night.

    1

  22. P

    PurpleTrumpet

    The category was Also a Car Part. What part of a car do YOU call a program???? Get serious, people! 🙄

    1

  23. R

    RedCupcake

    The final clue was completely idiotic. Even the contestants who are obviously elite didn’t know what it meant. I’m not surprised. The clue writing has tanked the last few years. I rarely watch the show now and I used to tape it. Alex would have set things right long ago, count on that

    1

  24. C

    CyanTree

    It was a battle of the buzzer both competitors were amazingly quick with the buzzer

    1

  25. R

    RedGoggles

    So many Jeopardy fans are a Bunch of

    Crybabies!!! Just Enjoy the show & Stop

    Criticizing Everything!!!

    1

  26. P

    PurpleFlame

    The question had nothing to do with who won. They were both wrong. It was definitely the bidding that decided the winner.

    1

  27. C

    CyanTree

    "I dun tin so Lucy"...The question was as apparent as you could get. A difficult one to mete out, however, not necessarily merited for a second chance. It is what it is, she lost and he won...that's the way it goes. Good contest though. Math skills should be in question actually...hehe😁

    1

  28. P

    PurpleBottleOpener

    I did not expect this answer to stump everyone. A 1919 political cartoon with Uncle Sam sleeping on a missing keystone clearly refers to the League of Nations, which the US never joined.

    1

    1. G

      Gray Panther

      If you look at the cartoon you will see that Uncle Sam is not sleeping, just lounging. This was a poorly-handled clue.

      4

  29. B

    BlueBullhorn

    As the Eagles say, "Get Over It"

  30. C

    CyanStrawberry

    Bring Abigale back. She's very bright.

    Bad Final question.

  31. R

    RedButton

    So what if the question was worded poorly. That happens often. But all players are impacted by it. What is the issue here????

  32. C

    CyanTree

    That's clearly a metaphor and has the words LEAGUE OF NATIONS on the sign. If you don't know, you don't know. Doesn't make the clue bad.

    1. C

      CyanPopcorn

      To be fair, the Jeopardy contestants don't get a picture of the cartoon...but the outright idiocy of the reddit poster is on plain display.

  33. R

    RedToast

    Umm the cartoon literally has a sign that say "League of Nations bridge" so "There’s nothing in the wording to indicate that the ‘this’ is anything other than a physical bridge, and there’s also nothing even vaguely hinting at the international focus of the cartoon." is overtly wrong

    1. C

      CyanPopcorn

      There's also the usage of "Uncle Sam," the year (1919), and the fact that it was almost certainly a political cartoon (which often have international scopes) that point to the focus of it.

      1

  34. O

    OliveLocomotive

    Who came first Liam or Sheldon? 🤭

    1 1

  35. B

    BlueTooth

    Her answer was correct within the confines of the question! A transmission is done by a transmitter of a station not by a network!

    1. O

      OrangeTag

      The category title was something like "also a car part".

      1

  36. G

    GreenLobster

    What a bunch of goofy looking characters ! The middle one looks trans, big time ! Glad I missed yesterday’s show ! Looks like it could have been a circus 🤡🤡🤡

    12

    1. G

      Gray Panther

      A bit true. lol