Should ‘Law & Order: SVU’ Have Written Out Kelli Giddish’s Rollins? (POLL)

Law & Order: SVU Kelli Giddish
Michael Greenberg/NBC

Law & Order: SVU fans were given quite the shock when it was revealed star Kelli Giddish would be ending her run as Detective Amanda Rollins in the forthcoming season of the Dick Wolf procedural.

While Giddish addressed her exit directly with fans via social media, writing on Instagram, “I wanted to address the chatter I’ve seen online and let everyone know that this will, indeed, be my last season on Law & Order: SVU. Playing Rollins has been one of the greatest joys and privileges of my life. I’ve been so fortunate to be a part of the Law & Order family for the last 12 years. There is simply no other character on TV like Rollins.”

Law & Order: SVU Kelli Giddish

(Credit: Michael Greenberg/NBC)

It has since been revealed that Giddish’s exit was not of her choosing. According to Variety, Giddish’s departure was a decision that was a “call made from above.” It was also reported that Wolf and star Mariska Hargitay pushed to keep the actress onboard but ultimately had no control in the decision.

Claims that the choice was made as part of keeping “the show as up to date and current as possible,” were used to explain Giddish’s exit, but salary disputes were also mentioned. Ultimately, Giddish’s Rollins will be written out of the series before Season 24 ends. But we want to hear from fans. Should she have been written out of the show? Cast your vote in the poll, below, and sound off in the comments section.

And stay tuned for more news on Season 24 of NBC’s long-running crime drama as it gears up to bid farewell to Giddish’s character.

Law & Order: SVU, Season 24 Premiere, Thursday, September 22, 9/8c, NBC

Law & Order: Special Victims Unit key art

Here Are Their Stories

Get absolutely everything about Law & Order: Special Victims Unit in your inbox!




Conversation60 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Comments are closed on this story.

  1. G

    GreenCarrot

    I’m going to miss Kelli Giddish(Rollins) she was a great asset to the show. Very disappointed with the higher up decision.

    33

  2. G

    GoldWheel

    In my opinion Keli is an asset to the show, she fits right in, they need her to make the foursome work, her absence will make show less desirable. Keep Keli on, Such a pretty lady and smart too🤗

    27

  3. O

    OrangeWeights

    A very poor decision. I thought Mariska had more pull than that. Couldn’t we have had a happy normal couple on the show with her and Carisi?? It certainly would have been something different

    23

  4. O

    OliveRadio

    I’m very unhappy with your taking Killi character off the show. Times are hard right now why remove a person who plays so good. Her role as Rollins is a very good character part why remove something that giving your show good ratings. You don’t need to lose ratings right now which that is what going to happen. Do not take Rollins character off the show put Kelli back on . Please do want right. I love this show.

    22

    1. B

      BlueRadio

      They will learn the hard way - when their ratings drop.

      1

      1. G

        GoldBlowdryer

        Ratings won't drop any more than they already have. lol. Contrary to what Rollins/Rollisi fans like to think, shippers and stans are not that influential.

  5. O

    OliveCactus

    NO!! I love this cast and she's such a big part of it!!

    22

  6. G

    GoldAnchor

    Watch Law& Order every night. Love it my husband too. Keli should stay, please don’t get rid of our favorite show!!!!

    22

  7. G

    GreenButton

    “It was also reported that Wolf and star Mariska Hargitay pushed to keep the actress onboard but ultimately had no control in the decision.” 

    Please correct this, as it’s been reported Wolf fired her.

    21

    1. R

      RedBulb

      This. It's evident Wolf was clearly part of the reason for her firing.

      11 1

  8. G

    GreenFlask

    I hate this decision! Rollins changed and grew as a character and Kelli beautifully played the many aspects of her personality. She was definitely not one dimensional and there were times that I was disappointed in her actions, but I have grown to love her. I'll hang in there until she is gone and then decide how to proceed.

    22 2

  9. G

    GoldSubmarine

    I was never a big fan of the Rollins character, but how do you explain firing her to keep things current? Doesn’t make sense!. You keep things current by having a completely new cast altogether! Firing one person doesn’t make the difference in my opinion! I can’t wait to see what happens with the ratings once she leaves! They should have had enough money to cover her new contract when Demore and Jamie were axed! How much did it cost to bring Raul back for that episode! ?

    13

  10. B

    BlueChefHat

    You might want to fact check this. You’re placing blame on the writers when the decision was made my Dick Wolf himself. With Dick Wolfs history of the mistreatment and firing of poc and women, this is not a good look at all.

    13 1

  11. C

    CyanFish

    This is NOT a writing decision. It's Dick Wolf firing a woman over 40 and replacing her with someone a decade younger to keep things 'up to date' (a thin veil for "she's too old for TV") a year after firing the first Lebanese, first LGBT detective on SVU AND the first Black police chief in the show's history.

    10

  12. C

    CyanPin

    Terrible decision! Why don’t you reconsider? Kelli is a great actress, and her character Rollins is great and believable. Don’t make these kind of decisions based on financial reasons . There is a lot to say for caring about your viewers and artistic integrity.Keep Rollins and drop the rebooted”Law and Order” if you need to save money.

    10 2

    1. B

      BlueGrapes

      I like the new Law & Order but I can't stand Organized Crime. Very Boring show. I can't stand Chris Meloni either.

      1

      1. B

        BlueSailboat

        Agreed. I can't stand him either, and I've enjoyed SVU so much more without him. I hate how it was used to launch Organized Crime, even though I understand why. Christopher Meloni has his own show now, but Stabler's still so involved with SVU through the constant crossovers and mentions. It makes sense, but I don't like it.  

        A lot of fans love Organized Crime for its serialized nature, because it sets it apart from the other two Law & Order shows. That's exactly why I don't like it, though. And like you said, it's just so boring. I really do not understand why everyone raves about this show. Is it just because it's more serialized?

    2. B

      BlueSailboat

      The rebooted Law & Order got so much better after their first two episodes. They have to make these financial decisions. The entertainment business is about making money, not "artistic integrity." They care about their bottom line. If it's too expensive to pay someone's salary, that actor will either have to take a pay cut or get fired.  

      I'm not saying that's what happened here, but WSJ reported just yesterday that NBC is considering nixing their 10:00 PM hour in Fall 2023 to save money. Their rationale is that giving it back to local affiliates will cut costs in an age where linear ratings continue to drop due to streaming. If it's that bad, cutting a series regular with a high salary makes sense.  They're focusing on Peacock, just like CBS is focusing on Paramount Plus and ABC is focusing on Disney Plus.

      CBS cancelled Magnum P.I., because they didn't think the lower ratings justified paying such a high broadcast fee to NBC Universal, when linear ratings are down across the board. NBC saved it, because they own the show. It's a co-production between NBC and CBS, but NBC Universal is the primary producer.

      2

  13. G

    GoldPuzzle

    I love her character! Please reconsider!!

    6

  14. R

    RedLobster

    Not a big Rollins fan, but how is getting rid of her and keeping others updating the show? This is a lousy way to treat her. That show hasn’t been what it used to be for a long time now. I think once Barba left, there was a void that couldn’t be filled, and now they are causing issues with he and Liv. They bring in new characters and then fire them. It’s a shame to finally begin a relationship between Rollins and Carisi and then not give it a chance, all because of money.

    5

  15. P

    PurpleDucky

    Kelli has been one of my favorites on L&O SVU. I often wished they would give her more coverage. I am not happy with this decision from the "higher ups" I watch all of the L&O shows and all the reruns. This makes me very sad...like losing family. I think they have made a bad misstake.

    5

  16. G

    GoldScooter

    Such a shame. And the news that Molly Burnett is seemingly taking her place makes this news even more of a slap in the face.

    5

    1. B

      BlueGrapes

      I agree. I think that's a very cruel thing to do. I have never heard of this new person either.

      3

    2. B

      BlueRadio

      I have never heard of her. She has really big shoes to fill. I hope she is up for it.

    3. G

      GoldBlowdryer

      She's a great actress. Molly was excellent on Queen of the South, and she was excellent in her episode of Chicago P.D. last year. I'm actually excited to see her in SVU, if I can't have Rollins.

      3

  17. R

    RedCoffee

    I've watch Law and Order SVU, for all 23 seasons. As a matter a fact, I've watched all the different Law and Orders. With that being said, this is the lowest decision this program has ever done. Fan have waited for the past 12 years just, for Rollins and Carecie to get together as a couple!!! Finally it happened, as fans we were excited!!! Please bring back Kelli Giddish, you won't regret it.

    4

  18. O

    OrangeTag

    I hate this decision! She finally found love. I think she was a great addition Won’t be the same

    4

  19. G

    GoldChilli

    I won't make the effort to make sure I watch SUV anymore without Rollins... She's the main reason I arranged my schedule around the time that the show aired... BIG MISTAKE... REALLY BIG MISTAKE!

    4

  20. O

    OrangeWeights

    Going to miss Kelli Giddish as Rollins on SVU, love her on the show. She was a true asset to the show!??

    4

  21. O

    OliveChefHat

    Trying to read between all the coded statements and messages that have been released…so we think it’s possible Kelly Giddish will be heading to Organized Crime or the Mothership L&O? Nobody, Giddish included, said anything about Amanda being killed or fired, but rather “Leaving SVU”. I think that wording leads me to believe Rollins and Carissi will get their happily ever after that they as characters and we as fans beyond rightfully deserve. If we don’t, then what is the point in investing one more second in any of their lives? It would be a slap in the face to the last 22 years of the franchise and those of us that love it. I say Rollins stays in NY and winds up on a sister show, or possibly leading her own show next season. Anything is possible in the Dick Wolfe world.

    5 1

    1. B

      BlueSailboat

      I doubt it. It sounds like she's being written out completely. I do not see Dick Wolf giving Rollins her own show. Unfortunately, I think this really is what it seems. One of the show runners did say that Rollins and Carisi will get their happy ending, but I don't see Amanda going over to Organized Crime.

      The phrasing doesn't really matter, because it's the same result. According to Variety, the decision was made "from above" against Mariska Hargitay and "at least one other producer's" objections. It's not Kelli's choice, and the star/EP of the show, as well as one other producer were overridden by someone "from above." That's Dick Wolf himself. The only one who can override him is NBC.

      This isn't like when Antonio was written out of Chicago P.D. in season 4, because Dick Wolf asked Jon Seda to join Chicago Justice. He left Chicago P.D. with the express purpose of anchoring Chicago Justice to it. When Chicago Justice failed, he returned to Chicago P.D. until Rick Eid wrote Antonio out of the show completely in season 6. That was Rick's decision. I remember him basically saying that Antonio's character had no more story left.

  22. O

    OliveChefHat

    I love her and watch everyday won’t be the same probably won’t watch it anymore I am so sad about it love this show my go to show everyday .

    I will have to watch another show she was so filled with energy she’s highlight of show

    5 1

  23. O

    OrangePumpkin

    It's a terrible decision! Kelli is wonderful on this show, her character is an extremely important part of this cast. I am very disappointed reading this of her being made to leave a show she is so amazing on. And you finally put Amanda and Carasi together, just to make her leave.....bad decision on your part.

    3

  24. B

    BlueSnow

    I am devastated about the decision to force Kelli out!! She rounds out the cast perfectly and will be missed! As much as I love Mariska, season 24 will also be my last!

    3

  25. B

    BlueSailboat

    "It was also reported that Wolf and star Mariska Hargitay pushed to keep the actress onboard but ultimately had no control in the decision."

    Not true. Variety reported that Mariska and "at least one other producer" pushed to keep Kelli onboard.  The decision was made "from above," which is code for Dick Wolf himself.

    I'll miss Rollins, because I really love her character. However, this doesn't actually surprise me as much as everyone else. It's very similar to how Christopher Meloni left in 2011. I suspect salary negotiations may have stalled, or Wolf thinks Rollins has run her course, now that she's dating Carisi.  

    Dick Wolf tends to avoid exploring too much personal drama on the Law & Order shows. For the most part, these are much more straightforward procedurals than Chicago P.D., where personal drama's built into the formula. That's why it's so jarring for SVU fans when the show does have personal storylines. Hence, why they're now being accused of turning into the "Olivia show" and/or the "Rollisi" show. A lot of fans miss the strict focus on cases/trials. And yet, when it was case heavy, fans complained there weren't enough personal storylines.

    Law & Order: Organized Crime is more serialized, but that's the point. It was designed that way, so that it stands out from the other two L&O shows.

    4 1

  26. G

    GreenWrench

    What a shame that Kelli is leaving. I will never understand why the hire ups make such stupid decisions. I will not watch anymore as she blended so well. Not the same anymore

    3

  27. B

    BlueCone

    I think the higher ups are Stupid for doing this to poor Kelli! She is wonderful playing her part and what a stupid reason to push her off, you have to keep things current! You can't come up with something better than that? She is the Best person on the show and I hope you are really happy with yourself for making such a stupid decision!  May all you higher ups get pushed out the same way you pushed out Kelli!  Me and lots of my friends will not ever watch Law and  Order SVU again since Kelli won't be on there! You are stupid people! 

    2

  28. O

    OliveCactus

    Terrible choice not having Rollins in the show. She is great and you will regret your horrible decision.

    2

  29. B

    BlueBox

    I think this is such a HUGE MISTAKE. She has been a crucial part of this show!!! This I believe will very much hurt the ratings of the show!!!

    2

  30. G

    GreenWrench

    It is a terrible decision . Rollins is a great actress and I love her in SVU. What they are thinking in eliminating her from the show. Stupid, stupid.

    2

  31. G

    GoldTeepee

    I hate that she is leaving. I love her role. And her and Caresi just started their relationship. It sucks

    2

  32. O

    OrangeBike

    These TV producers are going to find out the hard way that audiences can be quite fickle, especially when abused by sadistic plot lines and character destruction and disappearances. And we the viewers have been put on alert- do not get attached to any of these characters or shows because nothing and no one is expendable. We live in upsetting times- make us more miserable, we'll tune out. Some of these shows may go on a few more seasons, but some are already dead to me.

    2

  33. G

    GoldScooter

    This is a horrible disservice to those who watch SVU. I happen to love Kelly Giddish, she's my favorite character on there and to see her go makes me very unhappy. May the higher-ups hurry and change their mind and realize they've made a grave era!

    2

  34. B

    BlueFlower

    No keep her storyline open so when you realize you’ve made a horrible decision she can come back! I love her!

    2

  35. O

    OrangeCandy

    It’s INCREDIBLY TERRIBLE!!!! 😡😡… Y is she leaving???? She is ABSOLUTELY AWESOME!!!!! Y would Dick Wolf let her go??!!!! SHE IS ABSOLUTELY AMAZING ❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️

    2

  36. P

    PurpleWheel

    Big mistake on letting Rollins go ,been a big fan for 24 seasons, this is not good for the show!!!!

    1

  37. G

    GreenSushi

    I think that losing Kelli will be a huge loss😠😠

    1

  38. C

    CyanBus

    Fire Wolf. I love the lady.

    1

  39. P

    PurpleButterfly

    She should stay untill the end of this season as a full cast member. She's an asset to the show. The character of Amanda Rollins has been part of our lives for 12 years. We've seen her grown. And now that she is finaly thriving NBC and Wolf are taking her from us for no valid reasons. They even wanted to kill her at the start of this season? To save money?

    I don't know how much they spent for their crossover. But considering how bad the story was, how noisy, messy and superficial it was, they could haved many dollars. Kelli Giddish deserves to stay and to be paid fairly. Anyways, when she goes, I go. And I'm pretty sur I won't be the only one.

    1

  40. G

    GoldAnchor

    Loved her character. Should NOT have fired her. Show needs her!

    1

  41. G

    GoldBattery

    I think that Kelli Giddish is an amazing actress and that she makes the show better with her character!!!

    1

  42. O

    OrangeCandy

    I am very sad and angry. Horrible decision to remove Kelli. She's so talented. You do this and people are going to stop watching.

    1

  43. B

    BlueSnow

    Not a very good idea !!

    1

  44. B

    BlueGrapes

    Kelli is on of my favorites. I was looking forward to Amanda and Dominic taking their relationship further. I will miss her so much.

    1

  45. R

    RedSeahorse

    I'm dropping the show the second Kelli's last episode ends, just to show how ticked I am. This was the most terrible, insulting and hare-brained decision anyone could have ever made. I was already angry when we lost Jamie and Demore, but I continued watching because I was invested in Rollins and her story with Carisi. And after 12 years of watching her character struggle and try to find peace and happiness for herself, and finally achieve that last season, we get that ripped from us outta nowhere because what? Kelli is over 40 and TPTB don't want to pay her properly? Just as she's about to complete her character's character development arc? That's some PhD level bullcrap right there. This is how they thank Kelli for helping carry the show after Meloni left and keep it successful?

    She's a phenomenal actress and is able to bring out so much in everyone she shares a scene with. Ice, Dann Florek, Mariska Hargitay, Danny Pino, Raúl Esparza, Lindsay Pulsipher, Peter Scanavino, she nails it every time. Their scenes captivate every time. Put her opposite cardboard and she'll still pull at my heartstrings.

    Originally, I thought if Mariska ever left the show Amanda could have taken over Liv's spot as the leader of SVU, with Carisi still serving as the ADA. The new Benson/Stabler duo if you will. It never crossed my mind that NBC would shoot themselves in the foot by firing her. But here we are, I guess.

    Well, to put it in Amanda's own words: you've made that bed, now you lie in it.

    1

  46. P

    PurpleCocktail

    No her home story was interesting and Olivia is getting really old.

  47. G

    GoldBottleOpener

    They are gonna regret firing her!! She helps make the show what it is. And is one of two female leads. The show will not be the same. This is ridiculous. Kelli is so sweet and genuine! She is so beautiful! She deserves to be treated better then this.

  48. B

    BlueCone

    Crazy to let Kelley leave the show. She is a character who is down to earth & although a big fan, I hope ratings won't change. Love them all but she brings great drama. Do not let her go.

  49. B

    BluePlanet

    Hargitay could've paid for her salary for the next 5 years and never even missed it. But she didn't. Tom Brady took less pay so that the team could afford to keep other players.

  50. G

    GreenBone

    Yes I’ll be glad to see her go. I haven’t liked her character since the beginning

    6