‘The Trial of Louise Woodward’: See How HBO Cast Compares to the Real People

(6/1/04- Boston,MA)Omni-Parker Hotel Press Conference. Lawyer Elaine Whitfield Sharp talks to the press about the missing Aafia Siddiqui who appeared on a U.S. list as an alleged terrorist . In the background is a 1993 photo of Siddiqui after graduating from MIT. (060104pixrd Staff Photo by Renee DeKona saved in photo 1/wed) (Photo by Renee DeKona/MediaNews Group/Boston Herald via Getty Images); AFTER THE HUNT, Chloe Sevigny, 2025. © Amazon MGM Studios / Courtesy Everett Collection; Louise Woodward - What Actually Happened In The Trial of Louise Woodward; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0mZ_0rxUBtI; RIVALS — Courtesy of Robert Viglasky/Disney - CATRIONA CHANDLER
Renee DeKona/MediaNews Group/Boston Herald via Getty Images; Amazon MGM Studios / Courtesy Everett Collection; Real Crime/YouTube; Courtesy of Robert Viglasky/Disney

Nearly 30 years after the trial of British au pair Louise Woodward captivated audiences on both sides of the Atlantic, one of the most controversial criminal cases of the 1990s is getting the Hollywood treatment.

HBO’s upcoming 2027 five-part limited series, The Trial of Louise Woodward, revisits the shocking death of eight-month-old Matthew Eappen, whose 18-year-old nanny was accused of fatally shaking him while caring for him at his family’s Massachusetts home. What followed was an international media circus, a sensational murder trial, and a verdict that divided public opinion.

Now, a cast led by Catriona Chandler as Louise Woodward, Meghann Fahy as Matthew’s mother, Deborah Eappen, and Sagar Radia as his father, Sunil Eappen, will bring the story back into the spotlight. The series also features Hugh Laurie, Chloë Sevigny, Joanne Froggatt, Natalia Dyer, and several other familiar faces.

But how closely do the actors resemble the real people who found themselves at the center of the case? From the young au pair whose 1997 trial made international headlines to the grieving parents and legal figures involved in the courtroom battle, we’re taking a look at the stars of The Trial of Louise Woodward alongside the people they’re portraying

The Trial of Louise Woodward, TBA 2027, HBO

Catriona Chandler Louise Woodward - What Actually Happened In The Trial of Louise Woodward; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0mZ_0rxUBtI; RIVALS — Courtesy of Robert Viglasky/Disney - CATRIONA CHANDLER Real Crime/YouTube; Courtesy of Robert Viglasky/Disney
Real Crime/YouTube; Courtesy of Robert Viglasky/Disney

Catriona Chandler as Louise Woodward, the 18-year-old British au pair accused of killing 8-month-old Matthew Eappen.

Meghann Fahy - Debra Eappen - What Actually Happened In The Trial of Louise Woodward; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0mZ_0rxUBtI; DROP, Meghann Fahy, 2025. © Universal Pictures /Courtesy Everett Collection
Real Crime/YouTube; Universal Pictures /Courtesy Everett Collection

Meghann Fahy as Debra Eappen, Matthew Eappen’s mother.

Joanne Froggatt - Susan Woodward - What Actually Happened In The Trial of Louise Woodward; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0mZ_0rxUBtI; DOWNTON ABBEY: THE GRAND FINALE, (aka DOWNTON ABBEY 3), Joanne Froggatt, 2025. ph: Rory Mulvey / © Focus Features / Courtesy Everett Collection
Real Crime/YouTube; Rory Mulvey / © Focus Features / Courtesy Everett Collection

Joanne Froggatt as Susan Woodward, Louise Woodward’s mother.

Judge Hiller B. Zobel - Inside the trial of Louise Woodward: Baby killer or victim of flawed justice? | 60 Minutes Australia; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q79GURoPsx0&t=2119s; CATCH-22, Hugh Laurie, Daniel David Stewart, (Season 1, Episode 101, aired May 17, 2019), ph: Phillipe Antonello / ©Hulu / Courtesy Everett Collection
60 Minutes Australia/YouTube; Phillipe Antonello / ©Hulu / Courtesy Everett Collection

Hugh Laurie as Judge Hiller B. Zobel, the judge who presided over the trial.

CAMBRIDGE, MA - FEBRUARY 3: District Attorney Lynn Rooney points out defrocked catholic priest Paul Shanley as she makes the closing statement for the prosecution during his child abuse trial at Middlesex Superior Court February 3, 2005 in Cambridge Massachusetts. Shanley is charged with three counts of raping a child and two counts of indecent assault and battery on a child. Closing arguments were made February 3 in the trial and deliberation has begun. (Photo by Jodi Hilton/Getty Images); STRANGER THINGS, from left: Joe Keery, Gaten Matarazzo, Charlie Heaton, Natalia Dyer, (Season 5, aired Nov. 26, Dec. 25, & Dec. 31, 2025). photo: ©Netflix / Courtesy Everett Collection
Jodi Hilton/Getty Images; Netflix / Courtesy Everett Collection

Natalia Dyer as District Attorney Lynn Rooney, who helped prosecute Louise.

Elaine Whitfield Sharp - Chloë Sevigny (6/1/04- Boston,MA)Omni-Parker Hotel Press Conference. Lawyer Elaine Whitfield Sharp talks to the press about the missing Aafia Siddiqui who appeared on a U.S. list as an alleged terrorist . In the background is a 1993 photo of Siddiqui after graduating from MIT. (060104pixrd Staff Photo by Renee DeKona saved in photo 1/wed) (Photo by Renee DeKona/MediaNews Group/Boston Herald via Getty Images); AFTER THE HUNT, Chloe Sevigny, 2025. © Amazon MGM Studios / Courtesy Everett Collection
Renee DeKona/MediaNews Group/Boston Herald via Getty Images; Amazon MGM Studios / Courtesy Everett Collection

Chloë Sevigny as Elaine Whitfield Sharp, one of Louise’s defense attorneys.

Warren Brown Gary Woodward - What Actually Happened In The Trial of Louise Woodward; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0mZ_0rxUBtI; LIAR, l-r: Joanne Froggatt, Warren Brown in 'I Know You're Lying' (Season 1, Episode 2, aired US: October 4, 2017/UK: September 18, 2017).
Real Crime/YouTube; Joss Barratt/©Sundance Channel/ITV/Two Brothers Pictures / Courtesy: Everett Collection

Warren Brown as Gary Woodward, Louise’s father.

Jack Reynor - Gerry Leone - What Actually Happened In The Trial of Louise Woodward; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0mZ_0rxUBtI; MIDSOMMAR, from left: Jack Reynor, Florence Pugh, 2019. © A24 / courtesy Everett Collection
Real Crime/YouTube; A24 / courtesy Everett Collection

Jack Reynor as Gerry Leone, the lead prosecutor who argued the case against Louise.

John Magaro - Barry Scheck - What Actually Happened In The Trial of Louise Woodward; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0mZ_0rxUBtI; LANSKY, John Magaro as Meyer Lansky, 2021. © Vertical Entertainment / courtesy Everett Collection Real Crime/YouTube; Vertical Entertainment / courtesy Everett Collection
Real Crime/YouTube; Vertical Entertainment / courtesy Everett Collection

John Magaro as Barry Scheck, Louise’s lead defense attorney.

Sunil Eappen - What Actually Happened In The Trial of Louise Woodward; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0mZ_0rxUBtI; INDUSTRY, from left: Sagar Radia, Asim Chaudhry, 'White Mischief', (Season 3, ep. 304, aired Sept. 1, 2024). photo: ©HBO / Courtesy Everett Collection
Real Crime/YouTube; HBO / Courtesy Everett Collection

Sagar Radia as Sunil Eappen, Matthew Eappen’s father




Conversation

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Register or sign in to join the conversation.