Who Will Win ‘American Idol’? Ranking the Top 11’s Chances

American Idol Season 18
ABC

American Idol‘s third season at ABC and 18th overall is getting much closer to unveiling their champion, as the Top 11 battle it out in the coming episodes.

In a time where self-promotion could mean the different between moving forward and striking out of the competition, this year’s batch of contestants are varied in their possible chances for success. While they’re performing for judges Katy Perry, Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan, the Top 11 are also appealing to the viewers at home and on social media.

Could their social followings hint at their potential success? It’s certainly possible. We’re taking a look at the Top 11’s footprint via Instagram and YouTube to see where they stack up. Below, see how Arthur Gunn, Dillon James, Francisco Martin, Grace Leer, Jonny West, Jovin Webb, Julia Gargano, Just Sam, Louis Knight, Makayla Phillips and Sophia James hold up against one another.

And let us know what you think about the rankings in the comments below.

American Idol, Sundays, 8/7c, ABC

Grace Leer American Idol
ABC

11. Grace Leer

Instagram Followers: 44K

Highest Viewed American Idol Performance: 279K

Jovin Webb American Idol
ABC

10. Jovin Webb

Instagram Followers: 27.6K

Highest Viewed American Idol Performance: 2.4 Million

Sophia James
ABC

9. Sophia James

Instagram Followers: 54.4K

Highest Viewed American Idol Performance: 1 Million

American Idol Julia Gargano
ABC

8. Julia Gargano

Instagram Followers: 61.3K

Highest Viewed American Idol Performance: 1.8 Million

American Idol Jonny West
ABC

7. Jonny West

Instagram Followers: 67.6K

Highest Viewed American Idol Performance: 1.7 Million

Just Sam American Idol
ABC

6. Just Sam

Instagram Followers: 92.7K

Highest Viewed American Idol Performance: 1.1 Million

Makayla Phillips American Idol
ABC

5. Makayla Phillips

Instagram Followers: 149K

Highest Viewed American Idol Performance: 846K

Francisco Martin American Idol
ABC

4. Francisco Martin

Instagram Followers: 115K

Highest Viewed American Idol Performance: 1.7 Million

Dillon James American Idol
ABC

3. Dillon James

Instagram Followers: 83.6K

Highest Viewed American Idol Performance: 2.8 Million

Louis Knight American Idol
ABC

2. Louis Knight

Instagram Followers: 105K

Highest Viewed American Idol Performance: 4.9 Million

Arthur Gunn
ABC

1. Arthur Gunn

Instagram Followers: 222k

Highest Viewed American Idol Performance: 7.8 Million

American Idol key art

Hit All the High Notes

Get absolutely everything about American Idol in your inbox!




Conversation25 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Register or sign in to join the conversation.

  1. B

    BlueBandAid

    Arthur Gunn

  2. P

    PurpleScooter

    I pick is Julia Gargano she win

  3. B

    BlueBandAid

    Arthur Gunn

  4. G

    GoldLeaf

    Dillion James

  5. B

    BlueBullhorn

    Arthur Gunn all the way

  6. C

    CyanBucket

    Arthur Gunn is the best , he is going to win

  7. O

    OrangePin

    Dillion Janes

  8. C

    CyanScissors

    Johnny West

  9. P

    PurpleGlasses

    is da best!

  10. P

    PurpleGlasses

    Arthur Gunn

  11. P

    PurpleDucky

    Almost everyone got it WRONG. Why does Sam call herself “Just Sam”? It sounds like a lack of self confidence.

  12. C

    CyanFries

    I go with the dark horse

    Francisco Martin !!!!!!!

  13. G

    GoldScooter

    Dillon James absoutely

  14. G

    GoldWheel

    Dillion James

  15. C

    CyanGuitar

    Louis Knight!!!

  16. B

    BluePlanet

    James Dillion, Julia Gargano, Makayla could have won but she picks horrible songs.

  17. G

    GreenBulb

    Thunderstorm

  18. C

    CyanController

    Sophia Wakerman James. Her performance in Hawaii won the show!!!

  19. R

    RedWrench

    Dillion James or Sam or Francisco

  20. B

    BluePlanet

    I love Just Sam but I think Arthur Gunn will win

  21. B

    BlueBox

    Dillion James definite winner

    Just Sam runnerup

  22. C

    CyanStrawberry

    franscisco or louis or just sam

  23. O

    OliveLocomotive

    I think Just Sam has a great chance tonight

  24. C

    CyanGuitar

    Thunderstorm is voice

    1. G

      GoldChilli

      Thunderstorm is on The Voice, not American Idol!