‘A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder’: 9 Burning Questions We Need Answered in Season 3
Season 2 of A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder took fans on a roller coaster ride as Pip (Emma Myers) both attempted to find her missing friend Jamie Reynolds (Eden H. Davies) and do her best to keep a predator like Max Hastings (Henry Ashton) off the mean streets of Little Kilton.
The season offered a dark ending. Even though Jamie was reunited with his family unharmed, Max’s trial ended in a miscarriage of justice, allowing him to walk free and devastating his victims, as well as Pip, who had worked tirelessly to put him behind bars. Adding to the heartbreak, Pip appears deeply traumatized by her ordeal with “Child Brunswick” and everything she experienced while searching for Jamie.
While Season 3 has not been officially confirmed, the story leaves plenty of unanswered questions. Here are a few questions fans of the Netflix show will need answered. Warning: Spoilers for Season 2 of A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder ahead!
A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, Seasons 1 and 2, Streaming now, Netflix
Will Max ever face justice for his crimes?
Throughout Season 2, Max is on trial for multiple sexual assaults, with Pip determined to expose him. Several victims come forward, and Pip even obtains a recording in which Max all but confesses. A key piece of the case is Jamie’s testimony, but his disappearance prevents him from taking the stand.
As pressure mounts, Max threatens witnesses, manipulates those around him, creates a fake alibi, and gets Ravi (Zain Iqbal) fired. Despite the evidence against him, he is found not guilty.
The verdict devastates Pip, who struggles to accept that someone like Max can walk free. In retaliation, she releases the recording of Max threatening her. It is payback, but not justice. The question remains: Will Max ever be held accountable for his crimes?
Will Max's mother make the right decision?
One of Season 2’s most jarring moments comes when Max’s mother (Annabel Mullion) realizes he is guilty. After discovering hidden pills tied to the assaults, she confronts him and tells him he has become her “worst nightmare.” Max responds by threatening his own mother.
The season ends with Mrs. Hastings looking weary and haunted by the family she helped create, raising the question of whether she feels any guilt for turning a blind eye to Max’s sins.
Can Pip recover from her PTSD?
After the seemingly kind Charlie Green (Jack Rowan) is revealed to be the catfish who lured Jamie to “Child Brunswick,” a.k.a. Stanley (Misia Butler), Pip watches in horror as Charlie shoots Stanley in front of her and sets fire to the abandoned manor in an attempt to cover his tracks. Pip tries to drag Stanley to safety, but he dies in her arms.
In the aftermath, Pip is clearly traumatized, both by the incident and her guilt of leading Charlie to Stanley. Now flinching at every loud noise and sudden movement, Pip is changed for the worse. Will the young sleuth ever fully recover?
Did Pip completely lose faith in the justice system?
After watching a system that fails to protect someone like Stanley, a victim of his father’s crimes who was forced as a child to help lure victims, and seeing Max evade justice altogether despite the testimony of multiple victims, Pip no longer has faith in the system. By the end of the season, she is left questioning whether justice and the law are always the same thing.
What will happen to Charlie Green?
After murdering Stanley, a.k.a. Jack Brunswick, in cold blood to avenge the death of his twin sister Emily years earlier, Charlie flees the scene, but not before setting the manor on fire. Pip does everything she can to save Stanley, applying pressure to his wounds, trying to keep him conscious, and dragging him away from the flames. Despite her efforts, Stanley dies in her arms.
Amid the chaos, Charlie disappears. With Stanley dead and Charlie on the run, the question remains: Will he ever be brought to justice, or has he managed to escape the consequences of his actions?.
Will Ravi and Pip make it as a couple?
The adorable duo has its share of ups and downs throughout Season 2, from Ravi declaring his love for Pip in a speech she misses because she has to meet Max, to Ravi losing his job as a result of Pip’s refusal to bow to Max’s demands. At the same time, the two grow closer than ever, sharing intimate moments and ultimately working together to help solve the case and find Jamie.
But as the season ends, Pip is grappling with trauma, grief, and a growing disillusionment with the legal system. With so much weighing on her, will the challenges ahead prove too much for the young couple to overcome?
Will Cara ever recover from the fallout of Season 1?
In Season 2, Cara (Asha Banks) struggles with the fallout from her father’s crimes and imprisonment, creating a painful rift with Pip. When Pip exposes the details of her father’s involvement in the murder of Andie and Sal on her podcast, Cara’s life is thrust into the again spotlight.
Throughout the season, Cara grapples with trauma and trust issues while trying to rebuild her life. By the end, she and Pip have repaired their friendship, but the wounds of Season 1 are far from healed.
Will there be fallout from Pip posting the recording of Max?
When the legal system fails to convict Max of sexual assault, Pip takes matters into her own hands. She vandalizes his property and posts a secretly recorded phone call in which Max basically confesses to the assaults. Max’s reputation is probably destroyed in the town of Little Kilton, though he technically remains a free man legally, and Pip is reeling from the deep emotional and legal toll the case and Max’s legal case had on her.
Will Pip and her mother ever be OK?
In Season 2, the conflict between Pip and her mother, Leanne (Anna Maxwell Martin), intensifies as they grapple with the fallout from Season 1 and the stress of the impending Max Hastings trial. Determined to protect her daughter, Leanne tries to put her foot down, but her attempts to rein Pip in only create a deeper rift between them.
Over time, however, Leanne realizes that confrontation and ultimatums will not stop Pip from pursuing what she believes is right. Will her mother be more understanding now that Pip needs her more than ever?
Emma Myers
Zain Iqbal
Henry Ashton
Asha Banks
Anna Maxwell Martin
Annabel Mullion
Mathew Baynton
Carla Woodcock
India Lillie Davies
Orla Hill
Adam Astill
Jessica Webber
Yasmin Al-Khudhairi
Matthew Khan
Jude Morgan-Collie
Rahul Pattni
Yali Topol Margalith
Kitty Anderson
Raiko Gohara
Rowan Wallace
Mitu Panicucci
Georgia Aaron
Ephraim Sampson
⨁Full Cast & Crew
Conversation
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Register or sign in to join the conversation.
Watchlist Easy access to only the shows you care about — all in one simple place
Alerts Only important notifications — when a show is returning, when it becomes available to stream, and more.
Special Offers Exclusive products we release related to your favorite shows and streaming services