‘Gilmore Girls’ Star Kelly Bishop Hints at Cast ‘Problems’: 5 Biggest Revelations From New Doc

GILMORE GIRLS, Alexis Bledel, Kelly Bishop, Lauren Graham
Everett Collection

What To Know

  • Kelly Bishop hinted at behind-the-scenes problems on Gilmore Girls.
  • The documentary reveals that Luke was originally a woman named Daisy, and that Dean and Sookie were recast before Jared Padalecki and Melissa McCarthy took the roles.
  • Graham’s correct pronunciation of Jack Kerouac helped her land the role of Lorelai, while the show’s lengthy scripts required actors to speak rapidly and avoid improvising.

Gilmore Girls star Kelly Bishop hinted at cast “problems” behind the scenes in the new documentary Drink Coffee, Talk Fast — among other unexpected revelations about the beloved 2000s comedy-drama series.

For the project, released on November 17, several cast members reunited, including Bishop, Scott Patterson, Jared Padalecki, Keiko Agena, Chad Michael Murray, Liz Torres, and Sally Struthers. Notably missing were Lauren Graham, Alexis Bledel, Melissa McCarthy, Milo Ventimiglia, and Matt Czuchry.

“I loved working with that little nucleus of a family. The Hartford group got along great,” Bishop shared. “I guess there was a little bit of problems here and there in Stars Hollow, and I’m not gonna tell you what they were because it’s none of my business, and it was hearsay and I don’t do that.”

Although Bishop didn’t name any names, others in the doc suggested that Graham and Patterson weren’t the best of friends off-camera. Dialect coach George Anthony Bell mentioned that he didn’t think that Patterson and Graham “hung out after the show.” Meanwhile, Mark Strasburg, a Gilmore Girls cameraperson, said, “Off screen, I’m not sure if they’re besties, but they don’t really seem to really like each other. But on screen they’re amazing.”

Gilmore Girls cast

Other revelations from the Gilmore Girls doc include:

Luke Danes’ character was originally a woman named Daisy

Initially, diner owner Luke Danes (Patterson) was supposed to be a woman named Daisy until The WB asked for “more testosterone” in the show. Gilmore Girls are likely thankful for this choice, as Lorelai (Graham) and Luke become iconic will-they-won’t-they romantic interests.

Dean and Sookie were both recast

Jared Padalecki played Dean Forrester, Rory’s (Alexis Bledel) boyfriend. But before he secured the role, two other actors had been cast. “There was a Canadian Dean, and then there was this other Dean,” casting director Mara Casey said in the doc. “I think they fired two dudes.”

Meanwhile, Lorelai’s best friend, Sookie St. James, was also played by a different actress. It might be difficult for fans to picture anyone else but Melissa McCarthy as Sookie — but as the doc revealed, Alex Borstein originally played the character in an unaired pilot. A scheduling conflict was to blame for McCarthy taking over. The silver lining for Borstein: She later appeared on Gilmore Girls as a harp player and as Miss Celine.

Graham booked the role of Lorelai partially because of how she pronounced 1 name

In the first scene at Luke’s Diner, Lorelai referenced Jack Kerouac — and she was the only one who correctly pronounced his last name in the audition.

“Amy’s writing had so many references to theater and literature and contemporary music,” director Lesli Linka explained. “So we said, ‘You know what? We cannot have someone that doesn’t know who Jack Kerouac is.’”

Although there was initially a conflict in Graham’s schedule due to her obligation to the show M.Y.O.B., it wasn’t picked up for a second season. And so, she became Lorelai.

Gilmore Girls scripts were over 80 pages

Cast members were expected to stick to the Gilmore Girls‘ scripts to a T — but to fit everything into the allotted time, they had to speak quickly.

“We used to have delicious coffee drinks on set,” Rose Abdoo (Gypsy). “We all talked even faster, and I thought, ‘OK, they’re not just trying to treat us. We’re really all jazzed up now.’ … It wasn’t one of those shows where people could improvise… no, every word is there for a reason.”

Murray (who played Tristin Dugray) recalled Gilmore Girls creator and writer Amy Sherman-Palladino telling them, “Talk faster. I don’t want to cut any pages out of this show.”

Padalecki echoed, “We got 85 pages we gotta get into 42 minutes. Like, chop-chop!”

Gilmore Girls aired for seven seasons from 2000 to 2007. In addition to the aforementioned actors, the show featured Edward Herrmann as Richard, Sean Gunn as Kirk, among others. and more. A four-episode revival, Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life, was released on Netflix in 2016.

Gilmore Girls, streaming on Netflix, Hulu, and Disney+; Drink Coffee, Talk Fast: A Documentary About Gilmore Girls, streaming on Apple, Prime Video & More




Conversation

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Register or sign in to join the conversation.