How Long Could ‘Below Deck’ Star João Franco Serve in Turkish Prison After Fatal Fight?

Joao Franco
Fred Jagueneau/Bravo via Getty Images

What To Know

  • Below Deck alum João Franco and his brother Karlos face criminal charges in Turkey after a November 7 fight.
  • The brawl, which happened outside a store in Bodrum, left a 17-year-old boy dead.
  • Depending on the charges, the brothers could face sentences ranging from two to six years to life in prison.

Below Deck alum João Franco and his brother, Karlos Franco, are facing criminal charges in Turkey after a fistfight that left a 17-year-old boy dead.

According to Page Six, which spoke with New York federal criminal defense attorney Todd Spodek, the brothers could face up to life in prison if the Bodrum Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office decides to indict them.

Spodek, who has represented clients prosecuted in Turkey, explained the different charges João and his brother could face. This includes intentional killing, which carries a life sentence; intentional injury resulting in death, which can result in a 10-to-18-year prison sentence; or negligent homicide, which carries a prison sentence of two to six years.

“The single most important question in this case is how Turkish prosecutors charge it because that decides almost everything about the sentence,” Spodek told the outlet.

As previously reported, the incident occurred on November 7 at a local business in Bodrum’s Muğla district. An argument allegedly broke out between the brothers and employees before escalating into a physical altercation outside. During the confrontation, a 17-year-old employee reportedly fell to the ground, suffered a head injury, and subsequently went into cardiac arrest and died.

“If they treat it as an intentional killing, the brothers are facing a potential life sentence,” Spodek noted. “If it’s charged the way these bar-fight cases often are, as an assault that unintentionally resulted in death, the exposure drops to roughly a decade or more. If a court finds it was reckless rather than intentional, it drops further still.”

He added there is another option called “eventual intent,” which “means the person didn’t mean to kill but knew death could happen. It’s less than life [in prison] but still a long sentence.”

Spodek said he’d be “surprised if prosecutors could prove intentional killing from one punch and a fall,” and explained how the CCTV footage will prove to be the most important factor in the case.

In the footage, Karlos appears to throw the first punch, while a group of men fights back, with one lifting a stool and attempting to throw it at the brothers. João initially appears to attempt to pull his brother away and de-escalate the situation. However, as the fighting continues, João throws a punch, after which one of the men falls to the ground and lies there motionless.

Spodek noted that João may have a better argument than his brother “if the video shows [him] trying to break it up and only swinging once things got out of hand… Karlos has a harder time if he started it. You can’t start a fight and then claim self-defense.”

The attorney also explained how Turkey “doesn’t use juries” in criminal cases and instead “a panel of judges hears the evidence” and makes a decision.

João first appeared in the Below Deck franchise in 2018, starring in Below Deck Mediterranean before joining Below Deck Down Under in 2023. He featured in Down Under‘s second and fourth seasons.




Conversation

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Register or sign in to join the conversation.