Biggest Newsmax Controversies: Lawsuits, Misinformation Accusations & a COVID Conspiracy
Warning: The following post contains discussion of sexual assault.
Newsmax doesn’t have the pull that rival Fox News does — it ranked 38th on last year’s list of most-watched TV networks, while Fox News ranked number five, according to Variety. Still, like its biggest rival in the conservative-leaning cable news space, Newsmax does have a history of controversy — and, in fact, a history of lawsuits over its coverage of the 2020 presidential election.
Below, in our opinion, are the biggest controversies in Newsmax history — times when, you might say, the “news” about the network was “max” unflattering.
2020: Dominion executive Eric Coomer sues Newsmax for defamation
Dominion Voting Systems executive Eric Coomer sued Newsmax in state court in Colorado in December 2020 over false claims he participated in an “Antifa conference call” to rig the 2020 presidential election, according to Business Insider. “Newsmax took no efforts to verify or corroborate the false allegations against Dr. Coomer and Dominion before publishing them and disregarded reliable sources establishing the contrary,” his lawsuit read, as Business Insider reported separately.
Coomer moved to dismiss Newsmax as a defendant after reaching an undisclosed settlement with the organization, which later issued a retraction. “Newsmax has found no evidence that Dr. Coomer interfered with Dominion voting machines or voting software in any way, nor that Dr. Coomer ever claimed to have done so,” the statement read. “Nor has Newsmax found any evidence that Dr. Coomer ever participated in any conversation with members of ‘Antifa,’ nor that he was directly involved with any partisan political organization.”

Patrick T. Fallon/AFP via Getty Images
2021: Media Matters accuses Newsmax of “scams, grifts, and cons”
In May 2021, the left-leaning watchdog organization Media Matters of America published a rundown of what it called “Newsmax’s worst grifts, scams, and cons,” saying Newsmax had “used hyperpartisan content to build an audience of right-wing seniors and bilked them through an array of scams and dubious products for more than a decade” through media like Newsmax’s health and finance newsletters.
Media Matters reported, for example, that Newsmax had at various points sent emails claiming to know how to travel on taxpayer-funded vacations and add $1,000 to monthly Social Security checks, advertising a “Natural Cure for Alzheimer’s,” and saying that one of the tips for “how to survive the Coronavirus outbreak” was to not take the coronavirus vaccine.
2021: Dominion and Smartmatic sue Newsmax over election-rigging claims
Newsmax’s coverage of the 2020 presidential election brought about two lawsuits from voting technology companies in 2021. In a complaint that August, Dominion Voting Systems accused the network of spreading misinformation by accusing Dominion of rigging its voting machines in Joe Biden’s favor, according to NPR. In a statement at the time, Newsmax said it “simply reported on allegations made by well-known public figures,” and Dominion’s lawsuit was “a clear attempt to squelch such reporting and undermine a free press.”
Then, that November, Smartmatic sued Newsmax for defamation, stating that the network accused Smartmatic of participating in a conspiracy to rig the election in Biden’s favor, according to The New York Times. Again, Newsmax said in a statement that it had “reported accurately on allegations made by well-known public figures” and Smartmatic’s lawsuit was “a clear attempt to squelch the rights of a free press.”
In September 2024, Newsmax settled the Smartmatic suit and agreed to pay that voting technology company $40 million, according to NBC News. In August 2025, the network settled the Dominion suit and agreed to pay that company $67 million, per Politico.
2021: White House correspondent Emerald Robinson posts conspiracy theory about COVID-19 vaccines
In November 2021, then-Newsmax White House correspondent Emerald Robinson caused a stir by tweeting a COVID-19 vaccine conspiracy theory with a religious bent. “Dear Christians: the vaccines contain a bioluminescent marker called LUCIFERASE so that you can be tracked,” Robinson wrote on Twitter, per The Daily Beast. “Read the last book of the New Testament to see how this ends.”
The Daily Beast clarified at the time that luciferase was an enzyme used in COVID-19 research but was not an ingredient in the actual vaccines. And, the site pointed out, the name was not a reference to Satan or the devil but instead the Latin term for light.
Twitter later permanently banned Robinson for violating its policy on COVID-19 misinformation, and Newsmax took her off the air following the post, according to Deadline. In December of that year, Newsmax announced it would not be renewing Robinson’s contract when it expired the following month.
2021–2025: Accusations of misinformation and unreliable coverage at Newsmax go wide
In November 2021, the Center for Countering Digital Hate published a “Toxic Ten” report stating that Newsmax and nine other publishers were “spreading climate misinformation,” and that social media links to their websites accounted for up to 69 percent of Facebook interactions with “climate denial” content. (A Facebook spokesperson said the CCDH analysis used “flawed methodology,” per The Guardian.)
In December 2024, news of the conflict between the media reliability rating service NewsGuard and conservative publishers like Newsmax made headlines at Deadline and in The Washington Post. NewsGuard had given Newsmax a score of 20 out of 100, and Newsmax star Rob Schmitt said on air that NewsGuard’s goal “is obviously to bully conservative media out of existence,” per Deadline. But NewsGuard co-founder Gordon Crovitz pointed out that the service had rated some conservative websites higher than some liberal ones. “Newsmax may not like our rating, but that is no excuse for them to validate their low rating with inaccurate claims about NewsGuard or to mislead [FCC] Commissioner [Brendan] Carr,” he added.
In March 2025, The New Yorker noted that Newsmax is one of the outlets that Wikipedia editors consider to be the least reliable. “Concerns of editors included that Newsmax lacks adherence to journalistic standards, launders propaganda, promulgates misinformation, promotes conspiracy theories and false information for political purposes, and promotes medical misinformation such as COVID-19-related falsehoods, climate change denialism, conspiracy theories, and anti-vaccination propaganda,” reads the Newsmax listing in Wikipedia’s perennial sources ranking.
2023: Newsmax hires ex-Fox News anchor Ed Henry, reportedly angering staffers
In August 2023, Mediaite reported Newsmax had offered ex-Fox News anchor Ed Henry a job and had upset staffers in doing so. Fox News had fired Henry in 2020 following an investigation of sexual misconduct in the workplace, according to the Associated Press. Former Fox Business staffer Jennifer Eckhart, who died in September 2026, had filed a complaint about Henry to her employer the month before, and she also sued Henry and alleged he had sexually harassed and raped her, according to Deadline. Henry denied her allegations, and he settled the lawsuit in June 2025, days before the case was scheduled to go to trial.
Scoop: Newsmax has made an offer to Ed Henry to join the network.
The potential hire has sparked internal outrage among staffers who point to his long history of scandal.
https://t.co/6aM4ERwWBB— Mediaite (@Mediaite) August 15, 2023
“This guy is a walking lawsuit,” a Newsmax employee told Mediaite upon Henry’s recruitment at the network. “I can’t imagine why anyone would want to hire him. He’s a legal risk. It’s not even a question of it, it’s a guarantee. He can’t help himself.”
Another Newsmax insider told the site, “Guessing [Henry] buttered [Newsmax president Chris] Ruddy up in West Palm. But they probably did it to try to capitalize on the hardcore Fox audience.”
2024: Newsmax is accused of linking the wrong man to a mass shooting
In a March 2024 lawsuit, a Texas man named Mauricio Garcia alleged that Newsmax and other outlets had used an image of him in their coverage of a mass shooting perpetrated by a white supremacist with the same name, according to HuffPost.
“In their haste to cash in on the eagerness of viewers and readers to learn the identity of the May 6, 2023 mass shooter at the outlet mall in Allen, Texas, several media organizations recklessly disregarded basic journalistic safeguards and published the photo of an innocent man, branding him as a neo-Nazi murderer to his local community and the nation at large,” the lawsuit alleged.
A Newsmax spokesperson told The Daily Beast that the network “regrets the error and will be issuing a correction on air this evening” after repeatedly airing a mugshot of a different person and claiming he’s Texas gunman Mauricio Garcia.
https://t.co/4xh2v6qG5U
— Justin Baragona (@justinbaragona) May 9, 2023
The case appears to be ongoing. Court documents filed in October 2026 and shared on Justia indicate that a district court in Texas affirmed a trial court’s orders denying motions from Newsmax and fellow defendant Owen Shroyer to dismiss the case.
2024: Newsmax is accused of softening coverage of Qatar after Qatari royal invested $50 million
Also in March 2024, The Washington Post reported a member of the Qatari royal family had invested roughly $50 million in Newsmax at a time when Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates, and other countries had established a diplomatic and economic blockade against Qatar.
🧵: A member of the Qatari royal family made an investment of approximately $50 million in the pro-Trump media outlet Newsmax.
Following this investment, high-ranking officials within the Newsmax newsroom were reported by current and former employees to have encouraged the staff to moderate their reporting on Qatar.
— Brian Allen (@allenanalysis) March 26, 2024
The newspaper also reported, citing current and former employees, that senior Newsmax newsroom leaders urged staffers to “soften” coverage of Qatar before and after that $50 million investment. A Newsmax rep disputed the notions that the network had favored Qatar in its coverage and that Ruddy had told staff to not criticize the country.
If you or someone you know is the victim of sexual assault, contact RAINN’s National Helpline at 1-800-656-HOPE (4673) or text HOPE to 64673. If you or a loved one is in immediate danger, call 911.
Conversation
Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.
Register or sign in to join the conversation.