Nancy Guthrie Update: Detained Suspect’s Lawyer Speaks Out After Sheriff Refuses to Clear His Name

Martin Holmes
10 Comments
Savannah and Nancy Guthrie
Savannah Guthrie Instagram

What To Know

  • The lawyer for two men detained in the Nancy Guthrie disappearance case criticized Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos for mishandling the investigation.
  • Carlos Palazuelos, one of the detained men, alleges wrongful detention, defamation, and property damage.
  • Concerns have been raised about investigative missteps, including failure to secure the crime scene.

As the Nancy Guthrie investigation continues into its sixth month with no updates on her whereabouts or potential suspects, an attorney representing two men detained during the search has spoken out against Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos.

Jesse Showalter, the lawyer representing Arizona residents Carlos Palazuelos and Daniel Maddox, recently appeared on NewsNation’s Elizabeth Vargas Reports, where he blasted Nanos and the Pima County Sheriff’s Department for their handling of the investigation.

Showalter spoke specifically about his client, Palazuelos, who was detained on February 10 for questioning and released without charges. Palazuelos, who has accused the department of wrongful detention, defamation, and property damage, claims he was arrested in public at gunpoint and held for up to eight hours.

“As it stands right now, all of the reported evidence that they used to obtain the search warrant… search warrant we think was obtained without probable cause, is sealed,” Showalter told Vargas. “We can’t look at it. We can’t analyze it. And Sheriff Nanos won’t tell us what it is.”

Nancy, the 84-year-old mother of Today’s Savannah Guthrie, went missing on February 1, when police believe she was abducted from her home in Tucson, Arizona. Investigators have released doorbell camera footage of a masked suspect and sent DNA for testing at the FBI lab in Quantico, but no suspects have been named publicly.

“On the night in question, Carlos was not in that neighborhood,” Showalter continued, adding that the PCSD has provided no reason for his client’s detention.

Nancy Guthrie Case: Trump Weighs in as Investigation Hits 6-Month Mark
Related

Nancy Guthrie Case: Trump Weighs in as Investigation Hits 6-Month Mark

“From our perspective, it’s very clear that they made a mistake,” he added, noting that authorities conducted a DNA test on Palazuelos and took his phone but found nothing suspicious on it. “What’s not clear yet is the precise contours of that mistake. Were they relying on a false tip? Were they relying on bad information from Flock cameras or government databases?”

Showalter also said he found it “disturbing” that Nanos recently stated neither Palazuelos nor Maddox have been cleared as potential suspects.

“It looks like he’s just lost at sea,” the attorney stated. “It looks like he’s out of his depth. He doesn’t have control of this investigation. He doesn’t have leads, and he can’t even exercise restraint in his speech.”

Showalter’s comments follow a recent Wall Street Journal article highlighting missteps by the Nanos and his detectives. The article detailed how deputies reportedly failed to properly secure the crime scene and underestimated the significance of dried blood on Nancy’s front porch.

Nancy Guthrie



Conversation10 Comments

Please read the TV Insider Community Guidelines.

Register or sign in to join the conversation.

  1. C

    CEW

    I think it was the family.

    4

  2. Y

    Yeah

    Houses in this part of the country don't have basements, so not sure what you're getting at?

    1

    1. K

      Keiji

      They’re lucky to have foundations

  3. N

    Nader

    I don't know how long could she live without pasemaker that was departd from her body the night that she was abducted. Doctors might help by telling so her family could know if she is still alive?

    1

    1. Y

      Yeah

      It has bluetooth transmitting technology to her cellphone. When that bluetooth is no longer connected, the implanted device continues to work, but it does not transmit the data until back in vicinity of the phone's bt connection.

      1. T

        Tom

        I haven’t heard anything about the pacemaker being removed from her body.

    2. K

      Keiji

      I’m guessing she died in her house or w/4 hours. Also believe it was a sexual assault, which is primary reason women (even elderly) are abducted.

  4. L

    Leah

    Because her home is so close to the Mexican border, I think it might have been voodoo or satan worshipers who needed a victim.

    I don’t think the ransom emails that were sent to a local new station have anything to do with her real abductors. It seems the FBI agents dismissed the money demands early on.

    It’s horrible to think what might have happened and that is probably why this possibility isn’t explored much in social media.

  5. R

    Rob

    I think it is someone that lives near by how tall was the suspect?

  6. C

    Curious

    Has anyone thought to get the Blue print under ground of property around or the house was built on?